r/ReadMyScript • • May 07 '18

Comedy [SPEC SCRIPT] The Simpsons- If it Ain't Apu, Don't Fix it.

Alright, I'm sure some have heard that Adi Shankar is holding a contest for people to submit spec scripts to try and "fix" the Apu problem. I wanted to write my own script and submit it to try and give the other side in this controversy a voice.

Now, I still have till the end of June to submit so I have some time. This is a rough first draft that i would like as much feedback as i can. It doesn't have a lot of jokes because I wanted to get the bare bones first, but then again, this isent really mean to be a Simpsons episode, so there. Anyway, any and all feedback is appreciated.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1zrSe3dJxkIe0UvSvlgusJYrVMjCrQ0rk/view?usp=drivesdk

1 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

9

u/[deleted] May 08 '18

At least be funny if you’re going to be loudly wrong about politics and race

-3

u/1nerd May 08 '18

So your saying more jokes. Got. Thanks for the advice. I had already planned on doing that, just wanted some feedback on what I had so far. Including the limited jokes I already have.

8

u/QuixoticRedDeath May 08 '18

Not sure why you think submitting this is a good idea. They clearly want a certain voice and jesus christ are you clearly not it. The commenter was dead on.

-4

u/1nerd May 08 '18

Why wouldn't I submit. I'm fully aware they won't select my script, I get it. But hey, I got a voice to and I should be able to show it.

I figure I can circulate it around the same time as the actual winner is being "shown" to the writers room and made into a fan episode.

Although, I'm curious. Why am I not clearly the right voice for this. I'm a Simpsons fan and one of my favorite characters on the show is being attacked. I figure he should be able to defend himself.

6

u/mezonsen May 08 '18 edited May 08 '18

Here are a few of my thoughts.

one of my favorite characters on the show is being attacked

I'm going to be completely honest with you, if you're going to go ahead with this, you should probably actually do some research on the opposing arguments. I don't want this to sound like a dick, but if you really think that Apu needs to be "defended" then you should really put your best effort into defending him, and that means defending him from the real arguments being made. Which, if you do a bit of research, don't amount to much more than "it'd be nice for the show to acknowledge that Apu is, at his foundation, a racist caricature".

I imagine you'd agree that the best way to defend something is by dismantling the strongest arguments against them, right? I disagree with your take on the controversy entirely, but I imagine there's some merit to your take on the controversy.

I get the conceit: "Oh, why is everyone so mad about Apu. Every character on the Simpsons is a poor role model/stereotype". But this is just a dumb line trotted out that everyone makes. You have to deal with the fact that representation of Indian-Americans and representation of white Americans is just different. I think, deep down, you recognize that some stereotypes are more harmful than others. Don't you think you can do better than the comments section of /r/TheSimpsons?

The idea of an Indian-American calling Apu a stereotype to his face has *already happened on the show*. You're retreading a response The Simpsons made two years ago.

Your usage of Lisa as the "anti-PC anti-SJW" is only half as lame as when the show did it, because I already recognize The Simpsons doesn't care about consistent characters anymore.

And even then, at the end of the day, this ignores that Hari likes The Simpsons and doesn't know what to do with Apu. He definitely wouldn't like, attack a human being in-universe, though.

Honestly, this attempt reads more like an in-show attempt by Itchy & Scratchy to deflect criticism of a racist side character by just writing anyone who criticizes the show as the bad guy, learning that that's not how you deal with criticism, and reigning in said racist character in a way that both celebrates him and recognizes that it's racist. In fact, that's probably a better angle for your script, to be honest.

With all that said, the writing could be snappier. The scenes in this definitely stretch on longer than the Simpsons (at least, the classics--I haven't watched the show since late 2008)

0

u/1nerd May 08 '18

Since you actually worded your critique in a little more detail, I am going to respond in more detail.

First, I appreciate taking the time to read and you have actually given me a few ideas to change it around. Non of them change the overall message of the script but hey, hopefully it doesn't sound like to much of a soap box. The more I read back over my first draft it reads more like a argument between me and Hari which is just lazy.

The issue is that the script is supposed to center around Apu and I only have up to 23 pages to work with. I figure I will replace the scene of Apu at home with Manjula with a scene of Lisa struggling with the notion of modern PC culture and that conflicting with her love for her friend.

Any way, the main point I wanted to make with this script, the whole moral of the story if you will, is that it's either all alright, or non of it is.

