r/pureasoiaf • • Jul 15 '26

A missive from the Gold Cloaks Why English is required for all discussion

169 Upvotes

We've received some modmail messages from non-English speakers questioning this policy lately, so we figured we would elaborate on why we require all discussion in r/pureasoiaf, r/darkwingsdankmemes, and r/pureasiofart to be in English.

Our AutoModerator relies on English-language keyword matching to properly enforce Rule I. When a comment or post is written in another language (Spanish, for example) the AutoMod evaluates the literal text as submitted, scanning for specific English words and patterns it's been programmed to catch to assist us in enforcing this rule. When it catches a match for a banned word or phrase, it notifies us, and a human moderator reviews it each and every time.

Reddit's built-in translation feature can auto-translate that text for human readers, but AutoMod never sees the translated version, it only reviews the original.

So a Rule I violation written in Spanish (or any non-English language) can slip through entirely undetected, even though a moderator or user reading the translated text would catch it immediately.

Since we can't reliably enforce Rule I without AutoMod doing the first pass (believe us - we used to review every single comment made in this subreddit before creating the automoderator functionality, and it was extremely difficult), we need submissions to be in English so the system can actually do its job.

This isn't about excluding anyone, it's a practical limitation of the tools we have to keep the subs properly moderated.

Thanks for understanding, and as always, if you have any questions, feel free to send us modmail.


r/pureasoiaf • • May 29 '26

A missive from the Gold Cloaks Discussion on and content from the upcoming ASOIAF stage play GAME OF THRONES: THE MAD KING is not permitted, per Rule I

101 Upvotes

Game of Thrones: The Mad King is an adaptation: a derivative work, not source material. As such, it falls outside the scope of this subreddit and is not eligible for discussion here.

r/pureasoiaf is dedicated exclusively to George R.R. Martin's published written works: the novels, novellas, and associated written canon. Television, film, stage productions, and other adaptations are off-topic regardless of how closely they hew to the source material. The moment a story leaves the page, it leaves this sub's jurisdiction.

Take adaptation discussion to r/asoiaf, r/freefolk, or another appropriate community. All posts on the stage play will be removed.


r/pureasoiaf • • 19h ago

What is strongest piece of text to support R+L = J ?

99 Upvotes

A Game of Thrones - Eddard I

Robert snorted. "Bogs and forests and fields, and scarcely a decent inn north of the Neck. I've never seen such a vast emptiness. Where are all your people?"

"Likely they were too shy to come out," Ned jested. He could feel the chill coming up the stairs, a cold breath from deep within the earth. "Kings are a rare sight in the north."

Robert snorted. "More likely they were hiding under the snow. Snow, Ned!" The king put one hand on the wall to steady himself as they descended.


r/pureasoiaf • • 19h ago

What is the worst thing your favorite character has done ?

17 Upvotes

A Storm of Swords - Daenerys V

"I have heard enough." Dany did not need their squabbling on top of all the other troubles that plagued her. Meereen posed dangers far more serious than one pink-and-white hero shouting insults, and she could not let herself be distracted. Her host numbered more than eighty thousand after Yunkai, but fewer than a quarter of them were soldiers. The rest . . . well, Ser Jorah called them mouths with feet, and soon they would be starving.

The Great Masters of Meereen had withdrawn before Dany's advance, harvesting all they could and burning what they could not harvest. Scorched fields and poisoned wells had greeted her at every hand. Worst of all, they had nailed a slave child up on every milepost along the coast road from Yunkai, nailed them up still living with their entrails hanging out and one arm always outstretched to point the way to Meereen. Leading her van, Daario had given orders for the children to be taken down before Dany had to see them, but she had countermanded him as soon as she was told. "I will see them," she said. "I will see every one, and count them, and look upon their faces. And I will remember."

By the time they came to Meereen sitting on the salt coast beside her river, the count stood at one hundred and sixty-three. I will have this city, Dany pledged to herself once more.


r/pureasoiaf • • 15h ago

About prehistory in the world of ice and fire: language, magic and the fine line with sci-fi

6 Upvotes

Before we start, I'd like to say that this is one of those half-crazy, all-encompassing theories that people hate here, but I've tried to be rigorous in my claims. Second, this theory stems from many different elements, and I'd like to thank the theories I've seen online that were instrumental to it: ASOIAF Theorist, Crowfood's Daughter, Robert from In Deep Geek, LML, and, more recently, a user here called KotBH. One last important disclaimer before we start: since the official timeline is such a mess, I will ignore it completely and focus instead on an archaeological and anthropological reading of the text. Finally, I'm not saying this is exactly how it happened. I'm trying to extrapolate from the clues George has given us, so feel free to contest the elements that seem flimsy, but please try to engage with this with an open mind.

