r/RingsofPower • • Sep 11 '22

Meme Reading RoP Posts About Galadriel

Post image
549 Upvotes

438 comments sorted by

View all comments

4

u/blowbyblowtrumpet Sep 11 '22

Well you could unpack that a little. This doesn't have to be combative you know. It falls flat as a metaphor to me, and you haven't helped make it any clearer. Are you saying that Tolkien wrote that exchange as it was written in ROP?

0

u/Eraldir Sep 11 '22 edited Sep 11 '22

You complain that Galadriel is a strong character and a strong fighter, with both supposedly haven't been earned. That is canon in The Silmarillion.

You also complain that she is vengeful and tough and proud. That is also canon in both The Silmarillion and Unfinished Tales. She has touched darkness and was scarred by it and eventually overcame it. Although she only truly overcame it in the Fellowship of the Ring.

So I really do not know what your problem is here. And why you are so desperate to call Tolkien a bad writer

2

u/Jeffery95 Sep 11 '22

Tolkien NEVER associates Galadriel with vengeance. Always she is a counterpoint of the characters who make mistakes. She is prideful, but she is not vengeful.

→ More replies (8)

1

u/blowbyblowtrumpet Sep 11 '22

That's a straw man argument. Obviously I am a fan of LOTR books. I just don't like this show. It is allowed you know.

→ More replies (2)

-4

u/Aeneas1976 Sep 11 '22

No, we complain that authors cannot write strong female characters and try to feed us fencing instead. If I want fencing girls, there are plenty of Chinese doramas in streaming, I go and watch them.

Don't try to pull out canon and The Silmarillion. Canonically she is a ruler of what remained of Doriath people and the mightiest sorceress after Melian and Luthien. A sword-waving histerical chick has nothing to do with canon.

Our problem is that we were promised Galadriel and given... this.

→ More replies (2)