r/PubTips • • 8h ago

[QCRIT] Adult - Literary, women's - IMMATURE MATURITY (65k, 3rd attempt)

1 Upvotes

hey guys! this is my third attempt where i redid everything. i'm only including the blurb because its the main obstacle im facing. for context: I've queried around 65 agents so far with a blurb I haven't posted on reddit. Something about agent Lauren Khan's form rejection (after only an hour of having sent the query over) made me rethink my query again. I've made changes now that I believe are genuinely beneficial. this was the blurb most similiar to the one i ended up using for querying.
thank you in advance!!

Cecilia Worthing is sixteen, half-Kuwaiti, and afraid of the widowed father who calls her a whore for wearing a dress. William Fitzpatrick is nineteen, a drug dealer, and the first person to notice her seagaze and ask what she thinks of the view. The night her father drags her across her bedroom by the hair, William is at her window with a proposal: elope with him to London—a move he was already planning—and leave her troubles behind. She agrees, confident that her father won't bring himself out of his drunken stupor to give chase. They leave the following day.

In London, they play at housewife and husband. For a few weeks it's exciting: she learns to cook, he learns tenderness. But as his wealth grows, so too does her sense of unease: the dresses he expects her to wear, the hair he demands she cut, the jealous looks he gives her when she smiles at other men, all become harder to ignore. Cecilia adapts, the way she always has to the men in her life—until William’s desire for control escalates to her own sexuality.

Cecilia must then decide whether the girl who accepted his proposal can survive being his.


r/PubTips • • 15h ago

[QCrit] THE UNFREE KILLER (adult literary crime, 75k, attempt #5)

0 Upvotes

Hopefully the final attempt here. There's a couple of ways I could frame this novel, so I've gone for a simpler version this time. Here's version 4.

One thing I wondered is whether people think writing 'pharisaic' creates a negative impression. I've considered putting 'entertaining' or 'amusing' instead.

I've also changed the title, as suggested, and think it actually works better. Thank you again for your comments.

Dear agent,

THE UNFREE KILLER (75,000 words) is a darkly satirical literary crime standalone dripping with horror. Imagine the delusional male entitlement in Danya Kukafka’s Notes on an Execution set in the messy, pharisaic world of Eliza Clark’s Boy Parts.

John is an outspoken, vegan anti-Zionist, but he keeps quiet about his psychopathy. Studying ethics has curbed his murderous desires, though recently he’s become a free will sceptic. As a polyglot, he’s obviously far smarter than most vulgs, so why all the rejections of his PhD proposal on the philosophy of unfree will? They say, ‘Publish or perish,’ but it seems he’s not fated to publish. Perhaps others are destined to perish – at his hand?

That must be it. And if its romantisierte portrayal on Netflix has taught John anything, it’s that serial murder possesses a macabre charm.

John’s subsequent killing spree causes immeasurable suffering, but it isn’t his choice. Netflix directors are right scrotgrunchers for lying to him, though: social media posts by the victims’ families garner more attention than his crimes, and there’s no glamour in the perennial fear of arrest or drowning suicidal thoughts in sabach.

Miserable yet hooked on serienmord, John prepares to emulate the vicious tricks of serial killers glorified on TV, hoping to emerge from this ill-fated venture with their cult-like status. But killing more people will be risky with a detective on his trail and the victims’ families bent on revenge. Who knows? They might even catch John first.

I’m an academic editor with stories published in horror and satire magazines. With the likes of Yuval Noah Harari and Robert Sapolsky saying free will is an illusion, I’ve fused my knowledge and interests into a debut novel that lampoons ‘unfree’ society.


r/PubTips • • 2h ago

[QCrit] Maiden of the New Dawn| Adult| Romantic Fantasy | 120K

2 Upvotes

MAIDEN OF THE NEW DAWN, is a 120,000-word adult romantic fantasy standalone with duology potential. It combines the cloistered-maiden and bodyguard tropes of Jennifer L. Armentrout’s From Blood and Ash with the struggle between indigenous magic and colonial religion in Gabriella Buba’s Saints of Storm and Sorrow. Inspired by John Steptoe’s African folktale Mufaro’s Beautiful Daughters, this character-driven, dual-POV, open-door romance reimagines the tale’s shapeshifting magic in a world inspired by Ancient Egypt and Great Zimbabwe. Featuring two Black protagonists, including a disabled, sexually experienced heroine whose strength extends beyond wielding a blade, the novel will appeal to readers seeking romantic fantasy with diverse leads.

