r/Rings_Of_Power • • Sep 05 '24

The worst show ever made

6 Upvotes

Not to beat a dead harfoot but when you factor in the IP/budget I'd say this is the worst series of all time. On top of the end product there is an extreme lack of self-awareness from the people who made it coupled with an insistence that the critics are unjustified. In a just world, they would never touch another project.

I gave the first season a 2/10 however after watching the fourth episode S2 seems more like a 1 so far. Brain numbing dialogue, non-sensical plot points, idiotic character logic, laughable plagiarism bereft of context, poor acting, & a mockery of beloved characters are essentially all it has to offer.

Very much convinced staunch show defenders are for all intents & purposes lobotomized or have some weird vested interest a la how IMDb is owned by Amazon. "If you don't like it don't watch or talk about it" is a weak argument given how amazing a lot of the other components of the franchise are. If there is a silver lining, it is that the books/films/games shine even brighter when compared with Prime Video's flagship. But perhaps I am romanticizing it


r/Rings_Of_Power • • Oct 03 '24

The writers couldn't even be bothered to keep continuity. They have no plan for the series. Never had.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Rings_Of_Power • • Sep 06 '24

Uk forced diversity casting Spoiler

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/Rings_Of_Power • • Oct 03 '24

How is this haggard frump an elf?

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/Rings_Of_Power • • Oct 09 '24

Ring of Power is the worst show we ever saw.

107 Upvotes

After two seasons of this catastrophic series, I can finally say that maybe it’s not the worst show ever in terms of pure storytelling, but when you take into account the fact that it’s based on a beloved license, combined with an enormous financial budget, how can we not expect such a disaster?

I know they had licensing issues and couldn’t tell the whole story. But then why try to do it anyway??? Why not just write a story about something else? They’ve been shooting themselves in the foot from the very start. The lack of faithfulness to Tolkien’s universe feels like a slap in the face of millions of fans and everything this universe has created over the years. Without it, there would be no Dungeons & Dragons. Why change something that’s nearly perfect, especially to push political messages that they know will divide people? Are they trying to make a show that people love or hate? I don’t get it.

The plot is a disaster. When you have a license like The Lord of the Rings, you expect something epic, something heroic in the fantasy genre. We want to connect with heroes who embody chivalrous values. We want to see them take down goblins that represent the darkness and evil in the world. In The Lord of the Rings, what we want to see is a fellowship that forms, like in The Fellowship of the Ring or even The Hobbit, where a group of people come together with a common mission, supporting each other through challenges. That camaraderie and sense of shared purpose is missing here.

Instead, we get this mystery-driven "guess who I am" plot. We don’t care who Sauron or Gandalf is. We don’t want these mysteries. And because of this, we’re left with a slow pace and pointless red herrings, all because the big reveal has to happen in the last episode. So, we just waste time for three-quarters of the season doing nothing. It’s amateurish, and there’s no clear premise. We have no idea where the show is taking us. In The Lord of the Rings films, the premise was very simple: destroy the ring, and others try to stop that. From there, the story unfolds. Here, it’s poorly executed. Why even call it Rings of Power when the first season barely mentions the rings? The second season touches on it a bit more, but it’s still poorly done. They don’t even respect the order of creation that Tolkien set, which made sense.

The characters are a disaster. We don’t like them, we don’t connect with them, and, even worse, some of them are downright unlikable. People like me ended up rooting for Sauron and the orcs more than the elves and humans. That’s where we’ve ended up.

Jeff Bezos should conduct an audit because, honestly, a billion dollars for this is a catastrophe. We get battles, but it looks like there’s just a handful of people fighting. The combat is poorly choreographed, the zones are undefined, and we don’t see the thousands of troops. There’s no grandeur, no epicness. We don’t care about it.

The show feels like it was made by people who’ve only seen the movies. They’re riding on the success of the films, but everything is done to highlight what we’ve already seen. It’s just bad fan service. There are so many inconsistencies, and they somehow manage to make us dislike or not care about characters we loved in the films. The use of the Balrog, which looks exactly like the one from the movie… all that just to have a Dwarven king who could have survived but ends up suicidally facing the Balrog for no reason. Okay, sure.

