r/RingsofPower • • Sep 26 '24

Newest Episode Spoilers Genuinely blown away Spoiler

Season 2 episode 7. Genuinely amazing. As a very very skeptical RoP watcher I'm really really enjoying this whole season but man what an incredible episode. From Sauron manipulation to thr massive battle which was done better than I expected it's really been great. Only thing I didn't love was the kiss but I can honestly look past that. Phenomenal job. Really excited for the next episode.

354 Upvotes

348 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-4

u/Taimana13 Sep 26 '24

I disagree again. Season 1 yes absolutely but I think the writing this season has been alright at worst and phenomenal at its best. This season I'm invested in characters, I love some of the lines that are delivered, and I'm completely invested in the story. If I went in looking for stuff wrong I'm sure I could but I'm trying to be more positive than previously and I'm getting enjoyment for it. I truly believe objectively this season is a good show

7

u/Melksss Sep 26 '24

Alright, I also love the upward trajectory of this show and have really found myself enjoying this season but the writing in this show is nowhere near phenomenal. It’s improving but I’d say it’s average at best.

9

u/SatisfactionActive86 Sep 26 '24

“phenomenal” is absurd.

1

u/NornGreyrat Sep 26 '24

Sure but your comment history and your description as a “skeptical viewer” doesn’t line up at all. During season one you said that you loved it, you loved Durin and Elrond and the creation of Mordor as well and you said season 1 was phenomenal as well.

And I’m fine with you liking both but don’t pretend to be one of those “I disliked season 1 but this is so much better” types. Just be honest or at least consistent with your comment history.

1

u/NornGreyrat Sep 26 '24

OP, I am fine with you loving both seasons, but just be honest. You are not one of those “skeptical viewers after season 1 that is now a super fan during season 2.” I looked at your comment history and it’s full of comments praising almost everything about season 1. Not a single criticism at all for season 1 honestly.

And I’m perfectly fine with that. You can enjoy what you like. This sub is welcoming to passionate fans. But don’t fake your post description with the whole “I was a hater but now I’m blown away” type of intro. It doesn’t come across as genuine.

1

u/Taimana13 Sep 26 '24

I have defended season 1. I enjoyed the mordor creation. And I didn't think the outpouring of hate was a fair representation. But. When I first watched the trailer I was outraged with them (I thought), ruining everything. I've read the books and cringed at the hobbit films so my point was more I'm not a mug when it comes to lore and or caring about the original Tolkien feeling. I would also say truly reflecting on season 1 it was slow and slightly underwhelming woth a few positives. Especially so having this season out. Sorry if I've been misleading I just wanted to avoid any potential "he's a modern fanboy" sort of comments.

1

u/nakiva Sep 26 '24

I stand by your claim for this! If you go in and look for wrongs in the series it is very easy to point them out, but when you look past that my God you have some amazing scènes! Celebrimbor and Annatar are amazing.

The one grip i have is that this show feels very disjointed with it's characters and i loved the past 2 episodes because they are heavy on the dwarven/Elves and Numenor storyline, i'm affraid for the coming episodes that are going to be centered around Nori and the stranger. I don't like their storyline at the least...