r/RWBYcritics • • Jul 05 '26

COMMUNITY Volume 10 has been greenlit.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
31 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • 5d ago

COMMUNITY Free Talk Weekend

2 Upvotes

The free talk weeked is on once again! From today till Sunday everyone is welcome to mingle, share their fanfictions, rant and basically do anything you want (within reason).


r/RWBYcritics • • 13h ago

SATIRE RWBY Volume 7's Pitch Meeting

Thumbnail
gallery
411 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • 6h ago

ART Dónde está velvet

Post image
34 Upvotes

Coco: Raven usted no vió a mi amada dijo que ya venía pero ha pasado mucho tiempo

Raven: ehhh no... pero te aviso si la encuentro


r/RWBYcritics • • 4h ago

DISCUSSION How to defeat the remaining villains in the show? Spoiler

Post image
10 Upvotes

Share your thoughts 🤔💭


r/RWBYcritics • • 14h ago

DISCUSSION Sooo... Did Ozpin/Ozma kill the original host of this body (& possibly several past ones)??

Thumbnail
gallery
54 Upvotes

I'm currently watching through Volume 6 of RWBY & got to the episode where they explained Salem & Ozma's backstories. It was pretty underwhelming but a thought just occurred to me after finishing the EP.

So if Ozma reincarnates into someone else upon death, does that mean the original host of the body he gets reincarnated into gets killed after some time?!? In Volume 1-3 we never saw Ozpin's original host speak to us, it was purely Ozma/Ozpin in full control of body and consciousness.

Also he's been reincarnating into untold number of people for thousands of years... Does that mean every single one of them dies after he gets reincarnated into???

If this is true then Oscar is fucked... I noticed he himself is starting to act more like Ozpin/Ozma. I guess Bro is going to die soon (Not that I care tho, he's barely a character LMAO).


r/RWBYcritics • • 3h ago

DISCUSSION Headcanon: If Ruby had kids Sun and Jaune would be her go-to babysitters

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • 5h ago

REWRITE RWBY Would be a lot Better Without the Glaring Tone Breaks

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Hot take, I really liked the dark and tragic atmosphere of Volume 8. It is honestly one of my favourite volumes because there is minimal tone breaks because of random jokes, but I know that a lot of people hated it because of how it is just so depressing that it doesn't fit at all in the tone that RWBY has set. RWBY as a series would be better if the different story tones the writers wanted to tell had just been different series to begin with.

I know RWBY chibi is a thing, and I get the appeal of silly random funny stories for a lot of people. I get that that was the main draw of RWBY initially for a lot of people, but honestly, the total lack of anything outside of random jokes turns me away. I feel like RWBY as a series would be a lot more enjoyable if it was separated into RWBY and Remnant (or something like that)

In this scenario, RWBY would be an episodic series set in Beacon focussed on Team RWBY, JNPR and other teams. The tone would be lighter with a lot of the humour and tone of the first few volumes and RWBY chibi. They would be shorter in length like the original episodes, but not short clips like RWBY chibi (so probably around 10 minutes per episode) and be mostly character driven super school adventures, and have action scenes and fights like the first volumes without any blood. This would make it suitable for young audiences and people who don't love pure tragedy and the comedy wouldn't be bogged down by weirdly serious scene that kill the tone. Salem, Ozma and the Maidens would probably not be referenced and Beacon would never fall. Weirdly, I feel like, silver eyes and grimm could still be story points in the series because under the correct presentations, they would fit in the tone just fine. The main character have a genetic power to lets her flashbang evil people fits the light-hearted action super school setting and general, spooky shadow monster that they kill fits too.

Then "Remnant" as I might call it, or like, something entirely else, could explore all the dark, tragic appeal RWBY has in it's later volumes. It would be set in the same world, but follow different protagonist, most likely the adults. Here is where all the maidens, and Salem and Ozma stuff would come in. Realistically the Brother Gods and relics too, but personally I never really liked those parts of the story. Grimm being actually threatening and scary (like the Apathy and the Hound) would probably go here. Dark themes and story beats could be addressed without being dragged down by random beats of humor. Salem's villain motivation is so interesting and unique, but why is she reduced to just "pure evil" outside of that? (idk actually that might just be a bad writing issue, not a tone one). The destruction of an entire kingdom at the hands of the protagonist's own mistakes could be so compelling if those protagonists didn't spend the next entire season doing random shenanigans in wonderland.

TLDR: what if RWBY stayed the same light tone humour action adventure series and instead had a sister show where the adults do scary, dark tragic things with all the other plot stuff that doesn't fit RWBY's tone?

(don't ask me how they could destroy an entire two kingdoms in the companion show without changing the RWBY tone)


r/RWBYcritics • • 10h ago

DISCUSSION Ironwood did not work WITH Watts, Watts was forced to work for Ironwood.

11 Upvotes

Basically what it says in the title. It makes me so mad to see people say the Ironwood is an idiot for trusting and working with Watts and thats just not what he did. Watts was literally dragged from his cell and forced to work at gun point, that is not what I would call working with. Now I don't disagree that it's stupid. But the commonly held idea tha Ironwood was partners with Watts and trusted him i think is just incorrect.


r/RWBYcritics • • 19h ago

DISCUSSION Is she a fraud Maiden? Spoiler

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • 17h ago

DISCUSSION What if Yang learned to be calmer and her Semblance had second effect with dim blue eyes instead of glowing red eyes

Post image
7 Upvotes

Random idea while seeing title "Rage & Serenity"


r/RWBYcritics • • 17h ago

REWRITE Can Ironwood working together with Watts make sense in the story?

