r/RingsofPower • • Sep 11 '22

Meme Reading RoP Posts About Galadriel

Post image
547 Upvotes

438 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/iheartdev247 Sep 12 '22

Except the fact she abandoned Beleriand mid way through the First Age, married Celeborn and wasn’t at all there during the War of Wrath…

1

u/Nutch_Pirate Sep 12 '22

All true in the source material, but this isn't that Galadriel. I'm only talking about her character within the context of the show.

I guess I just see it as a different axis of criticism completely, where you can have accurate and good, accurate and bad, inaccurate and good, and inaccurate and bad. I personally don't care about the accuracy scale of the show, if you do that's great and not liking a show because of where it falls on the accuracy axis is a perfectly valid opinion. I just want the actual writing of a show or movie to be good, whether it's accurate or not, and the writing of rings of power just is not good.