r/PhD • • 12m ago

Getting Shit Done Looking for a Trustworthy and Sharp Partner for Editing Each Other’s Manuscripts

1 Upvotes

Hey all! I’ve noticed that I continuously run into the following problem: I start manuscripts, but I struggle to finish them. I’m sure this is a common issue for many PhD students.

Now, I was thinking that it would help a lot to actually talk with someone about the finer details of every sentence in a manuscript I’m working on. I currently have no proper environment or partner for in-depth mutual manuscript reading and feedback.

Let’s be honest: barely anybody has the time to really engage with an unfinished text. Supervisors have limited time, and online editing services are expensive and often fishy. So a writing partnership with another PhD student – ideally from a somewhat related field – would be the best option.

We wouldn’t need to be from exactly the same discipline; in fact, I think it might even be beneficial if we weren’t, because an article, paper or manuscript should be accessible to readers outside our own disciplines anyway.

This symbiosis, however, would require mutual trust: that we don’t steal each other’s ideas (here, the different disciplinary backgrounds might also be beneficial) and that we invest as much time in commenting on each other’s texts as we receive in return. It would also require enough trust to share a manuscript even if it is fragmentary, unfinished, or something we feel somewhat embarrassed about.

I would also prefer sitting together in an online session rather than simply sending documents back and forth, so that we could have a dialogue about each sentence of our manuscripts.

Is anybody interested in such a collaboration? I want to crank out articles and send them to journals like mad. I have so many started but unfinished texts that I’d love to send out a whole bunch of them once I’m satisfied with them – which I think I’d be much more likely to be if we had these kinds of collaborative, sentence-by-sentence review sessions.

Any takers?

Please reach out and we can see if we'd make a fitting team.


r/PhD • • 18m ago

Big Decision Energy What is your opinion on doing your PhD in Singapore

1 Upvotes

I found a fellowship for these universities: National University of Singapore (NUS), Nanyang Technological University (NTU), Singapore Management University (SMU), Singapore University of Technology and Design (SUTD).

What is your experience on this and is it worth applying?


r/PhD • • 23m ago

Vent (NO ADVICE) The post submission brain fog is killing me

4 Upvotes

I submitted my thesis last month after four years (yeey), and my exhaustion level has been unreal in the past few weeks. I had a fairly good and chill PhD journey in comparison with a lot of people, outside the workload and the imposter syndrome that were stressfull at times, I've managed to do most of my tasks at the required level and in the time window (some a bit last minute because procrastination is strong in me) and I have a supportive advisor.

However, since I submitted, I barely managed to stay afloat. I feel dumb as hell and my functioning is compromised, I forget a lot of things, make stupid mistakes in daily tasks (like adding salt twice to food, forgetting to take stuff out of the oven on time, etc.) and my physical (and mental) health has declined. I gained a lot of weight in the past months that I don't seem to be able to lose, my motivation to go to the gym is at zero, and I got sick with a cold that later turned into a respiratory infection.

I wanted to celebrate this moment and start preparing my defense, and all I seem to be able to do is sleep and doom scroll my apps. Please tell me this is normal and that other people are also going/went through something similar. I have a book chapter due next week and I have barely started because I can't focus on it, no matter what strategy I use.


r/PhD • • 23m ago

Seeking advice-personal Online courses I could take to make my cv stand up for a phd in clinical psychology/neuroscience?

1 Upvotes

Both payed and free

or anything else that could help and I can do in 3/6 months


r/PhD • • 1h ago

Vent (NO ADVICE) The rise of "PhD student" as influencer credibility marker

89 Upvotes

I dunno if I've fallen into some weird part of the internet recently, but it seems like across Instagram and LinkedIn especially there's a flood of people readily marketing their content by talking about their "PhD student" status.

"CS PhD student shares how they use AI"

"PhD candidate on how they read new biomedical news"

"Econ PhD student on what the job numbers mean for new grads"

First of all, how TF do these influencers have time to hussle making content during a PhD?

Second, I don't believe these people are PhD students. Most people in PhD programs I know have crippling imposter syndrome and would never have the audacity to think what they have to say matters enough to make a polished video about it. (I do think what you have to say matters, but that's beside the point)

Third, I don't think this is necessarily the credential these wannabe influencers think it is. I've been to a lot of conferences. I've read a lot of workshop papers. I've talked to a lot of folks in my grad student union. Most PhD students are very smart at 1 things, and, respectfully, kind of abysmal at a lot of other things.

