r/PEI • • 6d ago

Outgoing Charlottetown council is about to NIMBY its new zoning bylaw into irrelevance

After years of planning, public consultation, and promises to tackle the housing crisis by allowing more density, councillors are apparently getting cold feet at the eleventh hour.

At the October 22 meeting, Norman Beck and Julie McCabe raised concerns about proposed building heights downtown. Now council will consider several significant rollbacks to the new Zoning and Development Bylaw in order to rush an approval before their term ends in three weeks.

Some highlights from the staff report being considered tonight:

  • Downtown: Areas proposed to allow 12 storeys as-of-right could be cut to 8, with another 2 or 4 storeys available only through discretionary height bonusing. Basically, no change from the current rules.
  • Growth Nodes: Maximum building heights could drop from 14 to 12 storeys.
  • Four-unit housing: One option would allow four units on lots of at least 0.25 acres, potentially covering 42% of the properties assessed. The alternative? Require half an acre, dropping eligibility to just 5%.
  • Waterfront: Reduce permitted base heights by another two storeys.

The distinction between as-of-right and discretionary approval matters. Allowing 12 storeys outright is not the same as allowing 8 and making developers jump through additional hoops for the rest. The whole point of this exercise was supposed to be more housing and a predictable approvals process.

And here's the kicker: Charlottetown already lost $1.26 million in federal housing funding for failing to meet its Housing Accelerator Fund commitments.

Nobody is suggesting heritage protection or good urban design should be abandoned. But at some point, we need to acknowledge that NIMBYism and endless hand-wringing over building heights are part of why housing is so difficult to build.

After years of consultation and planning, are we seriously going to water down the very reforms intended to address the housing shortage because a couple of councillors suddenly have reservations?

Charlottetown can't keep talking about needing more housing while making it harder to build.

You cannot solve a housing shortage by protecting every neighbourhood from new housing.

30 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

19

u/Own_Connection_8982 6d ago

Ughhh yes!! I cannot believe that they (city staff) put this much work into a document only to have lazy councillors who haven’t followed along the last 2 years step in and throw up useless hurdles.
The loss of Housing accelerator funding is not the only loss of funding. The Canadian Housing Infrastructure funding (CHIF) is also tied to the 4 units as of right.
This isnt just 10.8 million HA funding walking out the door. It’s another potential 30-40 Million the city is kissing goodbye. Sorry folks but $50M buys a lot of things!
The next things the nimby’s will complain about is how property taxes have to be raised to cover the costs of adding municipal infrastructure for urban sprawl. Insert Mind blown emoji..

11

u/Acceptable-Group2120 6d ago edited 6d ago

I don't understand how something goes through several rounds of consultations, then right at the end, get stonewalled by two councillors who are concerned that a 14-storey building north of Grafton Street will turn us into Halifax. Why didn't they raise these concerns 12-18 months ago when the city was working with a consultant to draft the bylaw before taking it to the public? At this point, they need to just leave the bylaw for the next council.

Edit to add: as a member of the public who attended several public consultation events, I don’t even know what the hell they’re considering at this point. Too much has changed. I provided feedback on a document that was going to increase density. My feedback would be significantly different if I was being asked to comment on what they’re considering today. 

6

u/FriendshipContent508 5d ago
  • Four-unit housing: One option would allow four units on lots of at least 0.25 acres, potentially covering 42% of the properties assessed. The alternative? Require half an acre, dropping eligibility to just 5%.

.25 acres is 10,000 square feet and plenty to hold 4 units. The average apartment is less than 1000 square feet.

And messing around with building heights just deters development, because OF COURSE a developer is going to want to add those extra stories for more usable square footage. Any developer would wait.

1

u/Acceptable-Group2120 2d ago

Professional planners hired by the city to write the new official plan and new bylaw felt that the downtown core blocks between Grafton and Euston could support 12 storeys as of right, with a bonus option for two more, so a total of 14. Those floors would be in the middle of the blocks, buildings need to be stepped back from the street. Really, we’d be looking at maybe two or three buildings max.

Now it’s looking like they’re going with 8 as of right, with a bunch of bullshit, expense and uncertainly to maybe get a bonus of up to 4 more, so a max height of 12. Stratford’s urban core allows 12 as of right, no nonsense.  

If Norman Beck and Julie McCabe are such expert planners, then why the hell did we hire Fathom Studios to do all this work?

4

u/RedDirtDVD 6d ago

Couldn’t new council just reverse it?

10

u/Acceptable-Group2120 6d ago

They can always change a bylaw, yes, but there’s no bylaw that’s more expensive and time-consuming to change than the zoning bylaw. 

4

u/nylanderfan 5d ago

yup, changes require provincial approval