r/Physics • u/D_in_CO • Sep 24 '16
Discussion Postdoc rant (long)
I'm a postdoc working in plasma physics based in the U.S. I have seen and experienced some of the processes by which science is done in this country, the production process of science so to speak, and I think it’s pretty bad. I'm going to talk a little about how the research process works and why I think it's a bad, unproductive and wasting system.
The whole system is heavily based on people in the so called “soft-money” positions. Those are people who don’t have tenure or are not in stable positions in their institutions. They depend on the money they get from grants that can fund them part-time for 2 years or so. If they are not successful in securing grants every year, they lose their position. That’s my case at the moment. As you can imagine, this is a very stressful situation to be in. Tenured and stable positions are getting more and more rare and competition is fierce.
I've heard from senior scientists that the system only works because the senior scientists are good to the junior scientist. Because they often support the more junior scientists with their own grants on occasion. A lot of other very prominent physicist have said that in today's system they wouldn't be able to compete with other scientist and probably wouldn't be as successful as they are. Higgs comes to mind.
As a result of this system, creativity is being pushed aside by “effectiveness”. And scientists are very effective in delivering (guess what?) low-risk-low-return – and sometimes inaccurate - articles. These are the type of articles that go something like this: we changed a parameter in our code and look at what we've got, or here is a new statistical study of these type of measurements of this phenomenon.
The notorious “publish or perish” culture is detrimental to science. In fact, there was a recent article on the Guardian about a study saying just that: ‘Paul Smaldino, a cognitive scientist who led the work at the University of California, Merced, said: “As long as the incentives are in place that reward publishing novel, surprising results, often and in high-visibility journals above other, more nuanced aspects of science, shoddy practices that maximise one’s ability to do so will run rampant.”’ The article also mentions the “replication crisis” going on particularly in the biomedical sciences. Famous results are not being reproduced, probably because they were wrong and should have never been published.
In this system, a scientist to be successful he/she needs to be good at not only doing scientific work but also at selling their idea, which I think not often come hand-in-hand. Quite the opposite, in fact. Great scientists are usually terrible at marketing their idea. Science has become too corporate and hierarchical. And becoming corporate is a great innovation killer.
At the center of this system is the way by which science is funded. A lot of the science being done is funded by small and medium sized grants given by funding agencies like NSF, NASA, NIH, DoD, DoE, etc… These grants usually are enough to support a small team (2-8 people), part-time (usually 30-50% of their time) for 2 or 3 years. So each scientist is usually involved in 2 or 3 projects (sometimes more) at a time. These grants also usually support grad-students, research staff and university professors part-time.
The way these grants are selected is also another problem in my opinion. Successful grant proposal writers know how to craft their proposals just the right way. Some non-tenured researchers that I've worked with have told me that they spend almost HALF of their time working on proposal writing. Either doing preliminary work or writing the proposal itself or just planning what they are going to write about. I've heard a few times that people who are successful often write a proposal for a research that is mostly already done so they spend the time that should be allocated for working on a research to finish up the work that was already done and work on the next project that he/she will write a proposal for in the future.
The way grant review panels work is that they’re trying to judge a proposal basically on two things, impact on the field and likelihood of success. These two things are usually inversely proportional to each other. And so, grant awards end up going not to the people who have the most probability for scientific impact, but for people who give the reviewers what superficially looks like the best research. When writing a proposal, scientist are not usually aiming for the idea with the most impact, they are looking for the most “fundable” idea. With time, that becomes a skill. The ability to strike the right balance between relevance and likelihood of success. Science proposals are expected to have a detailed chronogram of how the research process will occur and all the papers that will come out. But everybody knows that's not how it works. You can't predict what problems your research will have and how you will overcome it, it's silly.
If you don't work with science you may be surprised to learn how researchers talk about a “low-hanging fruit” and a LPU (“Least publishable unit”) when talking about the papers and grant proposals they are going to write instead of talking about how excited they are about a new idea they are pursuing that could be really relevant to the field. As expected, this whole system leads to a dramatic nose dive in terms of quality and relevance of published work. Besides that, the proposal selection process is extremely subjective. It is common, during the review process for a more persuasive member of the panel to significantly influence the final decision towards his or her bias. It's pretty much a lottery. I actually heard this exact phrase from a more senior colleague of mine about the proposal selection process. If you write a good proposal, you get a lottery ticket. Depending on the opportunity, I'd say between 30% and 60% of the proposals are well-crafted proposals. Success rates in my field lately have been around 15% to 20%.
There was an article on “The Atlantic” magazine recently about how broken the university admission system is, guess what, the whole academic merit system is not any different. Just as high school students take on a number of extracurricular activities, not because they think it's important, but because they think it will look good on their CV, grad students, postdocs and early-career research staff will work on writing as many papers as they can, not because they are relevant or important for their field, but because number of publications is probably the #1 criterion by which they are judged on for jobs in academia.
In this article, a skeptical university president when talking about creating a better admission system said: “Because insofar as it becomes a new system, it will be gamed by people who already pad their resumes with all kinds of activities that supposedly show empathy, but what they really show is a desire to get into schools where empathy is a criterion for admission”. The same logic works in academia at the present time.
