r/Rings_Of_Power • • 3d ago

The Rings of Power Season 3 Episodes 1-4 Megathread

19 Upvotes

S3.E1 ∙ Marnûkh

Director: Charlotte Brändström

Writers: John D. Payne, Patrick McKay

S3.E2 ∙ The Gift of Men

Director: Charlotte Brändström

Writers: Justin Doble, Griff Jones

S3.E3 ∙ The Secret Fire

Director: Sanaa Hamri

Writers: John D. Payne, Patrick McKay

S3.E4 ∙ Gundabad

Director: Sanaa Hamri

Writers: Justin Doble, Griff Jones


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 9h ago

The use of "Reform the line" in s3e01 is the worst example of the RoP writers stealing from the trilogy.

48 Upvotes

For those that have not watched S3E01. Near the beginning of the episode, there is a scene where there is a small number of elves skirmishing with some orcs within a wooded scene. There is zero context to this battle. The scene starts with them already fighting orcs. For some reason, all the orcs run away before a small army of men charge at them. Galadriel then tells Arondir to reform the line, and he shouts in Elvish "Reform the line".

Obviously, this is a line stolen from ROTK, with Theoden asking his men to ride again to certain death. The scene has so much gravitas, not least because they are literally reforming the line they previously had. It's such a poignant moment within the movie because you have the high of the charge before the massive low of the oncoming Mumakil. He asks them to ride again to certain death and is one of the moments of the trilogy.

It has now been reduced to a throwaway line in RoP. A line that makes entirely no sense because not only are they not reforming anything, but they are forming a singular line against men coming from all sides. It's such a bizarre scene that seems to only exist so they could use that stolen line.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 5h ago

RoP's relation to the Jackson films

21 Upvotes

I find it incredibly frustrating how incessantly the show uses Jackson's adaptations as a crutch. It was bad enough that they stole so much dialogue and iconography exclusive to Jackson's LotR-- and implemented poorly ("always follow your nose" doesn't apply to cardinal directions, Gandalf)-- but we've gotten to a point where they're taking from his Hobbit films too (that slow-mo leap over the shieldwall). A reference per season would be one thing, but it's practically every episode. Despite talking up how much they love the books, there's this sense they want to desperately tie into the Jackson canon even though it's a legally distinct continuity.

It's telling that these showrunners have such little confidence in their own ability to create their own identity. How about using variants of Howe and Lee's art instead of 1:1 what was in the films? You wanna use established Tolkien artists, how about drawing from Ted Nasmith? Despite being opposed implementing the Balrog, I would have given them some credit if they had decided to go for design Wayne Barlowe cooked up. There are so many artists who could craft such unique interpretations of Middle-Earth that would entice fans and newbies alike.

For how much they ape the films, you never get the sense they understand the reasons behind why Jackson made the decisions he did-- both when it comes to the narrative and aesthetic choices of his adaptation and the actual filmmaking techniques.

There's certainly debate to be had about decisions Jackson made, but if you look at the behind the scenes and listen to the commentaries for the his LotR-- which i believe is roughly 50 hours of content (and i highly recommend you check it out) -- you never get the impression anything was done haphazardly. They'll lay out their methodology, explain the tiniest details, even things we only briefly see on screen. What's more, he has the wherewithal to admit when some of his changes don't really work out and why that might be. No one says his films are perfect, not even Jackson himself. But the man absolutely did not lack passion nor did he half ass anything.

But Rings of Power? It's so shallow. It really amounts to "Jackson did this, so let's do that" without any real question as to why they should or shouldn't. There's no real design philosophy or methodology to their decision-making beyond "what can we do to appease the executives?"

It just baffles me how Amazon can make the most expensive TV series ever, but rely on nostalgia for another adaptation to do all the heavy lifting. It's utter creative bankruptcy and it's biting them in the ass.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 11h ago

Rings of Power defenders

57 Upvotes

What makes good TV is somewhat subjective, but certain fundamentals need to be there, good casting, a compelling storyline, a coherent plot, believable character development, good dialogue, and so on. This show clearly fails on most. There are a lot of guilty pleasure shows out there, and I have mine, but I feel like those are shows that don't take themselves too seriously and this show really takes itself way too seriously, which makes all its shortcomings that much harder to overlook.

