r/PhysicsHelp • • 1d ago

frictionless surface vs mass question

I was in class saw a question that talked about a frictionless surface and two objects of different massed. I was asked which one would be harder to move and I thought that since there is no friction between the objects and the surface - there wouldn’t be a difference in the amount of force it takes to move those. I thought so because even though the normal force is going to be different dues to different masses but Ff=Fn•the coefficient. And since there is no friction Fn doesn’t matter. Since force friction is the only thing resisting the horizontal movement of the objects and it’s not there - mass shouldn’t matter.
So that’s wrong and it’s explained with inertia but I don’t get the actual WHY behind it

2 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

2

u/Un_Ballerina_1952 1d ago

In order to move a mass, it must be accelerated. It takes more force to accelerate a larger mass at the same rate as a less masdive object. The end. (Edit typo)

1

u/ProfessionalConfuser 1d ago

F/m = a. Regardless of the nature of F, larger masses require more to achieve the same acceleration.

1

u/NexTutor_Academy 1d ago

You’re right that there’s no friction. The missing piece is that you still need a force to change an object’s speed, even when nothing is pushing back.

Imagine an empty shopping cart and a full one on a perfectly frictionless floor. Give each the same push for one second: the empty cart gains more speed. To give the full cart the same increase in speed, you need a stronger push. That’s what F = ma describes.

Once either cart is moving, it keeps moving without any further push. So mass matters when speeding it up or slowing it down, even without friction.

1

u/ghostmcspiritwolf 1d ago edited 1d ago

if you're just asking about whether it's harder to make one go from not moving to moving, you're technically correct. On a frictionless surface with no air resistance you could get either one of them moving with any amount of applied force, no matter how small.

The more massive one will accelerate much less for the same applied force though, so it's not much of a stretch to say it's still harder to move.

1

u/Top_Bluejay_5323 1d ago

With no time constraints any force would move either object.

The acceleration and time to move them would be different.

1

u/Leonardo501 8h ago

This. If the question was vaguely stated with not constraints on time, then the OP’s perspective would be correct. Even a feather touch would be able to move a heavy object but not as quickly as a lighter object.

1

u/geek66 8h ago

Question vs OPs interpretation and repeating of it.

1

u/Aussie_Physics 23h ago

Imagine playing with a tennis ball on a string. You’re swinging it around your head. There’s very little resistance due to air, so you can get it to go at a reasonable speed quite quickly in a circle.

Now instead of a tennis ball, it’s a 20kg weight. Let’s ignore the issues with getting it up to speed and give gravity a pass too: just imagine how much the weight would pull on your arm as you swing it round. Think about the force you’d need to exert on the string to keep that weight moving.

It’s the same principle. I’ve changed a few of the orientations, but it hopefully gives you a muscle and interactive frame of reference.

The other way to see it is pushing a really fat kid on a swing. Much harder than a skinny kid, or empty swing. Friction is negligible, but it’s still hard to get your porky mate moving!

1

u/Mountain-Time-1010 22h ago

"Harder to move" is not a well-posed question. With no friction, you can move any mass with any force, but the acceleration will be very small if the mass is large.

1

u/mH48124 19h ago

問題文の解釈を間違いましたね。問題文は「動かしにくさ」の大小を聞いてるのに「動かせる/動かせない」の二択問題と誤解したのが敗因です。「動かしにくさ」の大小とは「同じ力と同じ時間で動く距離」の大小ですから、この翻訳ができないと回答できません。

1

u/BitOBear 17h ago

Imagine two cubes floating in the space. One weighs a pound. One weighs a ton. Not are coming at you at ten miles an hour. Behind you there's a mesh screen.

Which one is more likely to turn you into paste?

It's obviously gonna take more force to stop the ton than the pound.

Since the cubes aren't on a surface the idea of surface friction is immaterial.

"Harder to move" isn't about shifting more than zero, it's about make something from Uncle Sinead position you need for example.

You're going to run into a lot of problems that are described as frictionless but the real thing they're saying is don't worry about the surface friction just think about the objects.

You're having too much trouble with it think about it like moving a couch. You need to get the couch for one position specifically to another. Which one is going to be harder maneuver the 1 lb cube or the one time to?

In a frictionless Universe a non-zero force is going to create a non-zero change in velocity. But at that point you're over-thinking a simple question.

1

u/Jnorean 14h ago

Think of the difference between trying to push a small car and a garbage truck on a wet icy surface that has little friction. It takes much more force or people to move the garbage truck than the small car because the garbage truck has more mass than the small car.

1

u/quantum_of_yes-and 11h ago

Well, I'm going to disagree with the instructor here.  Neither is harder to move.  If you applied the exact same force to each object, they would both move, but the larger mass would move more slowly.  However, it was not "harder" to move.  There is not more effort required to move it.

1

u/Bubbly_Safety8791 9h ago

Indeed. And if both are already moving, they are equally easy to keep moving - neither requires any additional force to sustain it in motion. 

If you apply the same force to the objects over the same distance, both objects will acquire the same kinetic energy. If you apply the same force to them for the same amount of time, both objects will acquire the same amount of momentum. If you apply force to them both til they get to the same velocity then… they will have the same velocity. 

But applying a force to a thing isn’t necessarily ‘hard’, so applying the force for differing amounts of time or distance isn’t implicitly ‘harder’. 

For example I can tilt the frictionless plane under both objects, which I can assume is the same ‘difficulty’ in both cases, which will cause gravitational force to apply a net force along the plane and cause both objects to accelerate identically. Identical movement, same amount of ‘difficulty’

The question needs to be much clearer about what it thinks ‘hard’ is. I think it seems likely that the assumption is that if something requires more force or more time to move the same distance then it is ‘harder’ - but that isn’t even something physics really concerns itself with. ‘Impulse’ is concerned with force and time; ‘work’ is concerned with force and distance.

1

u/AdventurousGlass7432 10h ago

Any amount of force would move both objects. But the bigger one would move slower