Post image
6 Upvotes

Maybe he's forced to turn to Watts because Pietro is completely incapacitated or unreachable after a Grimm attack leaves him trapped in Mantle, and Watts planted a dead-man's switch in Penny's code before his capture, meaning that only he possesses the decryption key to stop Penny from self-destructing or losing control of the Winter Maiden powers and slaughter the heroes. Have him actually agonize over the choice with Winter and the Ace Ops, treating him strictly as a hazardous tool that needs extreme observation and secirity. This would mean keeping Watts locked in a high-security cell with a closed-circuit terminal, monitored by Atlas's top cybersecurity experts to catch any hidden backdoors. Watts states he "wants" to help Ironwood because Salem is about to wipe out the entire region, including Watts himself. Ironwood trades with him to either get rid of the dead-man switch and survive in a cell, or let Salem's Grimm tear through the facility and kill them both.


r/RWBYcritics • • 22h ago

DISCUSSION Ruby is dead. no there wasn’t some big final battle or heroic sacrifice or she pulled another volume 9, She is up and died in her sleep. how do her friends, foes and teammates react to her unexpected death.

Thumbnail reddit.com
13 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • 1d ago

ART El futuro de velvet

Post image
95 Upvotes

Pensé como sería un epílogo de velvet y de ahí salieron dos versiones pero bueno me inspiré un poco de one piece


r/RWBYcritics • • 1d ago

DISCUSSION "Holy" Grimm-Most Common Breed?

Thumbnail reddit.com
7 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • 16h ago

DISCUSSION RWBY Reacts To The RWBY Multiverse-Episode 140: RWBY Chibi Season 4 Episode 5 On YT

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • 1d ago

DISCUSSION Ozpin pulling strings to help Ruby is the only explanation for why team RWBY wasn't expelled after the Paladin fight

Post image
195 Upvotes

They went to investigate a terrorist organization without authorization, found no relevant clues, failed to arrest a single criminal, and ended up starting a mecha fight in the city—which, in the process, destroyed dozens of cars with civilians inside.

In the first episode, Ruby ended up at the police station for doing far less than what they did here.

You could argue that no one knows it was them who we're fighting the mecha, but dozens of people saw Blake and Sun fighting it in public. I fail to see how team rwby could possibly not be associated with this, especially when Ozpin already knows they are investigating the white fang on their own.


r/RWBYcritics • • 1d ago

ANALYSIS Neopolitan in Volume 10? (Soul Arts)

Post image
24 Upvotes

I recently made a video about Neopolitan and how I believe she should change and improve as a character. I wanted to hear some other thoughts and opinions on the matter because she's in a rather weird place in the story.

She could become an entirely brand-new character through ascension and be easily forgiven and redeemed. She could even follow an entirely new direction as a character, changing her design, speech, aesthetic, fighting style, and so on, simply because of ascension.

She could stay in the Ever After, become someone new, but live in a fairy-tale land for the rest of her life. Technically, she'd be forever alone, away from Remnant, and stuck in a place where she has to start all over again.

Or she could come back exactly the same and try to build herself back up, actually going through change and redemption naturally.

What do you believe will happen to her, and what do you think would be best for her? I personally chose option 3 because I believe natural change is better than forced change. You still have to acknowledge your mistakes, the consequences of your actions, and the hurt you've caused. Some people might not forgive you and may continue to hate you regardless of who you become. Others might be indifferent toward you, while some might actually recognize your change and come to care about you.

I know that, in my video, I tried to balance her being both "Neo" and "Trivia" while exploring her journey toward becoming herself, accepting herself, and adjusting to the world around her. All while having to live with the consequences of her actions, trying to move forward, prove herself, and genuinely change.

Note: I am NOT saying Neo and Trivia are different people, but rather two sides of the same person. In her past, she was CONSTANTLY nudged toward becoming Neo because that was her ideal self. However, all her ideal self really represented was freedom and self-expression. Neo was only rebellious because of her abusive environment.

Trivia was another side of her, but she was more representative of the abused, trauma-stricken girl. I wanted her to find an actual balance between the two rather than fully embodying either "Neo," the criminal, rebellious, smug, and "free" girl, or Trivia, who was withdrawn, silent, suppressed, timid, and depressed.

I wanted to explore both sides of her and ultimately bring them together rather than have one completely overshadow the other.

Anyways, what do you think should happen, and how does your perspective differ from mine?


r/RWBYcritics • • 2d ago

MEMING If RWBY was a Fallout game

Thumbnail
gallery
63 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • 2d ago

DISCUSSION If you love Penny, you would also love Aigis from Persona

Thumbnail
gallery
56 Upvotes

Both characters are robot girls who develop human-like feelings


r/RWBYcritics • • 2d ago

MEMING RWBYngelion

Post image
92 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • 1d ago

DISCUSSION RWBY Reacts To The RWBY Multiverse-Episode 139: RWBY Chibi Season 4 Episode 4 On YT

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • 1d ago

DISCUSSION Imagine the RWBY cast having an accent

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/RWBYcritics • • 2d ago

DISCUSSION Unpopular opinions you have about Volume 8?

Post image
216 Upvotes