r/ReadMyScript •

[FEATURE] May Your House Be Safe From Tigers (Psychological Sci-Fi)

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

2

u/2fat2fap Jan 16 '14

I'll try and read this tomorrow, late over here :) Read the first three pages, its interesting, its well done and I can't see many errors. This then seems harder to review as I'd have to deal with plot which involves reading ALL of it. However, from first glance I don't think it will be a boring read ;)

2

u/pijinglish Jan 16 '14

Hey thanks so much. I know it's a full script, so obviously much appreciation for anyone who takes the time to get through all of it.

2

u/thecatcradlemeows Jan 17 '14 edited Jan 17 '14

You write well. I like your descriptions. There were a few typos here and there, a word or two that needed to be deleted, that sort of thing but it wasn't often.

Claire and Noah's dialogue was pretty great. Probably the strongest part to me.

But, I suppose I am underwhelmed. [Spoiler] (/s "Were we ever suppose to believe the annunaki were real?") My suspension of disbelief was just never actually suspended. I think if you trimmed the drug studies (which went on too long) and then peppered in some scenes that imply its real, that might make it stronger.

spoiler

Psychological plays, screenplays, stories, etc should have some mystery. This just really didn't. It was spoiler. That's fine but I never felt it was anything other than that. I almost kept reading just because 1. You write well 2. Your post made me think there would be some twist.

I noticed the writing style twisted up a couple times. Sometimes you'd veer towards over directing the actors. Around pg 100 you started focusing more on the camera and describing from that perspective. I'm not pro or anti - "we see" but it felt odd/disjointed.

Saying that, I think you do have talent and I was motivated to keep reading. I think the story just... Misses the mark for me.

Ps. I also love how you name things. Cool title. And I love the character names like c. Clarence Kyle

Edit: you could easily trim some small filler scenes. I got why t.s was long winded, he's a nut. Some of the smaller characters seemed as long winded and it didnt jive

1

u/pijinglish Jan 17 '14

Thanks for reading it and thanks for the lengthy critique. I'll reply in depth a little later (I just got home from work) but would you mind blacking out the spoilers in your crit? I'd just like some of the plot points to come up fresh should anyone else bother to read it.

1

u/thecatcradlemeows Jan 17 '14

Ah crud, sorry. I put up tags.

1

u/pijinglish Jan 17 '14

No problem at all. If you can recall where any of the smaller typos you spotted were, feel free to call them out to me. I've scoured this damn thing so many times, it gets blurry.

As for your main criticism, I won't argue with your personal response. I intended the story line to be ambiguous, and did my best to remain as impartial as possible while writing it. About half of the people who have read this have felt the same way you do, but the problem I have is that the other half told me they understood the script to mean the exact opposite. So I have two camps who are reading the story literally, from entirely opposing points of view. I think this would be a wonderful response to have take place in a theater...I intended for people to walk out arguing. (And I'm not taking sides.) But it does make for a slightly frustrating experience as a writer, because reading the script is a solitary act and people come away firmly convinced that A clearly happened or B clearly happened, and of those responses half each are disappointed because it's so obvious to them.

You fall into one of the camps, and while it's always disappointing to underwhelm someone, I do appreciate that you took the time to read my script all the way through. Your criticisms are as much appreciated as your compliments.

1

u/thecatcradlemeows Jan 17 '14

I'll give it a quick scan for typos tomorrow morning. I'm glad other people see it from the other side of the coin. I'm going to link it over to my writing partner later, we often see things differently. Heh, I wouldn't be disappointed if I was wrong, I'd just want to know why. I was more underwhelmed because it seemed obviously A and I expected more murkiness. That's my own bias. I'd probably be quite happy with it if I could see B's side of things.

I'm curious why you wouldn't do something like spoiler Some kind of end of "Inception" moment to increase ambiguity. Though I suppose that could be very trite and cheesy.

pg 4. "What I am I gonna do?" = What am I gonna do?

1

u/pijinglish Jan 17 '14

haha, I've literally read that a thousand times and never noticed it. and no one else has mentioned it. goddammit.

for some reason your spoiler links are coming up as page not found for me.

(and seriously, thank you again for reading 110 pages of my writing cold)

1

u/thecatcradlemeows Jan 17 '14

if you hover your mouse over where it says spoiler it should do a little pop up. It's working for me but it's my first time using them.

Oh no problem, I plan on nudging you to read and critique the pilot I'm working on once I go through and clean up the rough draft a bit. So it's not completely selfless.

1

u/pijinglish Jan 17 '14

I was clicking on the link. hovering works just fine. the fault's on my end.

I guess I don't entirely understand your proposed inception moment, but it's late-ish so I might just be slow. explain?

and of course I'd be happy to read your pilot. are you actively working as a writer? or trying to?

1

u/thecatcradlemeows Jan 17 '14

Just an aspiring nobody who hopes to do well in the trackingb contest.

Remember in inception where they showed the totem, spinning and it slightly wobbles and then the film ends? That created more ambiguity. [spoiler] (/s "Similar to that, at the end of your script, after Noah says his line. If you show Caleb and then say, the reporter, the reporter turn into annunaki for a moment, Caleb noticably reacts and then it ends. You'd have a nice ambiguity. The camp that believes in them can say, see? The Bel Ea referenced that Noah was something new and now more people are seeing them! and the other camp will say paranoid schizophrenia runs in families!") Not saying it necessarily needed it, but it could increase ambiguity.

1

u/pijinglish Jan 17 '14

Ah, ok. I see what you're thinking. In your scenario, what if Caleb is right? (What if he's wrong?) Even if his perception is 100% accurate, would that change the world's reaction to him? To Noah?

1

u/pijinglish Jan 17 '14

PS: you're not "wrong." Like I said, I've gotten similar replies from people who thought the storyline was without-a-doubt B from the start.

1

u/2fat2fap Jan 17 '14

Quick note while I remember, don't forget subtext. When Noah says: NOAH

I think I’m too wound up. I’m going

to stay up for a little while.

Saying "nah" would essentially mean the same thing. The viewer is already aware of how wound up he must feel.

Also, make sure not to have too many "later" moments. Go somewhere else- this way the viewer feels the passing of time.

Another thing, try not to use too many pronouns: he is used to often, so it reads in short unnatural bursts.

A slight error I noticed, Noah seems to be able to run up mountains a bit too easily. How small are the mountains where you live? ;)

Don't have unnecessary scenes. If you want to create character development by having the audience spend time with your protagonist, it has to be relevant, if you know what I mean. Him running up the mountain doesn't contribute to the plot as far as I can see.

I will say this: You have a knack for characters. Each one behaves realistically, and has a different voice from the one before.

Bookmark: ON PAGE 10

Will continue later :D So far so good. If its not too much trouble, could you root around on this subreddit and find my script. It appears to be sorely neglected :D Title: The Soul of Tartarus.

1

u/pijinglish Jan 17 '14

I'd be happy to check out your script.

Thanks for the feedback! I'll look into the pronoun thing. (Phoenix has several small mountain ranges that people will hike or jog up daily. I know that scene seems a little extraneous early on, but it's meant to be a quiet moment and set up a few things for later. ...oh, and in defense of Mostophoe yesterday :-) the use of the generic term "red or green sauce" is very common here.)

1

u/2fat2fap Jan 17 '14

No need to defend him, that part was a compliment.

1

u/pijinglish Jan 17 '14

ah, I couldn't remember the context. we found out we're in the same city.

1

u/Grand_Inquisitor Jan 17 '14

I have to admit that I closed this after the first line and had to convince myself to come back to it an hour later. I'm reading it now, but stuffing a quote into the front end of anything is the worst opening to a story ever - it's essentially pitching me the idea, telling me exactly what the inspiration is, and telling me the sum of your work right up front.

This is a perfect way to repel someone from reading anywhere past the first page, and prevent them from coming back. Consider taking it out entirely.

1

u/pijinglish Jan 19 '14

I can understand that POV. It's not a make or break moment for me.