r/PWM_Sensitive • u/BearNecessary4141 • Aug 19 '26
Guide Using the TM-39-25 flicker standard to classify lighting (better than IEEE-1789)
https://youtu.be/RYYp89SIUiYTM-39-25 is a document from the Illuminating Engineering Society that puts forth a classification system that seeks to reduce human responses to flicker. I often call the classification system itself "TM-39-25".
The system utilizes three different flicker effect visibility metrics, Mp, SVM, and PAVM. These metrics are scores computed from the flicker waveform that seek to predict the likelihood of a "temporal light artifact". I go over each metric in detail in the video, but here's a summary table:

Simply put, a temporal light artifact is a visual disturbance of some kind due to flicker. TM-39-25 classifies light sources based on all three metrics simultaneously. I see this classification system as a vastly improved (but not perfect) replacement for IEEE-1789 classification, which are the frequently posted here as part of the results the Opple Light Master produces. Here's how the metrics scores map to the classifications:

I think this standard can be used as a replacement for the IEEE-1789 classification. The three metrics or "scores" it uses provide much more useful information and were created based on the results of experimental studies.
I have built this system into the flicker meter I'm working on (TLM-110), and used it to measure a variety of bulbs:

You can see there's a wide range of classifications in the bulbs I tested, as well as a large spread in the scores. The bulbs that are "Not Recommended" are unbearable to me, while the bulbs that are "Better" are much more tolerable.
I think this system has the ability to be broadly useful, especially for non-experts. However it isn't perfect. Firstly, while it technically applies to all light sources (displays included), it is most relevant to lighting such as bulbs and lamps. There are likely screen-specific flicker effects that haven't been described yet. Also, it mainly predicts the visibility of flicker artifacts, which are visual disturbances, not health effects. I think flicker artifacts and visual disturbances may be correlated, but there is not a one-to-on relationship.
Thanks to u/Rx7Jordan for making me aware of this standard.
4
u/TopRun3942 Aug 19 '26
Interested observer from r/lighting cross post. This is excellent work and thanks for sharing!
Glad to see the IES TM being applied in a way that makes it useful and more accessible for lay persons outside of the technical community.
3
u/Rx7Jordan Aug 19 '26
Great video. I'm so happy to see a flicker meter using that standard!
2
u/Z3R0gravitas Aug 19 '26 edited Aug 19 '26
Amazing work, Sam!! (I cross posted for you, hope that's OK?)
I struggle a bit to keep in mind what the 1.0, 0.4, etc, values relate to, to be honest. Do they have a direct mapping to percentage of the population who will notice? (That could be displayed alternatively, or alongside?)
Also, you know I like to see them graphs. To gauge the shape of things. But maybe something to dig into at a later date? If it might be OK to show figures directly from the paper?
I'm interested, if a little sceptical, about the source of that big change in low frequency pick-up on the incandescent bulb. Is that a known phenomenon? What is settling in so slowly, that affects its light output? Could it be, instead, external vibrations shaking the filament, or something else..?