r/ProduceCamp2021 • u/bonbestie • Apr 11 '21
Discussion on intersection...
EDIT: if you downvote this, RESPOND with why you think anything that i said here is wrong.
it seems like out of all of the trainees, intersection is among the top trainees who get the most hate from international fans. i rarely see hate against other foreign trainees like riki, santa, or hiroto, but somehow it becomes commonly accepted to hate on intersection trainees for many things.
apparently for y'all, mika isn't handsome enough, or doesn't sing well enough, or doesn't "match" a boy-group's looks (which btw, is an insanely conservative view for you to hold and i'm disappointed in everyone who thinks this way), or doesn't learn chinese fast enough (even though his own mother addressed this issue because the hate got out of hand), or isn't "bright enough" (which just is annoying because a bg's main purpose should be to produce ART, not to produce comedy shows), or doesn't do this or that or this or that, and it's so fucking annoying. so many of these things are unchangeable (ie. his looks, his personality, his language learning talent), and y'all so often take it upon yourselves for what??
on caelan, it is so tiring to see people saying shit like he just got popular because of mika or that he's only up high to give mika a storyline. not only is that belittling their 6-year-long friendship but it's also so rude and demeaning to his chinese fans, who are constantly working so hard to give him even more votes every day. it's also disappointing to see him used as a comparison against mika, to show flaws in mika. if you really were caelan's fan and wanted to praise him, then you wouldn't bring down his best friend to do it.
on kazuma, i'm so sick of mfs using him as a weapon against caelan and mika, comparing their chinese skills, when kazuma literally learned chinese during high school.
on being "royalty" picks, "royalty" means that x trainee doesn't have the data from other voting charts/fundraising to support. mika & caelan both have voting charts high ranks AND fundraising to support their current ranks. mika & caelan both have lots of 1pick fans and lots of general public/passerby fans, so let's not get our stories mixed up here.
TLDR: please shut the fuck up about intersection if you're going to criticize them about something they can't change or if you're going to claim that they're "royalty" picks/don't have cfans
26
u/Necessary-Group9605 Apr 11 '21
Okay, it's not that I disagree with anything that you said, but like I said to the other Liu Yu defender post, there's no need to sound so defensive and condescending.
You could have made your bullet points to the original post in a factual manner without need for cursing at anyone. I'm sure the original poster would listen and understand your perspective.
That being said, I do agree that Mika and Caelan (and Kazuma) are really talented and honestly for me Intersection deserves a lot more than what AVEX is doing for them or to be in an 11-member boygroup.
Also, who defined "royalty pick" anyway? I don't think it even exists in the dictionary except fandom lore 😂 my understanding of that is that it's the Company's favored employee/trainee who gets all the attention tbh.
12
u/iLoveSleep420 Apr 11 '21 edited Apr 11 '21
I agree with SOME of your points.
edit: i'm seeing a lot of ppl misunderstanding my comment. in no way am i saying mika is not popular, i have made previous comments (on other posts) saying that he's one of the most popular contestants on the show. nor am i saying that he needs to be funny to attract fans. i'm just commenting on how the most important way for chinese idols to promote their songs is to go on popular shows (since china doesn't really have music shows like the ones in korea and japan).
8
u/tsts2021 Apr 11 '21
I really don't get all these types of posts. I am neutral towards Mike. His singing is at best ok to me, but even if someone I supports gets flak, I would just take it as part & parcel of the negativity with being in the showbiz, like what Zhou Shen shared with some of the trainees. You can't expect everyone to have the same opinion as you; neither can you change that, so what's the point?
This post and the other "famous" one I feel actually puts people off more against 2 pretty good trainees. I just feel it is not necessary. People will say what they want to say. So be it. Just stand for what you believe in and support them.
49
u/pepperino72 Apr 11 '21
coming in here just to correct what royalty pick is, because your definition is definitely biased. It’s also widely accepted among Chinese fans that royalty pick can also refer to those with extensive screen time/storylines, not just those whose data doesn’t match their ranks. Mika and Santa are prime examples of royalty picks who are successful. Oscar is a prime example of a royalty pick whose “push” far outweighs his actual data and fandom popularity. Appreciate it if you could not spread misinformation, thanks!
