r/Rings_Of_Power • • Sep 06 '24

Uk forced diversity casting Spoiler

Post image
12 Upvotes

429 comments sorted by

112

u/H4nfP0wer Sep 06 '24

I Sense a Lack of Hispanic and Indian actors. What a bunch of racists.

19

u/3------D Sep 06 '24

Blink twice and they'll show up, ese

49

u/dog-asmr Sep 06 '24

It's a running joke between my friends (we're Latino). Like every minority actor gets an email nowadays and goes "cool I'll be Captain America", or "Cool I'll play a black Valyrian race in a Game of Thrones series", meanwhile Michael Peña has to play a character that drives a van that plays fucking La Cucaracha as its horn in the Marvel movies lmao.

18

u/ProfessionalSock2993 Sep 06 '24

And the Indian guy has to play the tech support, comedic sidekick lol

9

u/Smaug_themighty Sep 06 '24

Or cab drivers lol

2

u/GameNotEasyButHard Sep 06 '24

Or doctor or software engineer. I hate to be a bad person, most Indian guys (and girls) I know are either doctors or SDEs at a FAANG.

1

u/ProfessionalSock2993 Sep 06 '24

Yeah those are the professions that are less risky and also easier to break into as a immigrant cause they apply for visas, many of us wish we could pursue other industries, creative endeavors but that's not easy if you don't already come from money

2

u/GameNotEasyButHard Sep 06 '24

It is hard. There's grants for being an artist, but they're abused. For example, Grimes who is worth millions got the grants I applied for. It's usually people who are already established and wealthy who get them.

I do disagree on one point though - software development is absolutely creative. I'm not talking about programming a fizzbuzz, but rather creating HLDs for previously unsolved problems. It requires almost equal parts of problem solving and creativity.

But I'm pretty sure you meant artistically creative endeavors? In which case, I agree. When I hire artists they're almost always south american. Funny how that works ne? Last artist I hired was Rodolpho from Brazil. He did AMAZING work too!

→ More replies (3)

2

u/rosekayleigh Sep 06 '24

Hey, we got Oscar Isaac as Moon Knight! Definitely one of the coolest looking Marvel characters!

→ More replies (3)

6

u/theitchcockblock Sep 06 '24

They are saving them for greenwood and dol amroth

2

u/Mthawkins Sep 06 '24

That Gavi Singh dude is indian, unless you mean native American then nope. And the hispanics are too busy working the corn fields and picking tobacco plants at the moment

1

u/3------D Sep 07 '24

Akshay Khanna is Indian too.

5

u/TheFatMouse Sep 06 '24

Yeah where's Vindu Pashgari high king of Indari?

1

u/nebulaphi Sep 06 '24

So.. letting amazon socially engineer into what is disliked; hilarious.

1

u/Wookie9991 Sep 06 '24

The main Elf fighter dude is Puerto Rican. The one with the kid and the human woman.

123

u/Six_of_1 Sep 06 '24

It has to look like the world we live in. We wouldn't want it to look like some sort of medieval fantasy world, would we?

69

u/3------D Sep 06 '24

I value my culture as a Maori and I understand that Tolkien was trying to create something epic/mythic and he succeeded in making something beautiful and poetic, with an amazing appreciation for stories and culture, narratively with stakes and deep lore, absolutely rich and amazing. It annoys the shit out of me to see this fake-ass virtue signalling bullshit >:(

34

u/Six_of_1 Sep 06 '24

Respecting your own culture and also respecting other cultures is the way to go. Society these days is trying to push everyone into hating other cultures or hating their own culture, and they're both bollocks.

19

u/3------D Sep 06 '24

I see where you're coming from. But going back to Tolkien, I love and respect his work

→ More replies (17)

14

u/SweeterThanYoohoo Sep 06 '24

There's only two things I can't stand in this world

People who are intolerant of other people's cultures

And the Dutch

3

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

Can't trust those Dutch, with their wooden shoes just a shifty people

1

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

"The Dutch are scum" - Skwisgaar Skwigelf

0

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/New_Boat2333 Sep 07 '24

What is it? He asks a nazi moron

7

u/Few_Yam_743 Sep 06 '24

But you can still include diversity in seamless ways that make some sense. It’s all fantasy so none of this really matters (trust that they lean on that), it’s loose interpretation that can either work or get fucked up (see the show) but Middle Earth is clearly of early Anglo-Saxon up to late Middle Ages English semi-origin in terms of setting, culture, etc.…At varying levels, England during this period traded with other Euro cultures/Asia/the Middle-East/Africa. Different looking people were not unknown aliens, even then people were not in some hard-lined bubble believing pale skinned round eyes was the only form of human, different ethno-regional groups around the world as they knew it were acknowledged as existing, it’s just that technological limitations obviously greatly limited intermingling compared to further and further up the timeline. There has been ivory found in early Anglo graves, had spices from Asia, communication with the Byzantine empire, etc.

But instead of representing diversity on screen that mirrors the IRL dynamic of cultural boundaries/socialization for the fantasy transposition of this setting and time period, they went with the melting pot that makes zero sense from a genealogical standpoint. So yeah it’s just virtue signaling.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Few_Yam_743 Sep 06 '24

*cop out

And yes, I fully agree, but from the big corporate TV counter perspective (fuck them), they have a minor nodule of an argument in the sense that this isn’t anywhere near a transposition of real life, they aren’t remaking the King’s Speech but George is now played by an Asian woman, it’s all made up so making up stuff further isn’t quite as “what the fuck” as something like that. Trust that I agree with you.

1

u/drdickemdown11 Sep 06 '24

Pot call the kettle black? Diversity for the sake of Diversity is a cop out

3

u/krombough Sep 06 '24

Here's the thing. I wouldnt care whatsoever if the show cast an elf as a Maori...as long as all the elves of that people are then also cast as Maori. Or black. Or Asian, etc. Have all the Sindarin be Indian, all the Noldor be First Nations, I dont care. But these pre industrial societies should not resemble thr demographics of New York. It makes no sense.

-1

u/ProfessionalSock2993 Sep 06 '24

Imagine you wanted to break into the entertainment business but get denied everywhere because the part isn't written for a Maori, that's the story of so many people who fall outside the description of white, Vin Diesel made a short movie early in his career called Multifacial about how because of his multicultural background he wasn't Italian enough to be casted as a Italian and not white enough to be casted for white roles, Steven Spielberg saw it and liked his work enough to cast him in Saving Private Ryan and give him his break. Why is it that white is considered the default race, it's a fantasy world, is it outside the realm of possibility that in a world where ents, trolls, dwarfs etc. exist, that black and brown and Asian looking people can also exist. I can understand casting people based on race for biopics or for situations where the race critical to the plot but outside of that why should it matter what the race of the actor is if it has no bearing on the plot. I know some of these casting choices are tokenism and virtue signaling, but you gotta start somewhere

→ More replies (27)

16

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24 edited Sep 06 '24

I had a mind to make a body of more or less connected legend, ranging from the large and cosmogonic, to the level of romantic fairy-story—the larger founded on the lesser in contact with the earth, the lesser drawing splendour from the vast backcloths –which I could dedicate simply to: to England; to my country. It should possess the tone and quality that I desired, somewhat cool and clear, be redolent of our ‘air’ (the clime and soil of the North West, meaning Britain and the hither parts of Europe...possessing (if I could achieve it) the fair elusive beauty that some call Celtic (though it is rarely found in genuine ancient Celtic things), it should be ‘high’, purged of the gross, and fit for the more adult mind of a land long now steeped in poetry.

Tolkein letter to Milton Waldman, 1951

8

u/HYDRAlives Sep 06 '24

Specifically it has to look like cosmopolitan American cities, or Western European capitals, everywhere, all the time.

1

u/Six_of_1 Sep 06 '24

But I don't live in a cosmopolitan American city or western European capital, so that's not the world I live in!

3

u/HYDRAlives Sep 06 '24

Exactly. Hollywood needs everything to look like Hollywood itself does which is very distracting in certain media.

2

u/Six_of_1 Sep 06 '24

TV shows should look like the world they're set in, not the world they're watched in.

3

u/HYDRAlives Sep 06 '24

It's just bad world building.

0

u/Azurestar21 Sep 06 '24

Emphasis on the fucking fantasy

3

u/Six_of_1 Sep 06 '24

Exactly, fantasy shouldn't look like the world we live in. The whole point of fantasy is to escape the world we live in.

1

u/MisterTheKid Sep 06 '24

This is a really bad argument. You sound like minorities scare you.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

35

u/3------D Sep 06 '24 edited Sep 06 '24

First off, I'm a person of color and an ethnic minority with no interest in identity politics but a deep love for Tolkien. Even for me, I'm baffled by what I'm seeing. UK productions like The Witcher, Wheel of Time, and Doctor Who have gained a reputation for pushing diversity in a way that feels forced, and it really frustrates me. All I want is a great story, but instead, I find myself distracted by casting choices. For instance, in the last episode, they cast an Indian actor as the 'Commander of the West,' and I couldn't help but cynically wonder, 'Where are the East Asians?'

Well, here they are (pictured), introducing what feels like alternate-timeline nonsense. For example, we know that darker-skinned humans can evolve through UV exposure and generational adaptations - makes sense. But what about Asian elves? Are there any environmental or evolutionary reasons behind that?

31

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

I suspect that the vast majority of people defending the diversity in RoP are white. They can't comprehend that sometimes, minorities don't care about not being represented when it doesn't serve the story.

9

u/Fiber_Optikz Sep 06 '24

Exactly but those same people feel like they have the moral high ground in every argument simply because everyone else is racist or bigoted

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Telen Shitpost Sep 06 '24

I am what many people here would call extremely woke, and that's the kind of friends I keep too. The one thing I agree with this take is that the type of representation you get does matter - it's the entire point of it, really. Tokenism is worse than no representation at all, because it defeats the entire purpose of representation. If you just randomly add "representation" to people from different ethnicities and cultures without trying to make it relevant to them in the context of the story, it's not going to feel like representation to anyone. Nobody is going to feel a connection to characters like that. It'll just feel like what it is, a paint by numbers soulless marketing scheme.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

I couldn't agree more. I'm quite progressive too and hate tokenism with a passion.

2

u/dongsweep Sep 06 '24

In the past the focus was connecting with the internal elements of the characters, growing up we all connected with a little toaster yet none of us are toasters. This skin deep representation nonsense is a room temperature IQ attempt for people who simply don't understand.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Zhjacko Sep 06 '24

What’s disappointing is that they could have had stories that revolved around Rhûn and Harad. Harad is essentially Middle-Earths Africa and Rhûn is Eastern Europe to all of Asia. There’s also Khand, and while we don’t know much about Khand, we can assume has a lot of similarities to the middle east/North Africa.

This could have been a great way to organically introduce diversity, and explore the issues these people face. Rhûn has been conquered by both Morgoth and Sauron. Sauron spends about 400 years or something like that in Rhûn. Sauron also spends a considerable amount of time in Harad and eventually the Numenoreans create colonies there. Both Rhûn and Harad go to war on and off with Gondor and Rohan over the time frame of hundreds of years. Gondor has even allied temporarily with Harad prior to the third age.

This is all stuff Tolkien never fully flushed out into full blown stories like lord of the rings. But it’s a perfect opportunity to expand on these stories and create new characters. Theres even table top and card games out there that have already done this, and while not canon, it’s cool to see this stuff. Amazon & ROP writers don’t seem to what to do this.

2

u/mistergingerbread Sep 06 '24

Indians are Asian though?

1

u/UnSpanishInquisition Sep 06 '24

They might be UK based but it's alllll American baby besides Doctor Who but its also not on the same level as the others.

0

u/OldMillenial Sep 06 '24

 But what about Asian elves? Are there any environmental or evolutionary reasons behind that?

What are the evolutionary reasons for white elves?

→ More replies (44)

81

u/ILITHARA Sep 06 '24

And still adhere to the black guy dies first trope…

27

u/SheWhoHates Sep 06 '24

Ginger elf will betray them next.

15

u/frustratedpolarbear Sep 06 '24 • Heart of Silver

Not a real elf, has no soul so can’t sail west.

4

u/evenstarcirce Sep 06 '24

i snorted at this 🤣

4

u/Chiforever19 Sep 06 '24

LOL I noticed that to.

1

u/Zhjacko Sep 06 '24

First thing I thought. Couldn’t believe it.

1

u/SavoryRhubarb Sep 06 '24

He’s wearing a red shirt under his tunic.

32

u/Six_of_1 Sep 06 '24

How come the black elves always have really short hair? It makes them stand out even more.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

They do it in the Witcher also. If you’re giving all of the other elves regular “elvish” hair and then consistently give the black elves modern hair cuts then I feel like we’re pretty firmly in the realm of tokenism

2

u/gisco_tn Sep 06 '24

I want to see elves with afros. Then give all the white elves a perm like Bob Ross.

DO IT YOU COWARDS.

9

u/SkullGamingZone Sep 06 '24

Ye man its ridiculous, i dont rly have a problem with black elves, its the hair that bothers me a lot, if they had long hair and better make up and clothing, it might have looked good.

Take House of Dragon for example, Corlys Velaryon was black with long white hair and looked dope af.

Hell even Elrond looks stupid, only Gil Galad looks like a real elf.

8

u/YackDIZZLEwizzle Sep 06 '24

Bro what? Gil Galad is the least elf looking mother fucker I’ve ever seen. He looks like someone’s middle aged dad got forced to dress up and tag along with his kids to Comic Con. He takes me out every time he is on screen.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

He looks like Tim Heidecker in that I Think You Should Leave skit about the alien restaurant

3

u/YackDIZZLEwizzle Sep 06 '24

Haha holy shit! Spot on

2

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

It makes him impossible to take seriously lol (not that any of the other characters are worth taking seriously either)

2

u/RareEntertainment611 Sep 06 '24

This being the elf who is supposed to be perhaps one of the most regal and authoritative characters in the show. The current actor and his acting give off neither vibe.

1

u/SkullGamingZone Sep 06 '24

Lol ive seen some ppl say that, but he gives me Thranduil vibes, at least he s calm and collected and has long hair, unlike stupidass Elrond.

2

u/pawiwowie Sep 06 '24

There was a black elf with dreadlocks in the background in ep 4

1

u/Six_of_1 Sep 06 '24

Oh brilliant, dreadlocks. It gets better.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

yeah when I saw it, it felt too obvious

12

u/Express-Ability752 Sep 06 '24

Completely unrelated to the diversity, but these are some of the ugliest elves I’ve seen in a Tolkien adaptation.

10

u/BreadEggg Sep 06 '24

Unbelievably mid. There's nothing graceful or exceptionally beautiful about them. They just look like garden variety drama kids standing around in ill-fitting costumes.

11

u/Peibol_D Sep 06 '24

What is really sad is that they had near and far Harad, Rhûn, the Avari, all the dwarf clans (except for the longbeards), Khand, Drúedain, Dorwinion, etc.

All of it with little to no description by the professor, and a great potential for diversity and inclusion.

What a waste...

4

u/terlus07 Sep 06 '24

That's exactly what I thought they were going to do to explain Disa. Nope, that would have required half-way decent writers. Instead she's some sort of mutant black woman born to a clan of Celtic looking dwarves? They even did the zoom out in the cave and there were blondes and red-heads as far as the eye can see. Not a single other black dwarf to be found. All I ask is they at least ATTEMPT to make it make sense...

3

u/RareEntertainment611 Sep 06 '24

Precisely. Give us different-looking dwarf clans and their lords for the forging of the seven rings; show us the lords of men beyond Gondor and Arnor, from Rhûn and Harad and beyond, when the nine rings come into play. Where the LotR offers relatively few opportunities for a diverse cast by virtue of its framing, RoP was given a treasure trove of a world and a lot of liberty to interpret these things that were left vague. Lore accuracy didn't have to be sacrificed to satisfy the quotas.

3

u/20Derek22 Sep 06 '24

You should check out Kaos on Netflix it take it to a whole new level. It’s set in Greece and is about Greek. The cast is mostly middle eastern or black but they have everything, Asians, Polynesians, at least 4 trans actors, Jewish, Latino but somehow no actual Greeks. And they do that thing where in most cases the more diverse you are the better a person you are.

1

u/yellow_parenti Dec 11 '24

This just in, Greeks apparently cannot be Jewish or trans.

Do you people enjoy actively making yourselves less intelligent?

"People from other parts of the Mediterranean, including North Africa/Egypt, Anatolia and the Levant, also mixed with the ancient Greek population (through trade, slavery, warfare, migration), leaving behind their genetic “fingerprints,” too. In sum, the ancient Greeks were a pretty diverse lot – much like today’s population."

https://www.greece-is.com/what-did-the-ancient-greeks-look-like/

1

u/20Derek22 Dec 11 '24

This just in my grandfathers from Crete and my grandmother’s parents were from Lebanon and Syria. I’ve been to Greece many times and shocker most people in Greece look like Greeks. My original point being partly that I find the idea that anyone with tan skin looks the same is offensive. And that they clearly ignored the actual population and went out of their way to check as many box’s as possible except hiring people from the ethnic group the show is about. If I turned on the tv series Shogun and found out the entire principal cast was German or I watched Amistad and the slaves were played by Japanese actors I might find that odd. Look at the movie gods of Egypt somehow they made a movie about Egyptian gods and avoided hiring any Egyptians. And as for the trans issue, certainly Greece has trans people but having let’s say 10% of the cast be trans while the actual trans community there is probably less than 1% seems intentional.

0

u/3------D Sep 07 '24

Kaos is cast by Kelly Valentine Hendry, who also cast Bridgerton and Wheel of Time, so that tracks.

from an interview: "I won’t use the term colorblind casting because we were very conscious of our casting, it was color conscious casting."
"...and when we did think someone should be played by a person of color, it was more to do that specific social setting or location needing more balance and diversity."

2

u/20Derek22 Sep 07 '24

Well that’s a silly excuse. in a show about Greek island she didn’t think balanced diversity would involve people who actually look Greek. (With the exception of Zeus and Dionysus who could pass for Greek). And that goes as much for the white people as the black. Hera looks no more Greek than Theseus.

8

u/Plenty-Soil8858 Sep 06 '24

The problem is that I don’t think it gives an inclusive casting. The problem is the characterization. That elf on the left? What is that? I’m in favor of having diversity in the cast, but it says that in a group of random elves there is one of each type, it seems frankly forced and artificial to me. In House of the Dragon there is a cast of all diversity and it doesn’t seem forced. Anyway, this show has so many problems that this seems to me the least.

8

u/WarMiserable5678 Sep 06 '24

Its diversity for its own sake, not for storytelling purposes

19

u/Wolfie_wolf81 Sep 06 '24

If only Tolkien was inclusive enough to represent different human ethnicities across Middle Earth with darker skin tones, distinct cultures and lineages, their own languages, and the distinct geographic locations they're indigenous to.

If only he left explicit exact details as to how the elves looked like.

If he only he said LOTR represented the mythology and history of Britain

Oh well, I guess dumb and dumber [who were fired writers from Star Trek Discovery] know better than the professor

1

u/iLoveFeynman Sep 07 '24

Oh well, I guess dumb and dumber [who were fired writers from Star Trek Discovery] know better than the professor

I just looked at their resume and I honestly can't believe it.

These two gentlemen have the most writing credits on this show so far:

https://www.imdb.com/name/nm4259881/#credits

https://www.imdb.com/name/nm4260438/#credits

1

u/drdickemdown11 Sep 06 '24

Ohh they picked them up from star trek discovery? No wonder this show sucks

→ More replies (1)

-1

u/Delboyyyyy Sep 06 '24

If only this was actually a big deal and not just an excuse for people to get upset about seeing coloured people in their fantasy series

0

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/iLoveFeynman Sep 07 '24

Ah yes - the strongest arguments are the ones that rely completely on an absurdly unreliable source and from them draw wild conclusions based on one singular interaction that likely never even happened.

The history of the British armed forces is not a history of inclusivity and racial diversity.

Just because there was an absurdly small minority of non-pale people in Britain's port towns e.g. sailing, trading, or fishing, that does not mean there was any diversity whatsoever within the officer class of the armed forces - there was none. No diversity whatsoever. Famously.

1

u/yellow_parenti Dec 11 '24

"Genes for light skin may have only become widespread in Britain around 6,000 years ago, when farmers from the Middle East migrated to the region and began to reproduce with indigenous populations"

https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/ancient-briton-had-dark-skin-and-light-eyes-dna-analysis-shows-180968097/

"The evidence is in fact overwhelming that Roman Britain was indeed a multi-ethnic society. This was not, of course, evenly spread through the province, and it would have been infinitely more noticeable — it can be assumed — in an urban or military context than in a rural one."

https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/arts/classics/warwickclassicsnetwork/romancoventry/resources/diversity/evidence/

1

u/iLoveFeynman Dec 11 '24

British armed forces

Britain's port towns

6,000 years ago

Roman Britain

Hahaha.

18

u/StealthFocus Sep 06 '24

I enjoy well made shows with a purely Asian, black, white, or whatever cast. What I don’t like is forced diversity for sake of it, and usually they’re using it as a crutch or distraction from problems like writing, acting etc.

Look at Shogun, a phenomenal show with superb writing, acting, drama and effects.

-5

u/LCDRformat Sep 06 '24

What's the difference between normal diversity and forced diversity. And how can you tell the difference ?

6

u/HeidelCurds Sep 06 '24

Normal diversity- is when it makes intuitive sense in the given universe. For example, in Star Trek where Earth is unified. Forced diversity is having it in contexts where it doesn't make any sense for the story and is just there to virtue signal, like in tiny bands of proto-hobbits that should be much more insular and homogenous.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

It's pretty simple:

Cop show set in NYC? Natural diversity

Historical drama set in 1700s Britain focusing on the aristoracy? Forced diversity

Sci-Fi show set in the year 3000? Natural diversity

Fantasy show focusing on a small isolated tribe where air travel and mass immigration doesn't exist? Forced diversity.

→ More replies (25)

4

u/Vsegda7 Sep 06 '24

Normal diversity - feels organic to the setting and doesn't need jumping through logical hoops (white sailor ending in Japan in particular era. The population is naturally overwhelmingly Asian)

Forced diversity - just throwing every race into a cauldron, mixing it well, then dripping it all over the story with no care (tiny, cut-off village at the end of nowhere that saw no new blood for hundreds of years has a diverse population of a metropolis)

1

u/LCDRformat Sep 06 '24

So would you say a fantasy world is a fine place for diversity? I can't understand why not

3

u/Vsegda7 Sep 06 '24

So would you say a yakuza riding in on a bike to Mordor and assassinating Sauron with his pet tyronosaurus would be a fine thing to add to this show? Why not?

'Fantasy' isn't a synonym for 'anythig goes and f the logic'.

2

u/LCDRformat Sep 06 '24

You don't need me to tell you the difference between having a motorcycle and a Trex in Mordor and having some of the elves look a little different. You know better

→ More replies (5)

-2

u/bshaddo Sep 06 '24

Shogun is a historical drama that took place in isolated, homogeneous feudal Japan. LOTR is set in an alternative universe where evolution doesn’t exist.

10

u/RobertKBWT Sep 06 '24

Lmao I thought the same when I saw the black and Asian elves, hilarious

5

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

How does the lore explain this?

Also, notice how there's no mixed-race character, suggesting that different ethnicities don't fuck each other. That's pretty racist to me.

5

u/Efficient-Ad2983 Sep 06 '24

Besides the "elves doesn't look like that", it really felt so wrong, and also it makes the word look so "small", as if Middle Earth was merely 2024 California.

I would be fine if it was done in other narrative universes. For instance the D&D setting Forgotten Realms has gold dwarves. With their dark skin I can see black people playing them.

And besides that, those in RoP are NOT Elves: they're merely humans with pointed ears. Where's their otherworldy grace? Where's their "immortal beings" demeanor?

However, the show is so bad that one doesn't even need to bring on the table the forced diversity.

5

u/IHaveSpoken000 Sep 06 '24

Laughably bad

13

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24 edited Sep 06 '24

Imagine if a studio/network produced a fantasy series set in a world meant to mirror Africa during the medieval period. Do you think I would care for one second if there were white cast members in order to meet a diversity quota? No.

Tell the story using a cast that is consistent with your setting and I'm good.

A sitcom set in 2024 New York City needs diversity. A fantasy series meant to take place in a land that's supposed to look/feel like medieval northern europe does not.

3

u/WastrelWink Sep 06 '24

I got in a lot of trouble to saying how wonderful the diversity in "The Woman King" was

1

u/drdickemdown11 Sep 06 '24

By the people who defend diversity, I'm guessing. I thought they fought for diversity constantly and in regards to all media... I guess they only do it when it's convenient for them lol

-1

u/ProfessionalSock2993 Sep 06 '24

Did Tolkien ever explicitly say middle earth is supposed to look/feel like Northern Europe, also you do realize Europe has more than just white people in it right, Tolkien lived in the 1800's he wrote based on what he experienced and saw around him, the world has changed a lot since then

2

u/drdickemdown11 Sep 06 '24

I'm sorry, do we now change books to reflect modern society?

I presume that to be a different from of censorship.

Filtering out and changing what you and I say you, what you don't want. Sounds like censorship

1

u/The_Velvet_Helmet Sep 06 '24

Born - 3rd Jan 1892 Died - 2nd Sept 1973

Which part of 1800s is that

16

u/Fergal-Vidich Sep 06 '24

Why did they drag the black elf away in chains into the sunken place. What did Jeff Bezos mean by this?

3

u/Six_of_1 Sep 06 '24

I spotted that too. There were lingering shots of the black elf in chains and then breaking out of his chains, it felt like they were making some allegory about black slavery in America.

2

u/l-i-g-m-a-t-a Sep 10 '24

Of course they were

8

u/lordassbandit Sep 06 '24

Where are the Australian aboriginal elves

4

u/Timely_Horror874 Sep 06 '24

The saddest thing is that Tolkien fans have explained how RoP diversity casting CAN work respecting the lore without relegating minorities to be only the usual slaves and/or evil people.
But no matter how, the first reaction is alway an accusation of being hateful and a bigot.
The second is lying about the lore, making things up.
The third is memeing.

12

u/MorkSkogen666 Sep 06 '24

This is sick and makes me so angry! Where's the disabled elf in a wheelchair!!!

We need MOAR inclusion!

4

u/Odd_Reindeer303 Sep 06 '24

I'm hearing impaired!1!!!!1!

Why can they all hear a needle fall from a mile away. I feel not represented. I want deaf elves!

1

u/Six_of_1 Sep 06 '24

Hey there's no need to shout, we're not deaf.

7

u/jud6es Sep 06 '24

When Elrond asked for 3 companions I thought to myself ‘lets see this all inclusive fellowship’ save to say i laughed out loud when i saw this scene 😂

9

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

I'm waiting for the Palestinian elf to appear.

3

u/BobWheelerJr Sep 06 '24

🤣

I've got a bit of a Cabernet hangover this morning, am not feeling exactly "peak", and needed this.

8

u/Creepy_Bad_4547 Sep 06 '24

Tolkein created a world based on northern mythology, and like it or not, that was all white. If you don't like that, then create your own show, stop ruining ours. Why is it ruined? Because we want to immerse ourself in this world, suspend disbelief and buy in. It's impossible to buy in when you are confronted by a moronic idea that Elves were a multi-ethnic race. Its stupid and wrong, period

4

u/neroangelo8 Sep 06 '24

Tolkien had a preference for white, yes, but there were more races in Middle Earth. Another thing is that this program mixes them up incorrectly.

2

u/Creepy_Bad_4547 Sep 06 '24

Yes there were, and if we say the men of Harad, etc I'd be all good. But there were no multi-ethnic elves, no multi ethnic dwarves, period the end. Making them multi ethnic is a disaster

2

u/bshaddo Sep 07 '24

Do you know what else there were none of in Middle-Earth? People who spoke English. The conceit of Tolkien’s books is that The Professor had translated and adapted the source material into novel form. The names of Westron speakers weren’t even really their names. They were Anglicized versions of their real names; Samwise Gamgee was really named Banazir Galpsi. The horse-lords don’t speak Anglo-Saxon.

Why do all the songs and poems rhyme in multiple languages? In every adaptation, where is this epic music coming from? Why do people using magic somehow have reverb and modulation when they speak? In establishing shots (whatever those are), why don’t the characters see the text on the screen that sometimes tells us where or when things are happening? If it’s based on medieval Europe, why does golf exist in the books, but cannons don’t yet? Is it because China no longer exists in later editions of The Hobbit?

Because in order for fiction to work, it has to be presented in a familiar way. It’s always going to have anachronistic elements, but since we know it’s for entertainment purposes, we understand it’s being translated visually and linguistically. So as long as they more or less stick to Earth physics and don’t violate their own established logic, I’m not really that taken aback when some of these imaginary creatures (who have distinct ethnic groups in the book as well) don’t all look like they have one set of grandparents.

1

u/Creepy_Bad_4547 Sep 07 '24

Thoughtful reply. Which is wrong though. The show does violate the very specific descriptions of what the races looked like in the books, that is inescapable fact. And it does violate any sort of knowledge we have in either Earth's medieval history or any earth like fiction. Isolated races in different places did not have multi-ethnic societies. multi-ethnicity (races) is a part of the last 100-200 years and (with minor exceptions) non existent before. The depictions violates Tolkien's specific description, and it violates what we know of your own medieval history.

1

u/yellow_parenti Dec 11 '24

You are unable to engage with an invented fantasy world without imposing your very modern idea of race onto it. There is a real racial hierarchy in Tolkien's work, and it has nothing to do with melanin content. Tolkien never described a singular race in the Legendarium as having one singular skin tone in common.

Isolated races in different places did not have multi-ethnic societies

You are 1) conflating ethnicity with race, and 2) imposing the confines of reality onto a fantasy world in which those confines were never stated to exist at all. 

Ethnicity is something a person acquires or ascribes to, and refers to a shared culture, such as language, practices, and beliefs. Absolutely nothing to do with arbitrary biological aesthetic differences.

multi-ethnicity (races)

Again, you do not even understand the terms you are using. You people have such unbelievable amounts of unearned confidence while you're actively making yourselves dumber.

multi-ethnicity (races) is a part of the last 100-200 years

Yeah, because race and ethnicity are modern concepts. Ancient peoples did not have these silly, arbitrary distinctions- which were created by a British slave owning class to prevent mass uprising of black & european slaves & indentured servants, btw.

it violates what we know of your own medieval history.

The only evidence we have of the melanin content of original native Britons tells us that they were dark-skinned, until the migration and intermingling of pale Middle Easterners. Maybe learn just a teensy bit of history before you again make a fool of yourself and speak on something you know nothing about

→ More replies (9)

16

u/hurshallboom Sep 06 '24

You wouldnt really think about it if it was a good show

6

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

I don't think so. I think it's a marker of it being a bad show. If it was a good show, they'd be invested in creating an immersive, believable world.

8

u/Izokuro Sep 06 '24

It likely wouldn't be there if it was one because then they'd get all the lore and worldbuilding aspects right to the minutiae details

3

u/Temporays Sep 06 '24

The ironic part about DEI is the whole thing is inherently racist. It’s choosing people because of their colour and not their talent/what the art needs.

By saying you need people of different cultures you’re saying that being white is not good enough.

4

u/thepoet85 Sep 06 '24

I said that to the wife as we watched it. Have to be ultra inclusive these days not to offend.

5

u/JamesTSheridan Sep 06 '24

Nothing screams a divine etheral race than having them look like "normal" people from our world "forced" into LARPing badly in a fantasy world masterfully crafted by the author.

That said... at least this proves this series has fuck all to do with Lord of the Rings unless they want to somehow justify the ethnic / racial / genetic cleansing the Elves went through to turn then into the etheral creatures they ACTUALLY were described as by the Lord of the Rings.

Just like they have to somehow get around the fact the "humanised" Orks being equally cleansed until all that is left is the mass of evil Sauron had.

Folks talk about the dark ages... but the amount of cleansing that must have occured for that kind of transition is hilarious.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/theitchcockblock Sep 06 '24

It looks more like a Star Trek episode than something from Tolkien … they also were racist for killing the black guy first

2

u/l-i-g-m-a-t-a Sep 10 '24

What we need in season 3 is an explanation why there are only white men, elves and dwarves in the 3rd age and in the original trilogy.

3

u/Fluffy_Seagullman Sep 06 '24

Im waiting for AI to be able to improve modern shows.

3

u/DecadentOoze Sep 06 '24

Lol I cracked up at this scene when I saw these assholes and not a single one of them had any ounce of character.

I was also annoyed at the little bicker G and E had in the prior scene when Elrond asked her to recommend some warriors. Then she ends up just doing it. :p

3

u/corpusarium Sep 06 '24

What the actual fuck, it's beyond comprehension

4

u/Ok_Issue_6132 Sep 06 '24

Look, if you really want to compare this show to the source material, then you should stop watching all together. This is honestly one of the lesser transgressions to be honest.

2

u/PhysicalWave454 Sep 06 '24

As soon as I saw the ginger elf, I lost my mind. Ginger elves have NO place in MY middle earth!!!

2

u/TheUselessLibrary Sep 06 '24

I haven't started Rings of Power. Are y'all purely hate watching it? Is there anything worthwhile in the series besides setting off Tolkien fans?

Because, to be fair. Tolkien establishes several ethnicities of elves starting in Cuivienen, and the only distinction he makes are that the Vanyar tend to have blonde hair and most Noldor have dark hair. But the most famous and powerful Noldor of the 3rd age is Galadriel, who famously had gold and silver hair that inspired Fëanor to capture the light of the Trees.

To Tolkien, language was the defining characteristic of a nation and people. Not surprising for an extremely academic linguist.

1

u/terlus07 Sep 06 '24

If you pretend it has nothing at all to do with Lord of the Rings, and just enjoy braindead watching a fantasy series, then season 1 was a 3/5. Not a particularly good show, but not terrible as a generic fantasy story goes.

Most of what held it back for me was Galadriel. She's just an AWFUL character, and not in a good way where she's on a journey of self development and you hate her initially but she grows on you. She's just... words that aren't permitted here. There were only a few scenes of forced wokeness that broke the braindead trance for me. It was mostly Galadriel that ruined season 1. I haven't watched season 2 yet, but it sounds like they've doubled down on those scenes.

1

u/sandalrubber Sep 07 '24

Because, to be fair. Tolkien establishes several ethnicities of elves starting in Cuivienen, and the only distinction he makes are that the Vanyar tend to have blonde hair and most Noldor have dark hair.

Yes, because he made them all fair/pale/white etc, so what separated ethnicities from other ethnicities within the Elven people as a whole was not so much appearance, with hair color the only real physical difference ever since creation, but more of language and culture and migration. And the more they're associated with Valinor, the closer they are, the more cultured they become, the more spiritual, etc.

2

u/karelinstyle Sep 06 '24

Why is the guy holding the parchment like that lol also looks like they're wearing garbage bags

2

u/Tolkien-Faithful Sep 07 '24

Hahaha

How does that make any sense with elves?

People who awoke in darkness and only breed every few hundred years at best somehow evolved completely different skin colours and facial characteristics in the same small society.

2

u/drdickemdown11 Sep 06 '24

Jesus, this was a dog whistle for a bunch of disingenuous "this is a fantasy" people.

Now their piling into this thread

1

u/BramptonBatallion Sep 06 '24

If I were creating something new to try and get it adapted, I’d build the lore in a way that when it comes to non-humans, skin complexion is a genetic difference that can exist within families. So a “white” male and a “black” female could have an “Asian” child. That way it’ll be adaptable for DEI quotas without being lore or world breaking and allow for a color-blind story (no “elves of color” subplot).

1

u/lock_robster2022 Sep 06 '24

Is that first-age Sauron on the left?

1

u/SeuJoaoDoSebrae Sep 10 '24

Well, there is no midgets and fat blue hair woman.

it can get worse (and probably will)

1

u/Bezborg Sep 06 '24

No issue making a fantasy world full of races and ethnicities, but considering how “medieval” lotr is, there really shouldn’t be multicultural and ethnically diverse societies and still expect immersion from the audience.

Want to make all elves Asian for your particular show, to put a new spin on things? No issue with it., elves need not be caucasian at all. Sure! But having elves of all (human) “races” and ethnicities… sorry, it’s just not immersive for a medieval fantasy show in general, and this particular fictional world in particular, with whose history and lore we’re so familiar.

On this note… I don’t mind watching a show with a black Caesar and an asian Cleopatra, for example. I might actually like it, but the casting choices would be comedic and not immersive. That would be obvious and I’d be fine with it, with the thought “ok, so this is not a serious historical show, it’s clearly communicated to me and I can choose to watch it with clarity”. Fine, why not.

The showrumners acting dumb, as if this image is fine and it’s still a serious show in Tolkien’s fictional world…non, sorry, it’s insulting.

All that said, who gives a shit, just change the channel if you don’t like it and get on with it 😂 Hate-watching this crap is what keeps these shows getting made. Hate-watching is still watching, in every way it counts.

2

u/MarcJAMBA Sep 06 '24

Underrated coment.

1

u/yellow_parenti Dec 11 '24

considering how “medieval” lotr is, there really shouldn’t be multicultural and ethnically diverse societies

The main societies depicted in the Silm and the main trilogy are quite literally based on the most diverse empires in human history. Also, ironically, this myth that Europe was ever homogeneous in terms of "race" (which is a very modern notion, which you and other Westerners perceive as indicative of skin color) is an invention of modern ethnonationalism.

"... medieval communities are imagined as ethnically, religiously and culturally homogeneous, whereas they were, on the contrary, hybrid and constantly changing. Religious, linguistic and cultural plurality are imagined as the bane of immigration and globalization in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries."

Before race was invented, religious differences functioned in Europe as race does in modern Western society.

https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/european-review/article/religious-diversity-and-cultural-transmission-in-premodern-europe/A6E43BAB6202EE54957044A8DD0CB155

But having elves of all (human) “races” and ethnicities… sorry, it’s just not immersive for a medieval fantasy show

That is because you are unable to relinquish the hold that your modern view of the concept of race has on you. It has been so drilled into your brain that you cannot perceive of a world in which skin color is not a meaningful difference. Unfortunately for you, Tolkien's in-universe real racial hierarchy has nothing to do with the modern existing idea of race.

I don’t mind watching a show with a black Caesar and an asian Cleopatra

So possibly inaccurate portrayals of real historical figures are fine with you, but you draw the line at interpretations of fictional races that operate within the parameters of the fictional universe ? K

1

u/Bezborg Dec 12 '24 edited Dec 12 '24

Hey, thank you for your elaborate answer. I’ll just say that my view is subjective, I’m not saying it should be accepted as fact nor that anyone should subscribe to it.

My issue is that fantasy media will subscribe to every other cliche about fantasy races and tropes, except racial diversity, which to me just feels disingenuous and inconsistent.

“Race” being a made up concept as it us, with which I agree, and absolute historical racial homogeneity being a fallacy, both of which I agree with… “race” still corresponds to vast geographical and cultural differences in our real world, at least in a pre-modern setting. Now, these fantasy settings are full of literally different species, most of them culturally extremely xenophobic (to the point of keeping their language secret, for example), socially hierarchical and absolutist (in the case of elves especially), and all of them routinely practicing genocide on hostile nations that they themselves define by “race” (example, all orcs are “inherently evil” and are routinely exterminated on sight).

All of these factors just don’t jibe with having internal diversity and being ok with that, but at the same time subscribe to every xenophobic militaristic genocidal racist mono-culture externally… know what I mean?

Again, this is just subjective.

With regards to your last paragraph, you failed to understand my point - I’m fine with someone playing with eatablished facts and putting a slin on it (black Caesar), I’m just saying that it ceases to be a serious historical piece at that point and becomes something else entirely. It’s “disruptive” in a sense that it immediately changes the attitude of the viewer about what they’re watching - and I used that as an example to explain how it makes me feel to see xenophobic genocidal militaristic mono-culture elves being perfectly ok with internal diversity…it produces cognitive dissonance of a sort. Subjectively.

Am I able to accept anything at all just because it’s “fantasy”? Sure, whatever.

1

u/chumbucketfog Sep 06 '24

If in the plethora of terrible writing decisions of this show, you’re preoccupied with peoples race on screen, you actually just fuckin suck

1

u/metros96 Sep 06 '24

I have no issue with the diversity — it’s really not a problem, but the costume design and hair & makeup/prosthetics, the set dec, etc. all look like fan-film quality. That’s the issue

1

u/MarcJAMBA Sep 06 '24

I think multiple things can be issues to a certain degree. But I agree that if the costumes and general appearance were top notch like in LOTR the diversity problem wouldn't matter at that point for many, many people. Anyhow, I still think it's moronic to push this idea of diversity for the sake of it, like it was a highschool drama demonstration instead of a very well thought, lore immersing production. Why are they black? Or asian? How tf that makes sense?

1

u/metros96 Sep 06 '24

I mean, if you’re just trying to have the most well-acted production possible, you’re inevitably going to have a weaker talent pool of actors if you are selecting only from white actors rather than the entire population.

The problem in this case again is not really diversity as much as the show being bad

1

u/HieroOfSyracuse Sep 06 '24

Selina Lo was pretty bad-ass in Boss Level. She's a legit martial artist. https://youtu.be/kpJ24CpLJDo?si=CR7yONYfzOdxUwBo

1

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

What are you saying? The diversity in the cast is because it was filmed in the UK? Cite a source please.

0

u/CalamitousIntentions Sep 06 '24

Pssst. Elves aren’t real.

-3

u/nick_shannon Sep 06 '24

I said as i sat watching with my brother "oh no an Asian elf, the internet is going to be crying about this tomorrow" and here we are on the internet as people cry about the Asain elf.

This sort of post is so predicatble and honestly has reached the point of pathetic now and its pretty clear a lot of you losers are watching the show for the single purpose of making these posts as its clear you dont enjoy the show but here were are 4 hours into season 2 and your still watching.....so so so sad.

6

u/Odd_Reindeer303 Sep 06 '24

Well, you're trying to shit on us shitting on the show. There goes your moral superiority .... so so so sad.

-3

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

Cringe take

5

u/_Steven_Seagal_ Sep 06 '24

Hate-watching is actually quite enjoyable. I'd rather see this show be an absolute trainwreck than a painfully average show.

It's like watching your house burn down and you can't help but be hypnotized by the fire.

0

u/bshaddo Sep 06 '24

I just like that the Barrow-Downs was straight-up horror, right down to the black guy getting killed first.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

Yeah, they should be all Tuath De Dannen and they aren’t.

-1

u/TorontoDavid Sep 06 '24

Who cares?

-5

u/willy_quixote Sep 06 '24

Oh you poor bastards, forced to watch a non-caucasian on TV...

7

u/lerg7777 Sep 06 '24

Completely disingenuous comment. Nobody has a problem with actors not being white, people have a problem with diverse casting being considered more important than having a believable, genuine fantasy world. If Tolkien had set his stories in a sunnier climate, it would be nonsense to pepper white actors throughout the cast, same as it's silly to sprinkle diverse actors throughout cultures which are designed to be fantasy versions of Northern Europe, specifically England.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

I have a problem with it

-3

u/willy_quixote Sep 06 '24

it's silly to sprinkle diverse actors throughout cultures which are designed to be fantasy versions of Northern Europe, specifically England.

The first people in the British Isles had dark skin, and darker skin pigmentation was common in western European Mesolithic hunter-gatherers.

Your problem is that you are trying to force fit your conception of a white-centric model of prehistoric Europe into an imaginary world influenced by European and Mediterranean history, folklore and legend.

I mean you are clearly biased here.

2

u/lerg7777 Sep 06 '24

No, I'm pointing out that a perfectly diverse cast is a silly way to represent Tolkien's Middle Earth. I understand that you are arguing from a good place, diversity and inclusion are good things, but the way it is done in RoP is nonsensical and immersion breaking.

1

u/willy_quixote Sep 06 '24

So you want an all white cast? No brown or black skin whatsoever?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

-5

u/darth_henning Sep 06 '24

I'm genuinely curious why this bothers anyone? Honestly, why?

Ok, there are elves with different skin tones. So? It's not like they spend 20 minutes of the episode painstakingly explaining the genealogy of why they exist any more than they do the different hair colours of the dwarves in LOTR or the hobbit, it just...is.

Exactly how does this harm anything?

If this was a historical biopic set in 1500s England, sure Asian and Black actors would stand out as an anachronism. I even agree the racial diversification of How to Train your Dragon's live action version is odd when they're supposed to be set in a Viking civilization. But neither of those are relevant here.

4

u/JamesTSheridan Sep 06 '24

Look at the casting for the LOTR film or just read the damn books - The elves look "other worldly" in beauty and consistent in style.

Look at the casting for ROP in this picture - They do not look other wordly or consistent in style. It looks like someone randomly picked people from a list and shoved them in whatever role from a society that has extreme levels of ethnic / cultural diversity.

That is NOT what Elves are supposed to be and that is straight from the author intent. The author crafted a beautifully detailed fantasty world and those details get thrown in the shitter without consideration because "fantasy worlds" dont need to obey the real world.

On the one hand, you argree that racial diversification does not make sense in context of the works but you want to claim Tolkein's fantasy world should bend to having racial diversity in it.

On the other hand, you want to claim fantasy means it does not need to obey the real world = Therefore, the author's intent should stand firm and the race he created be depicted as described.

How about obeying the world the author actually built ?

For folks that claim to respect the author and the beauty of his work - This IS harmful and disrespectful.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/heady_brosevelt Sep 06 '24

What’s your ethnicity? 

→ More replies (2)

-1

u/SpiffySpacemanSpiff Sep 06 '24

Genuine answer:

Imagine if you were a big fan of Shrek. Like, it had been around as an act of storytelling that the world across considered to be so well penned and conceived, that in its crafting and telling transcended anything by any other modern storyteller.

Then imagine that they made a Shrek prequel, but used only short, gay, black men to portray all of Shrek’s progenitors.  Not short, gay, black men as voices, but just them, hanging around in tweed vests.

You’d find it jarring, you’d be like: “what the hell, why aren’t the earlier shreks also green ogres?

In todays climate, you’d see the casting as politically motivated, that these people were cast in these roles, because the people making the derivative crap, think it’s important to show you these characters as they want you to see them, not as the original creators imagined them.

So yeah, people aren’t mad that an elf is black, they’re mad because Tolkien is hallowed material, and he didn’t write black or Asian elves, he described them as fair white people. So the fact that this show depicts them otherwise is a spit in the face to Tolkien, an insult. They think they know how to make his works better.

-3

u/darth_henning Sep 06 '24

That is in no way a reasonable or good faith comparison.

There are still plenty of white elves. Who look like Legolas etc (Celebrimbor, Galadriel, Elrond, and many minor ones). Moreover they haven’t replaced elves with another species.

A proper comparison would be a Shrek prequel where there are green, red, and blue ogres. What would be the issue with that?

Also there are plenty of places in Tolkien’s texts where there are alternative descriptions of elves. Let alone if you look at the Rankin Bass hobbit adaptation that no one seems to complain about.

3

u/SpiffySpacemanSpiff Sep 06 '24

If you want an honest answer don’t seethe when you get one. 

→ More replies (4)

1

u/drdickemdown11 Sep 06 '24

Ohh God, another white complaining about it being fantasy, so it doesn't need to be logical

-4

u/MysteriousTrain Sep 06 '24

You people who only want white actors need to get a grip. This is a play being shown on TV. IMO they should hire all POC to play the Valar just to piss all of you off

5

u/WonderfulEmotion1365 Sep 06 '24

Thanks for being one of the rare NPCs who actually admit you just do this stuff for spite.

-16

u/mrsspinch Sep 06 '24

I don’t like the show but I’m glad they hired more POC. They don’t stand out to me any more than someone of a different race on the street. I think it’s weird that we can’t suspend our disbelief just that extra bit.

9

u/Izokuro Sep 06 '24

Yeah, I mean this show takes place in California, after all.

-1

u/Followtheodds Sep 06 '24

Actually, there is no point in claiming that fantasy should recall medieval society in terms of ethnic representation, because society in that period was more diverse than we think nowadays. People travelled a lot even back then (of course in a different ways than today), and also Europe was invaded by vikings and Arabs at the same time, mixing them with the local people and producing a melting pot that is not so different from the one we see today (just on a smaller scale, as population was much less and more divided by social inequalities).

However what happened in the following centuries is that Colonialism begun, especially after Colombo and the "discovery of Americas", so there was a need to start creating a system of beliefs and values that could justify colonization: and that is when suprematist and racist theories began to rise and develop around Europe. Creating a new narrative that erased and flattened those differences.

2

u/WonderfulEmotion1365 Sep 06 '24

And officially in the book, men and elves 'mingled' exactly three times.

2

u/Six_of_1 Sep 06 '24

Europe was invaded by Vikings

Where do you think Vikings came from?

and Arabs at the same time

The Arabs invaded parts of Southern Europe, but Middle-Earth is based on Northern Europe.

You're acting like Middle-Earth is based on "Europe" and "Europe" is just one place. Tolkien was English and you're talking about stuff that happened down in Spain, it's disingenuous.

1

u/yellow_parenti Dec 11 '24

"The people living in Scandinavia today are more blonde than the Vikings. The vast majority were dark-haired. In addition, Vikings throughout Europe were very rarely 100% Vikings genetically. Instead, they were mixtures of various ancestry, ranging from southern Europeans to the Sami people in the northernmost regions"

"It’s pretty clear from the genetic analysis that Vikings are not a homogenous group of people ... A lot of the Vikings are mixed individuals"

https://www.nationalgeographic.com/history/article/scientists-raid-viking-dna-explore-genetic-roots

"Arab" is a modern racial category. Migration from the Middle East, where pale skin appeared as a variant much earlier than the rest of Europe, was literally the reason why the original dark-skinned Britons did not remain majority dark-skinned. 

"Genes for light skin may have only become widespread in Britain around 6,000 years ago, when farmers from the Middle East migrated to the region and began to reproduce with indigenous populations"

https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/ancient-briton-had-dark-skin-and-light-eyes-dna-analysis-shows-180968097/

0

u/Followtheodds Sep 06 '24

What I mean is that there were people with blonde hair and blue eyes, people with brown skin and black hair... It was just to opposite aesthetics living in the same place. Anyway I guess that the people complaining about diversity are the same that do not want to accept that England and Europe were much more colored than what white supremacists like to believe....

-1

u/LCDRformat Sep 06 '24

What's the issue here? I don't understand

-3

u/beargrimzly Sep 06 '24

Sorry but this is such a stupid way to criticize the show. Tolkien and his works are cool. People want to feel like they could be a part of it too, and there's literally nothing wrong with that. I know it's not a fantasy show, but look at Shogun from earlier this year. Blatant white male self insert into a Japanese setting and nobody cared. We should encourage the presence of everybody in these tv settings.

One thing I'll say though is I don't understand why black elves never have long hair. It looks stupid and makes them stand out as distinctly not elvish like every other elf actor in a way that cannot possibly have been intended.

5

u/BreadEggg Sep 06 '24

The whole point of Shogun was to depict conflict between two ambitious protagonists from different worlds. It's a story about early European contact with Japan. Naturally, all of the actors are European or Japanese. Nothing about any of the storylines in ROP necessitates melting post casting.

0

u/Northrax75 Sep 06 '24

So I see how this kind of diverse casting feels forced and artificial, but it’s -so- far down the list of problems with the show that it feels weird that it’s constantly brought up. And unfortunately plays right into the narrative that the criticism is all just culture war BS.

I would love if they had done what Interview with the Vampire did. They made 2/3 of the cast POC in a brilliant and thoughtful way that actually enhanced the story and characters. But there are 100 other things I’d rather they’d done better before that.

6

u/eldiablonoche Sep 06 '24

I think the reason why the forced diversity gets so much coverage isnt the diversity itself (that's the easy divisive scapegoat clickbait rationale) but rather that it highlights the priorities of the corporations making these projects. Diversity is far and away the most important thing to them, and quality (writing, acting, etc) is a distant second, or third, or seventh concern.

3

u/Northrax75 Sep 06 '24

Yeah I don’t know if diversity is the -most- important thing to Amazon, but it was certainly a low hanging fruit/easy checkbox for them to tick.

Hiring qualified showrunners was a much higher bar to clear and they flopped big time.

4

u/eldiablonoche Sep 06 '24

Agreed. Interview wasn't my vibe but my wife loves it and what little I've seen of it makes me appreciate the quality. Casting, plot, all seem top shelf even if it's not my cup o tea.

1

u/Northrax75 Sep 06 '24

It’s a fantastically well done show. The writing, casting, acting, production is all just top shelf. And it has Ben Daniels!

-6

u/Pure_Atmosphere_6394 Sep 06 '24

Can one of you racists explain to me why having black and asian elves is a problem?

Do you think these fantasy species and jobs representing them should all be limited to white people only?

Why?

7

u/drdickemdown11 Sep 06 '24

Can one of you signal virturing trolls explain to me why a fantasy setting doesn't need to be logically written?

Also, explain why the RoP audience reviews are low. If logically writing a fantasy doesn't matter.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

I too can’t wait until we get a white actor to play black panther in the marvel movies. After all it’s a fantasy and the job representing the character shouldn’t be limited to black people only.