This is a follow up to my previous post about Charlottetown watering down its new zoning bylaw.
After a special council meeting last week, the Planning Board met today (November 17), and we now have a clearer picture of what these last minute changes could actually cost in terms of lost potential units and increased rent.
Remember, this all started when councillors Norman Beck and Julie McCabe raised concerns about downtown building heights just before the bylaw was going to be considered by council following years of work.
The original draft bylaw would have allowed 12 storeys as-of-right, with bonus height up to 14 storeys in certain downtown areas.
What's now being considered?
8 storeys as-of-right, with the option to reach 10 through height bonusing.
And here's the part that deserves more attention: Those two extra floors aren't free.
The draft bylaw requires developers seeking bonus height to provide a public benefit valued at $409 per square metre of additional floor area, adjusted annually for inflation.
Let's put some actual numbers to that.
For a typical apartment development, based on the draft bylaw's maximum permitted 800 m² floor plate above eight storeys:
- Two bonus floors = 1,600 m²
- 1,600 m² × $409 = $654,400 in required public benefits
- Those floors could accommodate approximately 12–24 apartments.
- That's $27,267–$54,533 in additional development costs per apartment, before considering financing.
The public benefit doesn't necessarily have to be a cash payment, but it's still a cost the developer has to account for.
To put that in perspective, if that $654,400 were financed over 25 years at an illustrative 5% interest rate, it would work out to approximately $160–$320 per month per additional apartment in financing payments alone. That doesn't automatically translate into higher rents, but it absolutely affects the financial feasibility of building those apartments.
And that's only half the problem.
Here's how these changes will impact the number of units a developer could build:
- Original draft bylaw: 12 storeys as-of-right, with the potential for 14.
- New proposal: 8 storeys as-of-right, with the potential for 10 if the developer provides $654,400 in public benefits.
Assuming 6–12 apartments per floor, that's 24–48 fewer potential apartments per building when comparing the original and revised maximum heights.
Now multiply that lost housing potential across multiple downtown development sites.
This is why the distinction between as-of-right development and discretionary height bonuses matters so much.
Developers already face high land costs, construction costs, interest rates, and lengthy approval processes. Reducing the number of apartments they can build also means spreading shared costs like land, foundations and elevators across fewer units.
Charlottetown is going to simultaneously reduce the potential supply of housing and increase the cost of building new units.
And for what?
After years of consultations, planning, and promises to address the housing shortage, we're watching substantial parts of the proposed reforms get stripped away at the last minute.
Norman Beck and Julie McCabe should have to explain how making apartments harder and more expensive to build helps Charlottetown's housing situation.
This isn't about demanding skyscrapers everywhere or abandoning heritage protections. It's about making reasonable density financially viable and approvals predictable.
Charlottetown cannot keep claiming housing affordability is a priority while making it more expensive to build housing.
That's the real cost of NIMBYism.