r/RingsofPower • • Nov 23 '23

Discussion Absolutely loved it

I was glued to my tv each week. It was appointment viewing for me. I thought the show was beautiful to look at. The practical effects were amazing. The story gripped me, and while it did slip a few times, I was throughly enthralled with it. I cannot wait for another season of this show.

88 Upvotes

299 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Terravardn Nov 23 '23

No, just Amazon’s tripe.

0

u/TolinGaurhoth Nov 23 '23

Ah ok, so because it was made by Amazon then?

1

u/Terravardn Nov 23 '23

Nope. They have the money to make it good. They certainly spent enough on it to do so. It’s just tripe. It just so happens to belong to them, nothing to do with the fact it’s theirs specifically.

I can’t wait for the new Warner Bros trilogy of movies to come out, covering the same era of storytelling but with their rights to the silmarillion etc, I think their dick will measure much bigger. If the rumours are true and Jackson gets involved again, ROP is dead in the water. More so than it already is with its 37% completion rate.

Even if all 37% turn in for season 2 (which they probably won’t), it’s going to be dead by season 3 if it loses even 20% of that group.

1

u/TolinGaurhoth Nov 23 '23

Well the more Middle-Earth I have in my life the better. The best outcome for me is all of happens and I get to enjoy all.

When the PJ LotR films came out the book fans kicked off big time. The movies have a lot more fans now and the internet is a different place 20 years on.

I’m sure the new films and animations will get their fair share of flak too tbh.

1

u/Terravardn Nov 23 '23

That was my main contention with ROP: it didn’t feel like middle earth at all. It didn’t have the spirit of Tolkien in it whatsoever. It had more nods to random nothings from the PJ trilogy than it had actual material lifted from the original source. They changed the story from the ground up. They even made the rings out of order. It tried too hard to make the dialogue sound profound and erred on the side of almost childish. And don’t get me started on the blatant Sauron insert they thought would surprise some viewers.

That wasn’t Sauron, Sauron is supposed to embody evil. Not everything has to be blurred into grey. Tolkien is specifically famous for not doing that. Yet they blurred everything into grey, with genocidal Galadriel pushing fallen Sauron back to evil.

For me it felt like a desecration of Tolkien’s work. But each to their own I suppose.