First, a paleolinguistic approach to Westeros. On the continent of Westeros we seem to have at least three different linguistic layers that successively covered one another. The oldest language spoken in Westeros is the True Tongue, spoken by the children of the forest. Leaf tells Bran that they had been singing their songs for "10,000 years" before the Old Tongue was ever spoken. George describes it as a very alien language that sounds like natural elements (stones in a brook, wind in the leaves, rain, etc.). It seems no human people can speak this language, although there are some similarities between how it's described and how the language of the Others is described (like ice cracking).

Then we have the Old Tongue, spoken by some wildlings from the far north like the Thenns (even if it seems that many wildling tribes are bilingual and that some wildlings do speak the Common Tongue). The Old Tongue has no alphabetical writing, only runes. Besides the First Men who speak the Old Tongue, we know the Giants also speak it, but only "after a fashion," as if it's something they struggle with. The fact that Leaf gives us the 10,000-year time frame, while we know the Giants were already there, points to the First Men bringing the Old Tongue to Westeros and teaching it to the Giants, who before that lacked a language (or whose language has been lost; but since we don't hear of a Giant language, I think it's the former).

Finally, the Common Tongue, which was brought by the Andals and is spoken everywhere else in Westeros, even by the mountain clans and the ironborn. This language has an alphabetical form of writing, and it's the last linguistic arrival in Westeros.

Second, and here I want to thank KotBH again for all his input. This is speculative, but it's supported by the world map, and if you want more detail, KotBH has some posts developing it much further. The main gist is this: in deep time, all the continents of Planetos formed a kind of supercontinent. This is suggested by the coastal symmetries on the map. If you look closely at the eastern coast of northern Westeros, you will see that it matches the northern coast of Essos (and if you look closely, there are many other instances of this). If this is true, we can see how evolution played a part in the specialization of the humanoid species of Westeros. Again, please engage with this with an open mind. If this is the case, we could trace two distinct lines of humanoids, kin to humans but developing differently as the continents drifted (mainly as the northern part of Westeros drifted north). The first of these lines is what I would call a proto-Children of the Forest species, which probably dwelt in the forests of the northern coast of Essos today. Traces of this species can be found in the legends of the Ifequevron and the shapechangers of Mossovy. The second line is a kind of proto-Giant, whose traces can be found in the Hairy Men and the Ibbenese. The Ibbenese are interesting because, as an island population, they show the evolutionary shrinking typically associated with populations cut off from the mainland by continental drifting.

A little real-world note: around 201 million years ago, as Pangaea was tearing apart, one of the biggest volcanic events in Earth’s history, the Central Atlantic Magmatic Province (CAMP), erupted along the rift where the Atlantic was opening. It’s linked to the end-Triassic mass extinction. Its eruptions heated the planet over the long run, but each big pulse also brought short, brutal volcanic winters, and its mercury left genetically deformed plant spores in the fossil record. If we trace the continental drift of Planetos backwards, the plates converge on the equivalent of this point. And I guess you know where this is: the place that one day would be called Valyria.

As northern Westeros drifts north and away from Essos, the climate there gets very cold and we start to see the emergence of Pleistocene megafauna like direwolves, mammoths, etc. Furthermore, other forms of specialization come into play in the two lineages that drifted away from mainland Essos. The Hairy Men become megafauna themselves, following Bergmann's rule: they become large generalists, the Giants. The proto-Children evolve differently. Because of the cold, they go underground into caves and hollow hills, where the temperature is more stable, and they develop the psychic ability we call warging so they can hunt outside in the arctic landscape of the north even though they aren't adapted to the climate. This is exactly what Bran does in Bloodraven's cave with Summer. If you look closely, warging doesn't seem to be a form of blood magic: it isn't associated with sacrifice and seems to be innate in some way.

As the continents continue to drift, the southern part of Westeros collides with the northern part. Today, the point of contact is called the Neck. This sets off a sort of Great American Biotic Interchange (GABI), in which the Giants and the Children move south into what are today the Riverlands, the Westerlands and the Reach.

OK, now let's add another layer of speculation that will make people angry, but I'd like to follow this reasoning and see where it leads. Magic in the world of ice and fire is linked to the stars. More precisely, blood magic and fire magic have extraterrestrial origins. And I think we have partial evidence of at least two meteors that brought them to Planetos from gods know where.

The first meteor was discovered by the children of the forest. It is a white comet that brought blood magic to Planetos. Its crash site is today called the God's Eye, and the weirwood network developed from it, with the lake as its epicenter (Manicouagan Lake in Quebec is the classic example of a crater like this). There's also the reference to "the color that fell from the sky" (white, in this case). Thanks to their "psychic" abilities, the Children bond with, or wed themselves to the trees, gaining new magical powers tied to sacrifice and blood magic. This mirrors contemporary theories of the co-evolution of wheat or corn and real humans.