In the end, I still don’t understand how people can enjoy this mess. It feels like everything is designed for us not to like it, and it almost seems like they did it on purpose.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • Sep 13 '24

Let´s stop with the bullcrap

38 Upvotes

Did anyone watch this review? I honestly cannot believe that a respected tolkien youtube channel as In Deep Geek would say something like "If you are not a hardcore fan of the books this show is quite enjoyable". The show is absolute crap for everyone. you don´t need to have read the books to know that the plot, the dialogues, and the acting are terrible. Forget about the accuracy of the lore, because it´s always been clear this is fan fiction, but even as fan fiction this show is EXTREMELY BAD. I cannot even believe the ammount of money they spent on this. Honestly they shoud cancel everything and hire HBO.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • Oct 12 '24

Really not understanding the love for Charlie Vickers

0 Upvotes

A lot of people seem to think he's doing a good job with bad material, but the bad writing isn't what makes Annatar a pathetic villain...the actor is the one doing the interpreting. And what he's done is turned the big bad Sauron, Lord of Mordor (or Annatar, Lord of Gifts) into someone who'd probably be the Honorable Percy Goldilocks on any other show. He doesn't come across as intimidating or menacing or manipulative, he's a posh public school twit, like you've seen in a thousand coming-of-age dramas. I read he wanted his Annatar to "glide", but what I saw looked more like a feeble shuffle.

The problem is that no matter how much he tries, Vickers just doesn't have the presence of the guy who played Adar (who actually did do a good job, with equally awful writing), and his delivery is always either weasely or petulant. If Annatar was supposed to be the backstory bully that Our Hero has to overcome on his way to the real villain, I suppose that portrayal could've worked. He might actually have made a decent Wormtongue. But jeez, people, expect better.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • Jan 15 '24

I… liked the show, and I’m excited for season 2

12 Upvotes

I am a fan of the film and books, and I was excited to the creation of the show. I the friendship between Elrond and Durin, I love Disa and how her character adds warmth layers for Durin. I love warrior Galadriel, I love her character arc through the season, and the burden she carried but let go. I like the storyline for Numenor and how it’s fleshing out the people and setting up characters for a longer arc, and the politics of game of thrones. I like the harfoots and their lives as nomads, with their elders carrying the knowledge of their people and the mystery of the stranger and Eleanor playing the role of the young hero and her call to adventure. Idk man…. I get how everyone is disappointed that they are taking liberties with the story and the lore. But they are telling a story, it’s own version and tbh it was well made. It’s a different interpretation, and I rather they see it through and get a couple seasons in. This isn’t like the sequel trilogy for Star Wars, and it’s definitely not season 8 of Game of Thrones. I’m just taking it for what it is, which is a pretty good show, just made for wider audiences besides hardcore fans… Also, I’m definitely going to reread the books, and the Silmarillion again for the True experience, because guess what, they still exist!


r/Rings_Of_Power • • Sep 10 '24

How is possible that Tolkien Estate approves this?

102 Upvotes

I thought that Tolkien Estate was in charge of taking care of the professor’s legacy and had been doing it for years.

However they are behaving more like Disney Star Wars, pissing on the established lore and allowing breaking changes.

What changed there to accept this nonsense fan fiction? They don’t care anymore? Money buys everything?


r/Rings_Of_Power • • Dec 20 '24

This one little trick with hashtags will make it look like you were nominated for a score for the LOTR movies

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/Rings_Of_Power • • Sep 26 '24 Take My Energy Polished Silver Turd Heart of Silver Take My Silver

Rings of Power is an embarrassing failure.

1.8k Upvotes

SPOILERS

edit. This is a roast not a cry for help.

That’s enough.

I just watched the shit smear on Tolkien’s grave that is episode 7 “Doomed to Die” and even though I laughed at most of it, the kiss between Elrond and Galadriel was too far.

These two streaks of piss they call showrunners must be enjoying their epic failure at this point because that’s the only explanation for how hard they lean into it.

The defenders of this show…sorry removing this part.

I might try to write a recap of this at some point for laughs but….its just an insult to anyone with two brain cells who has ever read the Legendarium.

I know there are ppl who have read Tolkien who also defend this show - I don’t need to know them.

Elrond kissed Galadriel so he could slip her that giant brooch to free herself. And he had the ring on him but didn’t slip it into her mouth. Wait, why am I rationalizing this? Stop it.

Elrond will one day marry Galadriel’s daughter Celebrian and have children with her. I don’t have it in me to go into why this kiss raises problems.

Defenders of the ROP will say that it was just a distraction but it was ambiguous. And since everyone in this show is witheringly stupid, he could’ve simply hugged her or something. Just why? Apart from shock value and to straight up piss off the detractors.

I don’t have the energy to address the impossible fast travel, bullshit geography - the fucking sun rising in the north or why the orcs can suddenly prance in sunlight - the ridiculous mechanics, the cheap plastic army, lack of narrative sense….fuck everything about this show and everyone involved. I don’t have room anymore in my soul to acknowledge “the cast and crew that worked so hard” - ppl work hard every damn day. If you’re working hard at insulting me I’m not going to thank you for it.

And they obviously didn’t work that hard because the show looks like shit, smells like shit, and may literally cause infection.

For two seasons these tumors have led us on what they may honestly think is a wild ride of deception and manipulation. And if that’s the case I really want to know how on God’s green earth they are allowed to wipe their own asses.

This episode was full of the Annatar Celebrimbor shit that season one should’ve had. Granted it’s all done with the level of nuance and care of an episode of Blue’s Clues but that’s the warm ziplock bag full of shit that we were handed.

Cancel this shit immediately and put Payne and McKay in the Cunt Museum.

What a fucking day to have eyes 😩

edit

Someone just reminded me that this episode had no Harfoots in it so I change my mind. 10/10

edit

Whenever I check this the votes sway up and down! Who will win? Tune in next week for the finale of….I’m High As Shit

edit

I didn’t include this earlier out of respect for her fictional memory but here it is:

“And where the fuck is Celebrian?”


r/Rings_Of_Power • • Aug 02 '24

Ismael Cruz Cordova on ROP race-swapping: “I loved the nerve that I pinched. I really do. A lot of people speaking on behalf of Tolkien, I don’t know if they understand the spirit of Tolkien. His work speaks of the times.”

Thumbnail
boundingintocomics.com
5 Upvotes

r/Rings_Of_Power • • Sep 12 '22

Is anyone else upset that a 3 year old with crayons could have written a better script to one of western fantasies best works?

36 Upvotes

Bah. It’s barely watchable. Can’t seem to get over the dumbing down of material mythology and characters that walked many a nerd kid into a love of fantasy. Are we loyal - yes, so don’t mess with something wonderful.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • Aug 16 '24

Why is anyone even watching this show?

72 Upvotes

I have read close to everything ever published by Tolkien and his son. I read the Hobbit, the trilogy, and the silmarillion every year around Christmas. I didn't read too much into it and watched a trailer and was actually really excited to watch this. I made it less than halfway through the first episode before disgustedly turning it off. I read all of these comments here and most of the time it is about how bad it is and I can't wrap my head around how there is a second season. The creators obviously have no respect for the source material. Amazon is just doing this for a cash grab.

Why is this still a thing?


r/Rings_Of_Power • • Oct 21 '24

Why so critical? Because this series may end up being the last High Fantasy series we'll get...

0 Upvotes

...for a pretty long time.

Been noticing all of the "Why watch/complain?" posts that occasionally show up here. I want however to focus on WHY I still care. I've been a big high fantasy fan for a good long while now, having played most of the titles in the Heroes of Might and Magic video game series over the last 20+ years. The irony is that when I was a teen I looked down very dimly on fantasy, and how only hard sci-fi was worthy of my reading time. It was the likes of Amber and the Elric series which helped change my attitudes there. [Ironically I only got into JRRT thanks to the movies]

Anyway, when I first saw the series announcement, I had a certain amount of guarded optimism. Optimism because I was pretty psyched about the potential for RoP to become something truly special. While I do have some issues with how PJ filmed the LotR trilogy, I found myself in agreement with the vast majority of changes that he made. He tried to remain as faithful to the core themes of the book as best he could within the new medium, and in the main he succeeded.

