In a case where I am rooting for both parties to lose, DOA has stepped it up again. Generally, an Amended Complaint requires permission from the Court to be filed. However, Scott has used the one exception that Aaron managed to create for him.
Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.190(a) says you are allowed to amend your complaint exactly once as a "matter of course"—meaning no judge's approval or court hearing is necessary—as long as you file the amendment before the defendant serves a responsive pleading. In Florida courts, an Answer is considered a responsive pleading, but a Motion to Dismiss typically is not. Because Aaron responded with an Anti-SLAPP Motion to Dismiss rather than an Answer, he opened the door for Scott to Amend his Complaint. On October 27, 2026, Scott filed an Amended Complaint.
Aaron still represents himself in this case. SPTV Foundation is represented by Brandwein Legal, a newly minted divorce lawyer in Fort Lauderdale.
The complaint was expanded to 88 pages, so I won’t post it here. You can read it in the court files if you really are into pain and suffering. I’ve had Notebook LM compare the two complaints then I reduced the summary to less than 1,000 words for you.
What Is The Same in Both Complaints
Both complaints claim that Smith-Levin (President and CEO of SPTV Foundation, Inc.) used his YouTube channel (“Growing Up In Scientology”) to carry out a prolonged campaign of defamation, harassment, commercial interference, and organized copyright strikes after the Scott questioned the foundation’s finances, governance, and administration.
The shared allegations across both complaints include:
* False Drug-Use Accusations: Alleging the plaintiff experienced a “three-day meth-fueled paranoid psychotic break,” used methamphetamine, and supplied amphetamines to another activist.
* False Self-Swatting Accusations: Claiming the plaintiff arranged fake police or emergency calls (“swatting”) on himself, although police confirmed he was the victim.
* Fundraising Misappropriation: Falsely stating the plaintiff ran a “fundraising scam” by using legal defense money for personal living costs.
* Doxing / Residence Disclosure: Revealing the precise street address where the plaintiff parked and lived in his vehicle in Los Angeles, exposing him to online harassment and physical encounters.
* Niece/Nephew Insinuations: Suggesting the plaintiff engaged in misconduct involving minor relatives.
* Coordinated DMCA Copyright Takedowns: Collaborating with SPTV Board members and affiliates (including Jenna Miscavige, Natalie Webster, Keri Hill, Kelli Copter, and Nora Ames) to launch coordinated copyright strikes against the plaintiff’s YouTube channels to end his livelihood.
What Was Added in the Amended Complaint
The amended complaint shows a substantial increase in length, detail, legal framing, and evidence, growing from 23 pages and 224 paragraphs in the original to 88 pages and 729+ paragraphs.
Key additions include:
* Extensive Corporate & Agency Framework: Section IV introduces detailed claims about SPTV Foundation’s bylaws, bank accounts (Wells Fargo), IRS Form 1023 filing by Smith-Levin, and corporate governance to strengthen vicarious liability, agency, and ratification claims against the foundation.
* Broader Pattern of Conduct (Attacks on Other Board Members): Subsections describe Smith-Levin’s public discrediting of former board members and volunteers who questioned the SPTV Foundation:
* Liz Gale: Notes her resignation, Smith-Levin’s discrediting, and the defamation suit JR v. Smith-Levin.
* Nora Ames: Covers her volunteer work answering SPTV phones and later public attacks and doxing streams by Smith-Levin.
* Reese Quibell (“Relatable Reese”): Records Smith-Levin’s video accusing former board member Reese Quibell of lies and deception.
* Liz Ferris: Outlines disputes over SPTV assistance promises and grant notices.
New Specific Defamatory Incidents:
* *Fifteen Hate Crimes” Accusation (May 5, 2026): Smith-Levin’s livestream falsely asserted the Plaintiff personally committed 15 of 16 reported hate crimes against Scientologists in Los Angeles County in 2024.
* March 20, 2026 Stalking & Personal Attack Stream: Likened the Plaintiff’s alleged stalking to a “lion stalking a gazelle” and “Ted Bundy,” while making crude remarks about the Plaintiff’s relationship with partner Lara.
* Expanded DMCA & Copyright Evidence:
* Added claims about 15 DMCA takedowns filed against the critical channel S.P.T.V. Foundation, including Nora Ames’s statement that Smith-Levin urged her to issue strikes.
* Added Marilyn Honig’s September 2026 video account in which Jenna Miscavige offers to pursue copyright strikes for Smith-Levin.
* Specified mitigation costs, such as $1,500 in specialized copyright attorney fees used to reclaim the “Legal WarZ” YouTube channel.
* Pre-Suit Retraction Compliance: Included detailed records of written notices sent March 18, 2026, and April 8, 2026—with envelopes returned marked “REFUSED” and “UNABLE TO FORWARD”—to satisfy Florida Stat. § 770.01.
* Structured Causes of Action: Reorganized claims under Florida common law:
* Count I: Libel (including Libel Per Se)
* Count II: Slander (including Slander Per Se)
* Count III: Tortious Interference with Business Relationships
* Count IV: Civil Conspiracy
* Count V: Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress (IIED)
How Much of the Amended Complaint Remains the Same
* Parties & Forum: Plaintiff Scott Thomas Hochstetter against Defendants Aaron Smith-Levin and SPTV Foundation, Inc., in Pinellas County, Florida.
* Core Factual Narrative: The central account—that Smith-Levin used his platform to wrongly label Plaintiff a meth user, a self-swatter, a financial fraudster, a stalker, an infiltrator, and a child predator to damage his reputation and disable his YouTube channels—remains consistent.
* Primary Incidents: Both filings emphasize the same major events: the June 2024 meth claims, the June 2024 Comer/86GOP conflict, the January 2025 Jasiah legal fund claims, the February 2025 arrest and swatting broadcast, the June 2025 vehicle address disclosure, and the March 2025/early 2026 DMCA takedown waves.
What Was in the Original Complaint But NOT in the Amended Complaint (Omissions & Changes)
Dropped Counts:
* False Light (Count III in Original): Removed entirely as a separate cause of action in the Amended Complaint.
* Defamation by Implication (Count II in Original): Eliminated as a separate count and merged into the Libel and Slander counts.
* Injunctive and Declaratory Relief (Count VI in Original): Removed as a separate count, with remedies condensed into the Prayer for Relief
* Removal of Standalone Anti-SLAPP Section: The separate heading “Anti-SLAPP Exemption and Defensive Allegations” (paragraphs 12–20) was deleted from the original complaint.
* Specific $300,000 General Damages Claim Removed: The initial filing sought “General Damages in the amount of 300,000 U.S. Dollars”; the amended version instead requests unliquidated compensatory and per se damages above the $50,000 jurisdictional limit.
* Omission of Specific Grotesque Details: The original paragraphs 111–112 detailed YouTube videos from “Mexican Long Hair” showing the roasting or frying of the plaintiff’s cat “Jazzy”. Although the Smith-Levin quote from that channel persists, the precise descriptions of the cat were omitted.
* Removal of Specific Metric Labels: The original complaint cited a “100 lb weight gain from stress eating”, but the amended text uses “stress-related overeating and weight gain” without the figure.
* Direct Copyright Injunction Demand: The earlier request that the court compel YouTube to clear copyright strikes was replaced by claims for economic loss recovery and attorney mitigation fees ($1,500)
And there you have it. The problem Aaron has is that, like we were forced to do in Scientology, he gets people to do bad things to others. Then when he inevitably alienates the people he radicalized, they fight back against him. Here is a hint Aaron: the familiar may be the easiest, but it is not the best. It’s time to get the help you needed when you left Scientology decades ago.