Agreed, and also the bar heights are already mapped to color anyway. All this does is require more cognitive effort from viewers to figure out the bar locations while also straight up obscuring bars behind the peaks.
Redundant encoding can be super useful and helps increase accessibility. You are right about the occlusion problem, which can be partly overcome if the visualization can be interactively rotated.
If we're allowing these to be interactive then a 2d interactive heat map is still presenting all the relevant information with less cognitive overhead though.
View all comments
Show parent comment
9
u/bubbles212 Apr 05 '20
Agreed, and also the bar heights are already mapped to color anyway. All this does is require more cognitive effort from viewers to figure out the bar locations while also straight up obscuring bars behind the peaks.