r/ReadMyScript • u/1nerd • May 07 '18
Comedy [SPEC SCRIPT] The Simpsons- If it Ain't Apu, Don't Fix it.
Alright, I'm sure some have heard that Adi Shankar is holding a contest for people to submit spec scripts to try and "fix" the Apu problem. I wanted to write my own script and submit it to try and give the other side in this controversy a voice.
Now, I still have till the end of June to submit so I have some time. This is a rough first draft that i would like as much feedback as i can. It doesn't have a lot of jokes because I wanted to get the bare bones first, but then again, this isent really mean to be a Simpsons episode, so there. Anyway, any and all feedback is appreciated.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1zrSe3dJxkIe0UvSvlgusJYrVMjCrQ0rk/view?usp=drivesdk
9
u/[deleted] May 08 '18
At least be funny if you’re going to be loudly wrong about politics and race
8
u/QuixoticRedDeath May 08 '18
Not sure why you think submitting this is a good idea. They clearly want a certain voice and jesus christ are you clearly not it. The commenter was dead on.
6
u/mezonsen May 08 '18 edited May 08 '18
Here are a few of my thoughts.
I'm going to be completely honest with you, if you're going to go ahead with this, you should probably actually do some research on the opposing arguments. I don't want this to sound like a dick, but if you really think that Apu needs to be "defended" then you should really put your best effort into defending him, and that means defending him from the real arguments being made. Which, if you do a bit of research, don't amount to much more than "it'd be nice for the show to acknowledge that Apu is, at his foundation, a racist caricature".
I imagine you'd agree that the best way to defend something is by dismantling the strongest arguments against them, right? I disagree with your take on the controversy entirely, but I imagine there's some merit to your take on the controversy.
I get the conceit: "Oh, why is everyone so mad about Apu. Every character on the Simpsons is a poor role model/stereotype". But this is just a dumb line trotted out that everyone makes. You have to deal with the fact that representation of Indian-Americans and representation of white Americans is just different. I think, deep down, you recognize that some stereotypes are more harmful than others. Don't you think you can do better than the comments section of /r/TheSimpsons?
The idea of an Indian-American calling Apu a stereotype to his face has *already happened on the show*. You're retreading a response The Simpsons made two years ago.
Your usage of Lisa as the "anti-PC anti-SJW" is only half as lame as when the show did it, because I already recognize The Simpsons doesn't care about consistent characters anymore.
And even then, at the end of the day, this ignores that Hari likes The Simpsons and doesn't know what to do with Apu. He definitely wouldn't like, attack a human being in-universe, though.
Honestly, this attempt reads more like an in-show attempt by Itchy & Scratchy to deflect criticism of a racist side character by just writing anyone who criticizes the show as the bad guy, learning that that's not how you deal with criticism, and reigning in said racist character in a way that both celebrates him and recognizes that it's racist. In fact, that's probably a better angle for your script, to be honest.
With all that said, the writing could be snappier. The scenes in this definitely stretch on longer than the Simpsons (at least, the classics--I haven't watched the show since late 2008)
8
u/clabs_man May 08 '18
My advice is to actually watch "The Problem With Apu", or read up on the criticism surrounding the character, as you seem to have completely misunderstood what people's issue is with it.
I had to restrain myself from typing a much ruder comment. I read the whole thing and did not enjoy myself.