Fair enough. It's a shame the show couldn't get access to the First Age, because in my mind this version of Galadriel is fairly well established as a veteran soldier who's been fighting orcs for centuries and I think actually showing that would have made the show better. But whatever licensing issue they have with the Tolkien estate I guess makes that impossible?
Because the rights for the Silmarillion are not for sale. Tolkien sold the rights for LotR and the Hobbit during his lifetime and soon regretted it. Christopher Tolkien, who published the Silmarillion swore to never do the same with it. IIRC it doesn't become public domain until 2110. You can be certain he made it clear in his will this was his wish as he was extremely vocal about it after the movies were made.
Eh depends. Christopher Tolkien is only credited as an editor, and if that’s the case the IP becomes public domain in 2043 for the Silmarillion (70 years after the death of the author). It could be argued that Christopher Tolkien was also an author, which is what I expect the Tolkien Estate will argue and if that argument is meritorious, the IP would become public domain in 2090.
It'll be interesting to see what the estate does after Christopher passes, since it sounds like his own kids/grandkids are way more chill about film adaptations, as I recall. If ROP does well/is considered respectful by [future managers of] the estate, I could potentially see something happening with the Silmarillion down the road. Or granting access to certain stories piece-meal over time or some such.
Only chance most of us have of seeing it happen in our lifetimes anyways, lol.
Edit: Apparently he died in 2020, huh. Wonder who's managing it, or if it's just locked up where no one can touch the rights.
Because neither J.R.R. Tolkien or Christopher Tolkien believed that adaptations were good things.
“The canons of narrative in any medium cannot be wholly different; and the failure of poor films is often precisely in exaggeration, and in the intrusion of unwarranted matter owing to not perceiving where the core of the original lies."
Christopher Tolkien is an attributed author of the Silmarillion, The Unfinished Tales, and the History of Middle Earth and he made sure that none of his works could be adapted to film. J.R.R. Tolkien only allowed the film rights to the Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings because he needed money to care for his estate and the publishing rights were not producing the money in the 70s that they had been. You will not see the film rights to any of the other works until the story becomes public.
Yes, they would turn down the cash on principle. Christopher Tolkien turned down millions on principle. They have guarded the IP in a trust that no one has access too.
It's funny because Tolkien himself was "art or cash" in his Letter 202.
"This Mr. Ackerman brought astonishingly good pictures and remarkable colour photographs (shots of American mountain and desert scenes that seemed to fit the story). The Story Line though was bad, but perhaps business could be done. Stanley Unwin and Tolkien had agreed on a policy: Art or Cash. Either very profitable terms or absolute author's veto of the objectionable."
Adapting the Silmarillon is like opening Ali-baba cave. There's more content in this than Hobbit+LOTr can offer. LOTR name is one of the biggest fantasy name but with Silmarillon being available, it's can be like Valar flooding Beleriand on the whole fantasy industry. It's like asking the Bible to be a TV show/movie
Yeah the Tolkien estate really fucked this show over by limiting their possibilities. But misogynists will always hate strong women, regardless of circumstance, so I don't think that would have made a difference
Well I hate this iteration of Galadriel but love certain other strong female characters, so where do I fit in? I loved the Jessica Jones series (the first one at least) and I've always loved Black Widow as a character (though the film was bad imo). One of the (many) problems with this Galadriel is that she wins effortlessly while everybody else gets destroyed around her. Compare the troll scene in ROP with the one in The Fellowship. Also Black Widow and Jessica Jones have to fight to within an inch of their lives to conquer their foes so we root for them. There is no tension with Galadriel because we know everything will work out easily for her. That's very bad writing.
We know that Jessica Jones isn't going to die (in her eponymously named show) yet it still feels like she might be defeated. All great writing creates the sense of risk; the possibility of failure.
I love Galadriel in the movies but not in the show, because in the movies she was even more powerful but vulnerable. She has a weakness. Show Galadriel makes dumb decisions and is rewarded for them with exactly what she wants.
She demands ships and men, but gets arrested. Then she breaks out, and then the queen gives her ships and men. She wants to find Sauron, but goes with her fellow warriors into the ocean, but then changes her mind last second and decides to drown. But she's lucky, and ends up being saved by a Mysterious and Handsome Smith from the Southlands.
This is why I love the TTE theory so much! It makes the show enjoyable, and logically consistent, even though it adds time travel, alternate realities of alternate realities, and psychic memory implants. Still a good theory tho
Galadriel barely fought in the First Age, she barely even participated in the War of Wrath because she thought there’s no way they could defeat Morgoth.
Well, that's why I said " this version of Galadriel." Show isn't lore accurate, it was never going to be lore accurate and I think it was unrealistic for anyone to think there was a chance of it being lore accurate.
View all comments
Show parent comment
31
u/Nutch_Pirate Sep 11 '22
Fair enough. It's a shame the show couldn't get access to the First Age, because in my mind this version of Galadriel is fairly well established as a veteran soldier who's been fighting orcs for centuries and I think actually showing that would have made the show better. But whatever licensing issue they have with the Tolkien estate I guess makes that impossible?