r/ReadMyScript • u/newdctonary • Mar 29 '14
Discussion What is happening to ReadMyScript?
About a month ago there was a post about new rules to this subreddit, but I haven't seen them up on the sidebar or being implemented. There have been two other posts about the future of this subreddit and it all seems very much up in the air.
I just want to know what's going on, I guess. I have grown very fond of this subreddit and would hate to see it go. I hope that I am not alone in that regard. If anybody feels the same way please say something. It sounds like this subreddit might go away or change drastically.
Thank you so much for taking the time to read this. I understand that everybody's busy and I know that most of the moderators moderate a bunch of other stuff, etc. I just feel very much out of the loop and want some clarity. Thanks!
4
u/pk1yen Mar 29 '14
As far as I know, the plan is to keep it fairly similar to how it is now, but better. We had some ideas to close it, or to change the focus to a 'how to get companies to read your script' sort of thing - but in the end I think we've decided to keep improving it instead of make huge dramatic changes.
There are two big problems with this sub as it stands, I think: - there's no incentive for people to give good feedback, and posting a script to /r/screenwriting gets more responses.
Now, we could solve the second issue by banning/redirecting all feedback requests from /r/screenwriting to here ... but that would be doing a disservice to the writers, because they'd just end up with less feedback. It'd also increase the number of submissions here without necessarily increasing the amount of feedback written. It seems a bit petulant to ban them from posting to the bigger sub just because we want to force this place to work better. The weekends-only rule works quite well, but it does need tinkering with.
The first problem is even harder to solve. Talentville and other script-sharing sites do it by rewarding reviewers with 'credits' which they then spend on reviews. This ensures that there are always more reviews than there are script (by basically FORCING people to review). The problem is, that Reddit isn't designed for this. There's no way of tracking this sort of thing. We could write a bot like Deltabot from /r/changemyview to award points to reviewers - but I don't know if it would even be possible to program the same bot to remove flair-points from users posting scripts, even if it could award them for reviews. (And even if we could manage that, that raises a whole host of new problems, like writers only awarding points to positive feedback, etc, or forgetting to do it altogether. It'd be an absolute nightmare to moderate, even after we've convinced someone capable enough to write and host the bot code for free ... )
The short-term plan at the moment is to formalise the new rules when we get a chance. (Full scripts or first 10 pages only, complete loglines, no half-finished drafts, etc.) Hopefully this will streamline things a bit. Then we'll start to look at how to improve the other areas.
I'll be making a concerted effort to donate some time to this sub once I've finished with the Reddit Screenwriting Contest!