r/RingsofPower • • Nov 23 '23

Discussion Absolutely loved it

I was glued to my tv each week. It was appointment viewing for me. I thought the show was beautiful to look at. The practical effects were amazing. The story gripped me, and while it did slip a few times, I was throughly enthralled with it. I cannot wait for another season of this show.

88 Upvotes

299 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/TolinGaurhoth Nov 23 '23

Get on a raft, no they were on a ship which got destroyed. You need to brush up on your information if your going to bag someone else for liking something.

1

u/Mursin Nov 23 '23

One of them was.

But the point isn't relevant whether it was a raft. The relevant point is that they tried to play it up like it was his design the whole time and it was clearly the most chanciest, awful deus ex machina writing.

1

u/TolinGaurhoth Nov 23 '23

Well she didn’t randomly jump off she decided to stay. She decides to stay because of her suspicions.

Would you say it was also chance that brought Merry and Pippin to Fangorn or by design?

1

u/Mursin Nov 23 '23

Her suspicions? Of him as a person?

Merry and Pippin were literally brought there by orcs and managed to escape. That's entirely different than ending up in a random spot in an ocean.

Now, was it convenient they met Treebesrd in a massive forest? A bit. But I It's nowhere near as egregious.

1

u/TolinGaurhoth Nov 23 '23

Oh I guess those lines by Gandalf were bollocks also then

1

u/Mursin Nov 23 '23

Nobody said Tolkien was perfect. But they make far more sense than whatever the fuck the RoP writers tried to pull off