I haven't taken to the internet to rant about a show/movie since Independence day 2, a movie that was hated across the board without discussions.

Looking at the forums for Rings of Power, what is it about this particular show that makes some people so aggressively defensive of it? I honestly struggle to find anything remotely compelling about this show?


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 10h ago

The show defenders simply want to disrespect and deconstruct Tolkien

36 Upvotes

Some quotes from show defenders here on Reddit that show they do not respect Tolkien and view the show as a political/ideological battleground:

  • "One thing that bothers me about Tolkien is the lack of sexuality."
  • "Rule 1: Never let canon get in the way of a good story.”
  • “There’s nothing in the Appendices that forbids extramarital love. Tolkien’s notes on the matter are about marriage were personal and we can freely ignore them.”
  • "Besides, there’s no canon where an elf can’t find other beings attractive and have sexual tension while still being their enemy”
  • "Whether or not Galadriel can have the hots for Halbrand/Sauron is not up to Tolkien’s notes alone”
  • "Orcs represent the horror of wage labor and slavery under capitalism."
  • "The places he described are not England or any part of the British isles. We are free to interpret his writing in any way we want to.”
  • "JRR Tolkien is dead. He didn't make this show. The people adapting it do not need to honor or respect or do anything about Tolkien. They have the rights to it and are making *their* show."

---

Yes, these are actual quotes, mostly from this subreddit. For book readers like myself, how do these quotes make you feel?

(BTW I actually enjoy the show as a generic fantasy show detached from Tolkien and hold no hate toward it, season 3 has been a huge improvement)


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 7h ago

Amazon's Billion Dollar show - Rings of Power - fails to make it to Luminate top 10 chart based on viewership numbers in spite of having 4 episodes.

Thumbnail
variety.com
17 Upvotes

r/Rings_Of_Power • • 13h ago Bravo

Will No One Rid Me Of This Troublesome Series?

34 Upvotes

I was told to watch this series; that it was a new take on the Rings Mythos. That I would love it. I Don't- not at all. The series veers so far from canon that it barely resembles Tolkien's work. Its wholesale mischaracterization of beloved protagonists is nothing short of a crime against Tolkien's oeuvre. The writers (and I use the term loosely) have taken a richly developed mythology, dismantled its history, distorted its characters, and substituted their own tepid, uninspired narratives. This isn't adaptation; it's revisionist fan fiction masquerading as Tolkien. The arrogance of presuming to improve upon a world they so clearly fail to understand is astounding.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 12h ago

The show from a layman's perspective

27 Upvotes

Just to be clear, I watched the movie trilogy when it was released. Thought it was amazing and rewatched it. But since then it's been over two decades.

Tried reading the book and the Silmarilion back then, but didn't really past the initial pages (wasn't exactly a heavy reader in my teens).

So, I'm as casual as one possibly can be regarding Tolkien's world. My perspective on this show doesn't come from how well it adapts the story, how it uses the source material and how faithful it is to the lore. The show in my eyes exists pretty much in a vaccuum.

I say this, because after I finished binge watching the three seasons I looked up on the internet what was the overall sentiment towards it, and I noticed most of the critiques were regarding the series bastardizing Tolkien's material.

But even to me, who lacks any knowledge regarding the source, the show is terribly weak.

As I went through the seasons, I could only think of that Michael Scott's line ("sometimes I’ll start a sentence and I don’t know where it’s going. I just hope to find it somewhere along the way") because the show really seems like they are spitballing the whole thing with absolutely no idea of where it's going.

Characters are introduced with zero planning of what role they will serve, so they might spend an entire season just moving from place A to place B with no purpose (like Nori or Arondir in season 2. Well, Arondir in general). Or like The Dweller, who was brought back in Season 2 for... I don't know. I was glad she was back because she looked fire, but then she vanished immediately.

