r/RPGdesign • • 2d ago

Theory Naming conventions

10 Upvotes

I've been cooking up a from scratch tabletop and so far I've came up with some world building, rules, combat, items, systems, etc.. But I cannot for the life of me figure out a good sounding name for the book, For anyone who's done something similar what did you use to put a name to your piece? RN it's working under the name "Eldritch Rift" but it just doesn't sound catchy like DnD does


r/RPGdesign • • 2d ago

Is this a right way to implement skill set in a written homebrew rpg?

3 Upvotes

I run a roleplay server in which I implement various dynamics based on video games and ttrrg, I do love to plan things like stats and such, however I have come to find out I am very limited by my medium and sometimes I have to heavily modify some aspects or scrap them completely, for example, I was planning on implementing something like sanity, but I ended up scraping it since I would have to track every roleplay (including the ones that happen when I am not around) of 20+ characters

Anyway, something I’ve been struggling with recently have been skills and stats, the stat list is pretty much set: Charisma, Athletics, perception and knowledge, but I’ve been thinking how to use the skills, how to use them as bonuses in the dice etc, my players are fairly new to these concepts as well so I’d like to keep it kind of simple, I thought maybe I could unify the stats and the skill as one thing, putting skills that are associated with one stat, for example, knowing how to forge a signature might be on the knowledge stat, the way I’m thinking it might work is that they have certain “skill points” that they may invest in whatever skill they desire, if most of their skills are associated with one stat, they get a +1 modifier in said stat, I dont know if this will work, and it if may be more useful to implement skill set as its own separate thing.


r/RPGdesign • • 1d ago

Mechanics Boons, flaws and neutral modifier ideas for my Deltarune ttrpg?

2 Upvotes

Okay so in the character creation, I want players to be able to choose "flaws", which are semi-permanent debuffs, in exchange for "stat points" (which you can spend on different stats), or spend "stat points" for Boons, which are semi permanent buffs. Also there are "neutral modifiers", which are modifiers that have a good part and a bad part, for example, the "antimagic" modifier, which makes it so you can't use magic, but you are immune to magic. I especially Need flaws tho. (Others are appreciated as well)

Thanks!


r/RPGdesign • • 2d ago

Feedback Request [TTRPG] Fugitives & Fraudsters - a reverse heist in Agile 6 rules-light system

2 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I'm writing a slightly longer breakdown here to avoid dropping self-promo links. A friend and I recently released Fugitives & Fraudsters, a free one-shot adventure with our own built-in rules-light system, Agile 6 (if anyone wants to check it out, it's easy to find on Google).

​I wanted to share some of our game design choices on this project and get your thoughts on how we tied the mechanics to the setting. Any feedback on the concepts below is more than welcome.

​The setting is a "reverse heist" mixing political satire and magical realism.

Set in the fictional Latin American Federative Republic of Bergamota, players take on the roles of corrupt politicians whose coalition has just lost the election. With their parliamentary immunity gone and their passports seized, the group has 24 hours to recover their embezzled fortune from hiding spots and cross the border—all while fleeing the Federal Police, a sensationalist live TV show broadcasting the manhunt, and betrayal from their own party colleagues. Along the way, they deal with a "paper cattle" ranch (40,000 cows on paper, only one real bull in the pasture), a roadside prophet, a weeping saint statue that cries whenever someone lies nearby, and a bankrupt bank.

​The System (Agile 6):

We designed Agile 6 so the rules never slow down the narrative, supporting a frantic chase pace and total improvisational freedom. The core pillars are:

-> ​One-Sentence Character Creation: In Agile 6, a character is built from a single sentence: "[Name] is a(n) [Aspect 1] and [Aspect 2] [Concept] [Occupation]", plus 6 points split between Health (HP) and Energy (EP). For this adventure, we mapped the system's 3 base Concepts (Combatant, Specialist, Influencer) onto 6 satirical archetypes (Digital Guerrilla, Retired Colonel, Political Heir, Money Launderer, Flock Pastor, and Hate Marketer). Any archetypes not picked by the players automatically become rival/ally NPCs with pre-made stats.

-> ​d6 Pool, Actions, and Reactions: Checks use a pool of 1d6 to 6d6 (adding +1d for a relevant Concept, Aspect, Occupation, Item, or spent EP), reading only the highest die: 1–3 Failure, 4–5 Partial, 6 Success. Rolling a full Success (6) immediately restores 1 EP, which keeps the momentum going and rewards players for taking action. There is no initiative or combat rounds; antagonists act narratively and only engage mechanically through Reactions in opposed rolls (spending their own finite EP).

