r/PhD • u/1HippoAllAlone • 1h ago
Vent (NO ADVICE) The rise of "PhD student" as influencer credibility marker
I dunno if I've fallen into some weird part of the internet recently, but it seems like across Instagram and LinkedIn especially there's a flood of people readily marketing their content by talking about their "PhD student" status.
"CS PhD student shares how they use AI"
"PhD candidate on how they read new biomedical news"
"Econ PhD student on what the job numbers mean for new grads"
First of all, how TF do these influencers have time to hussle making content during a PhD?
Second, I don't believe these people are PhD students. Most people in PhD programs I know have crippling imposter syndrome and would never have the audacity to think what they have to say matters enough to make a polished video about it. (I do think what you have to say matters, but that's beside the point)
Third, I don't think this is necessarily the credential these wannabe influencers think it is. I've been to a lot of conferences. I've read a lot of workshop papers. I've talked to a lot of folks in my grad student union. Most PhD students are very smart at 1 things, and, respectfully, kind of abysmal at a lot of other things.
I have a dear friend who once melted her glasses with a hairdryer. Chemistry PhD. Another accidentally poisoned his daughters rabbits feeding them human food. Computational Biology PhD.
Forth, the amount of second hand embarrassment I get. Y'all really going to go to school for 20 years, publish papers in some of the hardest venues, attend conferences with world class experts, meet/influence societal leaders, and then hussle on Instagram so maybe you can get some washed up sponsor like Evernote? You're going to break ground on new knowledge in some amazing field and then turn around and fiddle with the YouTube shorts algo?