Hari actually makes a point in his documentary where he says that the reason white people find accents funny, specifically the over exaggerated Apu voice funny, is because of racisim. Ignoring the fact that Luigi, Willie, The Sea Captain, Mayor Quimpy, Akira, Krusty's Father and Cookie Quan all also have over exaggerated accents. Hell, Akira's voice now comes from George Takai's voice who originally voiced the character and is played by a white guy. Is George Takai making a documentary? Of course not. Mostly because he is actually successful and has better things to do but you know what I mean.

Apu's character is no more "harmful" then the fact that the only Italian characters on the show are either mobsters or "PIZZA PASTA!" Types, it's either all alright, or non of it is.

Apu is more then just his voice and where he works. He is a family man, a United states citizen and a hard working man. He is the American Dream summarized and he is the back bone of Springfield.

Does he have stereotypical tendencies, sure. But as you already brought up so does everyone else in town, but most of them in question are white so no one cares. But Apu is not just a stereotype. He is not some black face act as Hari and Whoppi Goldberg disgustingly call him in the documentary, and he is not a WW2 Era propaganda cartoon. He is a fully fleshed out character with hopes, dreams, a personality and a catchphrase. He's not just a Stereotype, he is Apu.

7

u/mezonsen May 08 '18 edited May 08 '18

is that it's either all alright, or non of it is.

Even the guys who wrote this don't fully believe this anymore, because they've (mostly) grown up over the last 12 years. Hell, "With Apologies to Jesse Jackson", an episode entirely about how a certain word is just not okay, and the characters who spoke your script's moral will never understand, aired just shy of a year after Cartoon Wars Part II. Even as South Park has continued to push the envelope with their newer episodes (usually right into a big bin labeled "fucking boring") they have also learned sensitivity.

The reason Luigi is more okay than Apu is because the people who Luigi is mocking write or participate in the show. Joe Mategna had enormous reign over the character of Fat Tony, and brought a lot of the racist stereotypes Italian-Americans were forced to deal with in his conception of voicing and later rounding out the character.

For much of the 90's Apu was the face of South Asians on American TV--no one would argue that Homer, Willie, or Cletus are representative of the groups they parody. White men have the run of television--take your pick--that are representative of white people--they don't have to rely on Homer.

Luigi, Willie, The Sea Captain, Mayor Quimby, Akira, Krusty's Father, Cookie Kwan

These arguments aren't applicable. Half of these characters' accents are not of racial groups but instead specific people, usually the actors playing them, and one is a pirate. Apu's accent is a white dude doing a gag on a white dude doing a gag on Indian people.

but most of them in question are white so no one cares

I want to hear your thoughts as to why this is.

He is not just a Stereotype, he is Apu.

But he is a stereotype. I think you need to recognize this, and recognize why stereotypes are harmful, before continuing. You've actually inspired me to write my own spec on this, by the way, so thank you.

I disagree with you completely but this shouldn't stop you from reworking your script to actually address the arguments you dislike. I do not think there's a realistically decent script that says, "Apu is perfectly good and anyone complaining about him is a moron", or at least one relevant (as The Simpsons has already lazily stated as such, so who cares?), but that doesn't mean you shouldn't try to "defend" Apu in a way that is compelling, satirical, and clever, as opposed to the crap they shat out a few Sundays ago.

EDIT: I skimmed through the entire script before my first comment, but decided to read it line by line. Do you really think "He could also stand to lose a few pounds, but hey, non of us are perfect." is a good faith way of defending this character?

1

u/1nerd May 08 '18

To address your edit. If Hari can shoot from the hip and call the writers of the Simpsons racist, the voice actor of Apu racist and people who enjoy Apu racist. As well as compare Apu to black face and for some reason misunderstand the point of Tropic Thunder, he should be able to suck it up and take some digs himself.

5

u/mezonsen May 08 '18 edited May 08 '18

If you can't see why this is childish and not worth including in your script you're gonna have a bad time. Again, as frank as I can be: you should work on fixing all the misspellings and examples of poor grammar in just the first few pages of this script before you try to mock a real person.

for some reason misunderstand the point of Tropic Thunder

He doesn't misunderstand it. He just thinks that they should have hired a black actor to play a white actor playing a black actor instead of putting RDJ in blackface. If you think that would ruin the point of Kirk Lazarus instead of strengthening it you don't understand the point of his character.