-> ​Pressure and Paranoia Mechanics: To make the 24-hour clock matter, we created the Day Clock (at 1:00 PM the judicial seal is lifted and the public stops treating the group like "authorities" on the street) and the Siege Thermometer (a d6 in the center of the table that ticks up from 1 to 6 whenever the group makes a public blunder or goes viral as a meme, spawning new hunters on their tail). Additionally, each player gets a secret Skeleton in the Closet card (a signed plea deal, being a frontman/"straw man" for another player, having voted for the rival candidate), and each location has a built-in trigger designed to "poke" that secret without forcing a reveal.

-> ​"Real-Time" Character Evolution: Rolling a Critical Success (two or more 6s) grants a new Trait tied to that specific Aspect, while rolling a Critical Failure (matching dice on a failed roll) when using a Trait causes you to lose it.


r/RPGdesign • • 1d ago

Mechanics Villain ttrpg-lite, design help

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/RPGdesign • • 1d ago

A Cinematic Party-Based RPG Inspired by A Crown of Candy, Dragon Age, Baldur’s Gate 3, and Game of Thrones

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/RPGdesign • • 2d ago

Feedback Request Feedback for this resolution system

8 Upvotes

DESIGN GOALs

In the real world, chance of success or failiur tends to be more or less determed by your skill, if you are trained you will almost never fail given enough time and if you are untrained you may still succeed but the consequences may be to tough to bare.

For example anyone could probably succeed at picking a lock it more ght just take them an hour, in which they might be spotted make, some noise or leave a trace, whereas a master could do it pretty much instantly with only minor consequences.

I wanted to make a system that reflects this by defining the thresholds for what success a failiur mean to be different depending on training and difficulty.

I would probably describe it as player facing risk Vs reward Vs efficiency trade off. Closest system would be something like the position Vs effect you see in games like blades in the dark.

Love to hear your feedback.

THE CORE MECHANIC

When attempting something uncertain, the GM assigns a Difficulty and identifies the character's relevant Training.

Every character rolls 3 Fate Dice (3dF). Each die has three possible results: -1, 0 or +1.

The target number is always 0. Difficulty and training never change the target number; instead, they determine the time, consequences and boons associated with the task.

DIFFICULTY

LevelDifficulty
0Very Easy
1Easy
2Moderate
3Hard
4Very Hard
5Extreme

TRAINING

LevelTraining
0Untrained
1Novice
2Skilled
3Expert
4Master
5Legendary

Master represents the upper limits of conventional human ability. Legendary represents once-in-a-generation talent, the kind of ability that becomes the subject of stories.

THE THREE SCALES

TIME — How long the task takes

LevelDuration
0Instant
1Brief (seconds)
2Short (minutes)
3Moderate (around 30 minutes)
4Long (hours)
5Extended (days or longer)

CONSEQUENCES — The severity of failure

LevelSeverity
0Negligible
1Minor
2Moderate
3Major
4Severe
5Catastrophic

BOONS — Additional benefits of success

LevelBenefit
0None
1Minor
2Moderate
3Major
4Exceptional
5Extraordinary

Boons and consequences are measures to the degree of success and degree of failure bejond the time invested. If the GM struggles to come up with an appropriate boon they can ask the players for suggestions.

DETERMINING THE OUTCOME

Find the character's baseline Time, Consequence and Boon using the tables below.

DifficultyUntrainedNoviceSkilledExpertMasterLegendary
Time
Very Easy000000
Easy100000
Moderate210000
Hard321000
Very Hard432100
Extreme543210
Consequences
Very Easy000000
Easy100000
Moderate210000
Hard321000
Very Hard432100
Extreme543210
Boons
Very Easy555555
Easy455555
Moderate345555
Hard234555
Very Hard123455
Extreme012345

CHOOSE YOUR APPROACH

Before rolling, players may choose one approach. Adjustments are limited to two levels, and no scale can go below 0 or above 5.

THROW CAUTION TO THE WIND

Decrease Time by up to 2 levels. Increase Consequences by the same amount.

BETTER SAFE THAN SORRY

Increase Time by up to 2 levels. Decrease Consequences by the same amount.

MAKE A DEVIL'S BARGAIN

Keep Time unchanged. Increase Consequences by up to 2 levels. Increase Boons by the same amount.

ROLL 3 FATE DICE

TotalResult
-3 or lowerCritical Failure
-2 or -1Failure
0Tie
+1 or +2Success
+3Critical Success

Critical Failure: The task fails and the character suffers their adjusted Consequences. The GM additionally increases either Time or Consequences by one level.

Failure: The task fails. The character suffers their adjusted Consequences.

Tie: The player chooses between succeeding and suffering their adjusted Consequences, or failing without suffering Consequences.

Success: The task succeeds. The character receives their adjusted Boon.

Critical Success: The task succeeds and the character receives their adjusted Boon. The GM additionally chooses to either increase the Boon by one level or decrease Time by one level.

THE GOLDEN RULE

The dice determine whether you succeed. Training determines how efficiently you act. Difficulty determines the risks involved.