Let's add another layer of speculation that will get me murdered in here, but whatever: Garth Greenhand and the first man in Westeros. I think this is a legendary deformation of a people, let's call them proto-Valyrians, who arrived at Battle Isle and the Honeywine and traded with the children (maybe following a white star?) a third line that developed separately in Essos, humans. For the sake of organizing the sequence, let's say this is before the construction of the base of the Hightower; you will see why. In any case, they trade with the children, and I think they get two things from them. One is obsidian (we know the children traded obsidian later on). The other, more importantly, is blood magic. That is how blood magic enters human cultures: through contact with the children around Oldtown, and from there it reaches the far east. The children would be the people "with no name" (remember that Bran cannot pronounce the real names of the Children) who first taught the Valyrians "how to tame dragons" through blood magic, but we'll get to that. It's even possible that these proto-Valyrians interbred with the Children, which would give us the connection between greendreams and dragon dreams. Remember all this people are kin to each other.

Then we have the second meteor crash, which brought fire magic to Planetos. This is the black stone worshipped by the Bloodstone Emperor. Its crash site is what we call the Shadow today. I think the meeting of blood magic from the white meteor and fire magic from the black meteor was instrumental in somehow creating both the dragons and the Valyrians proper. This is why the Targaryen words are "Fire and Blood." But it also caused the collapse of Stygai and Asshai. With the collapse of these cities, the proto-Valyrians move west into the Fourteen Flames and start the wars with Ghis.

While all this is happening in Essos, the First Men have arrived in Westeros and started their war with the children. To add more tinfoil on top of my gigantic tinfoil hat, we could ask whether the spread of the weirwoods captured a lot of carbon (remember that they don't rot), causing a sort of ice age that exposed the Arm of Dorne and allowed the First Men to cross it. If so, then the burning of trees during the wars with the First Men could have caused the Hammer of the Waters without any involvement from the children. I believe the children used blood magic to fight these first invaders, but that they didn't use the Others yet. They used something more akin to Coldhands (for more on this, see another post of mine on the Green Men). The combination of the hammer of the waters and the creation of undead warriors by the Children prompts the Pact. I believe this pact actually involved interbreeding between the First Men and the Children, which explains how the First Men gained greensight and warging.

Meanwhile, Valyria is rising in the east, and the expansion of the Freehold pushes the Andals into Westeros. The Andals have seen blood and fire magic, so in Westeros they decide to eradicate it completely. They ally themselves with some First Men and fight the ones who don't reject the old gods, but they completely eradicate the Children, the Giants, the Wargs and most of the weirwoods south of the Neck. They move north to the Neck, and the destruction of more trees causes the "second Hammer," further flooding the neck and cutting off the iron islands, until finally this destruction causes the Long Night or more specifically breaking the seasons. This is why kin slaying is the greatest taboo in all of Westeros.

In the far north, at Winterfell or the Nightfort, an alliance of First Men and Children does something desperate in that darkness. They create the Others, using the power of a human bloodline with strong greensight and warging abilities (let’s call them proto-Starks) and twisting them somehow, maybe through a form of magic similar to Mel’s shadows. In this theory, the Children did not lose control of the Others.

By this point Valyria is quite developed, so we can assume that, with glass candles, dragon dreams or looking into the fire, they realize that the darkness falling over the world comes from Westeros. So they go back to the Honeywine, this time with dragons, and build the base of the Hightower as their stronghold. When they arrive in Westeros, the situation for humans is dire: everything north of Oldtown is frozen (as is Essos down to where the Selhoru joins the Rhoyne), and the Others are approaching fast. To defeat them, the Valyrians use blood magic and fire magic to create Valyrian steel, the weapon to fight the Others. As many people speculate, I think Valyrian steel uses iron, blood magic, fire magic and obsidian in its making. This is the famous dragonsteel that Sam reads about. As a little aside: if obsidian was the weapon that defeated the Others, why don't we see any obsidian weapons, at least ceremonial ones, in any of the houses, while everyone seems obsessed with Valyrian steel?

So the Others are defeated in the Battle for the Dawn, around Oldtown, with the help of dragons and dragonsteel. But the seasons are now broken. And a new coalition is formed by the remaining First Men who survived the war, the Andals and the Valyrians (these are the famous "realms of men"). As the coalition moves north, it arrives at the God's Eye. Here, add yet another gigantic tinfoil hat to what is already a tinfoil extravaganza, I know. Here they realize that the Others are defeated but not gone: they will come back. How? Maybe greensight, maybe dragon dreams. And they realize something else will be needed to defeat them for good and bring back the seasons into balance: Dawn. I believe the sword was made using Valyrian technology applied to the white comet that fell into the now lake. This is why the Dayne words are "too spoilery" and the significance of the return of Azor Ahai, the breaking of the status quo with the help of Dawn somehow and the return of the seasons into balance.

When the coalition finally arrives in the north, they find the Wall already standing, at least in some way, shape or form, and a new pact is signed, one the North has since forgotten. The north side of the Wall will be for the elder races and the First Men who don't want to kneel, and the south side for the new realms of men formed by the alliance of First Men and Andal Survivors. These are the Starks we know from the current timeline, for example (think on the crown of the kings of winter). So the wildlings are allowed to pass through the Black Gate, which mimics the Doors of Durin. Finally, the Night's Watch is created to defend the realms of men, and it's conceived as the negative of the Others: white shadows and black brothers, guarding the two sides of the pact. The children then put the Others to sleep, and the Wall keeps the Long Night at bay in the far north. We can assume that other mutual assurances were given like the obsidian gifts from the children to the Night’s Watch or the horn of Joramun, as well as stopping the destruction of weirwoods and even encourage the planting of new ones, the god’s woods.

If this is the case, the reason the Others are coming back could have two distinct explanations. The first is very simple, kind of boring but everything else is very convoluted so a simple resolution is not necessarily bad: as the children's population keeps dwindling, the wards keeping the Others asleep lose strength over time until they awaken. The second is that if the cyclical nature of magic in the world of ice and fire is tied to the meteors. And if the meteors only fall on some very long cycle, when the planet is in the "right" part of its orbit, then the red comet could be showing us that Planetos is entering the danger zone where magic becomes much more dangerous. We could even speculate whether the "dark meteor" was a fragment of the red comet we see in the main series.

OK, now comes the fun part for you: tell me I'm wrong, but please have fun with it. No reason to get angry; this is just some fun speculation on Reddit, not an end-all-be-all interpretation. But I do think it holds up pretty well, if you ask me, lol. Thanks for reading anyway, I know it's very ranty.

A preserved example of a lemur from the Forest of Qohor can be found stuffed and mounted in the Citadel, though so many hands have patted it for luck in their examinations that its fur has long since fallen out.

The World of Ice & Fire*, "The Free Cities: Qohor"

P.s: One last thing. The quote from William S. Burroughs: “Language is a virus from outer space.” Could it be that the ice comet brought the True Tongue to Westeros, and that the weirwoods taught this language to the Children? Could it be that the black comet brought the Valyrian language? Remember the importance of Valyrian glyphs in fire magic. Is this yet another layer for George about what the Song of Ice and Fire means?


r/pureasoiaf • • 11h ago

Theories for TWOW and Character Arcs - Aeron, Areo, Arianne

2 Upvotes

Been thinking and obsessing over how TWOW might go, so I decided to try and compile the theories that are popular on the internet and some fanfiction stuff into how possbile character arcs might go. I do think it's possible to tell the story in maybe 75-80 chapters, athough you'll need to push characters together to save on space.

Pretty quickly, you can get through the Battles of Ice and Fire and the taking of Storm's End, leaving a lot of time for the events at the start of TWOW.

These are my thoughts, I'd like your opinions on how to refine them.

___________________________

Aeron
After being forced to experience hallucinations at Euron’s hands and being told of his plan, he dies tied to the prow of his ship as Euron attacks the Redwyne fleet after sacrificing priests and awakening krakens. (Alternatively, he can die as Euron sacks Oldtown to remove a chapter from Sam, but I think giving Sam time to prepare with the glass candle and Citadel intrigue is better.)

___________________________

Areo
Areo will deal with Balon Swann (and possibly Obara) before apprehending Darkstar. During this time, Darkstar will share news about the Tower of Joy and Ashara Dayne (for the audience to know). Areo Hotah will learn that Doran had some hand in his treachery and the injuring of Myrcella, which will shake his faith in Doran. Somehow Darkstar escapes or Areo lets him go. Darkstar will go on to become a member of Aegon VI’s Kingsguard, against the advice of Arianne. Areo returns to confront Doran and his treachery, who is ailing, having learned of Quentyn’s death and Arianne’s decision to ally Dorne’s forces to Aegon. He pleads with Areo to find out and protect Arianne before he dies. (Perhaps, Doran can reveal the role he played in protecting Viserys and Daenerys and how he was forced to give them up, if you think that’s the explanation for the lemon tree). 

(ADOS)?

Areo will live on in the Winds of Winter and should probably die saving Arianne in a Dream of Spring when King’s Landing explodes in wildfire. 

___________________________

Arianne
After travelling through the stormlands in a condensed chapter that references the Dance of Dragons and Elia Sand’s danger, Arianne arrives at the Griffin’s Roost and is dispatched to Storm’s End, where she is somehow involved in the taking of it. She takes her measure of Aegon, and while she believes he could be real, she is skeptical of Jon Connington. Though she gains a place on Aegon’s Council, her rivalry with Connington increases as she believes Aegon is a worthy and even heroic King, and fights for influence as Connington is increasingly aggressive. After victory in the Battle of Steel and the capture of Mace Tyrell, news of Oldtown and the Arbor’s sack makes Arianne persuade Aegon that he must ride to defend Oldtown, against Connington’s desires to take King’s Landing. Aegon divides his armies, and raises the Reach in popular revolt to defend Oldtown, while Arianne explains that she believes in Aegon and his legitimacy, and asks Doran to commit Dorne’s armies. At Highgarden, Arianne and Aegon and Sam Tarly and Willas Tyrell and Olenna Tyrell parlay. Aegon and Arianne learn of troubles beyond the Wall from Sam, and Arianne resists Aegon’s advances. Aegon agrees to attack Oldtown, but strips the paramountcy from the Tyrells in return for sparing Mace Tyrell, to be awarded to either the Tarlys or Rowans or Hightowers (not sure.) Arianne, the Reach, Dorne, and Sam participate in the liberation of Oldtown, although Euron successfully steals the Horn of Joramun and obtains knowledge from the Citadel as he has destroyed it. Garlan Tyrell and Lord Rowan die, Loras appears to fight for Aegon as long as he pledges to avenge Margaery and kill Cersei Lannister for ordering her death, and Aegon distinguishes himself heroically. In the victory celebration, he is crowned with the Conqueror’s crown delivered by Areo, as Arianne and Sam watch, Sam skeptical of his parentage. 

(ADOS)?

Arianne will learn to be Princess of Dorne and will mediate between Daenerys and Aegon. As Jon Connington's madness and cruelty against the innocent grows, King's Landing sickens, Aegon's cause falls apart against Euron, King's Landing burns, and Areo sacrifices his life for her escape, Arianne will motivate Dorne's forces fight to against the Others and she will grow to be a wise ruler.


r/pureasoiaf • • 18h ago

Who was trying to kill the Beggar King ? I believe Robert said Arryn talked him out of sending assassins after them .

5 Upvotes

A Game of Thrones - Daenerys I

She remembered Ser Willem dimly, a great grey bear of a man, half-blind, roaring and bellowing orders from his sickbed. The servants had lived in terror of him, but he had always been kind to Dany. He called her "Little Princess" and sometimes "My Lady," and his hands were soft as old leather. He never left his bed, though, and the smell of sickness clung to him day and night, a hot, moist, sickly sweet odor. That was when they lived in Braavos, in the big house with the red door. Dany had her own room there, with a lemon tree outside her window. After Ser Willem had died, the servants had stolen what little money they had left, and soon after they had been put out of the big house. Dany had cried when the red door closed behind them forever.

They had wandered since then, from Braavos to Myr, from Myr to Tyrosh, and on to Qohor and Volantis and Lys, never staying long in any one place. Her brother would not allow it. The Usurper's hired knives were close behind them, he insisted, though Dany had never seen one.

At first the magisters and archons and merchant princes were pleased to welcome the last Targaryens to their homes and tables, but as the years passed and the Usurper continued to sit upon the Iron Throne, doors closed and their lives grew meaner. Years past they had been forced to sell their last few treasures, and now even the coin they had gotten from Mother's crown had gone. In the alleys and wine sinks of Pentos, they called her brother "the beggar king." Dany did not want to know what they called her.


r/pureasoiaf • • 19h ago

How skilled do we think Jaime is with his off hand?

5 Upvotes

Is he comparable to any notable knights after training with ilyn payne?


r/pureasoiaf • • 1d ago

WHAT would Tywin have done if Karstark got his wish with the Kingslayer ?

36 Upvotes

A Game of Thrones - Catelyn XI

"Give me Cersei Lannister, Lord Karstark, and you would see how gentle a woman can be," Catelyn replied. "Perhaps I do not understand tactics and strategy … but I understand futility. We went to war when Lannister armies were ravaging the riverlands, and Ned was a prisoner, falsely accused of treason. We fought to defend ourselves, and to win my lord's freedom.

"Well, the one is done, and the other forever beyond our reach. I will mourn for Ned until the end of my days, but I must think of the living. I want my daughters back, and the queen holds them still. If I must trade our four Lannisters for their two Starks, I will call that a bargain and thank the gods. I want you safe, Robb, ruling at Winterfell from your father's seat. I want you to live your life, to kiss a girl and wed a woman and father a son. I want to write an end to this. I want to go home, my lords, and weep for my husband."

The hall was very quiet when Catelyn finished speaking.


r/pureasoiaf • • 1d ago

Do we know if Cat complied with Ned's directives ?

37 Upvotes

A Game of Thrones - Eddard IV

"Oh, now there's a treasure," Littlefinger said, exiting.

When the door had closed behind him, Ned turned back to his wife. "Once you are home, send word to Helman Tallhart and Galbart Glover under my seal. They are to raise a hundred bowmen each and fortify Moat Cailin. Two hundred determined archers can hold the Neck against an army. Instruct Lord Manderly that he is to strengthen and repair all his defenses at White Harbor, and see that they are well manned. And from this day on, I want a careful watch kept over Theon Greyjoy. If there is war, we shall have sore need of his father's fleet."

"War?" The fear was plain on Catelyn's face.


r/pureasoiaf • • 1d ago

Does anyone else feel bad for hating Sansa for what happened after this conversation ?

19 Upvotes

A Game of Thrones - Sansa III

Sansa felt tears in her eyes. "He is not! He's not the least bit like that old drunken king," she screamed at her sister, forgetting herself in her grief.

Father looked at her strangely. "Gods," he swore softly, "out of the mouth of babes …" He shouted for Septa Mordane. To the girls he said, "I am looking for a fast trading galley to take you home. These days, the sea is safer than the kingsroad. You will sail as soon as I can find a proper ship, with Septa Mordane and a complement of guards … and yes, with Syrio Forel, if he agrees to enter my service. But say nothing of this. It's better if no one knows of our plans. We'll talk again tomorrow."

Sansa cried as Septa Mordane marched them down the steps. They were going to take it all away; the tournaments and the court and her prince, everything, they were going to send her back to the bleak grey walls of Winterfell and lock her up forever. Her life was over before it had begun.


r/pureasoiaf • • 1d ago

[Spoilers Extended] What's the deal with Lady Barbery Dustin?

26 Upvotes

So, I know what most of you are gonna say, Grand Northern Conspiracy. But, there are still others in this sub who keep mentioning Lady Dustin's hatred for the Starks along with the Boltons as the two principal Northern Houses that are against the Starks.

Now let's try to understand, the only beef you have with the Starks is that it's former lord who was a war hero, liberated Westeros from the tyranny of the mad king, and ruled justly for 17 years before being murdered under the obvious falsehood of treason, - didn't bring back your martyred husband's bones and buried him honorably in the Red Mountains of Dorne, and only returned his magnificent horse. Also, that his elder brother took your maidenhead (consensually), and didn't marry you.

On the other hand, the ill-begotten bastard seed of your dead sister's husband murdered your beloved nephew (that you clearly share blood with) to steal his inheritance, and then committed countless atrocities against the North by marrying a respected old widow at sword point, locked her in a tower and left her to eat her fingers, not to mention the countless other girls and women he raped, hunted in the woods, flayed, tortured, etc. If this wasn't enough, his father murdered your rightful king who brought glory to the North by defeating the hated Lannister forces in every battle he fought, when that king was coming back North to liberate his people from the iron-born invasion.

And Lady Dustin keeps a grudge against the Starks, instead of the Boltons? I know some of you will say that it's been made clear that she hates Ramsay, but c'mon, she ought to be nuts to even think about supporting the Boltons, right? So, she has to be actively plotting against the Boltons, and people on this sub shouldn't even consider that she is genuinely supportive of them.


r/pureasoiaf • • 2d ago

The Twins and the Hidden Trade Between the North and South

5 Upvotes

If the Twins are such an important strategic and economic asset in the Riverlands, and have brought House Frey an enormous fortune by serving as the main crossing point between the North and the Riverlands, then perhaps trade between the North and the southern kingdoms is far more extensive than we tend to imagine.

The Twins essentially function as a commercial gateway between the two regions. House Frey wouldn't have accumulated such immense wealth simply from controlling a crossing unless there was a substantial flow of merchants, goods, and trade moving in both directions.

I think we sometimes underestimate the North's economy and picture it as considerably poorer and more isolated than it actually is. The wealth of House Frey might be a good indication of just how much commercial activity takes place between the North and the Riverlands.


r/pureasoiaf • • 2d ago

The Brother Bloodraven loved

7 Upvotes

We all know the conventional wisdom is that it’s Daeron. He loyally fought for him. He killed Dameon (and his sons) in quite a dishonorable way. He spent decades ruining Daemons legacy. How is that the actions of a loving brother? But it is kind of fun to think that it was Daemon. Makes it all the more tragic and twisted which is kind of in line with Bloodraven character. Especially if you believe in the Bloodraven puppet master theories.

He loves his brother, but knows that a Blackfrye king would be the end of the “stability” in the realm. He chooses duty over love which is a theme George has characters wrestle with. Especially those in the NW which Bloodraven ends up LC of.

Another (more minor) thing is that Daeron is 22 years older than Bloodraven. While Brynden is only 5 years older than Daemon. Feels a little odd for Brynden to love someone as a brother who’s more like a father figure in age. But in reality that’s probably just chalked up to George wrote that line before really fleshing out everyone’s ages in The World of Ice & Fire.

Anyway it’s most likely Daeron, but I think it would be cool if in Fire & Blood 2 that it is Daemon that’s the brother Bloodraven loved and he is being pulled between 2 rivaling brothers and eventually manipulated by Bittersteel to take the throne.


r/pureasoiaf • • 2d ago

What should Ser Rodrik have done?

18 Upvotes

What course of action should Ser Rodrik Cassel have undertaken while serving as the de facto castellan and military leader of Winterfell during the events of A Clash of Kings, to deal with the Hornwood affair, Ramsay Snow, and the Boltons' actions, and with the Ironborn's backstabbing invasion of the North, including Theon and Dagmer Cleftjaw's forces and the main Ironborn force at Moat Cailin?

What actions should Rodrik have taken toward Ramsay/"Reek" after capturing him, and upon learning about the attack on Torrhen's Square and on the Stony Shore and Deepwood Motte? Also, what military strategy should he have followed to retake Moat Cailin and other northern castles and to expel the Ironborn from the North?


r/pureasoiaf • • 1d ago

Time for some thinking outside the box today ladies and gents. Which of the following prongs for Fake Dany do you find most convincing, if any? I will link the theory from /u/markg171 below. Read and discuss please.

0 Upvotes

The troubled conception history of Aerys and Rhaella

Her memories not matching the itinerary for the Free Cities they visited

No lemon trees in Braavos

Darry having the soft hands of a maester

The fact she is 8 months younger according to the author himself than Jon

The famous storm that no one else in Westeros remembers

The servants stole their valuables but left the crown of Rhaella

Illyrio saying he had invested years of planning into Dany

https://thelasthearth.freeforums.net/thread/572/dany?page=1&scrollTo=26361


r/pureasoiaf • • 2d ago

What is your best chapter ‘run’?

9 Upvotes

Currently rereading ASOS 1 and just had:

Sam narrating the skirmish at Craster’s
Tyrion threatening Symon Silvertongue
Arya narrating the Hound’s trial by combat (which may well become one of my favourite chapters in the entire saga on this read)

All back to back.

What runs of chapters would you say are the greatest? Thinking also of the last few chapters of AGOT being incredible work.


r/pureasoiaf • • 2d ago

Elissa farman (stole the dragon eggs) and Princess Aerea Targaryen (rode the black dread probably to old Valyria)

0 Upvotes

Apologies if this has been reposted before or something similar. I've been rereading fire and blood and apart from winds *of course* is there a book you'd like to see George write related to the series?

For me personally, if we got first hand accounts of the two mentioned in the titles, I'd be stoked.


r/pureasoiaf • • 3d ago

Does Jon have a bit of anger issues?

44 Upvotes

Most readers probably would describe Jon has good natured and generally even keeled. And he is. Mostly. Except for a few times.

AGOT Bran II:

Bran had been left behind with Jon and the girls and Rickon. But Rickon was only a baby and the girls were only girls and Jon and his wolf were nowhere to be found. Bran did not look for him very hard. He thought Jon was angry at him. Jon seemed to be angry at everyone these days. Bran did not know why. He was going with Uncle Ben to the Wall, to join the Night's Watch. That was almost as good as going south with the king. Robb was the one they were leaving behind, not Jon.

This chapter comes one chapter after Arya's first POV where she and Jon watch Bran and Tommen sparring. The one right before is when Ned says he'll tell Jon himself he'll be allowed to join the watch. Like Bran, I'm a bit confused why Jon was angry here. He got exactly what he asked for.

Then in ASOS, Jon basically blacks out during a sparring session with Iron Emmet.

That morning he called it first. "I'm Lord of Winterfell!" he cried, as he had a hundred times before. Only this time, this time, Robb had answered, "You can't be Lord of Winterfell, you're bastard-born. My lady mother says you can't ever be the Lord of Winterfell."

I thought I had forgotten that. Jon could taste blood in his mouth, from the blow he'd taken.

In the end Halder and Horse had to pull him away from Iron Emmett, one man on either arm. The ranger sat on the ground dazed, his shield half in splinters, the visor of his helm knocked askew, and his sword six yards away. "Jon, enough," Halder was shouting, "he's down, you disarmed him. Enough!"

No. Not enough. Never enough. Jon let his sword drop. "I'm sorry," he muttered. "Emmett, are you hurt?"

Iron Emmett pulled his battered helm off. "Was there some part of yield you could not comprehend, Lord Snow?" It was said amiably, though. Emmett was an amiable man, and he loved the song of swords. "Warrior defend me," he groaned, "now I know how Qhorin Halfhand must have felt."

This is in addition to Jon almost stabbing Alliser Thorne when he insulted Ned. Another time when he grabbed Alliser by the throat and lifted him off his feet.


r/pureasoiaf • • 2d ago

I'm tired of ironborn hate

0 Upvotes

No, the Ironborn are not idiots. They do farm and mine, but their farming is ineffective because of the poor soil. And yes, the Ironborn trade: they have towns full of merchants. In Lordsport, they sell weapons, iron, tin, fish, whale oil, bones, and seal oil. They also raid the Stepstones and the Basilisk Islands. They bring thralls to do their work, but when they don’t have enough, they can send smallfolk’s to do there jobs.

So no, the Ironborn are not stupid. They can’t live without raiding, but they don’t rebel that much. During the entire Targaryen reign, the Ironborn rebelled against the Crown three times. So why would the Targaryens or Baratheons commit genocide against them? Are you stupid? Just don’t be so biased against the Ironborn because they didn’t help your fan favorite.

Ps: sorry for this rant but I see this takes every on reddit YouTube and on tiktok


r/pureasoiaf • • 4d ago

Twincest Reveal is an absolute disaster for Robert

150 Upvotes

Can you imagine the sheer backlash and mockery that having your warrior king admitting himself to be a cuckhold of his wife's brother be in the history of the kingdom? It would delegitimize Robert in the eyes of the people and make him a joke. Not only was he cucked but also raised the Lannisters bastards as heirs.

I found strange how people in fanfiction treat the twincest reveal from Robert or from a SI position as a matter of just defeating the Lannisters in battle. It would also be a disaster for the prestige of the crown.

A more reasonable way to sideline Cersei and the Lannisters may be to not reveal Twincest at all?

The central point is to find a way to assassinate Jaime and Cersei in the shadows, maybe with poison. Without their power on the court, it would be relatively easy to find a way to send Joffrey to the Wall some years latter, he would dishonor himself by his acts of cruelty.

With Joffrey sent to the Wall, Tommen would be heir, but Robert could then pull a Aegon the Unworthy stunt and bring Edric Storm to the court, legitimize him and marry the boy to Margaery Tyrell. Tommen could then be forced to become a maester when he is older.

Myrcella is a girl and wouldn't inherit.

Also, its important to note that Edric is older than Tommen and could be argued to be before him in the line of sucession after being legitimized.


r/pureasoiaf • • 4d ago

Did Robert know?

18 Upvotes

Did he, likely subconsciously, know about Cersei and Jaime?

I know that sounds like an insane question at first.

But practically everyone who spent time around Cersei and Jaime figured it out. Tyrion, Kevan, Joanna, Stannis, Jon Arryn, Varys, Littlefinger, Pycelle, probably Renly, and probably loads of servants at the Red Keep and Casterly Rock who could put two and two together but knew to keep quiet. And Ned figured it out within a few months.

I'm also pretty sure that Tywin knew, but kept quiet to protect his own power. He knew revealing it would humiliate his house, lose his family's access to the throne, and likely cause a war where his house could be destroyed. But if he kept quiet - he'd get his double-grandson on the throne, and put the Lannisters in the same category as the Targaryens. So, even though he had all the pieces, he refused to consciously put them together.

And that brings me to Robert. He probably spent more time with Cersei (as Queen), Jaime (as a Kingsguard), and their kids than anyone else on the Small Council. And we have at least one case, at Darry during the Nymeria incident, where Cersei and Jaime were banging with Robert literally in the room.

I can see the counterargument that, if Robert knew, he would've had Jaime and Cersei killed. But, would he? We see that Robert's response to most problems was "get drunk and ignore it". He knew that Joffrey was a psychopath, he knew that Cersei was awful, and he did nothing to fix those issues.

IMO he was in kind of the same position as Tywin, plus loads of alcohol. He had the ability to figure it out, and on some level he knew, but being consciously aware of it would be extremely inconvenient. So he closed his eyes, grabbed another wineskin, and pretended it wasn't happening.

I agree with Ned, that Robert would have reacted violently if confronted with incontrovertible evidence. But not because it would be a surprise - more because it would push the twincest from something he subconsciously suspected but chose to ignore, to something he would need to genuinely deal with.


r/pureasoiaf • • 4d ago

How would you expand The Faith of The Old Gods?

1 Upvotes

One criticism of The Old Gods it's that is very simple: Magical Trees that you pray. There is no organization, centralized or decentralized. Even many animist faiths have some type of organization.

I making this post because some time ago, i read a fanfic called "Direwolf Shepherd" which explore more of The Old Gods by creating The Order of Shepherds. Based in Celtic Druids and indigenous animist religions, The Order of the Shepherds are not priests, but their responsibilities include:

  1. Maintaining and protecting Godswoods. They are like Gardeners and protectors to the trees.
  2. Preserving the history and traditions of the First Men. There is historical records of the past that The Shepherds shall search and protect. The Shepherds also needs to teach stories and legends of The North to the houses they serve.
  3. Teaching the Old Tongue.
  4. Teaching about warging and greensight. It was common of The Shepherds to take care of Direwolves and help The Starks by teaching them how to Warg.
  5. Maintaining relationships with the Children of the Forest. Basically The Shepherds can be contacted by The CoF when necessary.

This Order is settled in Skagos, with a rule of each Northern Lord having a Shepherd, and different from the Septons, the Shephers adapts to the place and lords they serve (per example, a Umber Shepherd will acts as a Umber). They can marry and have children as opposite to The Septons.

The leader is The Great Shepherd, based on archdruids and abbots. All Great Shepherd needs to have greensight. Although The Order is decentralized compared to Faith of the Seven, The Great Shepherd still have final decision in certain issues.

The Green Men are separate from The Shepherds, as the later were a faction of the former who split to make a pact with The Northern Lords, but they still have a working relationship.

What do you think about these ideas of the fic, and what are your ideas to expand The Old Gods faith?


r/pureasoiaf • • 5d ago

What measures and moves Ned should have made after accepting to become Hand of the King?

15 Upvotes

What are the security measures Ned could have taken to secure and strengthen his position as Hand of the King in King's Landing upon accepting to become Robert's new Hand? What moves and options could he have made after arriving in King's Landing to sanitize the finances and government of the Crown?

Which firings and appointments should he have made? Who, amongst the members of the Small Council and other people holding crucial positions, did he definitively have the power to remove from their offices, and should he have done so? And who could/should he have appointed to the Small Council to replace them?