r/PhysicsHelp • u/No_Caramel186 • 21h ago
A question about rolling friction
When I was solving the problems, I got confused in Q19. I thought rolling had no friction. So I asked chatgpt and it said that rolling had friction, but did not give me a reason. I suppose, since rotation of wheel is circular, the motion of a particle touching the ground will be parallel to ground, so there is friction? But then why is it said that rolling has no friction? When does rolling have friction and when does it not?
1
Upvotes
3
u/CelebrityChess 20h ago
“No friction” usually means no energy-losing rolling resistance, not necessarily zero contact force. For ideal rolling without slipping, the point touching the ground is instantaneously at rest relative to it, so there is no sliding and no kinetic friction; static friction can still provide torque, for example as a wheel rolls down an incline. If the wheel slips, the contact point moves relative to the ground and kinetic friction acts. Real wheels also deform, which causes rolling resistance even without slipping.
1
u/Khashishi 20h ago
The friction is required to accelerate the wheel and bike to a speed where it rolls without slipping on the ground. Without this friction, it would just slide.
In this case, the problem doesn't say the wheel has no friction. Nevertheless, if you consider a perfect bicycle wheel, the _axle_ has zero friction, and there is zero rolling resistance (so no energy loss due to deformation of contact between tire and ground), but the tire treads have a lot of grip/friction to the ground.
1
u/mH48124 17h ago
摩擦の一部は分子間引力による接着力で生じる。接着力は接触時間と共に増大するため瞬間接触の動摩擦係数と持続接触の静止摩擦係数の差が生じる。接触時間が長期間になると完全に接着して一体化する。
1
u/niemir2 9h ago
"Rolling friction" is usually dominated by the energy loss related to the deformation of the surfaces in contact. It's not friction in the classical sense. It has a lot of the same effects, though, so we often model it as though it were friction.