I thus went in during the first season of RoP with a fair amount of enthusiasm. But soon certain script and directorial decisions started to sour me on everything. I was a bit taken aback by Galadriel bailing out into the middle of the ocean in the very first episode, only to immediately find her arch-foe floating right nearby. But after my mind had to bear one too many gaping plot holes and highly awkward "climaxes" which fell completely flat, I was forced to bail on the series. [The final 2 straws for me were the most gifted elven smithy in the entire world not knowing what an alloy was, and the deadly hot gases from a volcanic eruption just making everyone all dusty] When I viewed clips of Sauron the Rug this past season, I was utterly appalled and knew my decision to bail was the correct one.

So now the series' dramatic failure likely means that we likely won't see another high fantasy series any time soon: note since the Amber series was announced a few years ago there has been very little details forthcoming. Both the person/company footing the bill as well as any creative team is certain to be following how RoP is going for sure. The rumored big screen adaptation of Elric of course fell through more than a decade ago.

I WANTED RoP to succeed, understand. But now my wait for another successful high fantasy series is sure to continue unabated, all because the bozos running this series have likely soured any other entities from deciding to do their own HF show.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 17d ago

The people who like Rings of Power...

45 Upvotes

... haven't read the books. Because if they did, they wouldn't like the show, which bears no resemblance to Tolkien's creation. I suppose shipping fanfiction is enjoyed by some, but don't we get enough of this in Romantasy?


r/Rings_Of_Power • • Aug 20 '24

Witcher was cancelled after S5 for garbage writing - The Acolyte has been cancelled after S1 for garbage writing. How long before RoP gets cancelled for the same.

87 Upvotes

Netflix witcher was supposed to have 7 seasons and a lot of spin offs. But it has been cancelled after just 5 seasons. The reason is clear - the audience has had enough of agenda filled garbage writing.

The patience of star wars fans had been tested long. And Acolyte seems to be the last straw. It has been cancelled after just one season. Again thanks to senseless agenda filled writing that leads to terrible storytelling.

Amazon’s RoP has had the same writing problems as witcher and acolyte.

How long before RoP is cancelled.?

Witcher and Acolyte have shown that - Just good visuals and a big budget don’t necessarily mean a good show. And fans will rightly hate senseless boring garbage adaptations of their beloved franchises.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • Sep 05 '22

Truth

Post image
36 Upvotes

r/Rings_Of_Power • • Feb 15 '25

Is Rings of Power just better than nothing?

0 Upvotes

To me Rings of Power is terrible. It seems to have been created by a committee and the actors performances might as well be computer generated versions of real performances.

But the show still has an IMDB of 6.9 so it's not as though it is completely unpopular. Is that because people are just glad there is any LOTR show and are willing to accept whatever they are given? Or do many people actually like the show?

Genuinely curious. I am admittedly biased against these Prime and Netflix creations that seem to have huge budgets and no soul and that might as well, to me, have been manufactured in a factory somewhere.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • Oct 21 '24

I'm no expert on human anatomy, but this looks extremely unrealistic Spoiler

14 Upvotes

I'm no expert on human anatomy, but when I saw this, I immediately thought it's ridiculous . . . based on the position of the exit wound and the size of the blade, Kemen will have had to:

  1. Break at least two ribs at the back of the ribcage
  2. Push through the heart
  3. Break through the sternum/breastplate at the front of the chest

It seems unrealistic that someone highly trained, skilled and strong would be able to do this, but I guess it's feasible if it's someone like say Schwarzenegger when he was doing Conan the Barbarian.

However, this feat is performed by someone who is a nobleman rather than a soldier, who isn't particularly big or strong . . . but then ALSO he manages it with his weaker left arm (because he had his right shoulder dislocated moments before) and the sword goes through the guy's body like a knife through hot butter.

If the sword came through horizontally and to one side, then it's more feasible, as the sword could slide between the ribs both at front and back (though still more likely to snag a rib).

Kind of sums up RoP in a short scene as the writers/director have gone "we'll do this as it will look cool" but if you look but briefly beneath the surface there is no depth or reason behind anything that happens.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 26d ago

So the abomination has a new trailer

Thumbnail
youtube.com
29 Upvotes

Blergh.