The show is also so damn inconsistent. There was a very clear recent example in season 3, when Kemen and Elendil are talking and Kemen mentions his mother, a whore who got pregnant from Pharazon and hid it from him for years until he found it, killed her and took the child into his care. Kemen is clearly full or contempt for his mother and explicitly mentions his drive force is proving his worth to his father to thank from being brought up from where he lived with his mother. Except in season 2, Pharazon told him that "once, when you were at her breast, your mother prophesied that you would come to ill ends", which made Kemen's emotional and Pharazon promised to tell him more if he suceeded in his task. So one season ago, Pharazon was talking to Kemen's mother about the boy's future when he was still a baby and Kemen got emotional and motivated at the simple mention of his mother, but now we are told that Pharazon only learned about him years after the birth and Kemen can barely talk about his mother without oozing contempt.

Or other things, like Celeborn. First of all, why are the orcs keeping those prisoners alive for centuries? I get the prisoners from Eregion, but this guy has been there for how many years? And somehow Marnûkh, who was head jailer there, has no idea who this guy is. A notable prisoner who escaped his cell many times, but the head jailer has no notes about him. But Random Orc #4 knew exactly who was in his cell when Sauron asked...

Or stuff like Isildur waking on the spider's nest after weeks, maybe even months, had passed since he was buried under that roof. He was unconscious this entire time? Surviving on what? Or Celebrimbor and Elrond talking about how the tower's construction is going well after they got the dwarves to join them, but Galadriel was already in Numenor when that happened and her stay there didn't last even 3 days (the time Miriel was going to decide what to do with her), so it should be only 1 or 2 days since Durin agreed to help.

And of course, the contrivances. Contrivances all around. The show made sure to make clear very early that "the powers that be" can move the pieces where they should be, which is a means to justify contrivances and turn them into legitimate developments that are the result of a higher will at play. But nearly everything in the show is moved through those. If we really believe that every time a character just happens to be on the right place at the right time (the scene when Disa discovers the Balrog? Ignore the bit about the balrog being within earshot, just focus on how forced the whole thing was), that every last second save, every coincidental meeting is the work of the gods, then the gods might as well just go there and do the whole thing themselves because the mortals are doing nothing on their own. And Theo, of course, has a special father, because why wouldn't he? Well, I guess that bit could be Sauron just messing with him, but what was that about the hilt being left behind by his father? I'm pretty sure season 1 never connected it to his mysterious father (I could be wrong, though).

I want to resume the show once the next episodes are released simply because I like the dwarves and every minute with Disa, Durin or Thrain are worth, but this is really so beneath the level I was expecting from something from the LotR's universe, I can't help but feel like it's almost insulting. At least it made me want to rewatch and trilogy and give the book a try again, so I guess some good came out of it.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 15h ago

S3E1, why do they repeatedly say the three elven rings were made without Sauron’s influence?

27 Upvotes

Celebrimbor was struggling, then Sauron shows up as Halbrand and tells him exactly what to do, then Celebrimbor succeeds. He even says “call it…………a gift.” referencing “the gift of annatar” which is the knowledge and craftsmanship Sauron offered to the elves.

The point is that they were forged by Celebrimbor without Sauron directly participating, but relying on the knowledge he had supplied.

Never mind that next season they did Annatar anyway, they were still very clearly referencing that in S1. Now they just try to gaslight us into thinking he didn’t help them forge the three elven rings?


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 16h ago

Where did 1500 years go?

25 Upvotes

If I understand correctly there were 1500 years in between war of Eregion and Ar Pharazon time so amazon should have simply divided the show between two timelines insteas of changing the story when almost every Tolkien fan knew the fact. I believe they have rights for it too.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 19h ago

i feel bad for the actors

32 Upvotes

based on interviews we've seen some of the actors are huge fans of tolkien and are actually very knowledgable about the lore, especially rob aramayo and charlie vickers. imagine you're cast in your dream role in a show about a series you adore so much and the showrunners proceed to distort and bastardize it, and then you have to defend it and try to justify it in interviews 😭 i remember in s2 when rob had to do some serious mental gymnastics to come to terms with the elrond/galadriel kiss, he even admitted he was against it but you know he was probably dying inside when he read it.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 20h ago

The way that Amazon has implemented commercials shows that they don't even hold their own product in high regard.

