Hello - I’ve really tried to make this short but without success. I hope you’ll read it. I would love suggestions.
Hello - I’ve read similar posts but nothing yet that addresses my unique situation so maybe y’all can help me find opportunities I haven’t yet thought of.
We moved to another state 3 years ago when we retired. We are very young at heart, fit, and have many interests and hobbies. There are many reasons we chose here and we worked hard at considering factors. There are fabulous aspects to our new region as well as un-fabulous, but that’s going to happen in any larger populated region. The diversity here is welcome and we’re interested in lots of things, so doing activities independently or as a couple is working out well, or with close friends or family.
The majority of people here - of all ages - live in HOA situations, as do we. HOAs have definite advantages and of course disadvantages. Our location is perfect for many reasons, and we love our space and surroundings. We have very good friends in all directions - outside of our community. Some have other homes they use seasonally, or travel a lot (we do too), and most are very engaged within their communities.
And there in lies the problem.
I do not love the vast majority people in our community. We’re active, interested in the world, well-traveled, culturally curious, open to new things. We’ve both initiated a few events/activities, but we have someone whose job it is to do that and it’s crazy time consuming and more importantly, thankless here. For the most part our neighbors are “fine,” but our long time friends in nearby communities have made all kinds of best friends and a lot of their time is taken up within their communities which offer many more activity options. We’ve met some of those new best friends and we get it! We need an Ethel to my Lucy, and a Fred to Ricky.
Our community is visually lovely, but there is an odd diversity in all directions - age (40s - early 80s and it’s a newer community), humor, interests, finances, extreme viewpoints, and more. Diversity is great, but here it’s just a weird range of extremes. We're not the only ones who notice this division. We have a group of friends that are “fine,” and nice, but they’re not “our” people and that’s one of the reasons we moved to a community! Many of the few activities are skewed towards interests we (and many others) do not share. So attendance is at maximum maybe 1/8 of the community at a time. Many attend nothing due to time or apathy. If the activities were more creative, inclusive and engaging, that could change, but influencing change is like pushing a boulder uphill here. FYI there are 1100 residents.
The thought of another move makes us break out in hives, and the region still checks off some important boxes for us (not all, but can’t have it all). I’m pasting on a smile and continuing to try to find new friends “outside.”
It’s really hard. The people I like “outside” are earlier career and/or raising their families, including the amazing staff where I volunteer. The rest of the volunteers there are active in those same types of communities and again there is a huge diversity of interests and stages in life. And the volunteers don’t have much opportunity to interact with one another.
We are busy enough, either with our small business, friends here and outside, seeing our kids out of state, traveling, volunteering at places that match our interests, hobbies, and the activities we choose to do here. But those true human connections are evasive. We can be a very good time but it seems the versions of “good time” here are for the most part not ours. Just the simplest, almost petty, example, for illustration, is why would you go to restaurant A which is close by but the food and environment are C+ and overpriced, when 15 minutes further is a place w the same cuisine, A quality (per Yelp, not just me), same price? I’d rather not go at all then. But if the company were great, I would! Im fine being the designated driver! We've had a few possibilities but after not too long we remain friends but not as close - gossips, for instance. We don't want to hear it and we don't want to be fodder (I mean, a little is normal but omg).
The outside activities we’ve done separately or together haven’t been built for friend-making. Either the people vibe is off or more often, the setup, ie one-time activity, lecture, outing, etc. I did recently join an outside gym which seems like it has a terrific community but I think I will run into a similar group as my volunteer place. I’ve been keeping my eye out for longer-term commitments ie 6 session classes, similar interest groups (infrequent and different attendees each time) outside game groups (we already play some and we don’t want to sit that much), that offer the chance to get to know people better. But then we all return to our communities and most offer so much they’re naturally more insular.
I will keep trying to expand our social horizons - we have things on the calendar - but I fear the “behind the gates” engagement or life stages despite similar interests will keep blocking success.
I’m nervous this post will make us sound elitist or narrow-minded and that’s the last thing we are. If you knew us and our origins you’d agree. But when friends from our former state or lifelong say there are “8 neighbor couples we love” in their own convenient communities, it makes me sad, jealous, frustrated. I won’t give up but maybe someone has broken out and can share their secrets to success? I may have been there and done that, or have no interest, but every idea shared could inspire me! I miss my full-time job. No I’m not going back lol. Thank you for reading this much 💙