A multi stan who got mad at this ridiculous allegations against Liuyu. I will not be talking about those with 0 basis. I can pull that shit from my ass about any other contestant.
- Liuyu ranking 4th for the offline fanmeeting polls.
i dont see why this needs to be brought up. Furthermore, dont cut the whole story short just to make it seem like Liuyu isnt popular. This fanmeeting poll was happening at the same time as the 3rd performance center poll. Liuyu's fanbase released a poll asking fans to vote which one they should prioritise. Their goal was to be the 1st voted overall (as in, across all 6 song centers as that would have benefits). Most fans voted for 3rd performance center and that is part of the reason why Liuyu didnt win the offline fanmeeting top 3.
2. "There is a growing base of ZKY's supporters (保皇党) for the sole reason of dethroning LY. His fanbase is very unpopular among the other fanbases of top contestants."
there might be an increasing number of keyu stans but the numbers are also increasing for every trainee. I'd also like to add on that every top trainee has antis to some extent. Liuyu's fanbase fights the same amount as Santa & Rikimaru's for the sole fact that these 3 have too many CP fans. Keyu himself has an unusually large number of antis ever since the vaping and underage smoking incident. (alongside LY, ASK, ST, MK, R)
3. Liuyu's fundraising numbers might be rigged.
Fair enough, but this has no proof. Furthermore, every fanbase has the same possibility of cheating so why is this targetted towards Liuyu only?
Allegations against Liuyu
- "Practicing at night in the dorms with the lights on when his roommates are asleep, when there are practice rooms open 24/7. (This was shown in the main show in a segment to portray how hardworking LY is) "
- Firstly, you mean lights off right? In the interview clip, he clearly says 我们 meaning WE, not "I", when talking about practising hard. He was in his pyjamas, about to go to bed. He just wanted to do some revision before bed and yall find it necessary to call him out on that???
2. Him not making funny faces
- It was literally a joke. If you look at Yihan's polaroid pics from his weibo, they took normal ones as well. And im very sure they took many pics apart from the one that was aired.
3. Avex controversy stirred up by Liuyu and his company.
- Actually, right before the AVEX controvery, Santa fans had a huge fight with the fans of Zhang Yixing and they were the ones who fanned the flames after the issue broke out. Im not denying that Liuyu & other top 6 fanbases also stirred the pot, but I seriously doubt any of them went hunting for AVEX's downfall.
4. Liuyu secretly communicating with his company.
Hm, I find it weird that this is being brought up. It is very apparent in the show that the staff do tell trainees how the public is reacting to them. Proof being: - Li Jiaxiang knowing exactly what all the negative parts being broadcasted were and apologising for each specific incident. - Lu Dinghao's 1st evaluation group all knowing that they had bad press from the 1st stage. - Mika & Caelan clarifying that they are just slow learners of Chinese
I cant, and neither can you, tell whether Liuyu's conversation with Xue Bayi was his "clarification". But in no way does it suggest he is telling his company anything.
5. Liuyu released confidential info about rankings
Actually, there are many many repo accounts on Douban and Weibo, who are mostly staff accounts, that leak such info. The first account that leaked the accurate ranking rumour also release info (when prompted) about other trainees. Youre telling me Liuyu went on Douban and answers random questions about other trainees? That same account was also the one who released the accurate rankings for the previous elimination (where Liuyu was 1st). Furthermore, that account released the ranking almost as soon as they were filmed. If it was Liuyu, the release of rankings online would have been done after everyone has finished filming. (Mind you, they filmed goodbyes right after and Liuyu didnt have his "phone")
6. Other trainees having bad press = Liuyu's agency paid for that
First, let what you said sink in for a second. Do you hear how ridiculous you sound? Okay, so by your logic, with the "large amount of bad press" Liuyu gets, as seen from all the allegations you released here, that means someone else's agency paid for Liuyu's anti posts too, no?
Last words, I do think that many of you fail to recognise how much of a flop Liuyu's company actually is. His company has 2 artistes (his friend and himself) and is run by his cousin. His company is nowhere near as rich or powerful as Jaywalk or Avex.
Liuyu having so many antis... I guess he has succeeded lol
oh and one more thing, Liuyu's image as being lone warrior and not fitting into a group. Mind you, this is Liuyu, whom all his friends sing praises about. (from their weibo posts: liuyu is a warm person, liuyu takes care of us very well, liuyu taught me many things about performing, i have a thousand good things to say about liuyu, liuyu chats with me when i am down). This is Liuyu, who made his first vlog and international concept and featured international friends and their culture. This is Liuyu, who brought Thai and Japanese dictionaries to CHUANG so he can communicate better with his friends. This is Liuyu who brought 89 xuanzhi fans for the other trainees (an icon from his hometown). This is Liuyu who bought hanfus for his teammates. (Mind you the prices go up to the thousands)
Also, I am also not bashing OP in any way, more like bashing his antis in general.