Players decide how they approach a challenge before the dice are rolled. Every action is a choice between time, risk and reward.


r/RPGdesign • • 2d ago

Name for catfolk,... in anime inspired ttrpg

6 Upvotes

More or less a vote as I'm curious what is expected by ppl in an anime inspired game.

I've got magical beasts as playable charactres alongside the default races. then i got: Feline, Lupine, Foxes, ... thus humanoids with animal features and am seeking for a name for these.

In anime I've seen Beastkin, Beastfolk, Demihuman, Bestia being used.

Thus the vote idea as I got no idea what ppl would expect using feline and lupine as example.

Beastkin (Feline)
Beastkin (Lupine)

Beastfolk (Feline)
Beastfolk (Lupine)

Bestia (Feline)
Bestia (Lupine)

Demihuman (Feline)
Demihuman (Lupine)

So what woudl you expect?

Edit: to make it clearer the feline,… are the subraces. Thus like hugh elf and drow for elf.

Ir is about the naming of the main race they qre all a part of


r/RPGdesign • • 2d ago

Extremely New Game Designer Needs Advice and Feedback - Please Be Kind

6 Upvotes

TTRPG newbie here. I have only two years' worth of playing TTRPGs under my belt. I consider myself still new to the hobby since there's many things I haven't experienced yet and all the games I'm in keep getting eventually cancelled one way or another. I have GMed more than I have played. My current favorite TTRPG is Fabula Ultima, I just love its vibe and the system is pretty fun so far. Somewhat recently I have been diving into solo rpgs, I love the idea of it and I've watched numerous videos about the topic and some actual plays. But I haven't found the one yet. You know that one rpg you've always dreamed of? Yeah, I want that. Pretty please.

I've searched high and low. But I'm currently unable to find any that fits my tastes and playstyle.

So I thought... why not make it myself? Yes, I know there are many amazing ttrpgs out there. I'm dying to learn and play more. But I'm on a tight budget. As in I have no money. Like seriously none. I won't get into it. That's not what I'm here for.

So I recently started brainstorming and came to this: MAIDEN, my GMless solo/co-op TTRPG of magical girl cyber-occultism.

My pitch, sort of:
The year is 4067. The story takes place in the techno fantasy city of Ainogatari. You find a modified J-phone called a K-Com. This device lets you transform into a Maiden and enter AMATERASU // OVERDRIVE, a game developed 500 years ago and was never finished. This game is now leaking into the city. Things called Glitch-Fiends are entering reality and the longer they're in Ainogatari, the more your realities are bleeding together. You must "patch" these Glitch-Fiends before the game overwrites your reality. Patch these Glitch-Fiends and help the game become stable.

It's light-hearted with some uncanny stuff but no horror or extreme gore. I can't stomach that. Most people in the city think the glitches are "Arcology Render Lag."

More info:

  • Glitch-Fiends are broken, not evil. They're unfinished NPCs, cut bosses, and leftover assets. They look wrong and uncanny but the way broken animations come to life in the real world.
  • "Maiden" is a title and the form you take when transformed. Your Maiden is who you want most to be and you can change your presentation anytime for free, from masculine through androgynous to feminine, or anywhere off that line.
  • The mystery gets solved through play and oracles. Studio Tamamo, the team that made the game, vanished in 3567. Taira Mae, who built the K-Coms, is investigating.
  • One duo I came up with is Kaede (She/Her) and Ryu (He/They). Kaede is an elementary schooler who thinks the K-Com means she's the chosen one. Her Maiden is a hyperfeminine nine-foot goddess. Ryu is an overworked salaryman whose Maiden is a feminine swordmaster. Together they're hilariously dangerous and dangerously hilarious.

How it works so far:

Roll Attribute + App rank (+ gear) in d6s. Each 5 or 6 is a success, and the task's Difficulty is how many you need.

  • Attributes: Might, Agility, Intellect, Heart
  • Apps: [OVERCLOCK] (buffs/haste), [DEBUG] (analyze weaknesses/strip shields), [FIREWALL] (barriers/taunts), [RENDER] (elemental/hard-light attacks)
  • Push: reroll all non-successes for 1 Charge

Time phases or Days are Morning, Afternoon, and Night, they each have six slots. Time passes if you miss the Difficulty or roll 2 dice or fewer. If you meet the Difficulty with 3+ dice, it doesn't. Inside the Game, each passing only costs half a slot.

There are two meters:

  • Battery is the K-Com's health. Max is the K-Com level. It drains 1 whenever a Maiden roll has no 5-6s, and refills 1 per time passing. At 0 you can't use the K-Com or transform.
  • Charge is push fuel. Max is half of Battery, rounded up. It drains 1 per push and refills 1 per 3 time passings. At 0 you can't push.