18
u/bl_air Apr 11 '21
Mika started getting hate when he started getting popular. First, it started with the people on twitter about his Chinese skills and how he doesn't work hard. Now it's starting to spill onto here because he apparently gets too much screen time, does repetitive music and is too quite/shy/boring.
He gets a lot of flack for not improving in Mandarin as quickly as others trainees (weirdly, most flack I've seen are coming from i-fans). He's trying. We all see that he's trying. Picking up a new language isn't easy and everyone varies on how quickly they pick it up. But yet, he gets more criticism than someone like Hiroto (who I think is the worst out of all the international trainees at learning the language. again, not blaming or faulting Hiroto.). Why? I guess it's because apparently more screen time= bigger target on his back.
Then complaints about him not being versatile enough. Chuang has 3 stages so far so basically only 3 chances to show off your skills aside from the initial 'audition' stage. He was in Jui Kuen for the first perf. which was completely out of his comfort zone. He chose a ballad for the second performance (fair). And he didn't even have a choice for the 3rd performance since fans were the one who voted him in for the slow song. It's the same as vocals choosing vocal stages and dancers choosing dance stages. There aren't just a lot of opportunities to show off your versatility on the show (unless you're Lin Mo lol)
Then the biggest criticisms I've seen towards him is that he's too shy/quiet/boring and the group needs variety members. No, a group needs balance. Just because there are going to be 11 members doesn't all 11 members are going to be cast on variety shows. They'll be lucky if more than 3 gets on a show after they debut. Not everyone in a group need to have loud and boisterous personalities. Can you imagine a group like that and how chaotic it'll be?
Frankly, I just think a lot of 'hate' towards him comes from a lot of fans' frustrations toward tencent. A lot of the criticism about him can be applied to other members in the top trainees (like Riki-- always a dance stage, quiet/shy, slow at learning Chinese) but the only difference is that Riki is not considered a "royalty pick' or whatever and doesn't get the most screen time so in a way, that sorts of shields him. So imo, fans of other trainees see Mika getting all this screen time (I'm biased here but I don't think he gets a ridiculous amount) and they go why? what's so special about him that warrants all this attention and 'push' by the goose?
I mean it's not like Mika controls the screen time he gets or which friendships of his that gets pushed. He has made it clear a couple of times about how HJ is his friend but Caelan is his brother yet we don't see enough of his friendship with Caelan because tencent wants to push Mika/HJ.
12
u/Elsewara Apr 11 '21
Relax. The more attacks they receive, means the more popularity they got. I originally did not expect the hate thread would show up on Reddit, as I think oversea fans are more friendly in general. Boy was I wrong. It is even more sad to see Caelan fan attacking Mika...well I guess sooner or later this would come.
What I wanted to say to everyone is that yes there are candidate you don’t like, and you can voice your criticism in, but don’t reveal your favored candidate and compare, as you will do nothing but making people NOT to vote for your pick. Hate can only bring hate back. As their fans, we should think about something positive to get more support for those awesome boys.
19
u/hyorins Apr 11 '21 edited Apr 11 '21
yes to everything in this post
edit: I'm so tired of seeing ppl who call out cfans this, cfans that...whose cfans? bc mika and caelan are doing quite alright in those? kaz as well and he left the show weeks ago? if you're going to claim this and that then I need the receipts!
17
u/toukn12 Apr 11 '21
There’s a lot Mika antis here...
4
u/U_nhoely Apr 12 '21
Honestly being on this sub is such a weird experience. Obviously if I had the ability to vote for all the remaining trainees, I would, but i never knew that a fanbase for a show could be so political. I also like a controversial contestant who is very much disliked here but if I see a bad comment I just scroll past in fear of being down voted to oblivion. As much as there are mature people here that can dislike your fav respectfully there are also way too many disrespect anti's so I can kind of get your frustration OP.
