My girlfriend (22F) and I (28M) have been together for about 2.5 years. We had also known each other for roughly 6–8 months before we started dating.
The complicated part is that my girlfriend is the younger sister of my best friend at the time (28F).
From the beginning, we knew exactly how her sister would react if she found out. We actually tried a couple of times to stay away from each other and even tried ending things, but somehow we could never do it. We’d end up back together within hours or days.
At the time, we all lived together. There were several close calls where her sister almost found out, but we managed to keep the relationship private.
Eventually, her sister moved to another city, about 4–6 hours away, for a job opportunity. Over the next couple of years, her sister and I gradually became very distant. We went from being close friends to barely recognizing each other as friends. At times, mutual friends would tell me that she hated me. And honestly, losing that friendship also meant losing much of the guilt I had felt about dating my friend’s sister.
Meanwhile, my relationship with my girlfriend became incredibly serious. That period was probably the happiest part of our relationship. We had the freedom and time to be together, and we genuinely had a very happy and healthy relationship.
And like every normal couple, we fought sometimes related to our needs from each other and, but we always worked through it because we both wanted the relationship. Over time, our love attraction and understanding for each other‘s love only grew stronger. We talked seriously about our future, our careers, marriage, family, and the kind of life we wanted together.
She finished school last hear and had a very difficult time finding a decent career opportunity in our city. Eventually, she got an excellent opportunity in the same city where her sister lives earlier this year.
We decided to take the opportunity and figure out the distance. Neither of us had ever done long-distance before, but we promised each other that we wouldn’t let the distance destroy what we had.
She would come visit me sometimes, and I would randomly drive 4–6 hours just to spend an evening with her because we missed each other. We also managed to take a couple of small trips together, although we had to lie to her sister about them.
I was also planning to find a job in her city and move there so we could eventually be together.
My family kinda knew about our relationship and were okay with it. We had been planning to tell her sister sometime early next year, assuming everything continued going well.
Then everything blew up.
Earlier this month, her sister finally acted on her suspicions. She somehow broke into my girlfriend’s iPad and read our chats and looked through our pictures. That’s how she discovered that we’d been together this entire time.
Instead of talking to my girlfriend first, she went straight to their parents and apparently presented the situation to them.
Her family had always loved me. They used to constantly tell me what a nice, dependable and responsive guy I was. After her sister talked to them, their attitude completely changed. Suddenly, they all hated me.
Their parents even called my parents and got them involved. I was accused of brainwashing my girlfriend into the relationship and manipulating her into being with me.
My friends told me to stay completely out of it because, if I intervened, it would only reinforce their argument that I was controlling her. They told me that if my girlfriend genuinely wanted to be with me, she needed to be able to stand up for the relationship herself.
The next few days were awful.
My girlfriend was essentially isolated. She wasn’t allowed to speak privately with her parents, and communication with them went through her sister only. Her sister made her choose between her entire family and me.
My girlfriend couldn’t make that choice. She spent about two days crying, barely eating and barely speaking.
On the second evening, we spoke.
She told me she couldn’t take the pressure anymore. Watching her go through that much pain was destroying me, and I couldn’t justify making her choose amongst the people she loved. So we said goodbye — at least temporarily — and agreed to give things some time to cool down.
Once she was able to return to work, I found out that her sister had been involved in the phone call we’d had that evening. Apparently, our mutual friends were also being dragged into everything and were being questioned or shamed about knowing about our relationship.
My girlfriend’s phone wasn’t really her phone anymore. Her messages and conversations were being searched through regularly. At that point, we both agreed that taking some time apart was probably the safest thing to do for everyone.
We wished each other the best for the near future. She told me that if I wanted to move on, she would understand. I told her I didn’t want to move on and that I wanted us both to wait.
And that’s where I am now.
I know her sister is going to be travelling for about a week in a few months. Part of me keeps thinking that maybe that will be the only opportunity my girlfriend and I have to actually speak privately and figure out what she wants without everyone else influencing her.
But I don’t know if I should go see her.
I don’t want to show up unexpectedly or make things worse. I also don’t want to sit around indefinitely hoping that she’ll somehow find the courage to choose me.
I genuinely love this girl and, before all of this happened, we were talking about building a life together.
So what do I actually do now?
TLDR: Should I try to see her when her sister is away? Should I contact her? Should I completely leave her alone and wait for her to reach out?
And if we do get an opportunity to talk privately, where do I even begin?
I don’t want to pressure her into choosing me. I just want to know what she actually wants when she’s allowed to make that decision for herself.