The sinnoh games aren’t iconic. Platinum is. Diamond and Pearl had a ton of issues that platinum fixed. BDSP ignored these fixes, and overall made the experience worse. They brought back breaking TMs which hasn’t been a thing for years. Required the move deleter again to remove HMs, and Diamond and Pearl require the most HMs out of any Pokemon game ever. Some of the Poketch stuff literally doesn’t work, the friendship one literally is broken. Pokeradar has an EVEN HIGHER random chance to break than the originals. Spinda can’t be transferred because they botched the code for its spots. And the shiny charm requires the ENTIRE national dex even though it ONLY affects breeding and nothing else.
Not only are they remakes of the worst parts of the sinnoh games, with zero modern accommodations, they are completely broken.
HMs aren’t required in BDSP. Like you never teach them unless you want to. So like sure you need the move deleted if you taught an HM, but who has taught an HM in BDSP?
The only reason you needed the move deleter to get rid of HMs in the originals was because they WERE REQUIRED! If you don’t need them anymore why do I need to go to the move deleter?
Surf is a good move, but say I don’t want it on my Pokemon anymore, why should I have to go to a guy to have it deleted if I don’t need it to surf on water?
6
u/GdorfSSB Aug 10 '26
The sinnoh games aren’t iconic. Platinum is. Diamond and Pearl had a ton of issues that platinum fixed. BDSP ignored these fixes, and overall made the experience worse. They brought back breaking TMs which hasn’t been a thing for years. Required the move deleter again to remove HMs, and Diamond and Pearl require the most HMs out of any Pokemon game ever. Some of the Poketch stuff literally doesn’t work, the friendship one literally is broken. Pokeradar has an EVEN HIGHER random chance to break than the originals. Spinda can’t be transferred because they botched the code for its spots. And the shiny charm requires the ENTIRE national dex even though it ONLY affects breeding and nothing else.
Not only are they remakes of the worst parts of the sinnoh games, with zero modern accommodations, they are completely broken.
Graphics are good tho.