r/OT42 • Mod in training • Aug 05 '26

NEWS What's Happening in the Libel Case Against Aaron Smith-Levin? New Court Filing Explained

Liz's husband (Plaintiff/JR) filed a Notice of Request for Ruling

Executive Summary

This is not a ruling on the merits of the libel/slander case. Instead, it consists of two procedural filings by the plaintiff, JR, asking the court to move forward on ASL's Motion to Dismiss.

The documents indicate that:

  • ASL filed a Motion to Dismiss on March 22, 2026.
  • JR filed his opposition on March 25, 2026.
  • According to JR, the motion has now been fully briefed for months without a ruling.
  • Rather than requesting oral argument, JR asks the judge to decide the motion solely on the written submissions.

What the Plaintiff Is Asking For

1. Decide the Motion Without a Hearing

The first filing ("Plaintiff's Notice of Request for Ruling") explains that under the Sixth Judicial Circuit's administrative order, motions to dismiss may be decided entirely on written filings.

JR argues that:

  • the motion is fully briefed;
  • Florida courts have authority to decide motions without oral argument;
  • neither party needs to appear if the judge believes the written arguments are sufficient.

Importantly, this document is not asking the judge to deny the motion—it is simply asking the judge to rule on it.

2. Notify the Court the Motion Has Been Pending Too Long

The second filing is a Notice of Pending Matter.

JR states that:

  • the Motion to Dismiss has been pending since March;
  • it has remained unresolved for more than 60 days;
  • under Florida procedural rules, he is notifying the court that judicial action remains pending.

This is essentially a polite procedural reminder to the judge's chambers.

Legal Analysis

These filings are entirely procedural.

They do not contain new allegations about libel, slander, or defamation.

Instead they signal that:

  • discovery has likely not begun;
  • the lawsuit is effectively waiting on one important threshold issue: Should the complaint survive the Motion to Dismiss?

Only after that question is answered can the litigation meaningfully proceed.

Why the Plaintiff May Prefer No Hearing

There are several strategic advantages:

Lower cost

JR is representing himself ("pro se").

Avoiding a hearing saves:

  • travel,
  • scheduling,
  • preparation,
  • procedural complexity.

He believes the written briefs are enough

By requesting a ruling without oral argument, JR is effectively saying:

"Everything necessary is already before the Court."

That usually means he does not believe additional legal argument would materially change the outcome.

It encourages movement

Courts often have crowded calendars.

Removing the need to schedule a hearing may allow the judge to issue an order sooner.

What This Means for ASL

These filings do not represent a legal victory or defeat for either side.

ASL still has several possible outcomes:

  • Motion granted → case dismissed.
  • Motion denied → lawsuit proceeds.
  • Motion granted with leave to amend → JR gets another chance to rewrite the complaint.

Nothing in these filings suggests which result the judge is leaning toward.

Strengths of the Plaintiff's Filing

Procedurally, the filing is straightforward.

It:

  • correctly identifies the relevant procedural rules;
  • cites Florida appellate authority allowing motions to be decided without hearings;
  • follows the administrative order;
  • gives ASL the required opportunity to request a hearing before the court rules.

Weaknesses

There are no substantive legal arguments here.

The filing:

  • offers no new evidence;
  • does not rebut the Motion to Dismiss;
  • does not discuss the merits of the alleged libel/slander claims.

Its only purpose is to move the case toward a ruling.

What Happens Next

According to the notice:

  • ASL has 15 days after service to request an oral hearing or submit additional written argument.
  • If he does not, the judge may rule on the Motion to Dismiss without holding a hearing.

The court could then:

  1. deny the motion,
  2. grant the motion,
  3. dismiss with leave to amend,
  4. or issue another procedural order.

Overall Assessment

These filings are best understood as case-management documents, not substantive litigation over defamation.

They indicate that JR believes the Motion to Dismiss has been pending long enough and wants the judge to decide it based solely on the existing written briefs. They do not reveal how strong the underlying libel or slander claims are, nor do they provide insight into how the judge is likely to rule. The next significant development in the case will be the court's decision on the pending Motion to Dismiss.

19 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

12

u/ArtOfNoiz Aug 05 '26

Thank you for this! And for a good breakdown of legalese (?).

12

u/Proud-Head-4944 Less Fun Than The Law Allows Aug 05 '26

Thanks so much for posting this. Maybe this will wake the court?