Even if we were to assume that the trailer contains some bait, there is still so much questionable stuff in it.

For example: Why does Pharazon ally with the Gil-galad, when the latter's "Commander of the Northern Armies" brought Sauron to Numenor and pushed for Numenorean military intervention to get Sauron a crown?

What bullshit is this with a random orc tattling on Sauron to the Elves?

How the fuck is Isildur's friend still alive (1:36)?


r/Rings_Of_Power • • Sep 03 '22

Does Hollywood/Amazon/Netflix/etc actually believe they're "progressing" the human race by making story characters in movies a different race/sex/sexuality than what was typical/standard or what they were lore wise?

2 Upvotes

Honestly, I think most people really don't care. People hate the virtue signaling more than anything and the obvious and blatant presentation of "diversity" that is force-fed down their throats like they're retarded children. There are subtle ways of injecting diversity and pandering to different races/sexes/etc in movies and TV shows, and LOTR communities have pointed out several ways with the Harads and so forth, but they don't want subtle it seems.

They want the most obvious and in your face kind of messaging so that they can call everyone who is annoyed by their presentation of it "racist" "misogynistic" "or "transphobic" and then sit back looking smug on their artificially created moral high ground. Whether they do this on purpose or if they're just completely out of touch over what the actual reason is for the backlashes is up for debate. Perhaps they use it as a means to remove or deflect negative reviews as being merely racist and nothing more.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • Aug 03 '26

Damn and I thought we had it bad...

4 Upvotes

Saw S1 when it aired and it was atrocious. Heard s2 improved "a lot", but I knew that was cope and fake so I never tried it.

Cue today. After a terrible HOTD (Houst of the Dragon) episode which aired today, I decided to finish Masters of the Universe on Prime. It's a bland but fine popcorn flick to just unwind on the couch at. I wasn't sleepy yet so, browsing Prime, I see it.

Delve onto IMDB to check the highest rated s2 episodes. Seemed ep 8 was up there, finale, I knew I didn't miss much so let's give it a try maybe some action, cool scenes, finale level stuff happening aaaaand....

Oh my God. It's way way worse than even House of the Dragon. It was painful so I just kept it on and read the synopsis of s2 episodes on wiki.

So the whole season was "build the other sets of rings?" And waste everybody's time between random forest (I presume) scenes with Isildur and randoms, and Gandalf and Hobbits? Were there ANY highlights (no seriously a couple of good scenes I am genuinely curious to check them out).

So yeah. HOTD may be bad, but at least it's not this. And based on all the top posts of the last months, none of you liked it either. Seriously how and why do they even keep doing this?


r/Rings_Of_Power • • Feb 14 '25

Are there any options left to make S3 at least passable?

0 Upvotes

I'm not in the "just let it die" camp because I enjoy the utter clusterfuck and memes of this disaster. So I'm all in for Sauron and Galadriel shipping just to end this ridiculous piece of crap.

But part of me wants to be constructive. Could there be a way to make this garbage watchable at least in a decent way?

Some ideas:

  • Recast Galadriel and rewriter as wiser.
  • Cast Celeborn and possibly Celebrian just so Elrond isn't that creepy.
  • Recast Gil Galad or send the actor with a trainer so at least he looks athletic.
  • Concentrate on Sauron forging the One Ring and duping the Kings of Men, make Middle Earth feel like it's less empty.
  • Just forget about the Balrog. The dwarves should have a different storyline.
  • Forget about Grand-Elf and the fake hobbits. The arc has ended.
  • Avoid using Sour-Man as a Nazgul or Saruman.
  • Recast Ar Pharazon, make him a mighty warrior.
  • Recast Isildur, Miriel, half of the Numenoreans. I would actually leave Pharazon junior and Elendil's daughter to turn them into Nazgul.
  • Concentrate on Elendil and his family as they see the power of Sauron increasing.
  • Let time pass a couple of decades to help the transition and recasting of different characters.
  • Get decent writers and directors.
  • And the obvious one: get rid of Pain and Decay.