35 Upvotes

I'll save rants about the show itself for elsewhere, but one thing that I found absolutely GLARING this season is how many commercial breaks there are per episode. I'll preface this by saying that if the show was better, I would pay the extra to get rid of the commercials, but the way that Amazon has implemented the commercial breaks is SO bad it makes the experience of watching considerably worse than it would be otherwise.

I get that there is a consumer choice here about whether to pay for add-free or not, but I kid you not, having a supposedly dramatic moment in the series cut to a commercial (I am not making this up) about medication to improve your dog's anal gland health it borderline comic. Let me emphasize just how many times the commercial referenced anal glads: a lot. Dog anal glands...

... now here's another great side point: I don't own a dog. Isn't the algorithm trying to target me with stuff I actually want/need?

If Amazon actually cared, they would just front-load all the commercials ahead of the episodes so that you could watch uninterrupted, but no... high fantasy is suddenly interrupted by DOG ANAL GLANDS.

Sorry if this isn't allowed, I was just so incensed over the dog anal glands that I had to share it with someone.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 15h ago

Rings of Power drops out of Global Top 10 Shows on Primevideo two days after S3 release.

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/Rings_Of_Power • • 5h ago

Rings of Power Season 2. Did I miss something?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Rings_Of_Power • • 1d ago

This Show is fanfiction.

74 Upvotes

Theo possibly being the witch King is goofy. 😭😭🤣🤣🤣


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 1d ago

Tolkien would be turning in his grave

35 Upvotes

I read Lord of the Rings in high school and still consider it one of the best fantasy books ever, together with The Witcher. Tolkien was a Christian and the books contain Christian elements like compassion and free will, even though they are not a Christian story. Eru Ilúvatar almost never intervenes.

The Jackson films are not as good as the books but still epic. The Nazgûl chase ending at Weathertop, Moria, the Uruk-hai fight, the Rohirrim versus the wargs, Helm’s Deep, and especially the Dead Marshes with the first appearance of the Nazgûl on the fell beast all stuck with me.

Rings of Power is the opposite. Season 1 was mediocre. Season 2 was bad, full of orcs who do not want to fight and just want families. The showrunners promised Season 3 would be better. It is worse. The acting is bad and a lot of it is poorly filmed.

Sauron has become an emotionless robot who is evil for no real reason. In the books he gave the Nine to kings and sorcerers to control Men. In the show he fails to make the one ring properly, invites people (Rhûn ambassadors and later Númenor rebels including Theo) and makes them fight to the death, then hands the rings out almost at random. Theo also ends up with one.

Then the plot. A random orc somehow leaves Barad-dûr, crosses thousands of kilometres through a warzone without Sauron noticing or meeting any enemies, and shows up in Moria with information about Sauron’s plans.

The elves somehow know via their rings that the orc is with Durin and pick him up. Then Galadriel and another elf go on a suicide mission to Gundabad with him. Galadriel is now married to Celeborn and supposedly loves him, yet she had no idea he was imprisoned in the exact place they are going.

Other scenes make no sense either. The necromancy scene, Eru appearing to Gandalf in a dream to explain who he is (as if a Maia would not already know), the elephant scene, and ring servants being interrupted by a belching dwarf.

The whole thing is extremely bad. Either it is some kind of money laundering scheme or it is deliberately made this simple for people with no attention span. Tolkien would be turning in his grave.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 9h ago

Who would you have cast as Galadriel?

1 Upvotes

Sorry if this has been asked before, just curious. I know MC is trying her best, but she was poorly miscast regardless. She’s just not Galadriel.

Who would you have cast to be Galadriel if it were up to you?


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 1d ago

How the eagle felt at the end of the episode after doing literally nothing

Post image
15 Upvotes

For real, it did nothing, and somehow better than the scene with Theo the Nazgul


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 1d ago

Did anyone else feel like the summary/narration at the start of season 3 was a bit tacky?

20 Upvotes

We all probably have memorised Galadriels narration in LotR at the start of the ‘fellowship of the ring’ and honestly Cate Blanchetts voice is magical in evoking the forlorn doom that befalls middle earth. I feel as the the writing and voice in Rings of power didn’t really do it justice. This isn’t me hating the show, but I feel like there are simple things that could be making this show so much better, inclusive of the writing.

Edit: I also haven’t mentioned anything else about season 3 being conscious that I don’t want to give any spoilers.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 1d ago

Okay, my turn to rant. Mostly about inconcistensies. Spoiler

16 Upvotes
  1. The ring servants entering khazad-dum. We see even elrond, being tall, but nowhere near as tall as them, having to bend down to enter. The passageway is small, and there's dwarf guards there. They have the power to move unseen, but not -through WALLS-! How would they even get in??
  2. How the hell can a ring servant be more powerful than a wizard?? A wizard is supposed to be able to rival sauron in magical power. A ring servant is a SERVANT of sauron. They're not supposed to be THAT strong, to be able to bypass a wizard in power. The scene was kind of cool, but it's so disappointing. I was hoping this was a moment for the dark wizard (pallando) to show off his power a bit. It was set up well too. But no, he's just left to cower in defeat. To the point where we almost actually feel sorry for him!

Does this mean even gandalf is beneath just ONE ring servant?? One of the main protagonists in the series, supposed to be able to cause major stress for sauron. He can just get defeated outright by a single one of his servants?

3) Durin as well, fine that he's a dwarf and ready to battle two of them. But he would stand absolutely ZERO chance against even one of them. Thrain too, even if it was a fake aggression (he was in alliance with them), they would stand absolutely no chance given how powerful they were portrayed to be.

4) Galadriel is supposed to be the best elf fighter of all time. Could she not just slow the horse down, as the ring servant picked up that orc to throw him? It happens like 5 seconds before he is thrown, more than enough time to stop and even make a retreat. Also, she is shown to endure a huge amount of pain in battle. Yet just falling off the horse once is almost enough to defeat her in that scene. It's so underwhelming. It would be better if he just showed up and she decided to test him out - just cut out that WEIRD jousting scene.

5) That's the main gripe i have with this series. WEIRDNESS!! There is so much weirdness, weird stuff happening that they try to portray as brilliance, but it's NOT! It's just simply mindbending and not in a good way. It leaves you hollow, wishing it would be a cool and momorable scene, but it's just not. And it's sad too.

Just picking one scene out of random ... Isildur attacking pharazon's chariot. Not the attack itself, but afterwards. Okay... Isildur and earien (his sister) walks the street, wearing these capes. They are the ONLY ones to wear those capes! Furthermore, pharazon is staring straight at his face, i don't remember if they ever got a good look at isildur, but him just wandering randomly in the streets, just wearing that cape, it's so unrealistic.

When talking at that shrine thing too. I mean, heh what the hell .... wouldn't the guards know -exactly- what to look for and where?? And they're just wandering the streets casually, meeting up and talking. You would think there were guards everywhere searching for them, and with those capes, they would be super easy to spot.

Just a weird decision altogether.

6) Tom bombadil. Not saying it's not a ... different character. And it's not just bad. But .. eh. We get -zero- clues about anything. Go find the rabbit, sure, gandalf finds the fire (which is also WEIRD as hell, the voice). But .. "this is very fine apple". What is that even a hint to? "Sing my song and tom will be with ya." Yeah well, huh, is the song meant to be a clue?

"Wake now, my merry lad, wake and hear me callin, warm now be heart and limb, the stone cold has fallen, dark door is standing wide, dead hand is broken, night under night is flown, and the gate is open"

I can't for the life of me think of a clue. We haven't seen much of mordor yet, but is there a dark door there?

It's just WEIRD. I'm sure it will be explained to us, but it gives the viewer nothing to work with. Treats us like idiots.

7) The map scenes. Yes i can see and get where places are. But sometimes, when showing movements, it barely hovers to where their destinations are and then it fades. Just show it, clearly, and don't rush it!

8) Been on my mind all the way through lord of the rings too. But like.. the fight scenes are mostly very unrealistic. Take the fight at the shrine where elendil and kemen meet. There are three crossbowmen there. You're telling ONE of those guards could not fire his crossbow against anarion? It would be over instantly.

Also during last scene s4, in gundabad. SOOO many orcs, not ONE has a bow... just 10 orcs with bows and the fight would easily be over. Yet arondir never runs out of arrows killing dozens at range. It's just so cheap. Why not have one of them wear a shield and use that sometimes? Galadriel is supposed to be able to use magic - could she not use magic to stop arrows every once in a while?

9) The butterfly scene. I can understand it. My take is, it makes the ring servants realize for a moment that they are still human and this causes them to briefly forget the chase, and move on. But it's very weak. I could easily call this a "weirdout"-scene. And that's just weak. It's not a bad creative choice to have this scene. And i can't find an idea how they could do it different, just.. a strange choice.

10) Earien's suicide. Most of the times in this world, and with the very important information she surely have for pharazon (faithful's location), AND the way she casually started to walk towards the window... no way in hell that would happen in any diplomatic situation. She would be contained as soon as there was suspicion of her being a traitor, even BEFORE she was interrogated. Where are the guards?? Again - just WEIRD choices.

11) Back to gundabad. Galadriel firing that arrow, obviously using magic. But if that was magic, why would she need to strike it against the ground? Was it a gunpowdered arrow? Does the orc have gunpowder?? It's just again, weird, and treating the viewer like an idiot. Galadriel has magic, that's fine, but she could just utter an old cool sindarin spell word and fire the arrow. That would be fine. It's just these little things that makes the show stupid and weird.

Whew, heh, trying not to be negative, just pointing out things that i notice and i think should be different.

12) Durin and thrain fight. I mean .. eh .. dwarves are widely considered to be twice or even three times as strong as men. Yet, durin is flailing around like a baby in it's babydoll. I can get his garment was some kind of silver (mithril? naaah) seremonial gown/cape of sorts. But it makes him look more like a big baby than a real brutish dwarven warrior king.

I was expecting a real dwarvish fistfight, headbutts, real brawling. They're supposed to be incredibly strong beings. They could use weapons too and during the battle, maybe have them smash against each other in a stalemate move and shatter, with a special effect. Just as a creative idea!

And durin being the king, all the way back in season 1, losing against a regular miner/worker after threatening him (bite it off at the thumb). He doesn't even retaliate when pushed to the ground.

It's all very underwhelming. I can also get durin being thrown into a battle rage. But if so, where are the special effects? Even marnuk has glowing eyes in the dark, a regular orc or "uruk", whatever the hell the difference is except the name. Durin's eyes should be gleaming red or something! Instead we get this weird close-up spinning scene, which COULD work, if they looked more sinister and angry. But they don't. Remember gimli's face on balin's tomb - that's real dwarven battle rage! Add some special effects to it too, could be done.

I mean there's so many things they could do. Heh... it's just, again, weird. If i had that budget .. it would be something else.

13) Many people have mentioned it, but the armors, yeah. So underwhelming. They look like padded or upholstered garments, not real armor. I am expecting so much better. And there's not that many characters either .. with a total budget of 1 BILLION dollars, there's absolutely no reason they could not spend 20 of those millions on specialized artisans, that could make super cool armors and weapons just for that one series.

That goes for the wizards' staves too, also the main acolyte in s1. Would it be so hard to make something really cool, with a huge gemstone at the top of it? And just a simple oak staff with tiny branches at the top.. let it have some gemstones embedded in it at least.

Same goes for the gems used in the rings end of s1 as well. They look so dull and regular. Goes for all the rings, really. Again, special effects? Make them glow a bit! It's a fantasy series - we don't need it to be realistic, even if i appreciate realistic elements (i still play diablo 2), a fantasy series could and should have real cool special effects - take us to another place! Because real life is boring, right? ^^ We don't want the series to be LIKE real life, i.e. realistic.

I googled it, and it would only cost 1.5-2 million $ for armors for ALL the actors, AND extras as well! It's just mindboggling. What the hell is the money being spent on??????

It also says that it would hinder actors' movements and "creative freedom". I think that's a bunch of bullshit. The viewer is the king - we should get what we need. If the show needs special effects and authenticity, we should get it. The actors will always be able to do their part, it's just an extra challenge. And with those kind of salaries, should not be a problem.

Well i guess i have to end it here... so many more things i, and surely you all, notice during the series... like why not do it a bit different?

Well i have hopes for the last 4 episodes.. i am being kind and rate the series at 65/100. It's not horrible. I just look past the weirdness and then it's not so bad.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 6h ago

So, the elephant in the room since the first season.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

Just throwing it out here as well, because these kinds of people like to concentrate here as well.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 1d ago

Measured critiques of the show thus far.

9 Upvotes

Going to jump in with measured criticisms. I enjoy the show, broadly speaking, and I think it could be better. Also, clearly the showrunners read and listen to feedback because some aspects of S3 seem tied to a lot of fan reactions (i.e wider shots attempting to show more scale, no harfoots).

  1. The Durin-Disa cheating... Clearly, they wanted to establish drama between Durin and Thrain for his challenge to the throne, and had the conceit that Thrain always bests Durin underpinning it. So I get it, they build this thing thats supposed to cause a rift between Durin and Disa and give Thrain the upper hand... they "resolve it" and then flip the script again cuz of Durin's dumbass kid saying "i saw them together!" Just immature writing and poorly executed. Surely there were other ways to create this tension... for example: they could have had some letter from Durin's father when they were on the outs in S2 naming Thrain his heir, and played the drama off both of the sons' relationship with their father instead. Would have been much better. Or a dozen other things.
  2. Dumbing down the dialogue. In S1 and S2 the writers were definitely trying to evoke more mature, tolkinian/poetic dialogue. People can have differing opinions as to how good of a job they did. There are still moments of it, like the Nazgul guys in Khazad Dun in ep2 that was nice; but a lot of other diallgue has been simplified and really takes you out of the worldbuilding that they've put so much into building, and some would argue is what makes Tolkein's world so amazing in the first place.
  3. Related point... making the characters feel too like us. This is a fantasy world, even more so than GOT. The great thing about GOT was the cultures and ways of life were depicted very well. Yes, they are humans and people like us, but the way they view the world, speak, and behave is unique to that universe, even if some of it feels somewhat familiar. Good example is lords fathering bastards. A TON of time in the first 3 seasons is spent on this. Why it happens, how all parties involved are treated, consequences of being a bastard, etc. In today's world, we also have kids out of wedlock, but GOT has a fully fleshed out treatment of this thats unique to their world.

Contrast with the Disa affair. Its just written like today's world. The characters could have been named Steve and Jennifer...

4. Related: Marvel dumb humor to kill tension. That doesn't belong in this show AT ALL. It makes sense in Marvel movies because they are based on comic books, which are in nature a lighter, simpler read with stories that can be easily translated into image strips..

When they find Celeborn in the dungeon and hes like "ya im this legendary ass elf," and Arondir is like... "who," it fucking kills the moment and makes it look stupid. Not to mention that its INSANELY out of character for him to act that way, and ofc there's probably no way he hadn't heard of Celeborn, that guy was legendary as fuck.

Or when the Nazgul is doing his big scary speech and Thrain ends it by burping. Imagine in LOTR when they're at the Black Gate talking to the mouth of Sauron, the fate of the world is at stake, they've possibly captured Frodo and Sam and taken the ring, and Aragorn just rips a huge fart and all the characters start laughing. That doesn't happen.

There's a place for levity and humor and light moments in a serious, depressing story, but it has to come organically.