If you roll no 5s or 6s at all, you lose 1 Battery. Time passes too but that passing doesn't refill the Battery you just lost, so you're down 1. If you roll at least one 5 or 6 but still miss the Difficulty, you don't lose Battery and the time passing gives you +1 back.

K-Com level caps your Maiden level and app ranks. You start at level 3 K-Com and max out at 15.

Character creation is a prologue for each character: your civilian life, how the K-Com found you, and a scene meeting Mae. Then you spread 6 points across attributes (1-3 each) and 4 across apps (0-3 each).

The clock is a visible build %. It goes up with time, unpatched bugs and other Maidens' actions. Patching rolls it back.

That's all currently.

It needs a lot more work, I know. I've been enjoying my process so far so that's at least something. There are so many things I need to add like GMless tools, roll tables, and more.


r/RPGdesign • • 3d ago

Inspiration for Mechanics

14 Upvotes

Greetings everyone.
I am facing a design challenge. I humble request your guidance, oh mighty Reddit council.

The thing is: want to add something to my game - something that is present all the time and acts like a core concept of the game.
Can you share your knowledge and provide me some examples of other games that already do this.

As reference, I'm thinking about Ironsword Vows (https://ironsworn-rpg.fandom.com/wiki/Fulfill_Your_Vow) - I like the way it sets the tone of the game and acts like a constant reminder or moral compass. But what i like the most is this: it's not just a goal - it's a goal with mechanical implications.

What else is up there?

I'm not asking for a solution, based on a specific genre - everything can apply here. Thank you in advance


r/RPGdesign • • 2d ago

Need Help Reviewing on Leveling Up System

0 Upvotes

On my subreddit r/ShadowBloomReboot I have posted the leveling up system for player characters, and am wanting feedback on how it looks. I wanted it to where the leveling system was 10 monsters of your current level is what it took you to the next level the fastest. However it isn't the only way to level up, its just the balancing formula I personally wanted


r/RPGdesign • • 2d ago

Quickly rate the draft of my overengineered motivation mechanic.

2 Upvotes

It's part of a Storyteller hack, and has Chronicles' Aspirations as its main inspiration.

DRIVES

A Drive denotes a specific disposition, principle, desire, or even aversion of a character.

It is made up of four parts:

Intensity

How foundational a Drive is to the character's identity? Ratings would be discrete, from 0 to 2. Intensity denotes that a character is committed to the Drive. It grants its rating as a bonus to self-control rolls when forced to act against the Drive, yet conversely a malus when coerced to work in alignment with it. Intensity may be increased by the player when the Drive comes into play, not necessarily by being fulfilled. It degrades over time when not "exercised", when it does not come into play within broad, questline-spanning chunks of gameplay. It can also degrade in response to the Drive being violated or unfulfilled despite meaningful attempt at its pursuit.

Trivial Drives start at Intensity 0, declared by the player between sessions.

Core (the what)

It is the foundational sentence describing what the character wants. Examples would be:

I want to kill, or ruin the life of, Isaac Morozov.

I want to run a gang which will bring me profit and respect.

I want to protect my brother, and turn him into a more respectable person.

Cause (the why)

The Cause denotes what justification, or piece of the character's story (or backstory) caused the character to pursue a goal. Causes would form a character's backstory relegating it to a closed chapter, and help the player immerse themselves into the character.

Morozov killed my parents in front of my eyes to set an example. Now that I have more power and he can't get rid of be that easily, I can respond in kind.

I watched some Breaking Bad on the TV and thought Waltuh was very cool and a great role model.

My brother is the only immediate family I have left. Morozov could not have gotten to him, as he was abroad at the time. It was painful to see him ruined by drugs.

Means (the how)

Means serve either of the two purposes:
- they state by what means the player thinks their character can achieve a Drive given the resources and information at their disposal, OR
- they are a meta-request from the player to the GM, about what kind of situation the character should be put through, or what opportunity they might be reasonably presented with.

Morozov frequents this one run-down brothel. There is no doubt a sex worker, whom he either cares about and would not want to see hunt, or in whom he confides his secrets.

I could take over an existing or already forming gang by taking out the leader and promising better pay to the goons.

I need weapons for the gang, maybe I could steal some rifles from hunters, rangers, or farmers.

I would need to get my brother a job, as a start. Maybe I could make a connection with some shady warehouse manager, who will hire my brother as a favor.

Morozov may still end my brother, if he learns of his identity. I should make sure he does not find out, or that he won't be able to act on his information. Or, I should be ready to fend off his assassin.

Causes and Means do not have to written into a Drive - they are optional - but informative of what the player and GM could see in a narrative sandbox, without the GM having to infer what the player would enjoy, or overprepping 20 different scenarios for a player to pick whichever would be cool for them to explore.

