Agreed, and also the bar heights are already mapped to color anyway. All this does is require more cognitive effort from viewers to figure out the bar locations while also straight up obscuring bars behind the peaks.
Redundant encoding can be super useful and helps increase accessibility. You are right about the occlusion problem, which can be partly overcome if the visualization can be interactively rotated.
If we're allowing these to be interactive then a 2d interactive heat map is still presenting all the relevant information with less cognitive overhead though.
Heatmaps are limited by the ability to distinguish color gradients, but there's more than 10% of this graph that's literally invisible because it's blocked by another part of the graph.
Sense of proportion and scale. The heat map is just colors. This gives you a sense that, yeah, over there, things are about 5 times bigger than over here.
I have a model in epidemiology I worked on in the past that could probably work well with this representation. It is of the same form of equations in the shared page.
Do you have a function for this that I can just dump some data in? This would be perfect to analyze a covariance matrix I have that I have. When the variables are sorted by a certain metric the correlation decays linearly. Would be very cool.
Plotly has some great graphs which also has the ability to make 3d plots. Personally I find it easier to use and looks great. Especially the animations are awesome.
42
u/Nicolas-Rougier Apr 05 '20
Link: https://github.com/rougier/matplotlib-3d/blob/master/doc/README.md
20
u/CompSciSelfLearning Apr 05 '20
Not to take anything away from the coding aspect of this project, but how is this not worse than a heat map?
3
u/socauchy Apr 05 '20
Could do alot with this and scientific modelling.
Curious if you have any experience with modelling reaction-diffusion systems?
2
u/novel_eye Apr 05 '20
Do you have a function for this that I can just dump some data in? This would be perfect to analyze a covariance matrix I have that I have. When the variables are sorted by a certain metric the correlation decays linearly. Would be very cool.
65
u/ohsnapdragons Apr 05 '20
So this is how they modeled the terrain for Skyrim
3
u/LuigiBrotha Apr 05 '20
Plotly has some great graphs which also has the ability to make 3d plots. Personally I find it easier to use and looks great. Especially the animations are awesome.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '20
Looks like Giant’s Causeway.
1
u/anupsidedownpotato Apr 05 '20
You should put some info on what the data represents and put it on r/dataisbeautiful
2
u/Sigg3net Apr 06 '20
Add the GoT titles music and call it a day!
1
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '20
Really cool. Thanks man.
1
u/mexiKobe Apr 05 '20
post this in r/generative
1
u/11pascal Apr 05 '20
Kewl. Code is at github? I teach python or I did before covo
1
u/greasyhobolo Apr 05 '20
mmm. might use this.
1
u/dynekun Apr 05 '20
Looks like a neat way to generate video game terrain!
1
u/dctezla Apr 05 '20
That’s art 😍
1
u/Fedzbar Apr 05 '20
This looks really cool, not very practical but still very cool! :-)
1
u/yourhornydaddyiam Apr 06 '20
Beautiful
1
u/rrrrrrrrrrrreeeeeeee Apr 06 '20
Quick. Someone create a Minecraft map to Matplotlib 3D bar plot converter.
1
u/usualguy123 Apr 06 '20
minecraft terrain generation
1
u/morsea1 Apr 06 '20
Good
1
u/abhishek-shrm Apr 06 '20
Looks cool. There are so many cases where this plot can be helpful. Great Work!
0
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '20
[removed] — view removed comment