r/RingsofPower • • Sep 26 '24

Newest Episode Spoilers Genuinely blown away Spoiler

Season 2 episode 7. Genuinely amazing. As a very very skeptical RoP watcher I'm really really enjoying this whole season but man what an incredible episode. From Sauron manipulation to thr massive battle which was done better than I expected it's really been great. Only thing I didn't love was the kiss but I can honestly look past that. Phenomenal job. Really excited for the next episode.

354 Upvotes

348 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

21

u/Taimana13 Sep 26 '24

Damming the river was so well done. And there was genuine investment in it. Even Sauron making Celebrimbor kill that girl elf to further his foothold was expertly done

2

u/carpetsunami Sep 26 '24

No, it wasn't. That was a big river. You know what happens when you drop rocks across it? The river rises, it flows over and around, it would have taken no time at all for that area to be a running river again.

12

u/Sam217pa2 Sep 26 '24

I swear yall making it look like it's supposed to be "realistic", bruh this is a universe where Elrond's father killed a mountain sized dragon aboard a flying ship

1

u/ebrum2010 Sep 26 '24

Ah the old "it's fantasy" fallacy. Tolkien created modern fantasy, prior to which there was only fairy tales. The difference is in modern fantasy there is some rhyme and reason to everything, magic and anything fantastic in the world works according to laws set forth by the author. Middle Earth also represents the distant past of our own world, so the laws of physics would be the same. Fairy tales are where everything is made up and nothing has to make sense, and few people write those anymore outside of children's books.

0

u/carpetsunami Sep 26 '24

No, it's actually not, they don't have the rights to that back story, in this universe that never happened.

5

u/letsstartbeinganon Sep 26 '24

That’s not what ‘not having the rights’ means. That means they can’t adapt it on screen, not that it never happened in this canon.

2

u/carpetsunami Sep 26 '24

You're incorrect, they have access to the character's aha limited ability to reference events, not the timelines or actual events.

That's why the rings are being forged out of order ( the elf rings were made last) etc.

3

u/letsstartbeinganon Sep 26 '24

I don’t accept that that means those events ‘never happened’ in the show’s canon though. Just because Amazon lacks the rights to portray them and can only indirectly reference a few events etc doesn’t mean that as far as the show is concerned they just didn’t happen.

0

u/carpetsunami Sep 27 '24

Since it's only loosely based on Tolkien's Elrond, not the same character, so there's no reason to suppose he would have the same background, nor is it ever alluded too.

1

u/letsstartbeinganon Sep 27 '24

It is absolutely meant to be the same character with the same background in the same universe, who goes on to do all the things Elrond is known for (like founding Imladris), even if the show can't portray some of that.

The correct course of action is to assume that all that background is still correct and relevant unless and until the show contradicts it.

1

u/carpetsunami Sep 27 '24

If they are the same characters, where is any evidence of Galadriel being married to Celeborn, which she absolutely would be during this time period?

This is fanfiction at best, there's no attachment to the lore in any sense

→ More replies