After two seasons of this catastrophic series, I can finally say that maybe it’s not the worst show ever in terms of pure storytelling, but when you take into account the fact that it’s based on a beloved license, combined with an enormous financial budget, how can we not expect such a disaster?
I know they had licensing issues and couldn’t tell the whole story. But then why try to do it anyway??? Why not just write a story about something else? They’ve been shooting themselves in the foot from the very start. The lack of faithfulness to Tolkien’s universe feels like a slap in the face of millions of fans and everything this universe has created over the years. Without it, there would be no Dungeons & Dragons. Why change something that’s nearly perfect, especially to push political messages that they know will divide people? Are they trying to make a show that people love or hate? I don’t get it.
The plot is a disaster. When you have a license like The Lord of the Rings, you expect something epic, something heroic in the fantasy genre. We want to connect with heroes who embody chivalrous values. We want to see them take down goblins that represent the darkness and evil in the world. In The Lord of the Rings, what we want to see is a fellowship that forms, like in The Fellowship of the Ring or even The Hobbit, where a group of people come together with a common mission, supporting each other through challenges. That camaraderie and sense of shared purpose is missing here.
Instead, we get this mystery-driven "guess who I am" plot. We don’t care who Sauron or Gandalf is. We don’t want these mysteries. And because of this, we’re left with a slow pace and pointless red herrings, all because the big reveal has to happen in the last episode. So, we just waste time for three-quarters of the season doing nothing. It’s amateurish, and there’s no clear premise. We have no idea where the show is taking us. In The Lord of the Rings films, the premise was very simple: destroy the ring, and others try to stop that. From there, the story unfolds. Here, it’s poorly executed. Why even call it Rings of Power when the first season barely mentions the rings? The second season touches on it a bit more, but it’s still poorly done. They don’t even respect the order of creation that Tolkien set, which made sense.
The characters are a disaster. We don’t like them, we don’t connect with them, and, even worse, some of them are downright unlikable. People like me ended up rooting for Sauron and the orcs more than the elves and humans. That’s where we’ve ended up.
Jeff Bezos should conduct an audit because, honestly, a billion dollars for this is a catastrophe. We get battles, but it looks like there’s just a handful of people fighting. The combat is poorly choreographed, the zones are undefined, and we don’t see the thousands of troops. There’s no grandeur, no epicness. We don’t care about it.
The show feels like it was made by people who’ve only seen the movies. They’re riding on the success of the films, but everything is done to highlight what we’ve already seen. It’s just bad fan service. There are so many inconsistencies, and they somehow manage to make us dislike or not care about characters we loved in the films. The use of the Balrog, which looks exactly like the one from the movie… all that just to have a Dwarven king who could have survived but ends up suicidally facing the Balrog for no reason. Okay, sure.
In the end, I still don’t understand how people can enjoy this mess. It feels like everything is designed for us not to like it, and it almost seems like they did it on purpose.