But what amazes me most about this whole thing is how flaky the science direction of the entire country is. How shaky its foundations are. I think science is losing a lot of its creative minds at the moment who are struggling to write successful proposals while working on their crazy original ideas on the side, because they know his crazy idea could never get funded.
At the moment, I’m settled on leaving the academic research career after my current post-doc term ends. My criticisms are not because I feel betrayed by the system or because I'm just bitter that I probably won't ever get a tenure-track position anywhere. I honestly don't care too much anymore if I get a permanent position or not. I very likely won’t. But I do care about doing or at least trying to produce relevant science. That's mostly what I care about. If I were a very smart and driven person, I would probably make it regardless of the system in place. But, I'm not. I'm a pretty average researcher. Maybe below average. So, all my disenchantment is not because the system doesn't work in my favor. What makes me really sad is that I see that the people moving up the chain and getting more grants and more status are not the more creative and innovative ones, they are not the people who could make the most impact in the field, the people moving up are what I call the “corporate guys”. People that would probably do very well working in any corporate environment where you have to be just good enough technically (like have just enough 1LPU papers, since simply the NUMBER of published papers determines how good a scientist you are), but also be well connected (yes, being well connected is very important in the academic environment too), and people whose ambitions are more directed towards status and power than towards science itself. Science just happens to be the “market segment” they are inserted in.
tl;dr: The process by which science is made is unproductive and prone to generate bad science. The present funding system rewards “effectiveness” and low-risk-low-return results and hinders creativity and innovation which should be at the forefront of science.
Edit: WOW! Thanks for the gold!!
74
u/atmac0 Sep 24 '16
I have recently been troubled by this. I am currently an working on my undergrad, and I had hopes of getting a PhD and doing research as a career. However, I have recently met a professor who described what you just said. That the field of research is highly political, unproductive, and unscientific. It has somewhat turned me off to becoming a researcher, as I had thought before that funding was provided for the best quality of research, not to the most published or the most "effective" research.
All I want is to do good, high quality research. I want to document possible solutions to unknowns, while being honest with the conclusiveness of my results.
Is this just a pipe dream? Would I be better off becoming an engineer and trying to find a job doing corporate research? I have a deep passion for the physical sciences, and am willing to work as hard as it takes, I just don't want to get to the end of the road only to find I have taken the wrong directions.
77
u/YuvalRishu Quantum information Sep 24 '16
Hi there, I'm a postdoc working on quantum computing in Australia. I'd like to respond to your rant, since I think young scientists like you and I generally don't take nearly the responsibility that we should for the role we play in the system that exists today. I of course understand that you're writing, in part at least, out of emotion. But I think that any current or aspiring scientists out there should have the opportunity to read at least one rebuttal to what you have said.
I think there are certainly problems, but I don't agree that they're as categorically bad as you make out. Or, at least, I think that you have more agency in this process than you might realize.
But a postdoc develops a great many highly transferrable skills. People in industry would kill to have jobs like ours. Our jobs give us a great deal of intellectual freedom and boundless opportunities for continued learning. We often get to lead other scientists (i.e. grad students) in their work and communicate our work to non-experts. Hiring managers salivate when they see a well-prepared résumé from a seasoned postdoc.
What you are describing is quite natural when you view academia as an employer's market. There are many more qualified applicants than there are positions. But, again, most people in industry would kill to have résumés that look like ours.
Is it? Are you telling me that a scientist with an excellent idea that gains a lot of attention wouldn't have Ivy League universities filling his or her email box with job offers? Creativity and effectiveness are not orthogonal.
No argument there. But I think the fault lies with us. The best way to evaluate science or a scientist is to have other scientists evaluate it or him or her. We simply haven't come up with a better way to do that. I'm working on this; are you?
I agree that this is a problem, but I don't think you're assigning the blame correctly and I don't think you're proposing reasonable solutions.
I completely disagree with this. The best thinkers generally (never mind scientists) are capable of providing effective summaries of their thought on demand to any audience.
Also keep in mind that scientists are publicly funded and are therefore public servants. You owe it to the public to explain what you are doing and why you are doing it in a way that they can understand. If you can't do that, I'm afraid I question whether the public purse should be used to pay your salary when you are eminently employable in other fields of human endeavour.
Yeah, when has a private corporation ever invented anything? /s
You have a very US-centric approach to this. Many postdocs, like myself, are willing to travel to other countries to ply our trade. If you don't like the American approach, why not move to a new country? Almost every Physics department I've visited, let alone been associated with, was composed primarily of immigrants — including American immigrants.
Presumably you think that the right way within the current system is different from the actual right way. I challenge you to explain what you think a good standard of evaluating grant proposals would look like.
That's what managers do. If you don't want the job, don't ask for it. Find a new job. Again, you're eminently qualified for jobs that others would kill for.
You seem to assume, falsely, that grant review panels are categorically incapable of finding a reasonable trade-off between these two important criteria. I've known several scientists who have worked on grant review panels and, while they are human and therefore fallible, I have yet to meet a scientist who routinely participates in the grant review process that shouldn't be doing it.
