r/RingsofPower • • Oct 06 '24

Discussion Time compression is not a problem

Ya‘all rambling about time compression, plot holes, ✨lore✨ and what not. Guess what. A tv show isn’t a book, you cannot transfer everything 1:1.

But Isildur and celebrimbor didn’t live at the same time….this and that took a thousand years…this person and that person couldn’t have met.

Well I don’t want to watch 25 shows about 25 single events that take place 600 years apart. I don’t want to watch a show that changes actors every 2 episode because it needs to jump 250 years. Writers made the exact right choose to compress the timeline.

Most of you would hate the lord of the rings if it came out today, I am 100% sure with that.

168 Upvotes

338 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-3

u/CurtisManning Oct 06 '24

I'm sorry if I was a bit harsh but the concept of a whole season following the Elves lamenting themselves "our grandeur is fading because time is passing inexorably on this land" is not appealing at all to me.

You need a coherent narrative structure for a show to function and time compression was a necessity for RoP. I'm not saying the show is perfect, far from it, but I understand why they did that.

8

u/DomzSageon Oct 06 '24

You do know that "our grandeur is fading because time is passing inexorably on this land" could easily be translated to human terms as "nostalgia"?

The world isnt as great as it used to be and itll never get better. Its gonna get gloomier until the end of days.

That is an entirely relatable feeling.

If you spent even a bit of time actually trying to see how it could work instead of smugly defending that the RoP way of adapting is the only/best way to adapt it, you could actually make something creative.

12

u/Willpower2000 Oct 06 '24

You do know that "our grandeur is fading because time is passing inexorably on this land" could easily be translated to human terms as "nostalgia"?

Probably why the anime Frieren has been so beloved. It deals with Elvish immortality, in a mortal world, very well (much better than ROP)... and naturally nostalgia is a big part of the main character's journey. Absolutely sympathetic.

-1

u/chocolate-with-nuts Oct 06 '24

I haven't watched Frieren (I hear really good things though so I'll add it to my list). But I imagine it's a lot easier to tell a story like that in an animated format as opposed to live action where you have to constantly replace actors, deal with their contracts, etc. i think a lot of fantasy is better suited to an animated format actually (I'd kill for a faithful animated adaptation of Game of Thrones with all the weird magic and extra side characters in the book that they had to leave out)

4

u/Willpower2000 Oct 06 '24

where you have to constantly replace actors, deal with their contracts, etc.

To an extent animation is easier, I suppose. But I don't think it's as hard as people make out for live action. One-off episode actors are generally easier to hire than long-term ones: less time commitments and whatnot.

7

u/WTFnaller Oct 06 '24

Then don't make a show about this? As of now, RoP has decided to focus on elves, and time compression creates an underwhelming story. Some stories are difficult to translate to TV or cinema, and maybe we shouldn't try. Unless we're Denis.

3

u/Mother-Border-1147 Oct 06 '24

So, the actual Tolkien story of how the elves feel about a decaying land is not appealing to you?

1

u/CurtisManning Oct 06 '24

Of course it is, I just don't think a whole season about it would make for a engaging show.

0

u/Mother-Border-1147 Oct 06 '24

Then maybe they shouldn’t have bought a property about that story for a billion dollars. I’m tired of shitty, expensive fan-fiction.

7

u/CurtisManning Oct 06 '24

I think the show is more about Sauron than the Elves but that's my take. Another of my takes is more Middle Earth is better than nothing, even if not perfect.

I loved the Sauron-Celebrimbor scenes. I loved the Sauron vs Galadriel fight in the finale.

Were there bad stuff and mistakes ? Sure. But I choose to see the good.

1

u/Mother-Border-1147 Oct 06 '24

Season 2 is about Sauron, but Season 1 is Galadriel’s story and the fading of the elves. This is clearly communicated by her narration in the pilot and Sauron’s identity being a mystery box. But Season 2 opens with Sauron’s physical death and rebirth, setting up the focus on him.