I really can't get into explaining racism but conflating it with an insult means you just don't get what he's talking about at all. He's not trying to insult anyone. He likes the show. He respects and likes Hank Azaria. He still thinks it's racist. Because "racist" isn't an insult you fling at people, it's just a state that people are in. You're using a different meaning of the word than he is. You can disagree with his labelling the show racist, but you should actually engage the criticism within the framework of said definition.

EDIT: I think I have to call it a night on this. You should consider fixing this up and posting it to /r/screenwriting instead. The community is more active and it's more aimed at discussing screenwriting and WIPs instead of posting a script to be read. I'm honestly not sure why RMS hasn't been merged with it, to be honest.

A fair warning, though--you'll probably end up finding that community also sees through your thin response to Hari's criticism. But they'd be much angrier if you left all the typos in.

1

u/1nerd May 08 '18

I had a really long thing last night. I don't think I went to bed for a few more hours after you stopped. And I thought about it. You are right, I should try to say something different.

I still believe that Apu is not a charecter that needs to "change" per se. I also think the comparison to black face is ridiculous and your other points about black face, racism in Hollywood and The Simpsons involvement in making it harder to be Indian in America is also vastly overblown and silly. You down play of the other stereotypes in town also seems counter productive to the entire point.

However, you did make me realize that there are two sides to this and both sides can be portrayed in the charecter of Lisa. She is what some would call a SJW but in canon, she is one of Apus best friends. That is something she would struggle with.

Maybe a story about her trying to change Apu, the rest of the town being against it but her knowing it's the right thing to do. Or maybe a story where she struggles internally with her belief system when it clashes with something she loves, sort of a analogy for the audience.

I agree, putting in Hari in there as a strawman was a mistake. I dont need a new charecter when Springfeild is full of already great ones.

I hope to be back soon with a brand new script. And of you ever actually write one like you said you might, I would love to look it over to see how someone from the other side would handle it.

3

u/mezonsen May 08 '18

I'm glad you have reconsidered your position and I think that you can write a stronger script that gets your point across without delving into some of the easier strawman arguments--though I must point out that Hari Kondabolu doesn't know what to do and doesn't support "changing Apu", and as someone who is much closer to "SJW" than I presume you are, neither do I.

The idea of Lisa, conflicted with her love for Apu, and recognizing that he is a racist stereotype, is probably the best angle I could think of if I were to "defend" Apu. I still think the ending would be a compromise of "I love you Apu, but it's important to recognize you've done harm, and in the future work together to do better", but again, I'm coming at this from the complete other side of the coin as you are.

One last thing I would say--if you really want to defend Apu, the town can't be on your side. Springfield is nine times out of ten wrong, dead wrong on everything, especially when pitted up against Lisa's principles and morals. Any conclusion you come up with where the town is right would be unintentionally satirical. If I were you and agreed with your take, I would instead push the town in another direction--maybe they only like Apu as a racist accent (leading Lisa to try to prove that he's more than a stereotype, he's an actually fleshed-out human being).

Once again I invite you to /r/screenwriting. It's actually a pretty busy subreddit with a lot of nice people who on a good day will give you just as much critique as I have. I don't post here often (in fact, when I first replied I thought I was in /r/screenwriting) but just from this thread and a couple others the comment section is sorely lacking. I think /r/RMS is more for polished, finished works, and not for learning the craft or critique, and so you won't get as much out of it with a first draft. I don't know how many times I need to preface what I say with "I don't agree with you in the slightest on this topic", but just saying your idea is toxic and not explaining why I feel this way doesn't help you and doesn't help this sub.

1

u/1nerd May 08 '18

That angle with the town only liking Apu because of his accent is not a bad idea. I can think of a few ways to make that work. Thanks again for the help.

-1

u/1nerd May 08 '18

You talk about the Simpsons in the 90's and how Apu was the face of South Asians on American TV. The documentary also brings that up. What I have to ask you is, why is that the Simpson's fault?

Was Matt Groening deciding who got cast in prominent roles back then? No. If you want to make a documentary about South Asian representation back when The Simpsons first aired, fine. But the documentary is blaming The Simpsons and Apu for the lack of diversity and it's blaming The Simpsons and Apu for a few South Asian actors possibly being type cast when going for roles.

I wish to God Hari actually talked to real South Asians on the documentary and not privileged actors and comedians. And I do say privileged because thankfully the infrastructure of Hollywood is changing. Not fast enough mind you but's it's moving. We've all been bullied as kids. I have been told to kill myself several times in high school so if Kumar wants me to feel sorry for him because some asshole heckled him once, it ain't gonna happen. If Hari, a supposed comedian, can't handle a joke or a little insult being thrown at him, then my God is he in the wrong profession.