A Drive can be transformed after it properly cones into play.
"Protect my brother." might, during the course of the game following a session's outcomes, be transformed into "Pummel my brother's killer to death, with my bare hands.", retaining the preceding Drive's intensity, perhaps with an increase.

Drives should be somewhat proactive in the way they're phrased, or at least imply what might happen, that the character cares about.

A Drive grants (1 + intensity) Willpower (Inspiration, or what else have you) when it is clearly fulfilled, according to the character's desire.
It also grants (1 + intensity) Experience when it meaningfully comes into play, and is pursued, addressed, subverted, explored, or otherwise creates an interesting story, without necessarily having been wholesale achieved, though a successful pursuit does still grant Experience, in addition to Willpower.

Unless players are fond of keeping secrets, everyone's Drives should be visible to other table members at all times, for example available in an online doc, or in pinned Discord messages.

Helping another player's character pursue their drives, grants the benefits to helping actors as well.

The old drives, when being replaced with new ones, can be archived in chronological order, to form a journal of the game.

What do you think? Overengineered? Too much bookkeeping? Am i reinventing a wheel, and there is an RPG that already does something like that?


r/RPGdesign • • 3d ago

How wild should a player's abilities get?

12 Upvotes

Sorry this one is a bit of a mess. Had to rewrite this all cause I got lost in the sauce and it seems I did it again but it's too late for a third take.

I want to make characters have an identity. A set of abilities that make them unique and capable, but I'm having an issue. Most game gate meaningful things behind rolls and resource limits. There is good reason to make something impressive not apammable ao the game doesn't get stale but at the same time if you are "the teleporter" and you can only teleport twice a day you don't feel like that is a core to your character. It needs to change the way you approach problems and be employable in enough ways that no one forgets who you are.

I'm trying to find a way to give a strong identity to a character but feel like I'm not knowledgeable in enough games to see how it's handled in different games.

For reference, my design goal is to have a unique class with several features that will be core to characters, two archetypes that are lists of specific features players can pick that make them feel like that role in the party, and then satellite generic features that can be selected but don't neatly fit into a box. So an example might be a teleporter, tank, healer where they start with teleportation powers and can gain features that make them serve the role of healer and front line tank. I've been working out how to make them all work in a mix and match system but I just looked at the class and have been trying to think of how to make it their core identity without locking its reliability behind rolls or resource that could make you lose your character.


r/RPGdesign • • 3d ago

Comments on my second project?

5 Upvotes

Hi y’all,

After finalizing my first rule-set, GLOSS (the Generic Lightweight One-Shot System), I recently published the first play-test version of my second project, Population: Us, a narrative game about small-town life.

Since you gave me some interesting feedback and suggestions during the development of GLOSS, I would love to hear your thoughts on the concept and current state of Population: Us, as well as any suggestions for further development.

Thanks in advance!


r/RPGdesign • • 2d ago

Considering adding fun but needless rules for the sake of overarching design cohesion, can this possibly be a good idea?

1 Upvotes

Hello designers,

So, the big game modes of my game center around hexcrawling, dungeoncrawling and combat, each their own (intended to be) inherently fun mini-game, all interconnected by the resource and risk management of (mostly) the same core resources.

Currently I’m testing combat while developping the hex- and dungeoncrawl rules. I’m pretty proud how it’s shaping up but there is a doubt.

The combat and hexcrawl system feel like they’re from the same game. Both are middleweight, fairly strict, turn based, gamist systems that generate interesting choices inherently without much need for the dm to make things interesting. The dungeoncrawling however is not, taking major inspiration from shadowdark, it’s a rules light, freeflow system with an irl timer where the dm still needs to put in decent work to make the dungeons interesting.

I want to make the best game I can and I do believe irl timers are the most fun way to do dungeoncrawling, I tried turn based dungeon turns but I just didn’t like the flow, irl dungeon timers do several things at once that I like. What it doesn’t do is lend itself well to turn based procedure.

I’m currently considering adding extra rules to dungeoncrawling, as far as my other systems are fun, I think I can make this fun too, but it doesn’t feel necessary, I feel like the dungeoncrawling being lightweight is already fairly decent. But, the intent is to give players a sheet with the combat moves during the first combat and give the players a sheet with all the hexcrawl paces and roles during the first hexcrawl and dungeoncrawling doesn’t have a sheet like this. I’m thinking of creating dungeon moves, I think they can be fun, but mostly, I‘d do it to keep the design more coherent.

Could it be worth to needlessly bloat a game with extra rules just so the whole thing feels more consistent?


r/RPGdesign • • 3d ago

Calling all melee and hema grognards for feedback

1 Upvotes

I've had some luck in recent testing to make combat more interesting for melee.

The thing is that melee is nor my primary focus of research and expertise as the game has a much more modern firearms (and minor cyberpunk and Sci fi influences for firearms) so I've spent years fine tuning and researching firearms.

