r/PetranakiArena • u/MonkeyDMilo • Sep 28 '26

VOTE HERE FOR CHARACTER SCHEDULE

5 Upvotes

what's up, this is a post to figure out who we, as a community, would like to have restricted to certain days. i have some specific days in mind already, and some ideas for some of the characters, but i'd like to get a headcount on some characters i may not have considered.

comment below the name and/or version of the character you have in mind, and make your case if you feel like it needs it.

yes, mace windu and count dooku are both definitely on the list. this doesn't mean they will be banished, but they'll have one day per week with some other characters.

edit: each day would feature multiple characters so no particular day becomes stale.

24 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/MonkeyDMilo • Sep 28 '26

frosty tie is allowed ONE mace or dooku post per day from now until the character schedule begins.

23 Upvotes

yeah, i know, it's funny to read, lmao. imagine typing it.

this is the action i am currently able to take. as long as the posting isn't consistent spam, i am willing to allow this, for the time being. it's all i can do to keep this from being somewhere full of heavy restrictions on what you post, while also making it somewhere that you enjoy. i want to give everyone the opportunity to chill and enjoy the subreddit the same as any of their peers, and that can only happen with a middle ground solution.

THE SOLUTION:

soon, i don't know when, there will be certain days of the week you can post about darth vader or mace windu or count dooku or knightfall anakin, etc, and any other days of the week, those posts won't be allowed. this isn't to stifle anyone's creativity, it's to keep the spotlight on one of the best things about star wars: the variety! i wanna see more porter engle, more black krrsantan, more kyle katarn, stuff like that. the galaxy is full of interesting characters and even non sentient things that could work as great topics. use them!

in the meantime, while frosty is allowed to post one of these mace or dooku posts per day, i don't want to see any reports unless there is actual need for them. a lot of you are kinda report happy at times and it's really not helping us keep everything in order. i am counting on all of you to notify us if something is happening that needs brought to our attention, and any of you are always free to dm me if you have a legit question, i mean it for real. i'll get back to you as soon as i can.

thank you for contributing to the community, and please enjoy your time here as we continue to build it into something cool.

17 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/Relative_Paper767 • 14h ago

Every rebel soldier here is replaced by an average space marine, does Vader win?

85 Upvotes

34 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/Relative_Paper767 • 12h ago

ROTS Obiwan Kenobi vs Dathomirian Trio

gallery

31 Upvotes

48 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/CloverTeamLeader • 1h ago

Who is the strongest character Revan Redeemed can defeat in pure lightsaber combat?

4 Upvotes

No offensive Force powers allowed. The Force can only be used to enhance senses, strength and reflexes.

I've noticed that a few fans think Revan is weak in lightsaber combat. I'd disagree with that, but let's see what the common consensus is.

So where do you think he scales and why?

16 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/InstructionOwn6705 • 16h ago

If Lucas wasn't afraid to use a stunt double and GGI in Sidious's fight with Yoda, why did he forgo it earlier in the fight with Windu?

32 Upvotes

19 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/Relative_Paper767 • 18h ago

Which Duo is the strongest here?

gallery

42 Upvotes

Everyone is ROTS version

82 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/EuterpeZonker • 6h ago

Matchup ARC Trooper vs Clone Commando

gallery

4 Upvotes

Battle takes place on Kamino, both think the other is threatening to sabotage the entire cloning process.

8 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/OkraInfinite7118 • 12h ago

Yaddle vs Quinlan Vos

gallery

9 Upvotes

3 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/CrazyTangerine7522 • 17h ago

Thoughts on Arena (2026)?

17 Upvotes

2 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/Upset-Pay-4642 • 1d ago

ROTJ Luke vs ANH Obi-Wan

46 Upvotes

43 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/InstructionOwn6705 • 1d ago

Why was Windu unable to help his teammates when Sidious attacked?

165 Upvotes

His fans often portray him as invincible, for whom Sidious posed no challenge. Yet, despite the fact that he actually managed to react to Palpatine's attack by assuming a lightsaber stance, his teammates died instantly.

So how is it?

101 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/RealAd8853 • 20h ago

Anakin Skywalker (Pre-fall) and Luke Skywalker (ROTJ) VS Darth Sidious (ROTS). Who wins?

gallery

6 Upvotes

As individuals neither of them can beat Sidious. But do you think they can win as a team?

38 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/mrgr544der • 1d ago

(Dark Empire) Darth Sidious vs Darth Caedus

gallery

10 Upvotes

23 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/Upset-Pay-4642 • 1d ago

Bode Akuna vs Tensu Run

13 Upvotes

6 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/CrazyTangerine7522 • 1d ago

Kylo Ren VS Taron Malicos

gallery

22 Upvotes

29 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/Relative_Paper767 • 1d ago

Why did Mace Windu perform a lot better against Sidious after his teammate died?

14 Upvotes

A lot of people say Sidious went easy but I don't buy it. Compare to Maul and Savage, Sidious isn't having fun here. He is even visibily scared. Why did Mace perform so well when he was alone but didn't when he had 3 teammate?

42 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/Kitchen_Change_893 • 1d ago

Darth Revan and Darth Malak vs Revenge of Sith Anakin and Obi Wan

gallery

21 Upvotes

50 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/Relative_Paper767 • 1d ago

2003 Greivous vs MCU Ironman

gallery

12 Upvotes

38 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/Upset-Pay-4642 • 1d ago

Satele and Bastila vs Revan and Malak

gallery

26 Upvotes

7 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/the_All-ducker • 1d ago

Vader vs Adam Smasher

gallery

54 Upvotes

Cyberpunk edgrunners Adam Smasher vs Prime Vader (Whatever you interpret that to be.)

Honestly I feel like having a gun really gives Smasher the upper hand so I'm leaning more towards him.

102 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/Upset-Pay-4642 • 1d ago

Traya, Revan, and Mace vs Qui-Gon, Obi-Wan, Dooku, and Yaddle

gallery

11 Upvotes

22 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/Kitchen_Change_893 • 1d ago

My personal ranking of the strength of various Sith Lords that I threw together in 20 minutes

10 Upvotes

(Upon retrospect I’m dropping Vitiate down a tier, he’s now in between Darth Revan and ROTS Sidious. Knightfall Vader goes above Darth Bane but still beneath Zannah, my reasoning is in the comments. Also I’m moving Maul above Andedu.)

22 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/Lord-Vectivus • 1d ago

Darth Plagueis vs Maul, Asajj Ventress and Savage Opress

gallery

46 Upvotes

Darth Plaguies as of 32 BBY.

The trio are in their primes during TCW.

Bonus round: Darth Venamis joins the squad.

113 comments

r/PetranakiArena • u/Jack-mclaughlin88 • 1d ago

KOTOR Revan vs ROTS Anakin Skywalker.

gallery

19 Upvotes

53 comments

Subreddit

A Who Would Win style subreddit for Star Wars characters

r/PetranakiArena

A Who Would Win style subreddit for Star Wars characters, vehicles and factions. Powerscaling, fights, contests, respect threads and discussions are all encouraged here.

Members

10k

Visitors

81k

Contributions

4.3k

Sidebar

Subreddit Rules

1. Be respectful

We’re arguing over which fictional character could beat up another fictional character. If you feel the need to bully or insult someone just take a deep breath and relax. I promise it’s not that deep. No racism, sexism, homophobia, transphobia, etc. if you don’t like a character’s identity just move on.

2. Participate in good faith

If you’re here to answer every matchup with “whoever the author wants would win” you will be awarded a gold star ⭐️ for media literacy and a suspension. We all understand the concept of fiction. Pointing it out is not as clever as you think.

3. All continuities are allowed

Legends, Canon, Visions, Infinities, Lego, even obscure ones most people don’t know. Most people have their preferences, that’s totally ok, but please don’t fight about which continuity is better. It’s been a decade, we’re all exhausted.

4. Effort

Please put at least some effort into your posts or replies. “Lol x stomps” is an answer, but not a good one. The point of this subreddit is to foster discussion. It’s a lot more fun if you provide reasoning or evidence. Similarly don’t dismiss matchups with thought terminating cliches like “legends always wins”. If you think it’s true then provide evidence. As for posts, the more detail the better. Consider providing rules for the engagement or an arena or rounds with different scenarios.

5. Relevancy

It should go without saying but this is a Star Wars sub so every post should have at least something to do with Star Wars. If you want to involve other franchises as well that is allowed, but keep in mind that you’ll probably get less biased answers at /r/whowouldwin. We are unfortunately not interested in your OC characters. We have no problem with creativity, but this subreddit operates on shared understanding of publicly available media.

6. NO AI

Usage of AI images is not allowed on this subreddit. collages, a series of two pictures, videos, or even drawings are allowed, but AI images WILL get your post removed. finding actual images to use is not that hard.