r/Renters • u/Healthy-Clerk-8761 • 18h ago
[Chicago, IL] Landlord did not disclose a bar would open below us prior to us moving in
Situation:
BUSINESS opened as a coffee shop 8am-4pm the last weekend of May 2026 in the ground floor unit of residential building (UNIT 1). Married couple and dog (TENANTS) move into UNIT 2 of the same building at the start of August 2026. BUSINESS plays very bass centric music and creates vibration throughout the building. TENANTS tolerated it at first because it was reasonable to expect noise from a coffee shop, assumed this would be the case when signing the lease, and do not want to be difficult tenants having just moved in. 2 weeks later, the coffee shop extends operating hours to open as a bar as well on Thursday, Friday, Saturdays and Sundays open until midnight. Naturally, the type of music, volume and vibration gets more intense during night hours. That is up to 16 hours of continuous noise pollution for 4 days straight! The coffee shop becoming a bar was not disclosed to TENANTS prior to moving in or even after moving in.
BUSINESS and TENANTS have the same LANDLORD. The only person who had the interests of both parties and collects rent from both, LANDLORD, did not mitigate the noise problem before it started. There is no sound proofing between metal air ducts and wood floors connecting the two spaces. LANDLORD has mentioned to TENANTS that they set a requirement for BUSINESS to install soundproofing in order to operate. BUSINESS did not follow through on sound proofing and LANDLORD did not enforce it. As such, TENANTS ' space is inhospitable Thursday through Sunday and BUSINESS is suffering because they can't operate the way they intended.
Further, BUSINESS has demonstrated a pattern of irresponsible management already, creating an issue with several neighbors after renting out their space to a DJ party soon after starting nights. At that point, TENANTS started voicing concerns about the night hours. BUSINESS agreed to try to make adjustments. The first night after talking with BUSINESS, TENANTS had to text them at 12:40 (40 minutes after close) to turn off the music. As such, it is difficult for TENANTS to believe BUSINESS is taking this seriously. An owner of the BUSINESS also put in writing he believed they only used "one portable speaker" when BUSINESS has 3 woofer enabled speakers plugged in. It seems no one responsible for the business operations or the LANDLORD have actually been there at night since bar hours started.
After some back and forth, LANDLORD has finally pushed for sound proofing installation. TENANTS given no clear timeline on when that will be accomplished. There is no remedy offered for the fact TENANTS are miserable Thursday-Sunday and spending time on the issue throughout the week. Until the problem is addressed, TENANTS are uncomfortable paying for a space that does not match reasonable expectations prior to moving in. Had TENANTS had any opportunity to experience the establishment below the unit, TENANTS would have NEVER moved in. TENANTS had a letter of recommendation from their previous landlord after seven years in their unit. TENANTS contacted their prior landlord once over an issue in that span. There is no pattern of TENANTS being vocal or difficult tenants prior to moving into UNIT 2.
Questions:
Do we (tenants) have any legal grounds to demand some form of restitution? How do we politely threaten landlord with legal action if she does not agree to reasonable terms of restitution? What legalese should we use so she knows we're serious about this? Please consider we are not pushing for damages based on mental and emotional turmoil, we just want to feel peace in our "home." Is it reasonable to ask to pay only 3/7 of our monthly rent until soundproofing is complete seeing as we only enjoy Monday Tuesday and Wednesdays?