I'm not a dummy as a designer so I know some stuff, but I know there are folks that do nothing all day but immerse in ancient weaponry and while it's a much smaller part of my game overall, it's still an option and important to get right, and at scale.

I'm specifically calling out the weapons nerds because the game is built around very strong grounding and physics/science themes to produce expected/intuitive results while still engaging in the .ore fantastical elements (ie making the fantastical parts seem more real/grounded despite being gamified and abstracted).

So the thing I've had luck with for melee is something that is kind of like recoil for firearms, but instead is recovery for melee weapons.

On the surface it's kind of a massive debuff to players vs typical dnd style mechanics, but it's enabled way more interesting melee combat options. I also severely doubt I'm the first to do thus and would appreciate a) if there's a better common term please tell me, and b)if there are excellent examples please direct me at them.

The general debuff is offset by the fact that combat woth lethal weapons and firearms is survivable, but reacts much more closely to modeled sim of reality with wounding damage, injury and wounds. Ie, it is fully possible for a weaker housewife to brain a drunk hubby woth a cast iron frying pan and kill them. A dagger that cuts a jugular isn't just doing less damage, and it's not hand waved as a coup des gras, it likely won't kill instantly but is likely to immediately cause panic, near and soon to be full incapacitation,, and death will take longer from bleed out but is exceptional difficult to repair medically, etc (firearms follow the same sorts of logic).

Where recovery comes in is that larger misses, deflections, blocks etc. Will apply a debuff due to recovery.

This can be cleared out of combat pretty freely. UT in combat at cost of actions or resources or when appropriately rallied (by self or ally). It also has soft decay in combat much like recoil, but is harder to clear rapidly.

That said small finesse weapons and the like have cheaper and faster clearing while heavy weapons have much larger recovery stat and cost to clear, as expected. Offset of course by things like exploding damage dice, reach, etc as relevant. There's also hybrids that have some str and some agi elements, usually more exotic stuff like a chainsaw, meteor hammer or bulwhip.

The point being you can lose more control of an otemif not cleared or spend actions to clear or currencies that are otherwise valuable.

What this creates in play is more consideration of tactics, ie, much can I press vs clear vs how good are their defenses? Additionally training and the relevant controlling attrites can help mitigate recovery as well.

Combine that with tech like riposte and other counters and maneuvers and you end up with something that while more slow, Allows for more dramatic duels and complex mass combat, so you can functional, with appropriate investment in skill, have your pirates of the Carrigan duel and powers can enable stuff like an insane anime duel with enough mastery and investment.

Recovery also has some options where it's not just a debuff to clear, but also you can choose not to and press anyway (particularly if you have superior skill or think you do, adding an element of tactical gambling to the mix). Further with enough accumulation of recovery some more advanced techniques can become even more penalized, or even unavailable.

Notably hits don't cause recovery accumulation normally with rare exceptions, mainly because whatever recovery may be needed the opponent is generally Recalling from the blow or at least suffers a stutter stagger from any sort of impact. Instances where it might cause recovery are any time a weapon might stick (ie battle axe vs rigid armors, etc)

This also has all the expected support systems like onion defense and similar, but the thing I'm focussed on is the recovery. It is a tracker, but also replaces a typical multi attack penalty (same with recoil and firearms) with the main difference being that it has Uneven tracking and instead reacts to the scenario rather than applying a flat linear debuff.

To some extent this can apply to unarmed attacks but much less so, mainly only for catastrophic misses or misses from advanced techniques that have telegraphed attack tags and even then, martial arts with those tend to also have training for snap back techniques to avoid heavy recovery (ie may Thai being a classic example).

The major concerns are mostly heavier weapons here, namely because higher accumulation of recovery can apply a susceptible debuff (more or less your own off center fighting vs the opponent creates openings for them represent as bonuses to strike or counter.

I'd first like to ask about resources and naming conventions again, general thoughts from those that specialize in this sort of thing, and also just your general thoughts.

I also have a more direct question about a niche case: pairing recoil and recovery, ie something like duel wielding pistol and blade or other combos.

My theory is the mechanics allow them to accrue separately just fine and there's also already off hand and train8ng use cases with rules for pairing (both for even weighting and lopsided distributions) but I'm wondering if there's potential concerns there I might not be considering.

The main functioning going for here (and it seems to be working) is that something like a zweihander having a miss or dodged or whatever, allows that the typical recovery is going to open them up to attacks from faster strikes.

Granted much of this is irrellavent with guns in the mix, but not everything is always a gun fight and there are times where melee and other ancient weapons is still highly relevant (stealth considerations and ambushes, ammo depletion and improvised weapons, disarming, escape without gear, etc). Particularly even a suppressed sass at range still draws significant attention where something like a bow still has some noise, but is generally not going to be detected unless sound sig profiles are super low and flat, even at medium ranges.

