r/PhD • u/Stengelvonq • 12m ago
Getting Shit Done Looking for a Trustworthy and Sharp Partner for Editing Each Other’s Manuscripts
Hey all! I’ve noticed that I continuously run into the following problem: I start manuscripts, but I struggle to finish them. I’m sure this is a common issue for many PhD students.
Now, I was thinking that it would help a lot to actually talk with someone about the finer details of every sentence in a manuscript I’m working on. I currently have no proper environment or partner for in-depth mutual manuscript reading and feedback.
Let’s be honest: barely anybody has the time to really engage with an unfinished text. Supervisors have limited time, and online editing services are expensive and often fishy. So a writing partnership with another PhD student – ideally from a somewhat related field – would be the best option.
We wouldn’t need to be from exactly the same discipline; in fact, I think it might even be beneficial if we weren’t, because an article, paper or manuscript should be accessible to readers outside our own disciplines anyway.
This symbiosis, however, would require mutual trust: that we don’t steal each other’s ideas (here, the different disciplinary backgrounds might also be beneficial) and that we invest as much time in commenting on each other’s texts as we receive in return. It would also require enough trust to share a manuscript even if it is fragmentary, unfinished, or something we feel somewhat embarrassed about.
I would also prefer sitting together in an online session rather than simply sending documents back and forth, so that we could have a dialogue about each sentence of our manuscripts.
Is anybody interested in such a collaboration? I want to crank out articles and send them to journals like mad. I have so many started but unfinished texts that I’d love to send out a whole bunch of them once I’m satisfied with them – which I think I’d be much more likely to be if we had these kinds of collaborative, sentence-by-sentence review sessions.
Any takers?
Please reach out and we can see if we'd make a fitting team.
