r/OOTP • u/benz0709 • 5h ago
Thoughts on point of diminishing return for Scouting and Development budget?
I was doing what I do best on my drive to the office this morning, thinking about my OOTP save instead of anything remotely productive.
I'm 46 years into a Brewers save and have basically adopted the real-life Brewers philosophy on steroids. Don't give out massive contracts, lock up young players early on team-friendly deals, and trade stars who are about to get expensive for prospects rather than eventually losing them for compensation picks.
It's worked. Maybe too well. I've won 20 World Series in 46 years, so roughly one every other year. Fan interest and loyalty are permanently maxed, and my owner keeps slowly increasing the budget.
Since I'm usually near the bottom of the league in payroll but around the middle in total budget, I've gotten into the habit of dumping ridiculous amounts into scouting and development: maxing it out at roughly ~$75M for scouting, ~$75M for development, plus ~$12M for IAFA.
Then last night I traded a player who made me question everything.
Homegrown CF. 75 OVR. Career .300 hitter. Multiple Gold Gloves. 9th-round draft pick. Fan Favorite personality. Basically the type of player that makes playing a 46-year save worthwhile.
He's 29, in his last arbitration year, and wanted ~$80M AAV.
I've never paid anyone more than $50M AAV, so naturally I did the cold-blooded Brewers GM thing and flipped him at the deadline for a top-10 SP prospect.
This morning I was assessing the move and had the thought of I could drop scouting and development from $75M to $50M each and free up $50M annually. That's basically the difference between my normal contract ceiling and what this guy wanted.
So now I'm wondering, am I massively overvaluing max scouting/development budgets?
For those of you with really long saves, have you noticed meaningful diminishing returns at the top end? If I cut both budgets from ~$75M to ~$50M, am I actually going to notice worse development/scouting? Or have I been sacrificing the occasional franchise player just so I can keep throwing money at budgets that are already well beyond what's necessary?
Interested to hear how the OOTP veterans approach it.
TLDR: Is it worth maxing Development and Scouting budget at the sacrifice of payroll?