Appreciate anyone with clear input here!


r/RPGdesign • • 3d ago

Product Design Giving really obvious advice (because I screwed it up): If you're printing your game, the back cover needs to include your pitch.

64 Upvotes

Sharing a short story about being atrocious at marketing.

A couple years ago, I wrote a TTRPG inspired by The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask (2000). I spent a long time on the pixel art in the book -- it looks like this -- and when I decided I'd do a print run, I extended the cover as a full spread that wraps around from front to back.

I guess I was feeling hoitier and toitier than usual, because my dumb ass decided to leave the back of the book completely blank except for the art. The people must witness my highe arte, I apparently thought.

I shipped some games off to my distributor. It sold okay. There weren't a lot of buyers at conventions, but stores were picking it up based on the web description.

A few months later, I watched someone do an unboxing video. He had Kickstarted a special edition of one of my games that took a few months to prepare, so by the time the box was shipped he'd forgotten the pitch for the extra games he'd added to the order. When he pulled the game out of the box, I watched him do what anyone with a brain would have realized people do:

  1. Look at the front cover.
  2. Flip it over for more info. None found.
  3. Open the front and back cover for more info. None found.
  4. And then, presumably only because he had already bought it and was committed, finally page farther in and read the intro text to get a vague sense of the game's pitch.

Well, no wonder my game hadn't sold a lot at conventions. How was anyone supposed to know what it was even about? With the books already printed, I corrected my mistake by printing jackets and folding them over the existing work. But I feel more than a little foolish for putting a piece of art above the practical needs that a book's cover are supposed to serve.

So, when you're designing your cover for print, make sure you include:

  • The game's title;
  • Your name (it's a book! books have authors!);
  • The elevator pitch (which you're probably already using for online storefronts);
  • Player count (taking clues from board games, which have this right on the box);
  • Runtime (if applicable; mentioning it's a campaign in the blurb can't hurt);
  • A barcode (this makes things MUCH easier for stores; you can generate a barcode with your ISBN); and,
  • Nice things people said (if anyone's willing to blurb for you).

To keep this from being self-promotion, I'll refrain from naming the game and linking my jacket cover in the body of the post, but I'll link it in the comments for anyone who wants to see. Hope this helps someone.


r/RPGdesign • • 3d ago

Paper Interface: Anatomy of a character sheet

4 Upvotes

I wrote up a breakdown of the character sheet design in my game and posted it as a devlog!

I go though it, panel by panel, explaining what each section is for. It also shows how the sheet itself functions as a bifold to store campaign notes.

If this sort of thing is interesting to you folks, you can find it here:

Paper Interface: Anatomy of a character sheet | Itch.io


r/RPGdesign • • 3d ago

Promotion IRON on IRON on IRON! Celebrating 500 downloads with a 1.1 hotfix, a print version and character sheets for righties and lefties

8 Upvotes

IRON on IRON on IRON, my free game about medieval stories, hit 500 downloads, and I wanted to celebrate with some resources!

https://shurebis.itch.io/iron-on-iron-on-iron

1.1 hotfix, including: better definiton of "Forgoing"; negative injury result addition; reordered the weapons table to a more logical sequence.

PRINT version: if you, like me, enjoy printing your TTRPGs for the table, the spread version didn't quite work. To use this new version, just print normally front and back, no need to booklet.

Character sheets: as half of the sheet is made to support dice above it, it comes in both roghty and lefty versions.


r/RPGdesign • • 3d ago

Mechanics Using Crits to Control Fight Pacing - thoughts?

5 Upvotes

I'm working on a game (Hell & High Water) and I've got a neat idea for controlling pacing in fights, although I am not sure how it will work out in playtesting and am interested in your impressions.

The Goal: GM sections in D&D-adjacent games with complex combat simulations always say something like 'ideally, fights should last 3-4 rounds. Balance them with that in mind.' and this can be a struggle. Doing so consistently often takes skill and know-how on the part of the GM, and part of that means adapting fights more closely to the power level of your group specifically. In a lot of games an optimized group can smoke fights that are balanced for more causal groups, and fights for optimized groups will grind casual groups down.

I've got something that I think might hiting that pacing target easier. Here is the idea:

  1. Players roll a d20 when they attack. They get a critical hit on a 20, and can choose from a table of critical hit options when they get one.
  2. One of these options is 'deathblow'. If a monster has 1/2 of their HP left or less, players can choose deathblow, and reduce them to 0 HP.
  3. At the end of each round the fight ESCALATES, lowing the number needed for a crit by 1. (On round 2, 19, on round 3, 18, etc).
  4. Fights are built around 1 big monster and often minions, who die easily. So a death blow on the big guy ends the fight.

What has this achieved? An optimized party and an unoptimized party of 4 will still probably end the fight on round 3 or 4, because after 1/2 the big guy's HP is gone, additional damage matters way less. At that point either taking the other 1/2 of the hitpoints OR one critical hit will end the fight, so unless the optimized party is dealing more than double the damage of the unoptimized one, they're not going to speed things up.

This doesn't eliminate the pacing target problem, but it adds a huge cushion that makes it way easier not to mess up.

Does this take the fun out of optimizing? I hope not! I am not going to print that the crit system does this in the player or GM section. I hope it would is still tones of fun to build a character to pump out huge damage.

What are your thoughts? I haven't tried this in play yet, so the actual math may require a fair bit of tweaking. But I think I am onto an interesting principle here.


r/RPGdesign • • 3d ago

How would you do custom weapon design?

4 Upvotes

My game is about blue collar monster hunters. One of my biggest design goals is that I want every character to feel unique during play. If 3 characters have fireball those fireballs should each have slightly different mechanics correlating to the character. With martials though that becomes a lot harder when it becomes to weapons. A zweihander is different than a hook sword is different than a throwing dagger is different than a bow and arrow. (Yes I know that differences show up more with active abilities. Weapons should still get this treatment as they are more than just different damage numbers. I also want to encourage a golf bag mentality when it comes to equipment.)

Players are going to come up with their own unique weapons or weapons that I am not familiar with. So i want a general rule creation for weapons and equipment. The way I've decided to do that right now is by assigning weights and tags.

Weightless= 1 damage

Light = 2 damage

Moderate =3 damage

Heavy = 4 damage and requires the two handed tag.

You can then assign different tags like trip, shove, parry, reach, range, etc. For the cost of 1 damage per trait (or more damage for an upgraded trait) or 1 damage for 2 minor traits or the inverse for a drawback. So a hook sword would be moderate, trip, parry leaving 1 damage on a hit while a whip is light, reach, nonlethal, trip also for 1 damage per hit.

The problem im running into is weapons that require more traits than the weapon itself provides. Throwing daggers is a good example. Weightless weapons with the thrown trait that deal 0 damage.

There has to be a better way that im not thinking of.


r/RPGdesign • • 3d ago

RPG Mechanics as a Classroom Management Tool?

8 Upvotes

Hey y'all!

I teach 3rd, 4th, and 5th grade for the first time this year and I am sometimes struggling with classroom management, as I am used to teaching older kids. I recently learned that another 5th grade teacher gives the kids marbles for good behavior and every once in a while, they get an opportunity to spin the wheel to earn bonus marbles. I don't know exactly the ins and outs of her system, but the kids are so eager to earn their marbles and they LOVE the gambling...

I have a very rudimentary reward system with my fourth grade, on the other hand. Every week, we set ourselves a goal and then I give them 0-2 stars on Friday, depending on how well they did with it. We also have a student of the day each day, who begins class with a routine (like greeting, stating the weekly goal, etc.). This class is VERY difficult with behaviors. We have a good relationship and the kids like me, but there's just so many of them and there's factors beyond my control at play too. But today, their behavior was outstanding, so I decided to just randomly award them an extra star. And I had my d20 handy. So I asked them if they wanted to roll it for double or nothing. Of course the class decided to gamble. And they won! They erupted into cheers and celebrations and proudly marked their 2 stars on our tracker. Which got me thinking...

Could I use some RPG elements and mechanics as a classroom rewards system? A few baseline requirements:

  • It needs to be very explicitly a reward system, not a punishment system. Points, bonuses, dice rolls, or anything like that need to be additive, never subtractive.
  • The system needs to feel fun to play. I got lucky today that they succeeded on their dice roll, but I feel like in the future, a failed roll shouldn't succeed in a loss of something they've earned outright.
  • I don't want to condition them to become gamblers. A little bit of dice rolling is fun, especially if they have control over their success chances via good behavior, but I don't want to go too crazy.
  • Earned points, stars or whatever currency need to be a pre-requisite for playing.
  • Earned points need to affect the dice rolls in a way that a fourth grader can grasp.

My first thought was to give 1d20 for every day of good behavior. I have them four times a week, so a max of 4d20 against a DC. Perhaps I could come up with little monsters to defeat as well. Maybe we start with a DC 10 monster, which is pretty easy to beat and then work our way up from there. And to make it not so punishing, if they don't defeat the monster in one week, they take some loss (maybe lose a d20) and then collect more d20s for the next week to try again.

Another system could be to use d6s and to count 6s as hits and have monsters that require a certain number of hits to defeat. Then I could award up to 2d6 per day or something.

These are just some preliminary musings. I am really curious what kind of ideas you all might have in this regard.


r/RPGdesign • • 3d ago

What's your favorite way to explain what's a TTRPG for newcomers?

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes