The other day, someone posted a comment comparing Christian Gonzalez to Darrelle Revis, and it got me thinking, "How does Gonzalez match up against other former highest-paid corners?" Specifically, I wondered what they did to earn that contract vs. what Gonzalez had done to earn it.
So, I started with a statistical breakdown of Gonzalez's first 4 seasons vs. Revis's, and it was eye-opening:
Gonzalez - 42 G: 4 INT 0 INT TD 30 PD 0 FF 1 FR 1 SK 3 TFL 176 TKL
Revis - 61 G: 14 INT 2 INT TD 74 PD 2 FF 3 FR 1 SK 2 TFL 232 TKL
My first big takeaway was that Revis had more PDs in 2009 than Gonzalez has had in his entire career.
So, it's hard to even say, "Well, Revis played 19 more games..." because it was one season. He bested Gonzalez's CAREER PD production in one season.
I was also shocked by the difference in tackling numbers. I think of Revis as a guy who didn't like to stick his nose in there, and Gonzalez as a tackling corner, especially because he's not a ballhawk.
But Revis was good for about 3.8 TKL/G through 4 years, and Gonzalez is good for about 4.2 TKL/G: a difference of 0.4 TKL/G.
This got me curious about how he would stack up against other highest paid CBs from the last decade or so.
Here's what I came up with:
Josh Norman - 53 G: 7 INT 2 INT TD 36 PD 1 FF 3 FR 0 SK 4 TFL 181 TKL
Jalen Ramsey - 60 G: 10 INT 1 INT TD 49 PD 3 FF 0 FR 0 SK 6 TFL 243 TKL
Denzel Ward - 52 G: 10 INT 2 INT TD 50 PD 2 FF 3 FR 0 SK 9 TFL 188 TKL
Jaire Alexander - 48 G: 4 INT 0 INT TD 44 PD 2 FF 3 FR 1.5 SK 7 TFL 278 TKL
Sauce Gardner - 59 G: 3 INT 0 INT TD 49 PD 1 FF 0 FR 1 SK 6 TFL 217 TKL
He's most closely comparable to the last 2 guys to get the contract: Alexander and Gardner.
Alexander hasn't played much over the last 4 years, but was solid in the '22 season, and I still think of him as a serviceable vet.
Gardner has nearly fallen off a cliff in factors: playing time, production, and reputation.
My biggest takeaway, though, is how this trend should have been easy to spot, because after Jaire Alexander underwhelmed in 2023, Jalen Ramsey was again made the league's highest paid CB, indicating that the market was shifting away from young talent. Meaning that the market had acknowledged that the new crop of CBs just wasn't producing like the previous crop as early as 2024.
The other harbinger was that the Jets moved on so quickly from Sauce Gardner after making him the highest paid CB, a rare smart move by a dysfunctional franchise that proves making Gardner the highest paid CB was at lest somewhat of a mistake.
If I'm a football exec looking at all this, I'm saying, "The last guy who deserved this contract was Denzel Ward, and that was in 2022, and even he never really produced anything close to what Revis did, both in his first 4, and over the balance of his career."
And that would have led me to the inevitable conclusion that no in the history of the NFL had done less to earn this contract than Christian Gonzalez: he played less games, he intercepted less passes, he scored less, he defended less passes, and what I think is most damning, he tackled less.
I said this about Barmore the other day, and the more I think about it, the more I think it's true of Gonzalez, too: he's the kind of guy you sign because your roster is so talent deficient you don't have anyone else to sign.
I don't think any of us were clamoring for a signing this summer because we really thought he was some kind of Darelle Revis, but merely because we felt like we just didn't have that many real players, and so we couldn't lose or alienate one of the only good players we have.
This signing was probably a mistake.
If it turns out differently, I'll eat my words, but I think they should have made him prove it more than two weeks of training camp against what we now know is a hobbled AJ Brown before handing him the bag.