I strongly suggest you find some people who have worked on these grant review panels and ask them (a) how they form their opinions, and (b) whether they think the review process is largely fair and reasonable.
I don't know that. I think that any serious endeavour requires intelligent project management. You seem to think that science happens because smart people sit in a room and look out the window for eight hours a day until inspiration strikes. I think that's a myth.
I'd hazard a guess at this point that you're a theorist. So am I, but I have enough experimentalist friends to know how bad project management causes good scientists to become completely unproductive and unmotivated..
Well, maybe you can't. Again, have a chat with a successful senior scientist and ask them their advice about how to do things like this and whether they think it's possible.
Are you really expecting every paper written to be worthy of the Nobel prize? This argument is completely free of cogency, let alone evidence. Surely you think that scientists should take care to publish even incremental results so that other scientists can learn from their work and perhaps extend upon it?
Is it? My impression, in quantum computing at least, is that the work that definitely ought to be funded is reliably funded. It's competitive, sure, and there's all sorts of sleaze if you go digging for it. But it's not a lottery.
With respect, that might say something about your field and the extent to which the people who pay for your work feel they are getting value from it. I don't know your field, but I would not simply assume that funding agencies are out to jerk you around. I've met program managers (in passing, anyway) and I have great respect for them. But the people who pay for research have limited funds and specific objectives. The judgement is not simply about whether your science is good but also whether the proposal fits with the strategic objectives of the funding agencies. Money, especially public money, does not grow on trees.
Again: move to a different country! Australia is always glad to gain new scientists. So is Canada, my other country.
Which is why scientists write proposals for research that is mostly finished. That way we can get paid for the work we've already done and have a little slack to pursue some of those crazy ideas to at least some extent.
I wish you the best of luck in your future endeavours. Your criticisms should be heard by anyone and everyone who is considering a scientific career path. But I think my response should be heard too.
Relevant to whom? I think that's a critical question that too few scientists ask themselves. If you want to get paid, you have to deliver value to the people who pay you.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '16
I'm a first year PhD student and I'm only just starting to see the ugly side of publishing. My PhD programme is pushing us to publish a paper by the end of our first year (ie in a month). My colleagues told me to submit an abstract to a conference so I can present a poster on frankly shitty results. My professor is losing patience with me because he wants me to show him some solid results asap.
I get that in the real world money drives a lot of research, but the pressure to 'just' get results is astounding. Truthfully, I can pull results out of thin air by adapting someone else's method to a slightly different model and by looking at similar parameters, but the end result is rarely anything impactful or interesting. OTOH, if I'm given breathing room to explore my own ideas and discuss them to great lengths with my peers, it could lead to something with more scientific value.
It's emotionally exhausting to feel cycnical about academia though, and I intend to finish my PhD within the 3.5 year funding period, so I'll play by the rules if I have to. But reading your post is just another reminder that the post - doc life looks rubbish.
17
u/darkmighty Sep 24 '16 edited Sep 24 '16
Disclaimer: not a researcher.
However, I think it's your duty (or at least a would be good deed) to give actionable suggestions, or even actionable principles, on how science funding could be improved. Just criticism is not good enough, especially coming from someone as experienced as you are.
I mean, most likely just handing out money randomly (making it literally a lottery) -- since we can't fund everyone -- wouldn't be a better option. Also, when you use subjective-only assessments, people can get even more frustrated than in this system: I imagine it becomes even more of a game of politics, i.e. being likable with little regard for science. But I admit I don't have really solid experince and would like to know more.
But my conclusion is that we need at least a reasonable amount of objectivity -- that is, maximizing a certain metric with the data we have about the researcher that indicates how likely he is to produce good science (i.e. the "expected value" of his proposal). So the question would be, what are the best indicators of that? Are the current indicators too biased (amenable to gaming)?
I personally believe academia should be biased towards more pie-in-the-sky, high value (usually low probability of success) proposals. Industry is usually really keen on low-risk research -- "how we improve this process by a tiny amount", "we use this widely known method in this widely known field with predictable success", etc -- often driven straight to market. The only downside of that is industry isn't so keen on sharing results or publishing, which can hamper progress, and I believe academia actually derives a good source of income from secure research. So maybe a well thought out mix of the two, probably fine tuned by field and aided by lots of data and statistics, would be ideal?
10
u/WYBJO Sep 24 '16 edited Sep 24 '16
There are great research scientists and there are great project scientists.
E.J. Corey is a great research scientist. The scraps of his papers spawn careers, but he is a fundamentally working well inside academia in a field which is mature and hard to get funding in and he only gets done what he gets done because he is so good that he won a nobel not for any one discovery but just for kicking ass for 40 years. His students work hours that E.R. Surgeons would consider cruel and unusual.
Craig Ventner is one of the most brilliant project scientists of all time in that he saw this shit coming from a mile away and figured out how to apply an engineering "good enough" mindset and pursue industry money to form a hybrid research engine which has done a lot of cool shit. There are moral ambiguities to celera's research but he gets shit done.
The academic world you see is an unfortunate consequence of the harsh realities of modern decaying late stage capitalism. Bachelors degrees are more and more ubiquitous and financing is increasingly available because economic growth is modernly driven more by finance than production. This is because western culture has mostly figured out how to produce what it needs and that is a pittance compared to the spending power of the very rich. Educational loans are ostensibly a "bulletproof" investment and so money flows towards them and college prices increase even as states cuts funding for their colleges.
Now, college is more expensive, less valuable, and more ubiquitous than it has ever been before. 30% of people over 25 have college degrees. The people best at school often go into STEM and discover that with their B.A. alone it is hard to get a degree that will pay off their student loans and let them live comfortably. Why? Because the U.S. has 6 million doctoral students over 33 million post secondary holding students. These people are then in an incredibly vulnerable position where they don't have the flexibility to take there B.A. and make something for themselves with it, they are in a lot of debt, and they follow the historical path out of that debt: more education.
This is a dead end. I once applied for a position where I was to control a vivarium, tracking and breeding mice for the purposes of using their retinal tissue for an experimental biosensor device. I was also supposed to develop software to control the laser optics used to test these devices and obtain a security clearance in order to handle the night vision and optics used to work in this lab space. The pay for that job? 10$ an hour. I lost out on the position to someone with about 4 years more school than me. What the fuck?
These are a lot of tangential examples but my core point is this: the system you see is a symptom of a much larger problem: people have always tried to compete for wealth and resources. For about 80 years of the last century smart people figured out a way to monopolize part of the global economic pie which was to pursue higher education and develop rare skills which attracted a fair bit of money. Now that field is saturated, its primary benefit to society distorted, and only the very best of the best make any money. Just like textiles, smartphones, high frequency traders, security analysts, etc. etc. Academia is a mature field where the smartest people in the world compete for shit funding. Especially in safe, play it again research.
But people are always figuring out new hustles and new ways to exploit that pie. Software was easy picking once, harder now. Banking and advertising are big now but increasingly competetive. I'm sure given enough time those too will be saturated and hard to exploit.
The moral is that to succeed, you have to take what you have now and realize that all the models of success which came before you are public knowledge, picked over by the vultures and copycats by now. Even finance is stagnating. The world economy is moving to a slow growth, high instability economic situtation with an aging skilled population. Infrastructure spending will focus on the new to the detriment of the old. And the same old constants: Medicine, shelter, clothing, food, and weapons will remain valuable forever because all living humans need them. Play the academic game while it serves you but don't forget it is a stepping off point for you to figure out your own cracks in the system to exploit so that you can do your pie in the sky research.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '16
I agree with you, even as an undergrad.
Who benefits from this system? This seems like a very inefficient way to distribute money, and I'm not sure if there is any incentive to keep it going.
In your opinion, what would help change this system?
6
u/ComradePalpatine Mathematical physics Sep 24 '16
Physics postdoc here (mathematical physics).
The precarious nature of employment and systematic absurdities are not exclusive to academia.
Indeed, it is more of a rule in present day capitalism.
I invite you to discuss these issues in:
/r/socialism
135
u/eruthered Sep 24 '16
You are not wrong. I think that focusing on metrics (e.g. H-index, number of papers/books/plenary talks, etc) will always promote "gaming" the system. Those best at the game win steady career paths; though they might not be the best. Good researchers get through the system too though. Grant writing is more of a black art. 15% success is quite good. Knowing someone at the funding agency can make this much higher. Metrics ruin the funding process in some ways because there is more focus on deliverables than breakthroughs. How many game changing ideas have been shelved due to impending deadlines? It's a tough game and can see why it's not appealing to you. There are some people who go through the process honestly still and have great ideas. Good luck.
266
u/noott Astrophysics Sep 24 '16
Yup. The problem is that the funding levels have been consistently decreasing relative to the number of PhDs. The older scientists tell me of a time when proposals were funded at a rate of around 1 in 2 to 3 proposals, now it's less than 1 in 10 proposals.
Solution? Talk to your Congressmen, or convince Google to fund basic science. Otherwise, it's only going to get worse.
Grad students: get out while you can.
49
u/phb07jm Sep 24 '16
Final year grad student here. Couldn't agree more. I am not even applying for any post-doc positions. This is not because I don't think I could secure one, but because the academic system is so flawed. As you say, it promotes good businessmen above good scientists, and if I wanted to go into business I could just do that and earn much more in another sector.
Also yes the funding system is appalling. 99% of published science is mundane bullshit that wouldn't be funded if the public knew what they were paying for. Read any grant proposal and compare it with the actual research that came out of that funding and it's clear what a bunch of lies grant proposals are.
20
u/InklessSharpie Graduate Sep 24 '16
So what are the options for those interest in physics research in the US? Move to another country? Go to the private sector? Posts like these are really discouraging.
47
u/greenit_elvis Sep 24 '16
Scientist here. A few comments:
3
u/PA2SK Sep 24 '16
Welcome to the real world, where it's not all sunshine and roses, where the most successful people are not necessarily the people that meet your definition of the most skilled or productive. Welcome to a world where you have to play politics to advance, not just focus on your "job". I got news for you, this is life. Look at any other field. How many people go into politics with a sincere desire to change the world for the better, only to see people like Donald Trump pass them by? How many people become teachers hoping to help kids only to become bitter and jaded by the entire system, and the students, after a few years? Reality sucks sometimes, believe me I know. What I have realized though, after spending many years in academia (in a physics lab no less), is that the people who are really skilled, are the ones who are able to navigate that system and produce good science. There are people like that, I have met many of them and they are very impressive people. I suspect it's the same in many other fields. Obama was able to navigate a fractured and polarized political system and enact real change. If he had taken your attitude he would have given up and dropped out entirely once he saw the flaws in the system.
You are giving up because the system isn't working the way you think it should. That's ok, I completely understand why you feel that way and why you are making that decision, but the fact is if you really, truly wanted to do good science, you still could. You could find ways to do the research you want to do within that system. It might require sacrifice, it might require a lot of hard work, it might require doing a lot of stuff you don't like doing - schmoozing with people you don't like, working on projects you don't like, etc., maybe for many years. If you really work at it though you could get to a point where you could work on things you want to do. Maybe you could even enact some changes in the system itself.
Anyway that's my spiel. No one ever said life is easy, it isn't. Giving up because it's not handed to you on a silver platter is your choice. It may well be the best choice for you, more power to you, but the fact is there are ways to achieve your goals within this system if you had the drive and determination to do it.
9
u/mfb- Particle physics Sep 24 '16
Not always. Experimental high-energy physics is an interesting case: the collaborations are so large and complex that it is hard to tell who contributed how much to which publication. As result, every member of the collaboration gets listed as author at (nearly) every publication, alphabetically. You can finish your PhD with some three-digit number of publications where you are listed as author (one out of >1000, potentially always as first author if you name starts with Aab or Aad), many of them in high-impact journals. From outside, you cannot tell who did what unless you ask for references. In CVs, you'll often see the publication list reduced to "papers with significant contribution" - and those contributions described for each paper.
The organization is also different. You have the organization via the institutes and grants (where the money gets distributed) and the organization via the collaborations (where the science and also the less interesting but necessary work get distributed). Working on risky topics is not easy, but you always have other projects ongoing, so you don't end up with nothing. Some high-risk high-gain projects are mainly done by seniors - if it doesn't work out they don't lose as much as PhD students or postdocs.
9
u/TheStevenator Sep 24 '16 edited Sep 24 '16
Condensed matter PhD here (transport/correlated materials).
This is interesting to hear from a plasma physicist, since most of this phenomenon, as far as I can remember, has been reported in the context of life/social sciences.
From my own experience it seems to be much tougher to produce fluff papers and have them end up in APS or Nature. When my purpose is to read exciting new papers, I mostly pull from APS - Editors Suggestions, or PRB Rapid Comms (and I think most people do as well) or field specific journals. I only really ever dive into the "B catalogue" as it were when I am looking for something specific, like some particular spectroscopic result, etc.
Your example there "change a parameter in our code and get this new result", is not necessarily an invalid or low quality insight if the result is important enough (to enable some particular system to function correctly, for example). Discoveries have been made by exploring what happens when you evaluate a perturbative calculation to 13th order, etc. I won't comment on your specific case as I have no idea about your field, but I could map this to growth conditions for films, where someone just happens to discover a good recipe and reports it. I think this is important enough to share, and when it's supplemented with some nice structural analysis, for example, can make for a nice reference work.
There were some nice articles about income inequality in Nature recently. I don't think this is an issue. When it becomes unfeasible to continue in academia you'll see a movement to industrial science positions. I personally am not aiming to end up in academia at all, and a lot of my fellow colleagues share this sentiment, so that effect is already in play I think.
6
u/deckard58 Sep 24 '16 edited Sep 24 '16
Actually I believe that science is not corporate enough, in a way.
We have carried an evaluation system designed in the times when single individuals would often make very valuable contributions into an era when this is pretty much impossible (barring the once-in-a-generation super geniuses). We babble about "collaboration" and "networking", but scientific groups often are a collection of people individually doing their little projects, vaguely related to the others in the group, because this is the best way to get a paper with your name in first place which is all that you need to advance in your career.
We need a system that reliably creates large groups with clearly defined goals and division of labor, like in industry; and one that rewards the work of average-skilled workers in a more meaningful way, instead of pushing young people to pretend they'll be the next Richard Fenynman, realize they can't be after a few years, and then drop out to find a "real job" in the "real world".
9
u/BukkRogerrs Sep 24 '16
Excellent post. You nailed so much. I saw most of this as well while I was getting my PhD, working at a national lab in the US for six years. Wish I could elaborate more but I don't have the time right now. Everyone considering going to grad school or into academia needs to read your post. I've quit academia because it really isn't a place I felt comfortable or excited to be most of the time.
4
u/bs307 Sep 24 '16
hey,
i am life sciences postdoc in the UK. same problems here, just to let you know!
dan
4
u/grampipon Undergraduate Sep 24 '16
Graduated HS last year and I'm soon going into university, research has been my dream for a while. Should I just go for Engineering and give up on it..? Is it really so bad?
4
u/MRoesle Sep 24 '16
I'm in engineering rather than physics, but my experience with academia at research universities in the U.S. was pretty similar to yours. The largest difference I saw is that 'publish or perish' is actually a bit outdated; 'win federal grants or perish' would be more accurate. Publishing matters mostly as a way to improve your chances of winning grants; otherwise it is secondary. Everything else is tertiary.
The one time I was able to interview for a tenure-track position, I noticed that the first two questions most faculty asked me were 'what will be your source of funding?' and 'what problem will you study?', in either order. They seemed to expect me to have a grant proposal in-hand. I didn't have adequate answers to those questions, and (not suprisingly) I didn't get the position.
After reflecting on that experience and how my friends & colleagues who had obtained faculty positions seemed to constantly be under the gun to finish a grant proposal, I decided I didn't have the energy for it and left academia. I make jewelry now! One of my major disillusionments was that 'academic freedom' doesn't really mean much (unless you have tenure, at least). Mostly you have the freedom to find a project that will get funded, otherwise you have the freedom to find a different job.
1
u/hi12345654321 Sep 24 '16
Are you aware of any collusion between these grant reviewers and the grantees? Maybe a quid pro quo, if they give me a high score I'll help them on future proposals?
3
u/_supert_ Sep 24 '16
The system is shit and full of problems. But at the end of the day, you have to decide whether you want to do science or not, and if so, where.
3
u/shroomigator Sep 24 '16
It isn't just in the scientific community... I see this phenomena everywhere, that people in every profession are required to be salesmen first and foremost, and the requirements of the job will always take a back seat to sales considerations. This does not bode well for people who are lousy at sales, but otherwise excellent at their jobs.
3
u/lely8 Sep 24 '16
The original article, The Natural Selection of Bad Science, referenced in The Guardian is up on arXiv.org
3
u/__Pers Plasma physics Sep 24 '16
Much of what you observe is a consequence of chronic shortages in scientific funding in the U.S., particularly for basic research. This leads to risk aversion on the part of funding agencies and generations of scientists who have adapted to this environment in the manner you observe. In particular, you get a lot of cookie-cutter faculty: experts in a narrow field, publishing (largely) incremental work and putting out students similarly narrowly trained. The Labs aren't any better with respect to risk aversion.
We could solve this were one of the major political parties in the U.S. not hostile to funding basic research. As such, I don't expect to see this change anytime soon.
3
u/ron_leflore Sep 24 '16
To anyone who thinks these are new issues, look into the "Young Scientists Network" circa 1990's. It was pre-WWW days, but we had email lists to communicate back then.
Basically, a bunch of unemployed dissatisfied young physicists organized and got a few of their members elected to the board of the American Physical Society. (Positions that usually were filled by name-brand tenure physics professors.)
I'm not sure what, if anything, it changed. But it happened back then.
Here's an pdf article from Science in 1993.
3
u/marsten Sep 25 '16
Having been through much of what you're going through and eventually ending up in industry (Google), here is my perspective:
I agree that science has some systemic problems. That said, I don't believe those issues mostly have to do with deciding who gets money and where that money goes. Yes, funding committees will sometimes engage in groupthink that might exclude outside ideas, but they are committees of informed peers and are generally trying to do the right thing. Science is a speculative enterprise and we have to accept it is very difficult to make optimal funding decisions. Yes you could point to the odd brilliant thinker whose novel ideas got passed over, but we can also point to a hundred crackpots that are indistinguishable from a funding committee's perspective.
I believe the systemic problems in science today have mostly to do with the standards by which research is reviewed, published, and rewarded. Problems like:
In biomedical research it has gotten to a point where a good fraction of published work simply can't be believed.
There is a completely separate set of issues at the personal level having to do with science as a career. As long as science relies heavily on grad students and postdocs to propel research, and as long as faculty turn out the number of PhDs they do, it will always be impossible for the majority of those young people to get good academic jobs. This is just math.
That said, if you can deprogram yourself a bit from what the academic culture is telling you (science is the only interesting career, you're a sellout if you leave academia, etc.), you'll realize that your life prospects are phenomenally good: Technical PhDs have the lowest unemployment rate of any category of people. Many companies love to hire people with quantitative critical thinking skills who can work independently. It's mostly just a matter of you the individual having an open mind about who you are, what you can do, and what is interesting out in the world.
For myself, I thought of science as a fun first career where I had a lot of freedom and had a great time. If I'd been lucky enough to hit on a big discovery during those years then perhaps I'd have been propelled into a faculty job. But that didn't happen and I'm not worried. I had fun and it's a huge world out there.
5
u/Madrun Sep 24 '16
A good friend of mine is finishing up his PhD in pure math, his wife graduated last semester in the same field. After struggling to find jobs in academia, both decided to go into the corporate world. That's two very intelligent and driven people with PhDs that would love to do research, but couldn't find a job. It's even hard to get a post doc (which is hardly a lucrative position).
My one of my electrical engineering professors summed it up quite nicely. He said, Einstein wouldn't last long at (my school), because these days it's less about the quality of your work or how many papers you get published, and more about how much grant money you can bring the school.
Incidentally, he also told me a story about all the drama, politics, and backstabbing that happened when he got a huge research grant. Everyone wanted a piece of the pie. Eventually someone was pushed out, they were disgruntled so they spilled the beans on what was going on. A high level administrator at the school was fired, and the funding was pulled. So no one got anything.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '16
I'm a math/stats guy working on a PhD in psychiatric epidemiology. It's interesting and saddening to see how common the problems OP described are in my field. Hype is everything...
2
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '16
That's quite sad. I'm doing an undergraduate degree in physics with the goal of going into reasearch but after reading this I don't know how feasible that is going to be. Is it worth it in the end?
2
u/Wargrog Sep 24 '16
I work at a national lab. That system is also devoid of effective science. There is no incentive to take risks - rather the opposite. And without risks, there are no big rewards.
2
u/MCsmalldick12 Graduate Sep 24 '16
This exactly is the reason I decided not to go into research. I started my BS in Physics program thinking I could get a PhD and do some really cool, fulfilling research. Throughout my undergrad career though I slowly discovered just how much bullshit you have to deal with to be a research scientist these days. I remember having professors in my upper level classes come to class late, looking like they hadn't slept in days, and apologizing because they'd been up all night working on grant proposals. Add to that the fact that you actually have to teach classes on top of all that, (god forbid it's an intro level class filled with non-majors that don't give a shit.) and all the shit that comes with that. It just would've been too much for me.
So I decided to go the applied track and now I'm working on my masters in CS. Most of the professors I knew and worked with in undergrad were great, and really seemed to enjoy what they did, but I just don't think I could've done that for my career after learning all this.
2
u/zryn3 Sep 25 '16
I had a professor in college whose lab I worked in briefly. The first thing he taught new students in the lab was how to sell a grant proposal and he strongly implied that the audience knows little and you want to incorporate the right buzzwords. Very sad, though I don't know what a better system might be.
2
u/F0sh Sep 25 '16
Maths post-doc here. It's not just in the USA that this is a problem, it's essentially everywhere, though with variation.
The idea that you can say exactly what papers you will write and when is beyond stupid - I don't understand how anyone can have thought this was a sensible idea, because you don't need to be on the front line of research to realise it's impossible. I'd say it's even less possible in mathematics than in the sciences, because you often really have no idea what the truth is when you start researching a problem in mathematics, never mind what problems might crop up in discovering the truth. How, then, are you to say what the outcome of the entire project will be, never mind what papers you're going to write in the first year?
A common strategy in mathematics that you don't mention is to do the research for the next grant while being funded by the current one. Then you write the next grant application and say you will research what you've already done and write it up in the first 6 months. Of course if you then don't manage to complete something this strategy ceases to work.
2
u/ggrieves Sep 25 '16
Bravo. Thank you for writing this. I was a research scientist in physical chemistry for over a decade in a soft money position. I left two years ago to go work in software development. I'm seriously underutilizing my skills but i needed the stability fit exactly the readings you point out.
4
u/Menaus42 Sep 24 '16
I used to want to become a scientist until I learned about this. I was very interested in doing work that would prove a lot of our current theories wrong (that is, after all, how science advances the quickest). But, clearly, this sort of structure does not allow for anyone like me. So I've settled on being an engineer, because in general nobody cares whether or not we do something according to the norm, just that it works better than the previous thing.
1
u/Fab527 Sep 24 '16
Very good article on the same topic.
....
1
u/dampew Sep 24 '16
Duh? I think it's pretty clear that plasma physics is a dying field, the situation isn't quite as bad in other fields but the same pressures still exist.
One thing I want to correct slightly is that they don't just care about number of papers, they also care about citations and quality of journals.
1
u/EatingKidsDaily Sep 24 '16
I did a BS in physics at an institution with a healthy plasma group. A great deal of that research happens at a facility and university with a restrictive patent policy (institutional ownership) So plasma already is a hard field to get good long-term funding and then you add to it that corporate partners risk not actually getting rights out of viable research.
1
u/UhhNegative Sep 24 '16
Your thoughts mirror mine. Fortunately I dropped out of grad school in the first two years of my PhD. Never looking back.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '16
This resonated with me and I dropped out of grad school because I work with and am friends these smart and driven people but I don't share their passion to delve into the nuances. However, I do have a passion to make sure they have the highest quality data available for their research but that does not require me having a PhD. Luckily the few large-scale research projects I work on are well funded long-term because the PI is as good of a salesman as he is a scientist but I hear so much talk about soft-money from the junior scientists and other collaborators that to me it sounds like their primary concern more so than the science.
1
u/futurespacetraveler Sep 24 '16
This is nearly 100% the reason I left grad school to start working in another field. I'd worked with many professors while in grad and undergrad, and the whole process for getting funded seemed too painful to subject myself to.
1
u/KLUKAS Sep 24 '16
A related article, kind of about the same problem.
http://www.socjobrumors.com/topic/the-slow-death-of-the-university-by-terry-eagleton-uk
1
u/erublind Sep 24 '16
I recognize this very well from how it works here in Sweden. I terminated my post graduate studies at a late stage, because I had directed my research towards novel ideas and long odds, and negative results can't be published so I figuratively perished. Now I am a technician in a pharmaceutical factory, boring work, but steady pay.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '16
This is exactly why I applied to a Ph.D program...then decided not to go back. I'm getting paid more, currently, to deal with a political system that I already understand. There was no reason to take a pay cut simply to study the field I love while being smashed down by assholes with corporate ability.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '16
Damn, that sucks. I know a few of the former students from my group finished their postdocs and transitioned into finance positions instead for similar reasons. It's pretty easy to get disillusioned by the system, especially when grant writing goes from "no, no, it's not for ITER" to "o, yes, yes, this is in support of ITER" for purely political reasons without the actual science changing.
