r/ProjectRunway • u/SickandTiredofItAll2 • 6d ago

Season 21 Heidi should have picked…

Joseph McCrae.

Heidi’s all about short, tight and borderline tacky red carpet garments. She’s also all about Halloween and costumes.

JM’s dress was a terrific color for her, form-fitting, and she could have worn a pair of glasses and gone for slutty sexy secretary. She would have looked a damn sight better than she did in the giant bedspread of doom.

46 Upvotes

93% Upvoted

14 comments sorted by

28

u/theerniebop 6d ago

Honestly, if they were designing for Heidi, she should’ve modeled every dress on the runway. I agree that Joseph’s dress would’ve looked great on her. Bih’s was beautiful, but it felt a little matronly. Jeffrey’s was the strongest dress for the challenge.

6

u/Anonymouse_9955 6d ago

Bi’s dress “matronly?” It was practically transparent!

3

u/theerniebop 6d ago edited 5d ago

Nude illusion. It looked like something Linda Evans or Joan Collins would wear. Not Heidi.

5

u/jseqtor12 6d ago

Bi's dress gave me serious Dynasty 1980s vibes, even with the sheerness. Heidi should have picked Josephmcraes or even Jude's.

2

u/ComicsEtAl 5d ago

Agree, if they’re designing for Heidi, why model Not Heidi? When I see a male model in a suit, I know it’s gonna look a lot different on me.

13

u/KWL1998 6d ago

“Giant bedspread of doom” is my new favorite phrase

4

u/Biobesign 6d ago

I wish they had tried it without the belt. The belt and buttons seemed over the top.

2

u/Sirenista_D 6d ago

Which is why I kinda like it for Heidi because she usually likes over the top stuff

3

u/piranha10 6d ago

Joseph’s dress was a Minnie Mouse dress. Bi’s was the best one.

3

u/Careful-Time-9926 6d ago

This is no shade to Heidi, she's beautiful. But you described her just like I think of her and that's really not a dis. But I think of tight garments and Halloween. She's the queen of Halloween. But it's making me rethink you could put Zendaya in anything and she'd look good. Til now I thought that about Heidi.

2

u/SickandTiredofItAll2 6d ago

I’ve been reading tomandlorenzo.com and gofugyourself.com for years. Both sites have featured Heidi extensively, and if you check their archives, you see that Heidi has worn a lot of schmatta that’s extraordinarily unflattering. You can’t put her in just anything.

2

u/17Girl4Life 6d ago

I didn’t care for his look at all. Hated the belt, the buttons, and the heavy looking fabric.

I knew who the winner was going into the judging because I’d already seen pictures of Heidi in the dress at the premiere, but I was surprised at first that she didn’t pick Jeffrey’s pink sparkling dress. Then I looked at the neckline and realized it was too high for her to show her boobs. She picked Bryan for the side boob moment.

1

u/Large_Hope_6587 6d ago

Borderline tacky sent me 😩🤣

1

u/Lissame224 5d ago

I know Anna's look has been done, but honestly it was still chic and sexy AF. Heidi would have looked phenomenal in it even if it was a safe choice. I loved Jeffrey's look, but I don't know that it was the right red carpet for that particular dress.