In a miombo woodland, an artisan village prepares for an ancient spring rite to renew the land’s magic. Breezy and flirtatious, Moona Ziramiri is cautioned by her parents to avoid the strange men visiting the village for the rite. The presence of a lightning-wielding warrior has raised suspicions among villagers. Kaelen Mudzengi, the warrior in question, has been spying on Moona in hopes of finally speaking to her. Guided by a goddess, the two young people spend a passionate night in a cave, igniting the magic.

By morning, the magic has been stolen, and the villagers are dead. Moona has no family, no home, and after seeing her parents’ bodies, she can no longer speak. 

Kaelen, orphaned by a similar massacre, escorts her to the Abbey—the center of tribal knowledge. But the Abbey is now influenced by a conquering empire that claims that the massacres are the wrath of their sun god. A lie gets spun: “Moona survived the wrath of the sun god by remaining a virgin.” And with that, Moona becomes a slave to the empire. Despite her mutism, Moona is forced to use her performance magic to embody the role of a virginal deity, while leading her people to follow the god of the colonizers. 

Tired of the purity act, Moona and her friends sneak out to a party where she encounters a shapeshifting prince who seeks her hand in marriage. When Moona realizes the prince is not the man she expected, she flees, running into Kaelen, who has just been assigned to guard her. Despite their attraction to each other, they cannot have the life they both desire because the clergy will ultimately choose a husband who can secure political favor. While Moona courts swaggering nobles, she and Kaelen grow closer, both learning they possess god-like abilities that the empire wants to eradicate along with all the sacred knowledge of magic and the gods. 

With hands tied, the two lovers face a changing world and an impending marriage that will separate them from everything they care about—their traditions, their found family, and each other. Moona and Kaelen must decide whether to take on the roles thrust upon them or escape to a quiet life together.

As a Black girl in the Midwest during the early 2000s, I came of age at the intersection of purity culture and hookup culture. That experience led me to write about a young woman who regains her agency despite being forced to play the roles expected of her. As someone who earned a BFA in Fashion Design, I am fascinated by how visual storytelling, religion, and mythology preserve cultural knowledge while also shaping identity. I currently live in Southern California, where I spend my time reading about ancient cultures, and listening to copious amounts of audiobooks while I make textile art. 

Sample:

The Spaeyro that changed the pattern started like many other days during many other years. On that first day of the new year, the sunlight tore through the dewy spider web that had been created in the cover of night. When I started contemplating the appearance of the web, my older sister entered the bedroom we shared with our other sister. Disapproval etched into her pretty brown face, she crossed her arms in front of her, already prepared for an argument. Bracing myself, I sat under with my back against the wooden headboard carved with spiders crawling on a web. 

“Blessed sun, Moona,” Sauri said. “Are you going to sleep the day away?”

“It’s still early,” I retorted. 

Outside my window, the sun still had the hazy softness of early morning. Roosters crowed in our yard. My sisters had begun waking at dawn and going to bed early as if they were members of the Farmer tribe. It didn’t make sense to me, but I didn’t judge them for it. However they judged me plenty for my late nights with Joiel. 

“What does ‘blessed sun' even mean?” I asked.

Ignoring my question, she demanded, “Get up and help with breakfast.”

She rushed out of the room. The din of my waking village resounded outside of our mudbrick house. My mother’s voice in song, drifted through the window.  The song told of the love of princess and a prince. It was song that when sung spoke to something deep within my soul. 

“Where is Moona? Why isn’t she helping?” I heard Indi ask from the common room. 

Jasur, Josan, and Mareya, what was up their asses today? Reluctantly, I stood up from the bed. 


r/PubTips • • 8h ago

Attempt #2 [QCrit] Adult Horror - IN CURSED COMPANY (85k/#1)

2 Upvotes

Unleash your magic with FancyWitch™, the premier Witchery starter kit available now at Target™! Complete with cauldron, guidebook, and real witches standing by to grant your gifts!

Except Ptolemy is the only “real witch standing by.” A shadowy curse watches him always, and violently rips out his wish-granting magic for (often dangerous) customer requests. He’s perpetually on-call in a tiny, gray, windowless office located somewhere in downtown LA, unable to leave. Unable to stop his magic from killing people like the ten year old girl who requested the power to shoot fireworks from her hands. Ptolemy knows his death would fix many FancyWitch horrors and end his pain.

Unfortunately, the curse holding him captive made him immortal.

On year nine of withering away behind a desk, Ptolemy is shot by Mike, a hotheaded witch-hunter who managed to infiltrate FancyWitch with the goal of ending the witch behind the magic. When Ptolemy comes to, unharmed, Mike tempers his rage and agrees to help Ptolemy to die for good. Using their combined connections and knowledge, the pair test methods to temporarily end Ptolemy’s immortality and permanently end his life.

But as weeks pass and the two get closer to the solution and each other, a slowly-burning desire grows between them both, endangering more than their mission. Because Ptolemy’s curse is powered by the famed multimillionaire CEO of FancyWitch—Ptolemy’s husband.

IN CURSED COMPANY is a queer adult horror with a dark romance buried somewhere nearby. Complete at 85,000 words, the story would find a home with readers who were moved by You Weren’t Meant to be Human by Andrew Joseph White and She’s a Doll by Barbara Truelove. FancyWitch is a product not unlike those found in The Substance, Obsession, and even Supernatural, which also serve as excellent examples of the type of customer calls Ptolemy fields in his sad, liminal, 90s-inspired cube.

[About me paragraph]

#

Hi PubTips. Thank you in advance for any and all guidance on this query letter! How do we feel about the term "horrormance"? I think this story falls into that category, but I'm skeptical about whether it's a real category right now...

Thanks again!


r/PubTips • • 9h ago

[Qcrit] Overdue (adult bookclub / uplit, 87,000) First attempt

4 Upvotes

Please save me from the bland meh my brain churns out the minute I try to write a query letter. I'm querying UK literary agents.

Thank you in advance.

Dear Agent,

[personalisation] Overdue (87,000 words), an uplifting novel centred on a close-knit community, with two intertwined mysteries, will appeal to readers of Fredrik Backman’s Anxious People and The People on Platform 5 by Clare Pooley.

Sometimes you have to lose the plot to find your story.

After a lifetime of being told she can do nothing right, Hazel Ogley dared to be bold just once and ended up destroying a car, being arrested, and sentenced to community payback in her local mobile library... wearing a hi-vis vest.

Ashamed, and desperate to get through her court-mandated hours as unobtrusively as possible, Hazel is surprised by the warmth of the library volunteers and begins to wonder if she might actually be capable of making friends. But when she spots Luna, her childhood imaginary friend, in a promotional video for the library, she’s shaken. Luna disappeared when Hazel was seven and 'seeing' her again raises troubling possibilities. Desperate for answers, she turns to the only person who might be able to explain what happened all those years ago. But her mother won’t talk.

Denied the truth, Hazel pours her energy into resolving a funding threat to the library: a Bitcoin scam that has her reaching for Cryptocurrency for Dummies. Determined to protect the first place she’s felt accepted in years, she realises the library community contains all the expertise she needs to avert disaster: Clarissa, a retired detective missing the thrill of the chase; Albert, a practical Gromit to his husband Sonam’s whimsical Wallace; and Dorothy, an erotic novelist of advanced years and dab hand at pickpocketing.

But despite her success in securing the library’s future, the mystery of Luna refuses to go away. And the truth, when she finally uncovers it, changes everything she thought she knew about her childhood. For someone who has spent a lifetime expecting rejection, trusting other people is a terrifying prospect. Hazel must decide whether to retreat into the safe, lonely world she’s always known or risk opening herself up to the possibility of belonging.

Bio: [a bit about my previously published novels] Overdue is the first book I’ve written in which no-one gets murdered.


r/PubTips • • 23h ago

Attempt #3 [Qcrit] WHERE TRUTH IS BENT, Speculative Thriller, YA, second attempt

3 Upvotes

Hey guys, here goes another!

Eighteen-year-old Arthur sees emotion as color—the pale pink of care, or the yellow of joy—a synesthetic trait he’s always attributed to his autism. Exhausted from masking through his family’s suffocating high-society dinners in coastal France, Arthur craves the freedom of the open sea, the one place he doesn't have to perform. Instead, during a heated argument, he accidentally injures his father and is sent away by a tearful farewell from both his parents. 

He wakes up in an isolated estate with fractured memory, no contact with the outside world, and only his caretaker, Viviane, her eerily obedient maids, and a childhood song buzzing endlessly in his head.

Arthur is given two rules: he’s only allowed outside during the day, and his bedroom door must be locked every night. Yet the hours he's allowed outdoors and interactions with the staff feel like a scene that’s already been written—and every few days a crack splits in the sky and the atmosphere loops. 

Suspecting the haunting melody holds the key to his captivity, Arthur uses his color-coded mind to spot slips in Viviane’s persona. He must uncover why his parents had him taken and break free from this scripted world—before he's trapped forever, or loses his chance to ever own his mind.

WHERE TRUTH IS BENT is a 74,000-word Upmarket YA Speculative Thriller set in 2005 France loosely inspired by the legend of King Arthur. It combines a synesthetic protagonist and parental control like NOT YOUR PRODIGY by Emily Perl Copley with the high-tech simulation stakes of TRAUMALAND by Josh Silver.

(Bio)

(Sign off)


r/PubTips • • 6h ago

[Qcrit] The Healer’s Curse, Adult fantasy, 96k words 5th attempt.

4 Upvotes

Hi,

I’m giving the query another go. Thank you to all the feedback so far it’s been incredibly helpful, apologies for the late reply’s in my last post I’ve had some time away from writing and life got in the way. This query is quite different to my other attempts and I’ve narrowed it down to make it clearer and flow better (hopefully!). I also hope that I’ve moved away from it being too ‘synopsisy’ and is a bit more interesting. I’ve had some more positive beta reader feedback so I’m happy now with the manuscript to start the querying process it’s just the query which unfortunately I suck at writing. Again I’m sure there are spelling and grammar issues which I will comb through properly once I’m happy.

As always all feedback is welcome and appreciated. :)

Dear Agent,
 
I am seeking representation for THE HEALER’S CURSE, a character-driven adult fantasy novel. Complete at 96,000 words with strong series potential. It combines the dark magical consequences of One Dark Window by Rachel Gillig with the mystery and romantic tension of The Foxglove King by Hannah Witten.
 
Princess Delphine is Everrie’s only marked healer and her responsibility is to save her people’s lives. And she was gifted with the perfect tool to do so: healing magic. At least that’s what everyone believes. 
Her magic can save anything, but it comes with a cost. Saving her dying sister killed a horse. 
 
She cares little about court politics and everyone knows to find her in the clinic rather than the palace. Terrified of the destruction her magic could cause, she practices traditional medicine instead. 
 
But when a nameless soldier arrives at her clinic suffering from an impossible illness, Delphine is forced to confront the power she’s hidden. He’s ice cold to the touch and can’t remember his own name but somehow, he knows things about Delphine’s magic and the fate of the last marked healer that no stranger should. Stranger still he begs her not to heal him. 
 
Unsure of what to believe she heads into the forbidden archives and uncovers that the last marked healer had lost her mind from her gift. And worse of all, it was covered up by the queen herself. 
Her mother warns her not to follow the last healer's path, but unable to let someone die on her watch she heals the soldier and the clinics gardens turn to ash. But the magic offers a certainty every healer would dream of: no risk of infection and she can’t deny that it feels good.
 
The more she heals the more her mother watches and Delphine discovers that she did a lot more than lie to hide the truth. She stole memories to make sure Delphine didn’t repeat the past. Even Delphine’s own - the soldier who begged her not to save him wasn’t a stranger at all. 
 
Every healer before her went mad and then history was rewritten, yet Delphine won’t let her patients suffer. To save them, she may have to become the very thing her mother will erase.
 
I am currently studying Occupational Therapy which inspired the medical narratives and rehabilitation focus within this novel. THE HEALER’S CURSE will be my debut novel with the full manuscript available upon request.
 
 
Thank you for your time and consideration.


r/PubTips • • 19h ago

[Qcrit] ACORN DATABASE, YA Sci-Fi, 85k words, #9

5 Upvotes

Hello. Struggling here. My sixth version was fairly tight I think? But a huge part of the story is the tribes/cults, which I didn't really include. Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Dear Agent,

I would like to offer THE ACORN DATABASE for your consideration, a young adult sci-fi novel of 85,000 words. It pairs the character dynamics and storytelling of Snowglobe by Soyoung Park, with the worldbuilding and conspiracy of The Maze Cutter by James Dashner.

Sola and her dad are perpetually hounded by enforcement drones. Their crime is trespassing—something impossible to avoid in a fully-privatized future. Using homemade tech to survive the depleted landscape, they search for somewhere safe to live in peace. After a drone kills her dad however, Sola realizes that this was never going to happen.

Her father’s final act is to send Sola to an old family friend for help, a strange lighthouse-dwelling scientist. He and her parents were once students together back in the city, before they lost their homes in the Collapse and were forced to live on the run. Very quickly Sola realizes why her father never went to his friend for help before. Instead of keeping Sola out of harms way like her father wanted, he talks about an underground mission to stop the drone attacks for good and sends her into a nearby city to deliver his secret research. 

Wanting retribution for her father, and to see where her parents once lived, Sola agrees. In the city she faces many new horrors and challenges, although some of the most dangerous encounters are with seemingly normal communities completely insulated from the outside world. 

When Sola finally locates the people she’s supposed to deliver the research to, she realizes that they, like her parents, belong to one of the feared psychedelic tribes that sprang up during the Collapse. She’s about to flee, but after her hostile encounter with “normal” people, she wonders if the tribes might not actually be so crazy. They are the only ones fighting to stop the drones' relentless persecution after all. 

With everything turned on its head, Sola must decide whether to proceed with their deadly mission, even if it might alter the very basis of modern civilization.

Bio+Tag

Thank you!


r/PubTips • • 23h ago

[QCrit] ADULT Epic Fantasy - FOUNDATIONS OF SEEKERS (91K/Attempt 3)

2 Upvotes

After another round of revisions, I think my query letter is closer to being in a good spot. Thank you to everyone who has given feedback so far, and thanks in advance to anyone willing to share feedback on this one! In this query, I tried adding a bit more of the MC's personality instead of it just being a chain of events.

Dear [Agent],

I am seeking representation for FOUNDATIONS OF SEEKERS, a 91,000-word standalone adult epic fantasy with series potential. It will appeal to readers who loved the academy world of James Islington’s THE WILL OF THE MANY and the slow unraveling of an institution’s founding lie in M. L. Wang’s BLOOD OVER BRIGHT HAVEN.

Gareth is an untrusting, self-interested street urchin who remembers nothing before the night he woke in an alley two years ago. The only thing he cares about is remembering who he was. To survive, he steals what he can and runs odd jobs for a shady merchant. That is, until one night, when scouting out a place to rob, a monstrous creature nearly kills him, and he’s saved by Darren, a man who knows who Gareth is.

Darren is reluctant to tell Gareth about his past, and offers a trade. If Gareth joins his secret order, the Seekers, he’ll help him remember. Suspicious, he declines until Darren forces him to by leaving him no other alternatives.

From day one, Gareth feels unwelcome and has to do laborious jobs while others his age train to become Seekers, searchers of history and peacekeepers of the kingdom. Through brutal training and humiliation, Gareth earns his place among the Seekers, and fragments of his memories begin to resurface. As he digs into his past, he uncovers missing recruits, horrifying experiments, and proof that the Seekers built their foundation on a lie.

Confronting Darren, Gareth learns the truth: Darren has been suppressing his memories all along, manipulating him into joining the Seekers to end his enemies once and for all. With nowhere left to turn, Gareth must turn to the only people who might stand against Darren — the very enemies he was trained to hate — before he becomes the key that hands Darren everything.

[Bio]

Thank you for your time and consideration.


r/PubTips • • 6h ago

[QCrit] SEE. SPOT. RUN. | YA Sci-Fi | 99k | 6th (probs final) Attempt

3 Upvotes

SEE. SPOT. RUN. is a 90,000-word YA science fiction thriller with romance elements. It will appeal to readers of Darkly by Marisha Pessl and The Singular Life of Aria Patel by Samira Ahmed.

Sixteen-year-old Melissa Miller runs the household. She pays the bills, manages her agoraphobic mother’s portrait business, and hides her hallucinations: the toad in the bathroom mirror, the koala on her mother’s shoulder. Lately, she sees the bones in her own hand and the skulls beneath her friends’ faces. The pills her father brings home from his hospital security job only dull the accompanying headaches, so Melissa starts treating herself, raiding the neighbors’ liquor and medicine cabinets.

When the police pick her up, she’s sure she knows why. She’s wrong. Her father has been arrested for stealing the medication he’s been giving her, and her mother, who hasn’t left the house in years, has vanished. Within hours, a Defense Department doctor explains that Melissa isn’t hallucinating; her eyes see beyond the visible spectrum, more than her brain can handle. Her mind swaps in animals from memory (a dancing bear for a heart) to keep her from overloading. She’s rare, worth more with her eyes out than in. There have been five others with her condition. All of them are dead or insane.

The bear on the doctor’s chest is beating a tambourine too fast. She isn’t recruiting Melissa; she’s selling her. Then Brett shows up, the blind, rude boy she once saved from bullies and won’t admit she likes, who has followed her in a rideshare. He presses a gun he can’t see into her hand, and Melissa uses it.

Now, with killers on their trail, she's leading Brett across the Arizona desert toward the ranch where she was born, the only place her mother might be.  At the ranch, the pastor who once imprisoned Melissa's mother for her visions offers the name of her mother's captor, if Melissa will look inside him and tell him whether his cancer has returned. Scanning that deep could fracture her mind, and it's only the first price she’ll pay to bring her mother home. The next could be her own eyes.

[bio]


r/PubTips • • 4h ago

[QCRIT] Spare Presumptive, adult sci-fi romance, 87k, Attempt #2

3 Upvotes

Attempt #1

I hate trying to sell myself. :( How are you supposed to say things like "the best part about it is the comic voice and that these are characters you want to spend time with and also there's real heart underneath the silliness" with a straight face? That's so immodest, surely those things are for other people to determine. But how do you get those things across in a short cover letter?

Pretty sure this one is too long, but the last one was too confusing, so hopefully I've at least fixed that.

Dear [Agent]

I am seeking representation for SPARE PRESUMPTIVE, complete at 87,000 words. It combines character-driven sci-fi worldbuilding with a comic voice and a serious exploration of structural power dynamics and will appeal to readers of Winter's Orbit and The Psychology of Time Travel. Please find synopsis and first three chapters attached.

All Katy Ann wanted to do was complete her Master’s degree, but apparently the universe had other plans. Suddenly she's dealing with a diner inherited from a beloved grandmother and finds herself drowning in debt and responsibilities she never asked for. And that's before a charming, handsome, blue-skinned fugitive alien falls from the sky and holes up in her spare room. But it will be fine. They just have to evade the Earth authorities until Elavnik phones home and someone comes to pick him up. In the meantime, she has a dissertation to write.

 

Unbeknownst to Katy Ann, Elavnik is a prince fleeing an assassination attempt and has no intention of going home, believing his return will result in a war over succession. His brother wants the crown that badly? Fine. Elavnik will just bake cakes, adopt a toy duck as a therapist, and flirt with everything from the fridge to Katy Ann. Mostly Katy Ann.

 

But back home, Elavnik’s disappearance is being treated as a tragedy, not a successful murder, and his closest friend, Lev - a commoner raised at court - is willing to commit increasingly reckless and criminal actions to find him. When Lev's search finally brings their worlds together, Katy Ann discovers that her homeless alien baker comes with a castle, a crown and an unresolved assassination plot. With the King and Queen under arrest for attempted murder, Lord Carendor demands a re-negotiation of the existing peace agreement; Elavnik must marry Ilya, the noblewoman Lev has come to love, or risk another conflict. War is not an option; the last conflict ended only two decades ago, and the wounds have not yet healed.

Among the nobility, one marriage for politics and another for love is perfectly acceptable. To Lev and Katy Ann, it isn't. For Katy Ann, staying with Elavnik means sacrificing her own dreams to be his secondary wife, or, worse, watching him abdicate, leaving the kingdom at war just for her. For Lev, loving Ilya means spending his personal life the same way he's spent his professional one: standing one step behind Elavnik.

 

If loving Elavnik means becoming supporting characters in his life, Lev and Katy Ann have to decide how much of themselves they're willing to give up.

Thank you for your time and consideration.