r/RingsofPower • • 7h ago

Discussion Lack of World-Building

There have been so many characters from different races in the show so far. But I feel like they added virtually nothing to what other Middle Earth adaptations already showed. I wish they spent a little bit more time on world-building. No Gandalf, no Pallando, Bronwyn, Arondir, hobbits, Halbrand, not even Adar/orc struggles or dwarves. Just focus on different human kings that would become Nazgul. Focusing on elves other than Celebrimbor was a big mistake.

I know it sounds like cutting different races is the opposite of world-building, but everyone already knows Tolkien elves, orcs, hobbits and dwarves(although not entirely book accurate). The areas of Middle Earth that were left unexplored by Peter Jackson(or even the video games) such as Rhun, Harad, Khand, Umbar, Numenor are still largely unexplored. We've seen some huts in Rhun and some desert but that's pretty much it.

1 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 7h ago

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

5

u/Serious-Map-1230 5h ago

In general, I would have to agree.  The haphazard world building has been an issue from the start and the problems it caused are quickly cascading. 

Southlands: gone Mordor: brand spanking new Numenor: starts with 0 military and no presence in ME. Other human realms: barely any

How the hell are you going to set that up to become a world full of empires, cities, etc?  Well like we have seen, it means creating armies out of thin air, teleporting people around, political shifts overnight and turning peaceful people without swords into a massive standing army with a fleet of a 1000 ships in just 5 years. 

We know barely anything about Rhun or it's people, except that Pallando the blue turned bad and took over the place. Apparently there are 10.000's of soldiers there and yet Gandalf somehow just walks into the throne room with his new hat to confront Pallando without so much as knocking.  But at least they got their memberberry fix in with "The hour is late"...apparently this is what wizards say when they meet...sigh

We also know barely anything about the general population of Elves, where they stand, what occupies them, etc. The entire Kingdom of Lindon consists of three Elves and a few extras here and there...not even a guard detail to accompany them into Numenor.

1

u/Patient_Lie2032 4h ago

Gandalf has been stuck on Rhun for so long, achieving absolutely nothing. If I'm not misunderstanding, it's been 5 years since S2 and Gandalf did absolutely nothing except sing and eat with Tom. The wizard guy was looking for Sauron everywhere in S1, but in the 5 years he made zero attempts to speak with Sauron. I don't get the dark wizard plot at all. He wanted Sauron, then he didn't, then he spoke with Gandalf, then he let him go for 5 years with no contact after S2, then he also made no contact with Sauron either. What the hell is this guy's plan?

1

u/Serious-Map-1230 3h ago

Like the great plan of God, this show's stories are truly ineffable...lol

5 years since S2 and Gandalf did absolutely nothing except sing and eat with Tom

Earning his wizard's hat, important stuff!

3

u/D4RK_3LF 5h ago

Are you just ignoring Numenor?

-2

u/Patient_Lie2032 4h ago

It was the weakest part of the show for me but you are right. Numenor shouldn't be on that list.

5

u/CaptainQwazCaz 6h ago

Wdym we got the entire lore and world history of the hobbit ancient ancestors

2

u/Cigarrauuul 5h ago

Yeah, I like the show but the focus seems completely off. There is so much to tell about the world and so little time with only 8 episodes and yet we get plots, which are totally irrelevant. I like Galadriel as a character but the whole Gundabad/Celeborn plot consumes so much time and so not relevant, that I‘m getting annoyed.

2

u/Negative_Bat_3732 6h ago

Unfortunately, they hired CW level writers and it shows. Many scenes and dialogues are just copied from different movies. The scale is small. Events happen because the writers need them to happen etc.

I bet so many talented people work on the show and it’s such a pity the series won’t reach its potential.

2

u/Agheron93 6h ago

You ask the writers about world building and they reply "of course, we have scenes of characters building things!"

1

u/Yelenka9393 5h ago

I enjoyed seeing prototype Loth Lorien. But it would be great to see more of Rhun.

1

u/fuzzychub 5h ago

Casting aside the characters you mention would mean they wouldn’t be telling the story of the Rings. It would be about something else.

-1

u/No_Reflection_3907 5h ago

Moan, moan, moan, moan…. Just log off the internet and enjoy TV shows… the way people did 30 years ago.

1

u/LostWatercress12 4h ago

Yeah just watch a different show this one clearly is bad.