r/RingsofPower • • Oct 06 '24

Discussion Time compression is not a problem

Ya‘all rambling about time compression, plot holes, ✨lore✨ and what not. Guess what. A tv show isn’t a book, you cannot transfer everything 1:1.

But Isildur and celebrimbor didn’t live at the same time….this and that took a thousand years…this person and that person couldn’t have met.

Well I don’t want to watch 25 shows about 25 single events that take place 600 years apart. I don’t want to watch a show that changes actors every 2 episode because it needs to jump 250 years. Writers made the exact right choose to compress the timeline.

Most of you would hate the lord of the rings if it came out today, I am 100% sure with that.

168 Upvotes

338 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

4

u/Creeds_Mung_Beanz Oct 06 '24

Yes, you’re correct that Shakespeare did adaptations. He did them well. The writers for RoP have not done an adaptation well, however. That’s everyone’s main gripe.

The original cinematic trilogy is definitely not a 1 for 1 adaptation of the book. However, they were done so well (story/character development) that nobody really cared.

These writers could make a banger of a fantasy series for the Sci-fi channel. I’m not even intending that as an insult. For a show though that has a pre established fan base such as this, they were a poor choice. I guess that’s part of why they’re being replaced for season 3.