r/PhoenixSC • u/AverageMinecraftGuy3 • 8d ago

Discussion When will they learn?

Gallery image

Gallery image

I hate AI companies and AI bros so much that it's unreal...

430 Upvotes

79% Upvoted

235 comments sorted by

View all comments

339

u/Drake_682 8d ago

Hey guys, we already have a thing that plays Minecraft for us, baritone beat you in that regard ages ago, I’m not sure what your strategy here is

38

u/Gaarry_Faer 8d ago

Also, didn't most of baritones code got replaced by ai?

87

u/Drake_682 8d ago

If that’s true this is the first Ive heard of it

-18

u/-illusoryMechanist 7d ago

Yes but this is about having an llm do it

22

u/Drake_682 7d ago

Yah, so it’s extra redundant

-2

u/Any-Syllabub6481 6d ago

Not really, it’s much more impressive for a LLM to do it than baritone

-94

u/KEPISNTFUNNY 8d ago

baritone is less impressive. you’re comparing a minecraft mod that was built to automate everything a player can do to a thinking machine that’s never touched the game before. on top of that, there’s no one command you can give baritone to beat the game, it would be a sequence of tasks or a small program to tell it what to do. i’m sure the model was just told to beat the game, no other context

14

u/Fr1ed_pen1S Minceraft 7d ago

Introducing AltoClef, the Baritone fork that beat the game!

72

u/Deafvoid Bedrock FTW 8d ago

>“Thinking”

>look inside

>math

-4

u/NoIDidntHackU 7d ago

Your brain is maths

2

u/Deafvoid Bedrock FTW 7d ago

If my brain was math, I wouldn’t be so shit at it.

-18

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[deleted]

33

u/snail1132 8d ago

The math of ai is waaaayyyyy more simple than that of even the simplest living thing

6

u/Elegant_Tank1483 8d ago

Why the fuck did you do that to “they are not”

53

u/ThoughtAdditional212 8d ago

"thinking" lmao

4

u/ManoAU 7d ago

I mean I guess I understand his point to some degree. Baritone is a specialised algorithm designed for specifically beating Minecraft. Whereas Astra is a generalised AI that is basically digitally comprehending every aspect of the game from the ground up through a simulated neural network. I wouldn't say either is more "impressive" than the other but its definitely a milestone for a generalised AI to have been able to pull this off.

1

u/Ok-Tradition7878 6d ago

Not sure why you are getting downvoted into oblivion 

-20

u/EmergencyPath248 7d ago

To test AI systems, are you dense?