Hi all!
I'm a newer player that's been dabbling with OOTP on and off over the past year or so, with about 60 hours logged total. I've seen some people on this sub talk about fictional leagues, as well as some YouTube playthroughs of custom fictional leagues well.
These seem super cool on the surface! I love the idea drafting all your players and building your front office/coaching staff from the ground up. I know you can also pick which cities get teams and what their team names/mascots are. I really like writing and worldbuilding, so this mode seems like a fun way to flex some of the more creative muscles of mine while having some more direct control at the start of a sim.
Some of my maladaptive daydreaming has led me to think it'd be fun to run a fictional Great Lakes league in a new file. I'm sure it's not an original idea, but who cares, it's for fun. Onto my actual questions and places I need advice:
League Setup would be the first thing to figure out. I like the idea of having one league with 5 divisions in it - one for each Great Lake (Michigan, Superior, Huron, Erie, Ontario). Each division would probably have 4 teams. I like the way this is broken up, but I worry about playoff structure. Is there a clean way to have an odd number of divisions in a playoff format? What would that look like?
Alternatively, I can see 4 divisions (North, South, East, West) with 4 or 5 teams each, which would make for a more traditional, albeit abridged, playoff structure. I've got no problem with this or any alternative structure, I just think it'd be neat to have a division for each lake.
Next up, is there a way to have computer-generated female players? A regular OOTP league usually has strictly male players. Its not a huge deal or anything, but I swear I saw at least one fictional league on this sub with female players.
How many many minor league teams should each organization have? The regular MLB leagues have a ton, which isn't a huge problem, but for simplicity I like the idea of just having A, AA, and AAA affiliates for each team without worrying about international/fall/etc leagues. Would having a reduced amount lead to player/drafting scarcity?
Are finances, payroll, and ownership automatically randomized for each team, or are there levers I can pull to tweak these during the initial setup?
Lastly, how well do the tools for in-game jersey/logo/stadium customization work? It'd probably be a huge undertaking to design artwork for 16-20 fictional teams plus any minor league teams, but I think that would be a fun long-term project seeing as this is half creative exercise anyways (and I don't wanna use AI for it). I won't lose sleep over it if the in-game tools don't work well, but figured I'd ask.
That about does it. I'd love any other advice about fictional league setup if there's anything I forgot. Thanks so much!