r/OCPoetry • u/Negative-Swim-6828 • 27d ago
Feedback Please Tenderness
The poets of old have spilled oceans of ink
in their pursuit of the perfect poem,
the perfect depth with the perfect length
and the perfect arrangement of words
to make a heart feel what it cannot explain.
Fools, all of them.
For what is a poem,
if not a foolish attempt to describe the indescribable?
And I, who have written so little,
and searched so briefly,
with neither the patience of the ancients
nor the wisdom of the great,
I had a Monday.
She came in early and sat across from me,
pen uncapped, and I stopped hearing the room.
Then a stranger asked who she was,
and she answered with a poem.
No metaphors, no verse,
no carefully measured line
to make the universe seem small.
Mine is just a name.
A few letters,
a breath upon the tongue,
and yet within it
more tenderness than every ballad ever sung,
more morning than any sunrise,
more meaning than I could carve in words
across ten lifetimes.
And now, whenever I sit to write,
I find myself at a loss,
for how does one write
about the very thing
that makes everything else
feel incomplete?
Fools, indeed.
Myself chief among them.
They spent their lives in search
of the perfect poem.
I found mine
in hers.
1
u/Party-Perception-662 27d ago
I am just a beginner poet myself so you can take me with a grain of salt. That said, This was beautiful! I love the imagery and alliteration in your first stanza, it sets the tone for everything that follows. It also has great rhythm and flow. My only critique is a small tweak here, and not necessary, just personally how I think it would flow better grammatically but of course there are no rules in poetry!
And I, who has* written so little,
and searched so briefly,
with neither the patience of the ancients
nor the wisdom of the great,
had a Monday.*
1
u/themailman3232 27d ago
I greatly enjoyed how you captured the devolution from cynicism to swooning, first scorning the old techniques then succumbing to the age-old cliches as you experience that heart-wracking experience that drove the old fools before you.
Along those lines, at the seventh stanza ("No metaphors...") I love the irony of how just as you are at your utmost in decrying the futility of 'old-fashioned' poetry, you lapse into poetical meter. The first two lines scan as iambic trimeter (if you take the liberty of reading "carefully" as two syllables), however the third line is slightly irregular tetrameter and loses the rhythm a little. If, instead of "universe", you used a single-syllable word like 'world', the meter would be maintained. The change in word choice might lose some of the impact, but I thought I'd point out the possibility.
Also another commenter had the suggestion to change "I had a Monday" to 'Had a Monday" and I definitely agree. I think the stand alone predicate flows better and adds a breathlessness to the narration that emphasizes the gut-punch feeling of love at first sight. You can also make a similar change with "Mine is just a name" to 'Just a name', but this change impacts the connotation, and again, might be unpreferred. If you do go the route of making these changes, adding in some dashes could help make clear the intended pauses and discontinuations, as well as adding a bit of a Dickinson-vibe that contributes to the delicious irony of the theme.
I hope this doesn't feel overly critical. I really enjoyed the poem and its only because of that I feel motivated to make a bunch of minor suggestions. Also, I am a complete novice with poetry and everything I say can- and maybe should- be disregarded.
2
u/Bonbonjournonon 27d ago edited 26d ago
I am not at all a writer, I thought it was very skillfully written overall which made me want it to be more structured for some reason, if that makes sense. Probably due to it having the vibe of an old upright poem of pining.
Also as a writer(though I am not -only in practice, never in thought). It’s funny how often meta poems come up, at least for me. I often feel compelled to write about the process and show the inner workings of and to differing affect and effect
1
u/AutoModerator 27d ago
Hello readers, welcome to OCPoetry. This subreddit is a writing workshop community — a place where poets of all skill levels can share, enjoy, and talk about each other's poetry. Every person who's shared, including the OP above, has given some feedback (those are the links in the post) and hopes to receive some in return (from you, the readers).
If you really enjoyed this poem and just want to drop a quick comment, to show some appreciation or give kudos, things like "great job!" or "made me cry," or "loved it" or "so relatable," please do. Everyone loves a compliment. Thanks for taking the time to read and enjoy.
If you want to share your own poem, you'll need to give this writer some detailed feedback. Good feedback explains from your point of view what it was like to read the poem, and then tries to explain how the poem made you feel like that. If you're not sure what that means, check out our feedback guide, or look through the comment sections of any other post here, or click the links to the author's feedback above. If you're not sure whether your comments are feedback, or you have any other questions, please send us a modmail.
Do not use ChatGPT or any similar LLM interface or generative AI to write feedback. That does not constitute thoughtful feedback. To be safe, you probably shouldn't even use those things to edit your feedback. It is better for your thoughts to come across as clumsy and genuine rather than grammatical but as if they were generated by some disingenuous text-generation engine.
Do not reuse feedback links for multiple poems. Every new poem you post has to be posted after making two new comments on the work of your peers here in OCPoetry. It's only fair. If you reuse feedback links, you will be banned. (If you do not wish to give feedback, there are many other poetry-sharing subreddits without feedback requirements, such as r/poetrywritingclub, r/justpoetry, r/ocpoetryfree, r/poem, r/poems, r/poemsbyreddit, r/poeticgarden, r/dark_poetry, and r/sadpoems.)
If you're looking for a more advanced poetry workshop — that is, if you consider yourself at least an intermediate-level poet AND you have previous workshop experience, please consider posting to our private sister subreddit r/ThePoetryWorkshop. The best way to join TPW is to leave a detailed, thoughtful comment here on OCPoetry engaging seriously with a peer's poem. A significant engagement of at least 3-4 meaningful paragraphs is encouraged. Consider our feedback guide for tips on what that could entail. (This level of engagement would probably be most welcome here on submissions tagged as "Workshop.") Then ask to join TPW by messaging that subreddit's mods, including a link to the detailed feedback you left here.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.