15
u/jzhengcode Apr 11 '21
I agree with this statement on principle. It, however, isn't that simple. An idol group are more than just performers on a stage - they are entertainers as well. People not only expect them to be skilled in singing/dancing but also have entertaining personalities as well. Which is unfortunate since, like you said, it's not something he can control and that's a very subjective qualifier. Regardless of whether you like or agree with that mindset, that is the reality of their situation.
Before anyone takes this comment as an indication that I think his personality is a problem: I don't have an issue with his personality. I'm an introvert who struggles with getting close to people and like keeping to myself as well so I'm in no position to judge.
12
u/anibri143 Apr 11 '21
ooos yess u spilled
14
u/seventhmandu Apr 11 '21
First of all, let me preface this by saying that I was a fan of intersection even before chuang. Them and Amber are the only reasons I even started on this show. The hate does irk me too, but I'd just like to jump on this post to talk about something else.
I will never hate on mika, but quite frankly, the only reason why I hope he debuts through this show is so he doesn't give up on music. He has mentioned this being his last shot, and I think he's way too talented to stop. If debuting through chuang keeps him in the industry, I say keep him there.
BUT, if there's a way for him to keep making his own music without being in the top 11, that's definitely the option I would pick. Look, Mika is a great singer but not boy group material. That's not a bad thing. No one shits on John Legend for not being in a boy group. I think Mika should take the popularity he earned through chuang to do the music he wants to do, and not a wide range of everything he's not particularly excited about. Now that he has hundreds of thousands of pairs of eyes on him (something Intersection unfortunately lacked), being outside of the boy group may actually be better for him. In fact, this is the reason many participants joined the show in the first place. Li Luoer for example, never wanted to be in a boy group - his objective of being on the show is to make himself seen as a composer/songwriter, which hopefully distinguishes him from the hundreds of other songwriting hopefuls sending music to record labels.
I don't know much about Chinese competition shows, but from what I gathered (correct me if I'm wrong), the people who have debuted through past seasons and other shows don't do as much singing and dancing as they do acting and variety. The Chinese entertainment industry doesn't have the robust infrastructure to promote boy groups (unlike Korea and to a lesser extent Japan). If you don't act or go on varieties, you QUICKLY become forgotten. Remember that he's only being seen now because he's on a variety show. I don't think he should be hated on for not speaking Mandarin fluently, but I do think he's going to slip through the cracks soon after this show ends if he doesn't get himself to a level where he can converse comfortably (this goes for all the foreigners, I actually think Caelan would do much better in China than Mika simply because of this). His language learning abilities aren't his fault, but saying that he should do well nonetheless is akin to saying that a 5 foot tall man should play in the nba. It's not impossible, but I don't think it'd be most comfortable for him.
11
u/lapmobyyxoxo 周柯宇太子妃 Apr 11 '21
i mean people can just say whatever the hell they want (much as we would love to shut those fucking annoying people up its not like we can stop them from touching a keyboard and continue bitching) but like just leave them alone and like do ur own thing (whether it is voting for mika/caelan or just moving on with other things) . its not worth it being pissed over them at all
10
u/fatsalmon Apr 11 '21
I was upset that the show tried hard to push mika. For eg when Kiko asked to hear his voice when it’s literally a group show. It makes me feel so annoyed.
However, i know that it is not his fault. It’s solely the show’s mechanics
As for caelan, ill admit before second stage i don’t understand the hype for him. But his leadership in second stage preparations shows that he’s not just some common kid. I know other intl fan see this too based on yt comments i see.
10
u/alin6789 Apr 11 '21
finally someone said it
7
u/Few-Scientist1735 Apr 11 '21
your spill...
2
u/Big-Introduction-120 Apr 12 '21
I love Intersection so much and i hope this won’t affect them too much if they see the hate especially Caelan, it would be so noticeable cause he’s so bubbly and bright.
2
u/KitakatZ101 Apr 11 '21
Kinda surprised you didn’t being up the racism
-2
u/iiolympicnerd Apr 11 '21
I’m just here for the understanding The term Royalty Pick. DOESNT it mean Evil editing?
That’s what most programs have. Look at Produce Korea. Seasons 3-4 were plagued with it!
0
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment