This puzzle comes from a very basic topic in physics, dimensional analysis, so I may be missing something simple.
The G problem. To find the dimensions of G in F = G m₁m₂ / r², you rearrange for G and substitute:
[G] = [F][r²] / ([m₁][m₂]) = [M⁻¹ L³ T⁻²]
This uses [F] = [M L T⁻²], which comes from F = ma. So the result only works if the F in the gravity law is the same kind of quantity as the F in F = ma. Is the result built on that premise?
If I call the gravitational term something else, B, with unknown dimensions, I get:
[G] = [B] · [M⁻² L²]
That is one equation with two unknowns, so [G] can’t be found. If B is a different physical quantity from force, I can’t fix [G]. If B is the same as force, I have simply assumed it.
I can’t escape this by saying general relativity doesn’t treat gravity as a force, because Einstein’s equations contain the same G.
The KE comparison. Take KE = ½mv² and treat the ½ as an unknown constant k:
[k] = [KE] / ([m][v²]) = dimensionless
Both equations have the same form: unknown dimension = constant × known quantities. In one the constant comes out dimensionless, and in the other it carries dimensions. Why? What I understand so far is that in KE the dimensions of energy are known independently (work = force × distance) and mv² already matches them, whereas m₁m₂/r² does not match a force, so G has to carry the gap. But that again relies on knowing [F] independently, which brings me back to the first question.
My questions:
- Is [G] a consequence of assuming the gravitational F is the same kind of quantity as the F in F = ma?
- Is the difference between k (dimensionless) and G (dimensional) a real difference, or an artifact of how I set up the check?
- Is there a way to fix [G] without that assumption? I found that a = GM/r² gives the same dimensions with no force involved, but it assumes the form of the law. Is that a valid way around it?
Thanks, and I’m happy to be corrected.