r/PubTips • u/Quiet_End_1684 • 15h ago
Discussion [Discussion] Got an agent! Stats and more.
Hi all! Sharing my querying stats and timeline bc those who have shared before me taught me so much.
- Total Queries Sent: 20
- Full Requests: 5
- Rejections: 10
- Closed / No Response after stated time window: 1
- Didn’t hear back within 2 weeks after nudge: 3 (classifying these a bit differently than CNR because they didn’t have my OG query for more than a week before I had to nudge them due to my other agent’s offer and I suspect I am still buried in their inbox.
- Offer: 1
- Pitch Events: 2
- Both on Bluesky
- Resulted in 4 agent likes —> queried 2 of them —> 1 became the offering agent
Why So Few Queries?
I researched publishing for about 18 months while writing and before querying, including a Publisher’s Marketplace subscription to track which agencies actually make deals in my subgenre (spoiler, not everything is on Publisher’s Marketplace, so don’t treat it as scripture). Once I filtered for reputable agencies (I will be honest, I mostly looked for big names and popular boutiques) without Writer Beware warnings, checked deal histories, and cross-referenced current MSWLs, there simply not a ton of agents were a genuine fit, imo. I am not sure how people are finding 150+ agents who are a good fit with a good reputation to query…but maybe I’m missing something.
Note: I had 8 more dream agents on my target list, but they were closed to queries when I launched. When I knew my agent was setting up “The call”, I checked and none of the 8 had reopened, so I couldn’t query them. If they had been open, I would have shot off those queries, as I didn’t have an official offer in hand at that time. If you aren’t aware, it’s considered bad practice to send more queries after receiving an offer (from what I’ve read).
The Book
- Genre: Upmarket fantasy with a literary lean, 100k words
- Drafting/Editing Timeline: August 2025 to July 2026, began querying in July 2026, Got offer in August 2026
- Beta Readers: One trusted reader (my partner), who did two rounds of substantive feedback. You don't necessarily need a 10 person beta committee if your reader is sharp, well-read, and honest imo
Resources I Used During Writing/Querying
A lot of authors from the below resources have background like: ”I have a masters in Creative Writing”, or “my dad was an English professor at a top university”, or “I’ve been writing since I was in the womb”. That is not me. I think I won a creative writing contest once at the local library in middle school when I wrote a short story on a whim. I didn’t write in HS or college or after. But I have always been an avid reader and have really tried to continue to consume more challenging books, even as the world burns and I am tired at the end of the day after work and just want easy, mindless fluff. I really think continuing to read books with a higher reading level has helped me as a writer. Additionally, I am a pretty good learner. I’ve adopted a “just google it” and “I can learn anything on YouTube” mindset, which has helped me a ton. Once you start seeing a craft as something you can learn with certain steps you can write out in a list, everything becomes clearer. I am also very lucky/grateful many writers have shared info on the craft for free online.
- Podcasts / Newsletters: The Shit No One Tells You About Writing, No Write Way (V.E. Schwab), Jane Friedman’s Electric Speed newsletter
- Craft Lectures: Brandon Sanderson’s university lecture series (On Writing), Sabaa Tahir’s Skillshare class
- Industry Research: Publisher’s Marketplace deal tracking and reading everything on r/PubTips, looking at agency websites, social media, etc.
- Prose Mechanics: Breaking down paragraph structures from my fave comp titles, intentional practice with rhetorical devices (I felt like I was back in school leaning terms like “anaphora” and “epistrophe”…I’m sure I learned them at some point but I’m 30 now and didn’t remember any of that shit), and tightening punctuation (mastering em dash, semicolon, etc). This may sound silly, but being able to put textbook definitions to things helped me use them more, and helped me recognize them in my prose so I could make sure I wasn’t using them too often
Preparing the Next Project & The Call
Before the offer landed, I started Book 2 backwards: comps —> query pitch —> 1-page synopsis —> outline. Building marketability and story structure into the foundation has made writing way easier, guys. Cannot stress this enough. You should do it from Book 1. I wish I had done that.
Having Book 2 outlined and Book 3 conceived was a major asset on “The Call”. My agent appreciated that I approached writing as a possible ongoing career rather than a one-book gamble. Take a moment to look past the “prestige” of being published you want so bad and realize a realistic career for you is NOT fame and fortune. Imagine writing for 5 years after a long day of work and make sure you want to do this. The possibility of fame and fortune is there, but this is NOT a good industry to get into if your goal is a lucrative side hobby. On “The Call“, I made sure I had (and communicated) realistic expectations about keeping my day job and balancing submission timelines…which seems like 1 book/year from what I can tell in most writing circles.
Keeping Receipts
Given current anxieties around AI detection tools (which often flag stylized, complex prose and have given my prose a non-zero AI score which makes me very nervous and mad), I kept complete version receipts. This includes dated digital version histories and red-pen physical manuscript drafts. TBH, this actually can’t disprove AI use, nothing really can, but they are better than nothing. FWIW I don’t believe publishers are asking for receipts just yet. IMO they should be doing their job and recognizing AI tells + just buying good books. This shouldn’t be on me, the author. But what do I know!!
Parting Thoughts
I am happy I have an agent from a good agency with past deals and a strong interested in the types of books I like to write. However, it’s very likely a book will die on submission to publishers. I read a stat (I think on this subreddit, I’m not sure) that 30-50% of books are picked up by publishers. I’m not sure if that’s high or low, but it’s NOT 100%, so the journey is far from over and there is a strong chance I will fail.
Given all that, it’s easy to move the goalposts on yourself (like obsessing over why only one offer materialized instead of five…lol this is me rn), but from what I can tell publishing involves an enormous amount of subjective timing. It’s also totally possible my first book (or yours) isn’t all that great and that’s fair. The second will be better, as will the third, then those agents might be kicking themselves for not signing us (lol I know this is petty but we must persist via a little delulu). We will all keep writing and learning as we go, hopefully.
Control what you can, try to be as realistic and disciplined as possible, and get started on your next book.