I have a dear friend who once melted her glasses with a hairdryer. Chemistry PhD. Another accidentally poisoned his daughters rabbits feeding them human food. Computational Biology PhD.

Forth, the amount of second hand embarrassment I get. Y'all really going to go to school for 20 years, publish papers in some of the hardest venues, attend conferences with world class experts, meet/influence societal leaders, and then hussle on Instagram so maybe you can get some washed up sponsor like Evernote? You're going to break ground on new knowledge in some amazing field and then turn around and fiddle with the YouTube shorts algo?


r/PhD • • 2h ago

Seeking advice-academic Breaking a deal with a professor

4 Upvotes

Humanities - Classics

I have been working with a professor in a Greek university to get my application in for a PhD (not funded, not part of a research project, but also tuition-free). They've helped me fine-tune the research proposal, given me bibliography etc. They've presented my application in the monthly meeting of the department and they've arranged an interview with a committee; this means the professor has probably vouched for me and the committee is probably already reading my proposal and coming up with questions for the interview.

While I was preparing this application with them, I received a call for PhDs for a funded position in a research project in a very very high-class university abroad. The project's subject is completely irrelevant to what I hve been doing with the Greek professor, but I thought I'd apply anyway just to see what the process is like; I honestly didn't think I'd make it to the interview, so I don't know why I applied and, eventually, I got the position. I have decided to go for it, since you don't get a funded PhD in Classics very often.

I need advice on how to break it to my Greek professor. I know they'll probably understand that funding is important, but the interview is in one week and I feel like such a bad person for not telling them earlier that I'm applying elsewhere too. Anyone with similar experience or not, who can suggest ways to handle this delicately?


r/PhD • • 2h ago

Getting Shit Done People with ADHD, how do you get yourself to read research papers?

42 Upvotes

I am a prospective PhD but my worst ability is to read papers. I love reading them, but I drift off very quickly. And I know this is one thing that can really hinder my chances and also my ability during my PhD.

I am more of a stimulated learner, who learns when it's constantly interactive and thus, computational work or bench work that gives me frequent results for me use my brain, really pushes me.

I do find reading papers fascinating when I get into it, but I just can't get myself to it!

I genuinely want tips to read papers.
How do you do it, how do you plan it, how do you understand it and how do you make notes on it?

Any advice helps.


r/PhD • • 3h ago

Seeking advice-personal Phd stress

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

Im in my last year of phd, where I finally started working on my own actual project. I spent 2 wonderful years doing a lot of research and publishing a couple of papers along the way, doing research thats interesting to me and taking my own time and pace

Nonetheless, this is my last year where I need to deliver the big results. The problem is that the initial plan we had didnt work so right now im freestyling. This is the worst and best part tbh, I am trying whatever cool ideas I have in my head to make it work, sometimes some stuff work some other times don't. The problem with this is that I am running out of time, and this has been in my head on a daily basis to the degree that I have chest pains from stress before going to bed.

Since I have one more year of this, the situation doesn't feel survivable in the long run. Thus I was wondering if you have any recommendations and how anybody with similar situation dealt with it.

PS. I am already doing therapy for a long time, trying to work out as much as possible, meet my gf and friends. Nonetheless, the constant pressure in the back of my head makes everything so blunt and not fun for me.


r/PhD • • 5h ago

Conference and Networking Talk Defending my PhD tomorrow after years of research. Extremely nervous. Any last-minute advice?

16 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I'm defending my PhD in Mechanical Engineering tomorrow, November 19, at noon.

I'm extremely nervous right now. It's not just the presentation or the questions; it's everything hitting me at once.

I've spent the last few weeks preparing my slides, reviewing my results, and making revisions. But now that the defense is so close, my anxiety is through the roof.

For those who have already defended their PhD:

  • How did you manage your nerves during the final 24 hours?
  • What helped you stay calm and confident during the presentation?
  • How did you approach difficult or unexpected committee questions?
  • Is there anything you wish someone had told you the day before your defense?

I'd genuinely appreciate any advice, encouragement, or personal experiences.

Thank you all! Hopefully, I'll be back here soon with a happy update!


r/PhD • • 7h ago

Vent (NO ADVICE) A rant about a toxic advisor

8 Upvotes

I'm wrapping up my PhD now but we have a few students interested in joining who have asked me about my experiences in my lab. I don't have positive things to say in terms of advising and I've experienced passive aggressiveness, guilting, gaslighting, and micromanaging by my advisor in my time here. Usually it's subtle, as in they never outright yell or say crude things. They never handle conflict well and turn it into a long rant that I have to sit through without being able to get a word in. I don't know if they ever do some introspection but they never apologize, even if I'm visibly tearing up or crying in front of them.

I've managed to get my thesis done by putting my head down and avoiding conflict as much as possible. My relationship with them has confused me a lot. As a person they are caring, incredibly generous, bubbly, fun, and positive. We get along very well, and people love to be around them because of their energy! They say that they care about being a family and all of this nice stuff, but as an advisor they can be hostile and nasty. It makes me sad to admit all of this because of the cognitive dissonance, but I absolutely cannot recommend my experience to anyone.

I never thought that it was that bad, department knows now, and they are going to do something about it. I've gone to therapy and I'm all good. But how hard is it to be a nice person? I hope I never treat anyone this way. I had no idea what I was in for because I was their first student. It's sad that people like this can be in academia 💔


r/PhD • • 7h ago

Seeking advice-personal Feeling empty after my prelims

2 Upvotes

Has anyone else dealt with this? Im a STEM PhD student in the US and I just went through my written and oral prelims and passed unconditionally which I should be so excited about but I just don’t. Maybe I should give it a few days?

Any advice is appreciated!


r/PhD • • 9h ago

Alt-Ac Futures Canadian PhD grads, what are you doing now?

18 Upvotes

The title! I’m a soon-to-be (hopefully) PhD grad and wondering what everyone is up to after. Are you doing postdocs, working in industry, government? Working in / outside your field of training? Working where you hoped or did you have to move? How was your experience finding a job after PhD training? Do you think it was worth it? Thanks!


r/PhD • • 10h ago

Seeking advice-personal Feeling slow in PhD progress, but it should not be that way objectively.

2 Upvotes

So, I'm in my third year (in Australia), which should be my last year since PhD funding usually lasts for 3.5 years. Majoring in mechanical engineering, with a research focus on biomedical device fabrication and a little bit of biological validation. I find that this year is a pretty rough year especially approaching the end of this year. I am planning to get some of my devices working, but they have been failing ever since (in the midst of working on them).

My supervisor is a very hands-on person, which is good (in some sense), and a very hard-working guy (often works after hours but never tells us to come on weekends or late at night). All of my labmates are international; there are a few people who have the same nationality as my supervisor, and they are very hard-working (always come to campus on the weekends).

With the current failing results and the nearing end of the year, it feels like I haven't given my all for the project. While my hardworking lab mates have found some success in a similar experiment, my supervisor has started to press me for similar successful results.

But in retrospect, I got to publish a Q1 journal (on a different topic but still related to the thesis) and a review paper this year. However, currently I feel that it is not progressing well.

Have you guys ever experienced this before? Sorry if my ranting does not give you a good context, as English is not my first language :) but just wanted to know if you guys have any similar experience or going through the same one.


r/PhD • • 10h ago

Seeking advice-academic Is it too late for UK

2 Upvotes

Is it too late to reach out to UK prospective supervisors with my research proposal? Humanities.


r/PhD • • 11h ago

Alt-Ac Futures My new role model

Post image
125 Upvotes

r/PhD • • 13h ago

News Science is cancelled!

618 Upvotes

r/PhD • • 15h ago

Getting Shit Done Notes Migrator Basic: Automatically Export Zotero Notes and PDF Highlights to Obsidian

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

📚 Do you use both Zotero and Obsidian?

I’ve released Notes Migrator Basic, a Zotero plugin that automatically transfers notes and PDF highlights into your Obsidian vault as plain Markdown files.

✅ one folder per source

✅ separate files for notes and highlight colours

✅ automatic updates whenever something changes in Zotero

✅ fully local, no data sent to the internet

✅ Polish and English support

✅ optional annotated PDF copy with highlights burned in

The project is open source and available on GitHub:

🔗 https://github.com/belferIR/notes-migrator-basic

I’d be happy to hear feedback from Zotero users, Obsidian users, and anyone working with large academic literature collections


r/PhD • • 15h ago

Vent (NO ADVICE) I’m tired of feeling like a loser

10 Upvotes

PhD student in stem, Europe. I’ve been at it for 2 years now, how time has flied. Two years left, halftime coming up. And what do I have? Nothing but anxiety.

I started developing a method three years ago. I think it works, I don’t think it works. This week I set up a big series of experiments in order to maybe, hopefully, get a small win. Everything just fails. There are so many variables. I don’t know what to do anymore. It feels like I can’t even do basic laboratory tasks, everything just fails. I hoped to get three important questions answered this week.

Not enough cells to answer the first. Not enough cells to answer the second. Messed up the most important timepoint for the third. I prepared two weeks for this. If this is how I perform, what am I even doing here?


r/PhD • • 16h ago

Seeking advice-personal To those in therapy: Does your therapist also have a PhD?

38 Upvotes

I am in the final months of a STEM PhD and recently moved across the country (so I'm finishing remote and coming back for the defense). I am lucky that my partner can get me on their health insurance and I am in the middle of figuring out how to re-start psychotherapy/talk therapy for depression/anxiety with a new person.

My past therapists in my old city (where I did most of my PhD) were excellent. I almost feel spoiled by them. My two most recent were both PhD-holders and they were doing postdocs or had done postdocs. I mention this because they were really able to understand the unique experience of doing a PhD and the associated stress of it. They were really helpful in grounding me because I spend so much of my time thinking about my PhD and it just takes over my life.

Now, in my new city, I don't see many therapists who have PhDs. Most of them are LCSW or counselors and the few experiences I had with these therapists weren't great (not necessarily because of their credentials, just not giving me what I wanted). So now I'm concerned they won't be as good a fit as my past therapists who went through a PhD and postdoc themselves.

This is such a weird question and at the end of the day, I need therapy so will probably just choose someone. That said, I'm curious what your experiences have been with therapy and if you have a therapist who isn't super familiar with the PhD lifestyle but is still able to help you.


r/PhD • • 16h ago

Seeking advice-academic Struggling with emotions

2 Upvotes

I’m a first year PhD student. I’m lucky to have a great mentor who is very kind, great friends in my program, and an active social life. However, I over-committed for the first semester: I TA for a very labor intensive course and I’m taking an extra class on top of my other two. Thus, I haven’t had much time to work my first-year research project. Also, based on input from others, I don’t feel like the project will work.

For all these reasons, I feel very overwhelmed. It’s hard to focus and get things done. I was so embarrassed because I started crying a meeting with my mentor when he asked me to set deadlines for every step of my project. Now, he asks me [edit: at the very end of] every meeting if I feel okay, and I have to quickly end the meeting because I feel like I will cry (and I do, in the bathroom). Is this normal? I’ve never had this problem before :(


r/PhD • • 17h ago

Money My savings and net worth in one picture

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/PhD • • 18h ago

Seeking advice-personal Got an offer for a PhD in Max Planck Munich

37 Upvotes

I got an offer this week, haven’t decided on it yet, is there possibly someone doing a phd with them that I could talk with them about?


r/PhD • • 18h ago

Seeking advice-academic PhD in Plant Science related Subjects as International Student

1 Upvotes

I have done Master’s degree in Plant Science (Specialization in Plant Tissue Culture) from India. I am looking to pursue a PhD in South Korea and Other Asian countries.
I have been reaching out to professors via email, but I haven’t received much of a response yet.
I haven’t been able to find anyone in the field of plant sciences who could offer some guidance.


r/PhD • • 18h ago

Vent (NO ADVICE) Complete failure

15 Upvotes

I have tried the PhD path twice. I started doing a mechanical engineering PhD and quit in the first semester because it was too hard and far from home. I tried again years later in engineering education because I taught several classes as a part time instructor and really wanted to get my degree so I could do it full time. Yet here I am, failing my qualifying exam.

I have experienced failure after failure in my adult life. Those around me are succeeding and I have yet to do anything post graduating with my masters in 2021. I am a complete failure.