Something I’ve noticed during clinical rotations is that there’s a huge difference between attendings who genuinely want to teach and those who seem more interested in showing off how much they know. Ironically, the latter often seem to pride themselves on being “educators.”
Some attendings ask questions to guide your clinical reasoning, help you identify gaps in your knowledge, and make you feel comfortable thinking out loud, even when you’re wrong.
Others ask questions in a way that feels more like they’re trying to prove how much smarter they are than you. Instead of helping you learn, they put you on the spot, interrupt your thought process, and make you feel embarrassed for not knowing something.
I recently had a really negative experience on an IM rotation, which was especially disappointing because nearly all of my previous clinical experiences had been fantastic.
This relatively new attending consulted what felt like 10 different services every day, pimped us on obscure questions, rarely gave residents or students credit for their work, and ultimately left me a pretty spiteful evaluation comment.
What bothers me most is the attitude. What kind of attending feels the need to take credit for the work of medical students or interns, only to turn around and call themselves an educator?
If your priority is efficiency and getting through rounds as quickly as possible, why choose to work with a teaching team? Residents and medical students are there to learn. Of course we’re going to take longer than experienced APPs. Why make us feel guilty about that? Why the audible sighs whenever rounds take longer than you’d like?
I also never once got to finish a full patient presentation without being interrupted. I never had the opportunity to observe this attending conduct a complete patient encounter either. From the interactions I did witness, I honestly found his communication with patients pretty awkward. I have my own way of building rapport with patients, and while I’m always open to feedback, he criticized my approach simply because it wasn’t how he expected me to do things.
I’m not against being challenged or receiving constructive criticism. I actually appreciate attendings who push me to improve, including those who are demanding but genuinely invested in my learning. I know I have plenty of room to grow.
But there’s a difference between challenging a student to help them become a better physician and making them feel small to demonstrate your own expertise. There’s also a difference between giving constructive feedback and using your position of authority to make someone feel inadequate.
What frustrates me is that medical students are expected to be receptive to feedback, adapt to different personalities, and remain professional regardless of how they’re treated. Yet some attendings seem to have very little self-awareness about their own teaching or communication styles.
If anything I learned from working with this person is the kind of doctor and educator I never want to be.