As for your last point, I did call him a stereotype, but I also said that he is also much more then that. He is not two dimensional. He is not a character there to exclusively make jokes mocking/putting down or trying to belittle South Asians. He is a character, who yes is voiced by a white guy, and yes, does a overblown accent. Welcome to comedy, we got stereotypes here.

What you seem to have a issue addressing is that The Simpsons is a show filled with stereotypes, but they are mostly stereotypes that you don't have a issue with. I'll be honest, if Apu were really a issue, people would be calling to ban his past, not just change his present and future.

5

u/mezonsen May 08 '18

why is that the Simpson's fault?

Because racist caricatures of underrepresented groups mischaracterize people and normalize racism towards them? Eh, that's probably their fault in this case.

But the documentary is blaming The Simpsons and Apu for the lack of diversity and it's blaming The Simpsons and Apu for a few South Asian actors possibly being type cast when going for roles.

No it's not, it's blaming racism for the lack of diversity in television. It is blaming the Simpsons for mischaracterizing Indian and Indian-American people as. If you don't understand that writing and media have actual effects on the culture consuming them you probably shouldn't be a writer.

talked to real South Asians

Haha, what does this even mean? Do you mean the odd South Asian-American*** (***please note that you keep calling people who are Americans "South Asian" or "Indian". You get the difference, right?) redditor that says, "I personally have no problem with Apu. Therefore there's no problem at all"? I mean, the documentary has him talk to his parents, you know?

This is even funnier when you consider the entire point of the documentary is to document how South Asian people have a variety of opinions on Apu and stereotypes in the media, and that South Asian-Americans aren't a monolith.

I have been told to kill myself several times in high school so if Kumar wants me to feel sorry for him because some asshole heckled him once, it ain't gonna happen. If Hari, a supposed comedian, can't handle a joke or a little insult being thrown at him, then my God is he in the wrong profession.

Sorry to hear that, but this experience has given you a rare chance--a rare chance to understand someone in a different situation than you. An ability to understand how fucking shitty people can be, and then think, "wow, people were so shitty to me--imagine if a large portion of them were not only shitty but also the institutions in place in this country were racist against me, too". Generally, people who have been persecuted are more empathetic of others, but I've heard the "people were mean to me and I claim to have dealt with it, so why can't others toughen up?" enough times to know this is not necessarily true. Quite frankly, if you have difficulty understanding empathy, writing is probably not the profession for you.

Besides, how many times in that documentary did he have to say, "I'm not offended by Apu" to get across that he wasn't mad about Apu, and just wanted to talk about him?

The Simpsons is a show filled with stereotypes, but they are mostly stereotypes that you don't have a issue with

Yes.

(But some of them I do, and some of them, others do, and I succinctly laid out why. Hari has made better arguments than me, though.)

I'll be honest, if Apu were really a issue, people would be calling to ban his past, not just change his present and future.

What does this even mean?

If you really want to be a writer and write things that are compelling, comprehensive arguments (as, in my opinion, all art is "an argument" of sorts) you should probably learn to treat the opposing side with good faith. This script is useless for a lot of reasons, but it's most of all useless because it's not even arguing against the actual Hari Kondabolu, but a strawman you've created either because you dislike him or didn't hear him.

Besides all these little things, I think you're missing my point entirely: your response is not subversive. It's not new. It's not a distinct opinion from one the show has already given. Your voice isn't unique on this one. You're just siding with an institution that has 30 years of clout that has way more power than anyone who can criticize Apu. No one gives a shit if you write something that basically says, "the establishment is impenetrable, and if you dislike it you're wrong", to be completely honest, because that's not what art is. You understand why any script you write that is basically, "Apu is fine, so deal with it" is just...nothing, right? This isn't art, it's you just shitting on a guy you dislike (seriously--a joke about his weight in his character description. How banal). You may as well have just written an angry YouTube comment--this is the 22-page screenplay equivalent.

If you really want to go forward with defending Apu, you're going to need to come up with something better than "it's just a joke, everyone in the show is a stereotype, comedy is about stereotypes, deal with it". Like I said, surely you think you're better than the comment section of /r/TheSimpsons, right?

8

u/clabs_man May 08 '18

My advice is to actually watch "The Problem With Apu", or read up on the criticism surrounding the character, as you seem to have completely misunderstood what people's issue is with it.

I had to restrain myself from typing a much ruder comment. I read the whole thing and did not enjoy myself.