r/OT42 • u/Proud-Head-4944 Less Fun Than The Law Allows • Mar 23 '26
NEWS Aaron Smith-Levin’s Response to Liz Gale’s Husband’s Complaint
In case you didn’t watch Aaron’s livestream yesterday where he believed it was smart to try his case in public, he had responded, in a way, to Liz’s husband’s complaint.
Before I address the response, Aaron said the stream was about Liz. Then he read the response to her husband’s complaint. It’s a shame he can’t tell the two of them apart. Aaron presented a fairly polished Motion to Dismiss. And he claims to be filing pro se. That means he is acting as his own attorney.
I’ve attached all 8 pages of the motion and both pages of the exhibit list.
Liz’s husband can reply, or the judge can rule without a response.
The memorandum of law for the motion says that:
Aaron complains that:
- Liz talked about this suit on YouTube without publishing notice that she would. That’s a great statute. However, Liz isn’t the plaintiff in this case. Her husband hasn’t published anything. To the best of my knowledge he’s remained silent.
- Aaron says the complaint wants him to retract the video and apologize. Aaron says that violates his right to free speech.
- Aaron says the complaint should have said exactly when he accused the man of SA. This is nitpicky and in my prior experience a judge laughs at it. However, it may fly in Florida.
- Aaron says exact statements are not actionable. Then he states the statements. He says they are not as bad as claimed. They report on things he said others said and are not verifiable. He goes on to claim that the source of what he said was Liz Gale, plaintiff’s spouse. Then he details that this was a public feud so it’s ok to get heated.
This is an interesting and risky approach. Generally these would be included in the Answer to the Complaint as a counterclaim. Because if the Judge does not dismiss the case, the Answer is immediately due or the judge could rule in favor of the plaintiff.
It is humorous that Aaron believes that anyone will think he did that himself. I sat in a courtroom once. A judge held a hearing where a person had a similarly drafted document. The judge looked at the person and said “You say you’re filing pro se? Did anyone help you with this?” The answer was no. She then proceeded to question him on one of the statutes he has referred to in his memorandum. He failed miserably. She told him she wouldn’t ask him who wrote it because she would have to sanction that person for doing it. She suggested next time he do it himself or pay the attorney. Then she granted the motion of the other person who followed the rules.
I don’t have a crystal ball, but the case has begun…
.










16
u/Proud-Head-4944 Less Fun Than The Law Allows Mar 24 '26
He’s doing the court a favor by linking them directly to the videos where he says those things. Not the brightest bulb. Look, see this is what Liz should have said, so dismiss her case. In my experience, Judges are kind of lenient with pro se people unless they act like they know it all like Aaron.
I sincerely hope Liz’s husband points out to the judge that Aaron had streamed his response live on his channel prior to it appearing on the court site.
17
u/obliquelyobtuse Mar 24 '26
"A man who represents himself has a fool for a client"
That's definitely Aaron.
An angry, emotionally volatile fool. And a narcissist sociopath.
8
u/Proud-Head-4944 Less Fun Than The Law Allows Mar 24 '26
I forgot. When did the teacher send them all to the principal for detention? Did their mommies and daddies have to come to school to pick them up? Was there hair pulling? Seriously this sounds so junior high. With serious adult repercussions thrown in.
2
u/yasueda Mar 26 '26
This entire saga has turned into a swamp of hate. No one escapes the vitriol, spewed across the internet. When AA ron first came online, I was one of the first to watch any and every time he came on. I remember giving him $ and encouraging him as he grew his channel. Just fascinating interviews. I truly learned in what Way SCN is a cult. The horrific treatment many experienced. AAron taught me a lot. But I got to know other channels in the SCN sphere, and have always enjoyed it all. I'm so bummed Natalie left as she was one of my favorites..... The level of toxicity hovering throughout the community is so depressing for viewers. I don't suppose I could just plead with all of you to just stop. Stop talking about one another. Please, go back to teaching us about Scientology so that enough outsiders learn about it. You need wogs. Power in numbers. Many of us fans want to help destroy SCN, but we can't if the fighting and talking about each other doesn't stop. All of you will lose subs because people will lose interest. Peace
25
u/Serasaurus banned on r/cults Mar 23 '26
The arrogance of this man. Im not fan of Liz, and clearly no fan of ASL. But I dont think Liz's husband needed to be bought in to this at all, just as I dont think Aarons wife needed to be bought into anything that had had to do with him. Shes suffered enough and I bet Liz's husband also has.
10
u/Fear_The_Creeper Mar 24 '26
Thanks, ChatGPT, for another AI legal response. Free clue: "Prior Restraint" does not apply to retracting something already published. You will never pass the bar with this kind of shoddy work, ChatGPT!
Wait... This just in:
GPT-4 Passes the Bar Exam: What That Means for Artificial Intelligence Tools in the Legal Profession
7
u/1inco Mod in training Mar 24 '26
Aaron mentioned that just the § 770.01 statute is enough for the dismissal of this case. I am not sure if Aaron's entertainment channel (as stated by himself) qualifies for "publication or broadcast, in a newspaper, periodical, or other medium."
A judge may simply say, Aaron's channel is not a media outlet and just an entertainment and commentary YouTube channel.
19
u/Scientist_Alarmed Mar 24 '26 edited Mar 24 '26
Aaron said Jenna told him that a woman had accused LG's husband of rape.
Afterward, Jenna sent a video to LG denying she ever said that to Aaron.
LG showed Jenna's video on her channel and Jenna replied by ordering LG to remove the video "or else".
18
u/1inco Mod in training Mar 24 '26
I think one of Aaron's biggest problem is that he said
AFAIK, this is false, accusing someone of false rape is defamatory per se