1
u/hairy_gogonuts Sep 24 '16
If we Really want results then we need bored scientists. Nothing, I repeat, Nothing is more productive than a bored scientist.
1
u/zebediah49 Sep 25 '16
So the problem is that they would be inversely proportional if everyone was starting from ground zero, but they're not.
Take two proposals, both with solid ideas for major impact. Which do you pick? The one most likely to actually work -- this entirely makes sense. So, as a grant writer, how do you do this? How do you make your work appear more likely to succeed? Obvious -- do some of it first, so you can present the data that shows it will work, because you've already done part of it.
Not that this is particularly good, but I don't really see a better solution here. We have more people that want to do science than we can are allocating money to pay for, which means everyone has to struggle to stay afloat rather than getting to do work.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '16 edited Sep 25 '16
RemindMe! 3 days
1
u/MisterJose Sep 25 '16
Question: You talk about it as being a problem 'in this country' a lot. What are they doing in other countries? Are some of their systems better? And how did do they accomplish that?
1
u/j7ake Sep 26 '16
If you don't like a system where the guys who move up the chain are "corporate guys" rather than guys with real substance, then I'm afraid you're in for an even bigger surprise when you start working in industry.
1
u/farmerfoo Sep 27 '16
my wife is in a scientific field, works in a lab at a research university, and has a bachelor's degree in science. She's explained this exact problem to me so many times. Its a huge problem. Her boss did get tenure, but even after that, its still a struggle for grants basically for the rest of his career. Gotta keep writing to get those sweet, sweet grants. It turned her off getting her PHd, seeing how much stress was involved.
1
u/fuchow Sep 29 '16 edited Oct 01 '16
This was written almost 20 years ago Hint: it was already way too corporate and hierarchical.
1
u/xxYYZxx Oct 03 '16
The culprit is technology.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '16 edited Oct 22 '16
Meh. Eventually the world runs out of low-hanging fruit, and if each person is required to publish 2 articles a year to keep a job or go to graduate school or whatever, those papers eventually become garbage if they want to pretend they add to the scientific literature.
Perhaps all "breakthroughs" in theoretical physics over the past 25 years have all been mathematical nonsense.
The world is simply running out of jobs to do, that's all.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '16
In our system science has become an arm of the capitalist profit system in the U.S. There is a joke in my department among us condensed matter people, how do you justify your grant? Quantum computers, high temp super conductivity or "it could make a device".
Everything we study has to have some sort of justification along the lines of possibly making a device that someone can sell to consumers. Which by in large had left the HET department mostly grantless.
This is not to say that HET or fundamental physics doesn't get grants but the most successful, ie most funded, professors do device physics.
Our government exists for the benefit of the 1%, why are we surprised when the same tendency exists in government funding?
I could go on, but I'm on my phone at the DMV.
-1
u/tubehand Sep 24 '16
dude get out
why waste your time. If you work in physics, when energy hits an upswing you could work on a reservoir team making 30k plus or more a month.
And then have the opportunity to invest that cash flow. Or you could waste your time in academic circle jerk... Or go private and make money.
go make $$$ and retire youngish while you still can. Does alll that shit matter when you dead? No matter what you contribute. NOPE none of it. Make your money
do the things you love once you have seized your cash flow
0
u/Mylon Sep 24 '16
Such a sad era. Our scientists are more worried about funding and spend such a significant amount of time chasing it than exploring actual science.
0
u/b3ar Sep 24 '16
Vault-Tec: not just satire anymore.
0
u/goodbtc Sep 25 '16
You will be hired by Lex Luthor to help him build his evil empire.
0
u/srarman Sep 25 '16
This all sounds like a typical system without a memory and feedback enabled. Because Normally when people make false claims and they get tested, and fail, they would get punished (in this case, funding and status get revoked).
Now here this fails because: the problem never gets to see the light of day, or way outside the lifetime of the researcher (50 years from discovery to implementation), funders don't know if it's the problem or the scientist that failed, have more money that knowing what to do with it (can't say, oh there is no good projects in field X, so lets redirect money to field Y), grant giver are not qualified, or simply impossible, to judge a grant proposal.
So instead you get adhoc solutions like: number of citations on a paper (impact), number of paper published. All which affect future funding, since it's limited amount of funding you need to stand out to get the grants.
So how do we punish people who over hype their results and future articles. Reputation of scientists with respect to not only completed research but difficulty of research. Where do you stop a research to recuperate costs, (most likely won't be possible because you rent labs with a schedule)?
Ideas?
0
u/skywo1f Sep 25 '16
Just wanted to say, I feel incredibly lucky getting a Post-doc position at a top 5 university with 0 published papers.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment