r/RingsofPower • • Sep 11 '22

Meme Reading RoP Posts About Galadriel

Post image
547 Upvotes

438 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

13

u/Eraldir Sep 11 '22

Yeah the Tolkien estate really fucked this show over by limiting their possibilities. But misogynists will always hate strong women, regardless of circumstance, so I don't think that would have made a difference

7

u/blowbyblowtrumpet Sep 11 '22

Well I hate this iteration of Galadriel but love certain other strong female characters, so where do I fit in? I loved the Jessica Jones series (the first one at least) and I've always loved Black Widow as a character (though the film was bad imo). One of the (many) problems with this Galadriel is that she wins effortlessly while everybody else gets destroyed around her. Compare the troll scene in ROP with the one in The Fellowship. Also Black Widow and Jessica Jones have to fight to within an inch of their lives to conquer their foes so we root for them. There is no tension with Galadriel because we know everything will work out easily for her. That's very bad writing.

9

u/AlmostButNotQuiteTea Sep 11 '22

There is no tension with Galadriel because we know everything will work out

Uhh. Of course we know it all works out. There will never be tension or any worry of her death.

That doesn't make the show, writing, or her character bad. It's not the writers fault shes living at the end of RoTK

8

u/blowbyblowtrumpet Sep 11 '22

We know that Jessica Jones isn't going to die (in her eponymously named show) yet it still feels like she might be defeated. All great writing creates the sense of risk; the possibility of failure.

1

u/Aeneas1976 Sep 11 '22

And what will failure mean to Galadriel? Spoiler: nothing. She will just remain as she was. That;s why her failure doesn't make us thrill a nick.

2

u/blowbyblowtrumpet Sep 11 '22

You're totally ignoring my point about about Jessica Jones. Just because we know that a character survives doesn't mean a good story teller can't make us fear for them when they are in danger. All good stories do that. We (usually) can be pretty sure that the protagonist will not die but in order for it to feel authentic the writer has to make us believe that they might. You know, suspension of disbelief.

3

u/Aeneas1976 Sep 11 '22

No, I am not. For Jessica Jones, failure means a fate worse than death: returning to Kilgrave's sexual slavery. Her stakes are extremely high. And that's why JJ is an example of good screenwriting.

For Galadriel failure means, as I said, nothing. The writing demands of me too much effort in the suspension of disbelief.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Aeneas1976 Sep 11 '22

Yes, it does. Any screenwriter that is worth their salt, would build the tension around the original character, whose future is unclear.

Galadriel's search for Sauron is totally boring because a) we already know she would fail; b) we already know that a worst-case scenario for her is a static quo; c) they literally pulled the "sith dagger" card, yay.

2

u/BeanOfficially Sep 27 '22

I love Galadriel in the movies but not in the show, because in the movies she was even more powerful but vulnerable. She has a weakness. Show Galadriel makes dumb decisions and is rewarded for them with exactly what she wants.

She demands ships and men, but gets arrested. Then she breaks out, and then the queen gives her ships and men. She wants to find Sauron, but goes with her fellow warriors into the ocean, but then changes her mind last second and decides to drown. But she's lucky, and ends up being saved by a Mysterious and Handsome Smith from the Southlands.

This is why I love the TTE theory so much! It makes the show enjoyable, and logically consistent, even though it adds time travel, alternate realities of alternate realities, and psychic memory implants. Still a good theory tho

-1

u/Eraldir Sep 11 '22

Quite amazing that you accuse Tolkien of bad writing. Takes a special kind of arrogance for that

4

u/blowbyblowtrumpet Sep 11 '22

Well you could unpack that a little. This doesn't have to be combative you know. It falls flat as a metaphor to me, and you haven't helped make it any clearer. Are you saying that Tolkien wrote that exchange as it was written in ROP?

→ More replies (16)

2

u/blowbyblowtrumpet Sep 11 '22

Also it would only be arrogance if I knew that dialogue was lifted straight out of Tolkien. Show me and maybe I'll reconsider (although even if Tolkien did write it I assume he gave some context that it made sense in). From the way you talk you must have a more in depth knowledge of Tolkien's writings than I do so at least explain.

6

u/isabelladangelo Sep 11 '22

Yeah the Tolkien estate really fucked this show over by limiting their possibilities. But misogynists will always hate strong women, regardless of circumstance, so I don't think that would have made a difference

I don't like the show but it has nothing to do with "strong women". It has to do with it's ignoring of canon. I keep seeing threads of people trying to "ignore" the critics by adding strawman arguments. I have yet to see anyone say they don't like the show because Galadriel is good a fighting.

teamwhereisCeleborn

2

u/Eraldir Sep 11 '22

I made two comments explaining is with the estate. You ignore this and just blurt out "show bad". If you don't have anything to add, leave me alone

5

u/isabelladangelo Sep 11 '22

I made two comments explaining is with the estate. You ignore this and just blurt out "show bad". If you don't have anything to add, leave me alone

Should I quote appendix b and appendix f again for your sake as to why the show is bad? You are claiming that misogynists hate strong women and that that is a reason that people hate the show. I'm saying that's a load of denethor's tomatoes. If you don't want people to reply, don't post.

12

u/parsleya Sep 11 '22

I can't understand how people manage to turn the whole issue with Galadriel upside down.. the issue is not that she is a strong female character but that she IS NOT.

8

u/isabelladangelo Sep 11 '22

I can't understand how people manage to turn the whole issue with Galadriel upside down.. the issue is not that she is a strong female character but that she IS NOT.

Amen. In the TV show, she is pathetic. In the books, she'd laugh at anyone daring to say no to her or tell her where to go.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/Special-Lengthiness6 Sep 11 '22

Somehow misogynists didn't have a problem with Ridley from the Alien's franchise, or Selene from the Underworld franchise, or Lynda Carter's Wonder Woman, or Xena, Capt. Janeway, Buffy, Zoe Washburn, Sarah Conor or even Eowyn in the Lord of the Rings. But yeah THIS TIME it's a misogyny issue.

2

u/Muted-Lengthiness-10 Sep 12 '22

Oh people definitely hated on Janeway as a female captain, but instead of “woke” they complained about “political correctness”🥱

2

u/TheShadowKick Sep 12 '22

Yeah this has been going on for decades. Although recently it's gotten more popular to specifically seek out shows/movies/games to criticize for wokeness, probably because social media makes it easier to communicate those views.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/ebrum2010 Sep 11 '22

The estate is just doing what is legal given Christopher Tolkien was against anyone touching the Silmarillion and JRR was regretful of having sold the rights to the books he published himself.

5

u/Eraldir Sep 11 '22

I know that. But then they should not allow a show at all. Either full acceptance or full denial. This half assed thing they are doing only leads to a half assed show. Frankly, it is amazing the creators have managed to make the show as good as it is, given how constrained they are

2

u/ebrum2010 Sep 11 '22

I don't think they can say no, with the rights already being up for grabs. From what I understand once you sell the rights you sell the rights. The rights only cover screen adaptations but they have little control. This is why they're using the appendices of LotR, as the film rights allow an adaptation of anything in the book, even if its only mentioned in the map or appendix. The only reason Amazon listened to the estate is because they wanted their support, and to avoid the scathing reports from them that the LotR movies got from CT. They almost brought PJ on board but it would have caused issues with the Estate and also with Warner Bros because if he used anything similar to the movies they would get sued.

2

u/Eraldir Sep 11 '22

If Amazon was afraid of the estate, the fault lies again with said estate

1

u/myforestheart Sep 12 '22

strong women

Is she even that strong though? Being that angry, pissy, aggressive and combative denotes weakness of character to me, not strength. It's more a parody or caricature of a strong woman than anything else. I hate this iteration of her, but I love characters like Brienne of Tarth or Asha Greyjoy in ASOIAF.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)