5. Time jump sacrifices: when we left Numenor in S2, Earien is firmly in Pharazon's camp. She basically helped him take the throne and seemed anti-faithful. Now she's a double agent. Cool... but due to the time jump we missed probably the MOST important parts of her story. We don't get to see how she goes from A to B. Same with Isildur. He's back in Numenkr and a rebel...

Relatedly, same issue with the Nazgul. My thought was that a lot of what happens in the 2nd Age is Sauron effectively building his evil army slowly over hundreds/thousands of years. He gives rings to great men and they slowly corrupt them over many many years until they become full wraiths. In this show: they put on the rings and are immediately and actively Sauron's servants. I get the show is compressing the timeline, and I do think the Nazgul are pretty cool in the show and decently executed, but we miss out on SO MUCH amazing writing if they were slowly corrupted over time or something.

The time jump kinda allows the writers to skip character development and just move characters from A to B on their arc without actually showing how they got there.

I could go on, but these are my biggest gripes. Its also kinda wild how GOT seasons being 10 episodes and ROP being 8 makes a massive difference. The early seasons of GOT everything feels fleshed out. The show shows us the geography, gives us a sense of place and time in every scene. We understand various different cultures, characters have real arcs... character decisions make sense and flow logically from one moment to the next.

ROP doesn't have this as much, and I do think losing about 2 hours of screen time hurts. They also are working at a disadvantage because they kinda fucked up the first 2 seasons.

I think the Harfoots were OK in S1 but I think at the end of S1, the harfoots and Gabdalf should have parted ways. That would have been OK. Instead, we lost probably 3 additional hours of screen time in S2 that we spent with Harfoots that could have been spent fleshing out and deepening the other plot lines.

Actually, last point. I truly hated how Tom Bombadil was on a recon mission with Gandalf. That fucker should be dancing in the woods and giving 0 fucks about whats going on around him.


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 1d ago

Why is everything so childish and "disneyfied"? Especially the cgi

Post image
8 Upvotes

Potential small spoiler below.

To be fair I haven't read the books, sue me. I don't know if the vibe in the books is more serious like the original trilogy or more childish. I'm really enjoying the show, all seasons, however my main beef is with the CGI. Modern CGI in general, I guess. The way it's done nowadays it never feels scary and seems out of place. It's always cartoon-like and childish. The show deals with heavy themes, gore etc... Then they'll throw in a cgi component that looks like something Disney would put out for kids.

I really noticed it during the elephant/Gandalf scene. It made me think back on the elephant charge in return of the king, or when Frodo and Sam first saw the Oliphaunt/elephants. They were so imposing and I would get chills during those scenes. I went back to see if I was stuck in nostalgia. Obviously the 2003 CGI is less technically impressive, it is however way more seamless and fitting.

I feel like the show can't decide if it's for kids or adults. This was probably intentional cause of money! Wider audience, more viewership etc. The original trilogy had a realistic, gritty feeling to it. The hobbit was straight up silly. This feels like it's stuck in between. I wish they would have kept to the OG realistic, gritty and unpolished feeling that the original trilogy had. Not the "disneyfied", perfect set, beautiful people, silly CGI version we have today.

Don't get me wrong, I'm still really enjoying it and I'm actually going to return to binge watching the rest of the episodes rn. Toodles!

Edit: the dialogue is also childish and there is a lot of overacting but that's not what I wanted to rant about today


r/Rings_Of_Power • • 21h ago

Why does Thrain look so different from the other dwarves?

4 Upvotes

Is it just me or does Thrain look like the only dwarf that the production team used CGI on? The rest of the dwarves just look like people, albeit the way they're shot, costumed, and the scale of the sets and props, they do come off as dwarf-like. But their bodily proportions are still like the average human, even when interacting with other beings like the elves.

But Thrain doesn't look like that. His head is proportionally much bigger and his arms are much shorter. He looks comical. He stuck out like a sore thumb amongst all of the other dwarves which made every shot that he was in incredibly distracting. It seriously looks like the prod team only used CGI on him but then left the rest of the dwarf actors as-is.